The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
JustDad and I use different words to describe things in this world. But that caveat aside, here his account of the year that saw the collapse of the transgender-activist project:
Quotes a post by A1525; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Yes, the prevalence of trans identification and the experience of adolescent gender dysphoria. It is highly unlikely that these two things were as common or occur in the same way as now.
Nick Confessore on the trans rights movement: https://www.nytimes.com/2025/06/19/magazine/scotus-transgender-care-tennessee-skrmetti.html?smid=nytcore-ios-share
I’m going to go with the Lost Generation and also this Substack by @[private account]: https://open.substack.com/pub/americandreaming/p/memory-hole-archive-sex-and-transgender?r=7wxo1&utm_medium=ios&shareImageVariant=overlay
Some bitter criticism of the Substack about trans activism has come in:
Quoting @benryanwriter: This is a stunning must-read on what became of the LGBTQ activist movement in recent years, by @[private account]. https://open.substack.com/pub/americandreaming/p/memory-hole-archive-sex-and-transgender
Andrea James is very proud of her defamation project, Transgender Map, in which she furtively threatens her subjects by posting eerily personal details about them and their families—just to show them she can (eg: the year of my mother’s death).
Quoting @benryanwriter: Andrea James “Transgender Map” defamation project is a creepy exercise in illiberalism and sociopathy. Just today she boasted on Bluesky that she’d created a page for Frank Bruni for the sin of “platforming” Katie Herzog at an upcoming event at Duke.
Here’s Katie Herzog’s offending article that got her driven out of Seattle (my whacky hometown!). God forbid reporters should describe what’s going on in the world, rather than selectively edit what they report lest it prove inconvenient to anyone. https://www.thestranger.com/features/2017/06/28/25252342/the-detransitioners-they-were-transgender-until-they-werent
Andrea James “Transgender Map” defamation project is a creepy exercise in illiberalism and sociopathy. Just today she boasted on Bluesky that she’d created a page for Frank Bruni for the sin of “platforming” Katie Herzog at an upcoming event at Duke.
This is a stunning must-read on what became of the LGBTQ activist movement in recent years, by @[private account]. https://open.substack.com/pub/americandreaming/p/memory-hole-archive-sex-and-transgender
Strangio continued: “We have seen the devastating consequences of similar policies at the state level, and we have fought them every step of the way. Let us be clear: If this administration moves forward with this attempt to enact a national ban on our medical care through coercion, the ACLU will see them in court. We will not rest until the rights of transgender youth to live authentically and access the care they need are fully protected.” https://www.aclu.org/press-releases/aclu-will-challenge-trump-administrations-unconstitutional-effort-to-ban-gender-affirming-care-for-transgender-youth?utm_source=substack&utm_medium=email
ACLU Will Challenge Trump Administration’s Unconstitutional Effort to Ban Gender-Affirming Care for Transgender Youth
Press Release:
Today, the American Civil Liberties Union condemned the Trump administration’s latest proposals to implement two nationwide rules that would significantly shut down access in hospitals to gender-affirming medical care for transgender youth. The proposed measures follow the recent House passage of legislation aimed at criminalizing such care and represent an unprecedented federal intrusion into the private medical decisions of families and their doctors.
The administration’s proposal seeks to block the provision of evidence-based, medically necessary care for transgender people under 18—care that is supported by every major medical association in the United States, including the American Medical Association and the American Academy of Pediatrics.
“These gratuitous proposals are cruel and unconstitutional attacks on the rights of transgender youth and their families,” said Chase Strangio, Co-Director of the @ACLU’s LGBTQ & HIV Rights Project. “By attempting to strip away essential healthcare, the administration is not 'protecting' anyone; it is weaponizing the federal government to target a vulnerable population for political gain. Healthcare decisions belong to families and their doctors, not politicians. The latest proposals from the administration would force doctors to choose between their ethical obligations to their patients and the threat of losing federal funding. It would uproot families who have already fled state-level bans, leaving them with nowhere to turn for the care they need to survive and thrive."
Quoting @benryanwriter: BREAKING: Hospitals Giving Gender Treatments to Kids Would Lose Federal Funding Under New HHS Rule
https://benryan.substack.com/p/hospitals-giving-gender-treatments
The Trump administration today announced new federal regulations that would bar Medicare or Medicaid funding from hospitals that provide gender-transition interventions or surgeries to minors.
California state senator Scott Wiener, who’s running for Pelosi’s seat in the House, lambasts the Trump admin for proposing to cut off federal funding to hospitals that give gender transition interventions to minors.
He says: “Trans kids: We see you and we will fight for you.”
He also blasts the four Democrats in the House who voted for the bill to ban Medicaid coverage of pediatric gender-transition treatment, painting them as traitors.
Trump's push to end transgender care for young people opposed by pediatricians, @[private account] reports.
https://www.npr.org/sections/shots-health-news/2025/12/19/nx-s1-5649891/transgender-pediatrician-trump-rfk-jr-ban
RFK Jr.'s proposed rule to bar hospitals from receiving Medicare and Medicaid if they provide gender-transition interventions to minors will almost certainly get tied up in litigation. But if it goes through, Erin Reed reports that the Trans Youth Emergency Project is prepared to help families find the independent clinics that don't take Medicaid that would still be able to provide such treatments to minors. Reed also pointed to Mamdani's proposal to spend millions of dollars to provide such treatment for free in New York City. https://www.erininthemorning.com/p/trans-youth-emergency-project-offers
Quoting @benryanwriter: BREAKING: Hospitals Giving Gender Treatments to Kids Would Lose Federal Funding Under New HHS Rule
https://benryan.substack.com/p/hospitals-giving-gender-treatments
The Trump administration today announced new federal regulations that would bar Medicare or Medicaid funding from hospitals that provide gender-transition interventions or surgeries to minors.
Blueskyism tends to favor a low bar to entry for disadvantaged identity groups or to receive treatments or benefits for certain disadvantaged-identity-based conditions, such as being disabled or transgender. People on Bluesky tend not to worry that over-inclusion into these groups will threaten services for those who are more deserving of the benefits or for whom treatment is more appropriate, so to speak, whether because there are limited resources or public opinion sours on benefits that people start to think are being distributed too broadly and unfairly.
Dr. Oz has published this oped in the @WashingtonPost:
Mehmet Oz: No more public funds for sex-rejecting treatment for kids
Trump administration says it will prioritize evidence over risky experiments in gender care.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2025/12/18/mehmet-oz-transgender-children/
David Roberts supports the no-compromise philosophy on the aims of transgender advocacy, asserting that if Democrats give an inch on trans inclusion in girls’ sports, Republicans will take advantage of this to robs trans people of all civil rights.
In their brief to the Supreme Court, attorneys for the trans girl who sued to overturn the Idaho law blocking trans females' inclusion in females' sports argue that trans people should be considered a protected class under the Equal Protection Clause.
To support their argument that transgender people lack political power—a criterion for a group being designated a protected class (ie: a quasi-suspect class, like sex)—they assert that trans people have been subjected to a history of discrimination in the law. They point in part to a 1917 eugenics law that targeted transgender people for forced sterilization.
Meanwhile, opponents or skeptics of providing minors puberty blockers and cross-sex hormones to treat gender dysphoria in the current day argue that such treatments are unethical because they can lead to sterility. These opponents/skeptics argue that minors cannot consent to lose their fertility and that absent a fatal condition for which a sterility-causing treatment would be necessary (eg: chemo or surgery for cancer), adults cannot ethically consent on a minors' behalf either.
https://www.supremecourt.gov/DocketPDF/24/24-38/384129/20251110175630987_Hecox%20Respondents%20Brief%20Final.pdf
Seth Moulton recently backpedaled after saying he was uncomfortable with trans girls in girls’ sports and then getting pilloried on it by activists. He has fallen back in line as he seeks to win the Senate primary.
Wes Streeting ‘not comfortable’ with puberty blocker clinical trial
The UK Health Secretary made a ban on puberty blockers indefinite in December last year.
Health Secretary @WesStreeting has said he is “not comfortable” with a clinical trial into puberty blockers.
He also claimed the windows in his constituency offices have been smashed three times by transgender activists and he has received “all sorts of threats” since the study was launched last month.
The trial follows recommendation by the Cass Review into children’s gender care, which concluded that the quality of research claiming to show the benefits of puberty blockers for youngsters with gender dysphoria was “poor”.
Speaking to LBC radio on Friday, the Health Secretary said the Cass Review uncovered “utterly shocking levels of unprofessionalism, lack of proper clinical oversight and the prescription of puberty blockers without evidence”.
He added: “But Hilary Cass also recommended that we do a proper study.
“The Pathway study involves a whole range of treatments and care, including therapeutics or mental health support, but it also included a trial on this puberty blockers thing.
“I’m not comfortable, candidly, about it.”
Mr Streeting said his concerns involve the safety of children, ensuring they receive effective and evidence-based care and that clinical advice is followed. https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/health-secretary-lbc-government-kemi-badenoch-conservative-b2883303.html
I don’t misgender trans people. In fact, I am so routinely hounded by GCs for using preferred pronouns that my block list is in the 10s of thousands, because those people are so insanely insufferable.
As I wrote here, the only study to directly assess whether gender transition drugs were tied to a lower suicidal death rate in youths found they were not. https://nypost.com/2024/02/24/opinion/a-finnish-study-is-changing-how-we-approach-trans-kids/
A small study compared people persistently identifying as transgender with those who had detransitioned. It found that they tended to have different psychological profiles, with the trans people "exhibiting more externalizing symptoms and [detransitioners] reporting more neurodiversity and internalizing symptoms." https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/spanish-journal-of-psychology/article/differences-in-personality-and-psychopathological-symptoms-among-adults-with-distinct-gender-trajectories/44B28D1EBD62BB7F34731DEB9538F2DD
I do not speak in such reductive terms. I use the terms that I do intentionally. To call someone "anti-trans" presumes a sweeping set of biases, such as the notion that there is no such thing as trans people, that trans people deserve no civil rights protections whatsoever, or what have you. To presume simply and reductively that someone who has concerns about the ethics of providing life altering drugs to children—with little to no assessment based on unfalsifiable self-reported claims to their necessity—is "anti-trans" is to completely ignore the myriad ethical considerations at hand. This includes the question of whether a nine year old child can consent to being put on a path to infertility absent a fatal condition for which those treatments are being prescribed (ie: cancer). To call such questions, simply, "anti-trans" is an insult to the very notion of medical ethics. The use of such terms is what intimidates the vast majority of reporters out of ever using their brains when reporting on this subject.
The Florida attorney general has sued the World Professional Association for Transgender Health (WPATH), the Endocrine Society and the American Academy of Pediatrics for their support of gender-transition interventions for minors.
For years, these groups insisted the recommendations were settled science, but behind closed doors, they knew the evidence was weak,” Attorney General James Uthmeier said. “They knew the outcomes [were] uncertain, and the risks very real. Parents were not told the full story. In fact, some parents were told that if they didn’t put their kids through permanent, life-altering, sick procedures, like double mastectomies and castration, their child would commit suicide. Not only is that unethical and dangerous medicine, but it is against the law.”
Quotes a post by A0094; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Early-career trans researchers reconsider their futures amid lost funding and fear
‘I don’t know how I’m supposed to have longevity in this career’
https://archive.is/20251209125351/https://www.statnews.com/2025/12/09/how-research-funding-cuts-impacted-trans-nonbinary-scientists/
I wrote about that here: https://www.nysun.com/article/pressured-by-transgender-activists-star-academic-backs-out-of-his-own-research?member_gift=CUZ5qwd3crq4pmz-xrd
Diane is helping me read the amicus briefs for the pivotal upcoming Supreme Court case about state bans of trans females participating in girls’ and women’s sports. She found this brief, by experts such as @[private account] and others about the science of sex-based differences in sports competition, especially enlightening.
Comedian Aidan Comerford has attacked me for accurately stating in late February that at that time it did not appear that Trump was attacking gay rights.
Compared with his all-of-government assault on the major goals of the trans advocacy movement, the Trump admin has still not placed nearly as much focus on gay issues. But there are important and in some cases woefully overlooked exceptions.
As I reported earlier in the year for NBC News, HHS has sweepingly canceled NIH grants related to gay men’s health and HIV more broadly.
Kash Patel recently fired an FBI officer for, a lawsuit states, displaying a pride flag at his desk that a supervisor had given him.
The Trump admin has also weakened federal nondiscrimination enforcement for sexual orientation. The DOJ and HHS have aggressively expanded religious-freedom exemptions for various entities to permit discrimination against gay people, such as adoption agencies and religious schools. HHS removed or attempted to remove rules that had required federally funded programs to serve people without discrimination based on sexual orientation.
And if UK comedian Adrian Comerford were paying attention, he would see that the majority of those books are, in fact, what he would characterize as the “pro-trans” types. But never let the facts get in the way of a viral Bluesky post.
I find it frustrating when journalists refer to an individual person as "being LGBTQ", which makes no sense. Or when reporters conflate trans or gay issues that are distinct from one another as being "LGBTQ issues." I find a reluctance among reporters to even use the word "gay", or to refer to "gay people." GLAAD, in fact, says that journalists should not refer to the "gay community," because they claim this is not inclusive. Despite the fact that a gay community does in fact exist.
Also, I'm one of those older gays who absolutely cannot stand the word "queer". I find it especially bothersome when people refer to periods in gay history and describe it using the word "queer," despite the fact that at the time, most people would've used the word "gay".
Quoting @benryanwriter: Not LGBT men. Gay men. There is no such thing as an LGBT man.
Children taking DIY cross-sex hormones before going to gender clinics
Hundreds of young trans people are buying puberty blockers, oestrogen and testosterone without prescription from websites and even recreational drug dealers.
https://archive.ph/2025.12.07-002838/https://www.thetimes.com/uk/healthcare/article/children-hormones-drug-dealers-2xrflrwqm

What Chase Strangio of the ACLU said about The New York Times in June in the wake of his loss in Skrmetti before the Supreme Court:
https://benryan.substack.com/p/insidious-the-aclus-chase-strangio
“I think when it comes to the trans coverage is, it’s so insidious,” Mr. Strangio said of the Times. “The New York Times, especially has been fixated on casting the medical care as being of an insufficient quality.” He said that “the characterization of the science” backing pediatric gender medicine in the Times “is wrong.”
Speaking to the legal arguments in the Skrmetti case, he said that “even accepting that there is a debate over the medical care, this isn't a quality-based argument. What the states have to show is that there's a reason why they’re treating this care differently. So even if there are different views about the best care, even if there is evidence that is not as robust as, you know, as we would like, that is true in many other aspects of pediatrics.”
Mr. Strangio faulted the Times, in particular, for what he characterized as its deferential reporting of the British Cass Review, which was authored by renowned pediatrician Dr. Hilary Cass and published last year. The review found that the field of pediatric gender medicine was based on “remarkably weak evidence.” Despite the fact that the National Health Service tapped Dr. Cass for the job because she was not involved in treating transgender youth and therefore came to the subject without a professional conflict of interest, Mr. Strangio lambasted her for that lack of experience.
He asserted that U.S. medical associations had “looked at the same evidence that Hilary Cass looked at” and concluded “that this is a robust body of evidence when it comes to pediatric medical care.”
Chase Strangio Pivots, Taking a More Moderate Tone
The @ACLU's Chase Strangio, who post-Skrmetti lavished scorn on @NYTimes, blaming it as a chief antagonist of the trans movement, has now gone to NYT to speak with remarkable even-handedness with @[private account].
⭐️Highlights:
👉Strangio agreed that if there were a treatment that could, without hormonal or surgical interventions, reconcile a person’s discordance with their natal sex, he would not be opposed to a person making the choice to go through with that treatment. He said what he’s opposed to is the government forbidding people treatment options.
👉Regarding gender-transition treatments for minors, he said:
“I understand why people feel nervous when it comes to kids. I have a kid, I get very anxious about bringing my kid to the doctor and not understanding what information I’m getting back. I also think that we as parents do a lot of work to help our children grow and thrive — and I think my clients, who made these decisions for their children, also did that.”
👉When Douthat observed that the medical space for this treatment for minors is much less regulated in the US than in Europe, Strangio said, “Yes, there are a lot of differences between the U.S. and Europe. Absolutely.”
👉This exchange about pediatric gender clinics:
Douthat: “Do you think that law addressed a real problem with clinics moving too quickly? Do you think there were clinics that moved too quickly from diagnosis to prescription?”
Strangio: “I don’t necessarily think that the existing safeguards that we have for medical malpractice and other oversights weren’t enough. But, as in all of medicine, there are probably examples where things were prescribed without the oversight needed, that things were moving too fast in some places.”
👉When Douthat referred to denouncing as transphobic the psychotherapy style of, say, Ken Zucker, in which the treatment seeks to get kids to reconcile with their birth sex, Strangio responded:
Strangio: “For myself, I am very hesitant to announce things as transphobic without having an opportunity to try to have conversations. And that’s where I am right now.”
Douthat: “You’re here right now.”
Strangio: “That’s why I’m here with you. I want to understand where people’s anxieties are. I want to find places where we might agree.”
Strangio also said: “I do not want a parent to feel like they can’t have a conversation with members of their community or trans adults or doctors without being afraid of being called transphobic. That is something I feel really strongly about. Maybe I’ve grown in this area, especially as a parent — the last thing I want is for people to feel like they can’t ask questions.”
👉Regarding gender-transition treatment for minors, Strangio said:
“I do think that there’s a lot of confusion about some of the science related to gender non-conforming young kids and what happens at puberty. I agree that there are a lot of young people who express gender non-conforming expressions and behaviors who are not trans and who will never be trans.”
👉Regarding sports, Strangio said:
“Yes, I am in favor of sex separated sports in most circumstances.”
“Yes. I accept the premise that, in the aggregate, men have athletic advantages in a majority — though not all — sports and that one of the ways that sex separation has worked is to ensure those opportunities for women.
“However, I do not think that’s the only reason. I also don’t think that’s the relevant question when we talk about trans inclusion in sports. But, I do accept that sex separated sports is an important part of preserving women’s opportunity in sports right now.”
⭐️Note that I have a recording of Strangio from a few years ago in which he dismissed the notion that there are sex-based differences in athletic ability. Referring to trans girls who notably won track competitions in Connecticut, he said that they were “hard workers.”
👉Douthat asked about his personal belief that pediatric gender transitions for kids will likely be regarded one day as a grave mistake. Strangio replied:
“ Well, I certainly don’t think your position should be ruled out of bounds. I don’t want you to not have the position that you have that’s core to what you see and experience in the world."
⭐️Here is what Strangio said about the Times in June:
"Insidious": The ACLU's Chase Strangio Slams The New York Times In Leaked Audio
In some of his first comments since U.S. v Skrmetti came down, Mr. Strangio never acknowledged or responded to the sharp critiques in a recent Times investigation of his own rhetoric and actions.
https://benryan.substack.com/p/insidious-the-aclus-chase-strangio
In June 2020, Chase Strangio wrote in Teen Vogue that efforts to ban gender-transition treatment for minors and other ADF efforts to limit the rights of trans people: "It is more than just transphobic; it is racist and colonial in the ways that many of our systems are."
https://www.teenvogue.com/story/united-states-government-transphobia-trans-existence-transcendence
Quoting @helenlewis: Chase Strangio has had a sudden and very welcome conversion to the concept of mutually respectful dialogue. https://www.nytimes.com/2025/12/04/opinion/transgender-rights-strangio-douthat.html
I’m still in the middle of the @[private account] interview with Chase Strangio. But in the meantime, it’s remarkable that just six months ago Strangio was busy blaming the ACLU’s losses on trans issues on The New York Times, as I reported:
Quoting @benryanwriter: I'm still in the middle of the podcast, but I'll have some thoughts when I finish. But in the meantime, indeed, it's interesting that he blamed the Times for everything and now is at the Times pleading a more moderate case. https://benryan.substack.com/p/insidious-the-aclus-chase-strangio
Marisa Kabas reports: The United States Tennis Association (USTA) quietly updated its player eligibility policy to ban trans women from competing as women in their leagues, tournaments and competitions in order to comply with Trump's anti-trans sports executive order. The policy went into effect on Monday.
At their conferences, closed to outsiders and the press, the gender clinicians allowed themselves to speak freely. They spoke about the boys who said they wanted to be girls and the girls who felt they were meant to be boys, and the medical and surgical interventions that would make them appear as the opposite sex. The clinicians also discussed new procedures for a new type of patient—some of them adolescents—who wanted to be made to look as if they had no sex at all.
In one of the videos, obtained exclusively by The Free Press, from the 2021 conference of the U.S. Professional Association for Transgender Health, Amy Penkin, a social worker with the Transgender Health Program at the Oregon Health & Science University (OHSU) spoke about one such case. Penkin told the audience about Sky, who she described as an 18-year-old recent high school graduate who was living on his own for the first time.
Penkin explained that Sky expressed a desire to look like “a Barbie down there.” Sky, Penkin said, reported “being asexual, never having had sex, and having no desire to have sex in the future.” Indeed, Sky did “not want to feel any pleasurable sensation and hope[d] removal of all erogenous tissue [would] be possible,” according to Penkin. https://www.thefp.com/p/were-all-just-winging-it-what-the
The Girl Guides in the U.K. will now, against their will, exclude transgender girls, the organization has announced.
A release states:
https://www.girlguiding.org.uk/information-for-volunteers/updates-for-our-members/equality-diversity-policy-statement/
Following April’s Supreme Court decision relating to sex and gender, many organisations across the country have been facing complex decisions about what it means for girls and women and for the wider communities affected.
Girlguiding’s governing charity documents set out that the membership and people who benefit from our organisation are girls and women. The Supreme Court ruled that girls and women are defined in the Equality Act 2010 by their biological sex at birth.
Following detailed considerations, expert legal advice and input from senior members, young members and our Council, the Board of Trustees for Girlguiding has made the difficult decision that Girlguiding must change, following the Supreme Court’s ruling.
From today, 2 December, it is with a heavy heart that we are announcing trans girls and young women will no longer be able to join Girlguiding. This is a decision we would have preferred not to make, and we know that this may be upsetting for members of our community.
There will be no immediate changes for current young members, but more information will be shared next week.
Most adult roles, including unit helpers, district helpers and administrative support, are already open to all, so we are confident that no volunteers will have to leave the organisation.
Girlguiding believes strongly in inclusion, and we will continue to support young people and adults in marginalised groups. Over the next few months, we will explore opportunities to champion this value and actively support young people who need us.
A new taskforce will explore ways to support everyone and create new opportunities. Members of all ages are encouraged to contribute to this taskforce to help us shape a future organisation that is inclusive.
Girlguiding is proud to be the UK’s largest youth organisation dedicated to girls and is focused on creating an equal world for girls and young women. For over 100 years, we have been a welcoming space for all girls to have new experiences, support their communities, build friendships and grow their confidence.
While Girlguiding may feel a little different going forward, these core aims and principles will always endure and we remain committed to treating everyone with dignity and respect, particularly those from marginalised groups that have felt the biggest impact of this decision.
Two thirds of the University of Michigan faculty supported a motion calling pediatric gender-transition treatment “medically necessary” and “life saving.”
Neither of these are evidence-based claims.
WPATH put the term “medically necessary” into its trans-care guidelines to help secure insurance coverage and win lawsuits. We know this from subpoenaed internal emails.
Only one study has directly assessed whether prescribing cross-sex hormones to youths attending gender clinics was associated with an independent, statistically significant difference in the suicide death rate. Conducted in Finland and based upon a large data set, it found no such association.
More on the suicide question: https://benryan.substack.com/p/suicidality-declined-after-youths
Quotes a post by A0452; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Often if you submit a request this broad the FOIA office will say no and ask you to narrow it. Or they’ll ask for an ungodly amount of money to complete it.
I submit these requests constantly. That’s where this article came from, for example: https://www.nysun.com/article/the-aap-files-inside-feud-within-american-academy-of-pediatrics-torn-over-transgender-issues-about-groups-decision-to-hold-meeting-in-anti-lgbtq-florida-of-ron-desantis?member_gift=CUZ5qwd3crq4pmz-xrd
Responding to a poll that finds widespread mistrust of the media among teens, The New Republic’s Melissa Gira Grant says:
“If you’re a young person in solidarity with Gaza, or against police killings, or you’re trans or queer, would you have reason to trust the news?
“If the news business wants young people to trust it, it needs to be honest about its failures, its limitations, and its power. At the very least it can help more people recognize that the news business is a business, one that is also sometimes a public service, and that often also does public harm.
Indeed, the Times article on the settlement links to this press release about the NIH study that Lurie Chidlren’s contributed to: https://news.feinberg.northwestern.edu/2023/02/02/gender-affirming-hormones-improve-mental-health-in-transgender-and-nonbinary-youth/
Erin Reed’s erroneous proclamation that this new study shows this treatment “saves lives” was quoted by Truthout, which added its own dramatic flair by declaring, “New Study: Gender-Affirming Care Dramatically Lowers Suicide Risk for Trans Kids.”
https://open.substack.com/pub/benryan/p/suicidality-declined-after-youths
That article then went viral on Bluesky, leading theoretical astro-physicist Chanda Prescod-Weinstein (who is known for being a leading voice in broadcasting contested claims about astronomer James Webb’s alleged anti-gay activities) to gripe that The New York Times “isn’t in a rush to cover this story.”
Erin Reed’s erroneous proclamation that this new study shows this treatment “saves lives” was quoted by Truthout, which added its own dramatic flair by declaring, “New Study: Gender-Affirming Care Dramatically Lowers Suicide Risk for Trans Kids.” That article then went viral on Bluesky, leading theoretical astro-physicist Chanda Prescod-Weinstein (who is known for being a leading voice in broadcasting contested claims about astronomer James Webb’s alleged anti-gay activities) to gripe that The New York Times “isn’t in a rush to cover this story.” https://benryan.substack.com/p/suicidality-declined-after-youths
In an unsurprising move given the climate at the Manhattan Institute for her after she came out as transgender (she was also brutalized on X), renowned economist Jessica Riedl is leaving the conservative think tank and joining the Brookings Institution.
Quotes a post by T04592; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
You’re suggesting that George Soros funded the World Professional Association for Transgender Health (WPATH)? Do you have a citation that backs such a claim?
Asked about the criticisms of her social presence, trans activist Alejandra Caraballo touts the maxim: “Be brutal to systems, be kind to people.”
“We need to hold people to account, we need to hold systems to account, but try to be kinder to people,” she says.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6Rhy-wcgCsM
Researcher Natacha Kennedy, in a viral post on Bluesky, calls the new UK puberty blockers trial “a thoroughly unethical piece of ‘research’.” In reply, others say, “This will literally kill people,” and that this is all “to take away” trans children’s “right to healthcare.”
Quoting @benryanwriter: BREAKING: UK's NHS to Launch Long-Awaited Puberty Blocker Trial
https://benryan.substack.com/p/a7b8bf86-e7b1-4934-a918-b8b85feb4891
The trial will randomize 226 gender-incongruent youths under age 16 to receive puberty blockers immediately or on a one-year delay and will follow them for two years post-randomization.
Sure enough, what I anticipated Erin Reed's Substack would do, it did. I was off in how long it took her to publish it—30 hours. https://www.erininthemorning.com/p/trumps-anti-trans-report-authors
Erin Reed's Substack has issued its scathing account of the 9 coauthors of the HHS report on pediatric gender medicine:
Trump's Anti-Trans Report Authors Revealed: Hate Groups and Billionaire-Funded Anti-Trans Activists
The majority of the “expert” comments cited in the “peer review” seem to be just as ignorant as the authors about the reality of trans people’s care.
https://www.erininthemorning.com/p/trumps-anti-trans-report-authors
Quoting @benryanwriter: Unmasked At Last: The 9 Authors of the Trump Administration Report On Pediatric Gender Medicine. So Who Are They?
🧵👇The coauthors, all skeptics or opponents of pediatric gender medicine, were finally revealed today after HHS published the final, peer-reviewed report. https://benryan.substack.com/p/unmasked-at-last-the-9-authors-of
Alma Avalle, the trans woman who led the crew who assembled outside the Condé Nast's HR director's to complain about Teen Vogue being dissolved, writes in @TheNation:
If Condé Nast Can Illegally Fire Me, No Union Worker Is Safe
The Trump administration is making employers think they can ignore their legal obligations and trample on the rights of workers.
https://www.thenation.com/article/activism/conde-nast-fired-four-union-labor/
How Right-Wing Superstar Riley Gaines Built an Anti-Trans Empire
The swimmer tied a trans woman for fifth. The MAGA industrial complex took care of the rest, by @MotherJones.
https://www.motherjones.com/politics/2025/11/riley-gaines-anti-trans-lia-thomas-ncaa-trump/
It’s similar but does some different things. Like I don’t think the US report theorizes about how porn might have led youth to identify as trans. Cass is written a bit more like it’s someone’s aunt who wants to remind them that they deserve the best care but also need some tough talk about realistic expectations in life.
Who are the newly revealed coauthors of the HHS report on pediatric gender-transition treatment? Dr. Michael Laidlaw has earned the most scathing assessment from trans activists among them.
Quoting @benryanwriter: Dr. Michael Laidlaw
https://benryan.substack.com/p/unmasked-at-last-the-9-authors-of
An endocrinologist in private practice in Calif., he is the HHS report coauthor most likely to set off alarm bells among trans activists. He has a notorious reputation among them for his expert testimony on behalf of state bans of pediatric gender medicine.
Dr. Jamila Perritt, President & CEO of Physicians for Reproductive Health and ob/gyn in Washington DC responds to the final HHS report on pediatric gender medicine:
“Let me be very clear: the information presented in today’s report is not grounded in scientific or medical evidence. This pseudoscience is, instead, grounded in hateful ideological language. Simply suggesting this research is ‘peer reviewed’ does not mean it is supported by research or that the evidence presented is credible. In reality, a multitude of research supported by mainstream medical organizations such as the American Academy for Pediatrics, Endocrine Society, Pediatric Endocrine Society, and the World Professional Association for Transgender Youth shows that gender-affirming care is essential medical care that supports the health and wellbeing of trans people across the country.
“The Trump Administration is clearly touting mis- and disinformation and calling it ‘evidence’ to advance false and unsupported claims about gender-affirming care. Their agenda is clear and dangerous: the Administration will rely on the so-called findings in this ‘report’ to issue orders that restrict gender-affirming care.
“It is critical that we pay close attention to who the Department of Health and Human Services has tapped to ‘review’ this ‘report’ and who has declined to participate. This ‘report’ was reviewed by people who are well known for touting harmful, transphobic rhetoric within and outside of their own communities. The individuals are well known transphobic actors. None of them provide gender-affirming care and many of them have made public testimonies in support of transphobic legislation. Unsurprisingly, the Administration stacked its review board with people who would agree with these dangerous claims.
“Physicians for Reproductive Health proudly supports and will continue to support the physicians in our community who provide gender-affirming care every single day. The providers in our network follow the guidance of the American Medical Association and American Academy of Pediatrics, among other relevant medical societies and organizations. These leaders in gender affirming care make it clear time and time again that gender-affirming care is safe and lifesaving for transgender people of all ages. The Trump Administration’s attack on established research protocols and practices is an effort to undermine medical evidence, scientific research, and the expertise of providers who listen to the needs of their patients every single day.
“It is our duty to follow the medical and scientific evidence when advocating for and providing health care, not the ideological and political views of those not qualified to care for those who need it.”
https://prh.org/press-releases/hhs-anti-trans-report-gender-affirming-care-response/
Quoting @benryanwriter: Unmasked At Last: The 9 Authors of the Trump Administration Report On Pediatric Gender Medicine. So Who Are They?
🧵👇The coauthors, all skeptics or opponents of pediatric gender medicine, were finally revealed today after HHS published the final, peer-reviewed report. https://benryan.substack.com/p/unmasked-at-last-the-9-authors-of
Most of them focus on the pediatrics issue. If you're aware of specific things they've said or done that cast doubt on the legitimacy of trans adults and their right to transition, please point that out.
This is a paraphrase from my notes of my convo with Dr. Laidlaw regarding his thoughts about adults transitioning:
For adults, if you’ve gone through the thought process, you’re at liberty to do it. I don’t harbor that sort of animus toward trans people.
I asked Dr. Laidlaw about that particular point. He said that the reason he avoids using any pronouns in official reports he's writing about pediatric gender medicine is because he thinks that puts the finger on the scale of a matter of substantive dispute. But he said that in everyday conversation with/about a trans person, he would use their preferred pronouns. He said he would not want to be disrespectful.
"Now we know why the authors were previously kept anonymous," Scott Leibowitz, MD, child and adolescent psychiatrist and WPATH board member, told @[private account].
"Reports focused on transgender and gender diverse individuals, especially those commissioned by the U.S. government, should be authored by experts who have dedicated their careers to serving the patient population. Regrettably, this is one of the only fields in medicine where having experience and understanding the complexities are viewed as deterrents rather than assets." https://www.medpagetoday.com/washington-watch/washington-watch/118601
Quoting @benryanwriter: Unmasked At Last: The 9 Authors of the Trump Administration Report On Pediatric Gender Medicine. So Who Are They?
🧵👇The coauthors, all skeptics or opponents of pediatric gender medicine, were finally revealed today after HHS published the final, peer-reviewed report. https://benryan.substack.com/p/unmasked-at-last-the-9-authors-of
The individual coauthor of the HHS report on pediatric gender medicine with perhaps the most notorious reputation in the eyes of trans activists is Dr. Michael Laidlaw, given his influential testimony on behalf of successful Republican efforts to ban gender-transition treatment for minors in red states such as Alabama and Florida. A 2023 Mother Jones investigation defined Dr. Laidlaw, an endocrinologist in private practice in Rocklin, Calif., as a member of a “secret working group that helped push anti-trans laws across the country.” The article stated: “In his South Dakota testimony, Laidlaw compared gender-affirming care to Nazi experimentation and the Tuskegee Syphilis Study.”
Dr. Laidlaw told the Sun that while he was politically conservative, dispassionate clinical concerns and a thorough assessment of medical research motivated his critiques of this medical field.
The disclosure that likely has the greatest potential to impact the battle over the increasingly limited future of pediatric gender medicine is the fact that among the report’s coauthors is the cofounder of the Society for Evidence Based Gender Medicine @SEGM_EBM, health researcher Evgenia (Zhenya) Abbruzzese.
SEGM, which is a small but influential nonprofit focused on scrutinizing the evidence base behind this medical field, was branded a hate group by the left-wing advocacy nonprofit the Southern Poverty Law Center @[private account] in 2024. Transgender activists have since leveraged this fact to attack two major North American universities for working with SEGM and are seeking to compel the retraction of the academic products of those partnerships. Others have dismissed the hate-group designation as indicative of the SPLC’s own political bias (the SPLC has also characterized conservative groups such as Turning Point U.S.A. as extremist groups) and asserted that such scurrilous branding of SEGM is supported by dubious arguments.
Final Trump Administration Report Sharply Questions Benefits of Medical Gender Care for Kids: Newly Identified Authors Criticize Poor Scientific Evidence
https://www.nysun.com/article/final-trump-administration-report-sharply-questions-benefits-of-medical-gender-care-for-kids-newly-identified-authors-criticize-poor-scientific-evidence?member_gift=CUZ5qwd3crq4pmz-xrd
🧵👇The nine coauthors, all known as at least skeptical of such treatments, will now likely face intense scrutiny from transgender activists, I report for The @[private account].
Dr. Michael Laidlaw
https://benryan.substack.com/p/unmasked-at-last-the-9-authors-of
An endocrinologist in private practice in Calif., he is the HHS report coauthor most likely to set off alarm bells among trans activists. He has a notorious reputation among them for his expert testimony on behalf of state bans of pediatric gender medicine.
Evgenia (Zhenya) Abbruzzese
Cofounder of the Society for Evidence Based Gender Medicine (@SEGM_EBM). SEGM is the bête noire of transgender activists. So Ms. Abburzzese, a health researcher, is the HHS report coauthor whose identity reveal is the most likely to make waves. https://benryan.substack.com/p/unmasked-at-last-the-9-authors-of
Substacker and transgender activist Erin Reed, an ardent supporter of minors’ liberal access to gender-transition medications, calls this a “sad day for NZ trans youth.”
The transgender movement faced setbacks during Mr. Trump’s first term as he rescinded many Obama-era policies. After President Joseph R. Biden Jr. was elected in 2020, Republicans turned up the pressure, leaning into fights over transgender athletes in school sports and transition care for teenagers.
In retrospect, she said, some transgender advocates may have erred in asserting that children who experienced gender distress should be allowed to transition without rigorously establishing that they were, in fact, transgender.
“Was there a period here of, Rah, rah, rah, yes, we will celebrate you, we will just promote you on your path?” she pondered. “Maybe that was too much, too fast.”
https://www.nytimes.com/2025/11/18/us/robyn-mccutcheon-diplomat-transgender-refuge-trump.html?smid=nytcore-ios-share&referringSource=articleShare
As Rights Are Taken Away, a Transgender Trailblazer Seeks Refuge Abroad
Robyn McCutcheon, the first American diplomat to come out as transgender, helped to shape personnel and foreign policy at the State Department. The country she served doesn’t feel like home anymore, @[private account] for @nytimes.
https://www.nytimes.com/2025/11/18/us/robyn-mccutcheon-diplomat-transgender-refuge-trump.html
Trans issues are set to play a major role in the fierce battle for the Democratic primary for Senate in Massachusetts. Progressive incumbent Ed Markey showed up at the No Kings rally draped in a trans pride flag.🏳️⚧️ Centrist Rep Seth Moulton @[private account] recently walked back his statement from a year ago asserting concern about the fairness of trans girls playing in girls’ sports and has sworn fealty to the trans cause.
At a recent Boston protest, transgender activists demanded that Fenway Health, a local LGBTQ-focused community health center, provide gender-transition drugs to minors "free and on demand," without any psychosocial assessment as recommended by the World Professional Association for Transgender Health.
Quoting @benryanwriter: After Fenway Health, an LGBTQ-focused community health clinic in Boston, recently stopped providing puberty blockers and cross-sex hormones to patients under 19, activists demanded pediatric patients receive such medications “safe, free, and on demand” at a protest on Friday, according to Assigned Media.
Fenway ceased providing treatment to this age group for fear the Trump administration would cripple their finances by taking away their status as a federally qualified health center, which qualifies them for higher Medicaid reimbursements.
An interesting account on @PodSaveAmerica with @[private account] of the Deciding to Win report, in which @[private account] et al theorized about how Dems can regain power. The report has caused quite the stir, including pushback over arguments that would see certain progressive priorities de-emphasized, including cultural issues like trans rights. The report is quite unpopular on Bluesky, to say the least. Bazelon is notably quite young and is quite in the weeds with polling data about how Democratic priorities have changed and how those changes may have led Dems to lose grasp of power.
Quotes a post by T07714; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Hannah Barnes @[private account], author of Time to Think, whose special on the Tavistock clinic was the rare BBC program to evade the apparent internal LGBTQ censor on trans issues, writes:
The @[private account] is worth fighting for
The corporation must turn this crisis into an opportunity.
https://archive.ph/P0tRL
Some people have objected to my citing of the Times' headline, which uses the term "transgender women," saying it should be "biological males," or simply "males."
Here is my generic response:
https://benryan.substack.com/p/why-i-use-trans-peoples-preferred
Why I Use Trans People’s Preferred Pronouns
Regardless of whether there will ever be any winners in the battle of the genders, I choose being kind over waging war.
Transgender women to be banned from all female Olympic events
IOC likely to announce new policy early in new year after findings of a scientific review about the permanent physical advantages of being born male.
https://www.thetimes.com/sport/olympics/article/olympic-ioc-transgender-athlete-ban-womens-sports-zhlpfll3b?srsltid=AfmBOoqsgJXmVyDjAoL7xCJH3svNhZYfshQXa37cfT0MRck84bl7NOqV
Gov Gavin Newsom says he has not been able to reconcile the issue of fairness regarding the inclusion of transgender females in girls and women’s sports and that there should be changes to California law accordingly.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4Dm3diA6z08
A press release about the case from a transgender legal advocacy group:
"When trans women are excluded from participation on teams that align with their gender identity, they are often excluded from participating altogether.
"Discrimination and exclusion inflicts stigma and causes long-lasting harm to trans people. This exclusion is even more disturbing considering the stigma and violence trans people already face in our society."
https://www.genderjustice.us/work/cooper-v-usapl/
NEWS: The Minnesota Supreme Court has ruled that denying transgender women inclusion in women's sports violates the Minnesota Human Rights Act.
The case concerned a transgender woman, JayCee Cooper, who sued after being excluded from a power lifting contest for women.
NEWS: The Society for Evidence Based Gender Medicine, or SEGM, is now offering continuing medical education (CME) courses on caring for youth with gender dysphoria. These courses include:
•Transgender Identities and the Brain: What Do We Know?
•History: How Problems in Adult Gender Medicine Launched Pediatric Transitions
•Gender Dysphoria: The Role of Social and Cultural Context in the 21st Century
•Misconceptions in Youth Gender Medicine
•Gender Dysphoria Treatment Guidelines: Assessment of Trustworthiness
•Managing Gender Dysphoria in Youth: European Practice Changes
•Hormonal Interventions for Gender Dysphoria in Minors: International Debate
In a popular Bluesky post, one trans person addresses criticisms of trans-activism overreach, saying:
“I'm so sick of discourse from supposed allies about where trans people went wrong.
“Where we ‘went wrong’ is that billionaires spent unimaginably large sums to attack us repeatedly and major media outlets have spent a decade piling on.
“Hastening to add that yea, of course, we have our issues as a community. Racism, classism, etc. There is much to criticize, just as there is with the LGBTQIA+ community generally. But that's not why they're stirring up hate against us.”
Those highlighted statements are in keeping with what @[private account] found in the data. https://www.generationtechblog.com/p/trans-identification-really-is-in
The data that @epkaufm provided wasn't specific enough to support @MattWalshBlog claim that "transgenderism is effectively over." Neither is @[private account]'s for that matter. But the data she found does support Kaufmann's claim that trans IDs are falling.
https://benryan.substack.com/p/no-the-data-hasnt-shown-that-transgenderism
It is likely that 2023 will represent the absolute peak of medicalization of gender transitions in minors, both because of bans and because of declining trans identification in youth.
1 in 1,000 Privately Insured 17-Year-Olds Were Taking Cross-Sex Hormones Prior to State Bans
https://benryan.substack.com/p/1-in-1000-privately-insured-17-year
The authors of a new study analyzing 2018 to 2022 insurance claims data characterized such prescriptions as rare and said this rarity undermined arguments for bans of these interventions.
This 2024 paper found an exponential increase in trans identity with younger Americans. But the data that @[private account] found indicates that this graph represented the peak at the youngest end. With successive years, the rate declined.
https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s13178-024-01001-7
NEWS: Trans and nonbinary identities are indeed in free-fall in college age Americans.
Prof. Jean Twenge @[private account] found new survey data that supports @epkaufm's much disputed claim from last week.
Twenge also found data indicating that trans identity increased exponentially by birth year until those born after about 2002. These identities have plummeted in those born more recently—who are now 20 to 23 years old.
The problem with Kaufman's data is it didn't distinguish between trans and nonbinary identities. The data that Twenge found does.
The decline in such identities in younger Americans raises important questions about the future of the field of pediatric gender medicine and the question of whether these identities are at least partially driven by social influences, as opposed to immutable, inborn traits.
The boos and jeers at Rep Seth Moulton @[private account] (D-Salem, Mass.) are at 2:36 in this video. Protesters remain angry at him for expressing concern in November about the fairness of including trans girls in girls’ sports.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oebfH9MkABc
Detransitioners abandoned by doctors, community face 'detransphobia' …
A Canadian-led study, the largest of its kind in decades, finds support missing for young people who halt or reverse a gender transition.
About 60 per cent said they “sometimes” or “always” avoid doctors, which other research has put down to fears of being judged for detransitioning; 42 per cent reported that their health-care provider “never” seemed knowledgeable when discussing detransition. Some reported receiving no information at all about what to expect going off hormones and how to avoid the side effects of stopping cold turkey.
“I had no confidence in my providers when I stopped transitioning,” one said.
Some described wanting “non-trans-affirming care providers,” saying past therapists were too eager to encourage their transition in the first place, or to retransition after detransitioning, “despite no expressed desire to do so.”
“Many shifted from (transgender) to gender non-confirming lesbian, gay or detrans identities, and, in hindsight, wished they had access to providers who took a more neutral approach to care,” the researchers wrote.
That backs previous research “and carries implications for gender-affirming care delivery,” they said.
Many described a need for professional mental health support, such as grief counselling “for losing a life I thought was gonna make me happy.”
Some felt detransitioning is being politically weaponized. “Conservatives want us to speak to them to ‘prove’ that transitioning is ‘evil.’ Liberals want to silence us for fear that we’ll somehow ‘influence’ trans people to detransition,” one said.
“We’re in a horrible space and it’s nearly more painful detransitioning for me than it was just suffering through an identity that didn’t fix my problems like everyone said it would.”
People expressed a need for detrans support groups and other community resources “to speak with other detrans people in person,” not online.
The study was funded by the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council, a Canadian federal research funding agency.
This claim by Gillian Branstetter, an ACLU spokesperson, is at least partially incorrect. The New York Times published a comprehensive report on Jamie Reed’s whistleblower report about the Wash U pediatric gender clinic. And while there were a few notable errors in Reed’s report, by and large Reed’s claims could be substantiated. As for Reed’s trajectory since 2023, it is correct that she has become increasingly devoted to undoing the entire transgender project.
Val Draper says of the Bluesky CEO: “Jay is actively diminishing the concerns of trans folks about Singal. I ain't saying she's evil, but she really needs to stop being terminally online.”
"The conflation of self-reported transgender identity with clinical gender dysphoria represents a significant methodological flaw in a growing body of research. The data presented by McNamara et al. (Citation2024), Hughes et al. (Citation2025), Lee et al. (Citation2024), and other recent studies inadvertently provide evidence of a profound shift in clinical practice. It suggests that a substantial majority of adolescents currently receiving hormonal interventions would not have met the established diagnostic thresholds for treatment in the recent past.
"By conflating non-clinical self-reported identity with a formal clinical diagnosis of gender dysphoria, this methodological error undermines the principles of evidence-based medicine. It is imperative for researchers, clinicians, and policymakers to recognize this critical distinction to ensure that care is ethically grounded in the principle of non-maleficence and is appropriately targeted to those who meet clear diagnostic criteria, thereby avoiding the risks of diagnostic overshadowing.
"Restoring diagnostic clarity could involve requiring multidisciplinary evaluations before medical interventions, implementing psychometric tools to distinguish persistent dysphoria from transient identity exploration, and promoting evidence-based mental health support as a first-line treatment. Such measures do not restrict care but aim to safeguard its appropriateness and effectiveness. These children deserve nothing less."
A bunch of people are up in arms because this cartoon on Netflix, created by the guy LOTT is angry at due to his remarks about Charlie Kirk, has a character who is a trans child.
The gulf between the policies that the Trump administration and statehouse Republicans have undertaken to undermine the central goals of the transgender movement and the actions of Democrats on this issue is just about as wide as it could possibly be. It is unclear to me how Ms. Gray has come to the conclusion that Democrats compromising on some of these issues, such as trans females’ inclusion in girls and women’s sports, would immediately equate them with Republicans.
Quoting @briebriejoy: It’s actually so sick and dark sided to argue that if we only had thrown trans people under the bus trans people would be safer now. No! We’d just have two anti trans parties.
There are some who distinguish between honoring the humanity of trans people and drawing lines that demand compromise in scenarios when trans rights conflict with those of other people or when gender-transition treatment poses risks to children; and there are some who lump all of this together and either accept or reject these considerations wholesale.
Prof. Sarah Richardson of @Harvard has prompted sharp rebukes to her Lancet essay in which she denounced those who adhere to the gamete definition of binary sex as bigots.
“I engage in scholarly debate as well as address public audiences…but I do not engage with inflammatory personal attacks and threats,” she posted on Bluesky.
This after she wrote in The Lancet:
“But although the gametic definition
makes reference to biological systems,
it is sophistry, not science. Those who
promote this definition favour the
assertion that sex inheres in gamete
(sperm and egg) production because,
in part, it facilitates their political
aims by fuelling unhinged panic in
some quarters about transgender
threats to traditional gender roles.
Like scientific bigots of yore…the recent favour bestowed on the gametic
definition of sex by anti-trans gender
traditionalists appeals selectively to
science to naturalise and rationalise
inequality and exclusion.”
Quoting @benryanwriter: There Are Only Two Gametes
"The gametic understanding of sex is consensus mainstream science that makes research and understanding possible across a variety of key fields. So why are professors at Harvard and Princeton and editors at ‘The Lancet’ framing it as bigotry?" writes @[private account] for @[private account].
Heritage Foundation Uses Bogus Stat to Push a Trans Terrorism Classification
By inflating numbers and narrowing definitions, Heritage promotes a false link between transgender identity and violence in its push for the FBI to create a new terrorism category, @[private account] and Dell Cameron report for @[private account].
In the wake of Charlie Kirk’s killing, the Republican policy apparatus went immediately to work. The Heritage Foundation, which published Project 2025, and its spinoff, the Oversight Project, issued a call for the Federal Bureau of Investigation to designate “Transgender Ideology-Inspired Violent Extremism,” or “TIVE,” as a domestic terrorism threat category. The push comes as President Donald Trump just signed an executive order that seeks to mobilize federal law enforcement against vaguely defined domestic terror networks.
The Heritage Foundation and Oversight Project document, which defines “transgender ideology” as “a belief that wholly or partially rejects fundamental science about human sex being biologically determined before birth, binary, and immutable," grounds its policy recommendations in a startling claim: "Experts estimate that 50% of all major (non-gang related) school shootings since 2015 have involved or likely involved transgender ideology."
When WIRED asked for the data behind this claim, the Oversight Project did not respond; the Heritage Foundation pointed to a tweet from one of its vice presidents, Roger Severino, claiming that “50% of major (non-gang) school shootings since 2015” involve a transgender shooter or trans-related motive. Severino also lays out what appears to be his entire data set: Eight shootings, four of which, he claims, involve “a trans-identifying shooter and/or a likely trans-ideology related motivation.”
"[Harvard Prof. Sarah] Richardson not only thinks the 'gametic' definition of sex is wrong; she also insists that its adherents have sinister political motives:
"'Although the gametic definition makes reference to biological systems, it is sophistry, not science. Those who promote this definition favour the assertion that sex inheres in gamete (sperm and egg) production because, in part, it facilitates their political aims by fuelling unhinged panic in some quarters about transgender threats to traditional gender roles. … Like scientific bigots of yore … the recent favour bestowed on [this] definition of sex … appeals selectively to science to naturalise and rationalise inequality and exclusion.'" https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/jaga6wp13mkuhgt52jmq3/Fuentes-Book-Review-Lancet-July-2025.pdf?e=5&fbclid=IwQ0xDSwL5qDNjbGNrAvmoH2V4dG4DYWVtAjExAAEeNsQwYrJHJfIEDbYTha3tYk9hJFR8phHCoUHRnkog9r8zmdYWvSU8ZxHzwY4_aem_LqvOID3hvY2VT5Y9uAcp6g&rlkey=p9ftxdfmcithmo85rlddtwdjh&dl=0
Interestingly, the generation with the highest rate of opposition to pediatric gender-transition treatment is Gen X. I saw someone theorize that this is because this is the cohort whose children are in the generation that has experienced the boom in trans identification.
Quoting @benryanwriter: Opposition to access to gender-affirming care for minors was highest among men (70%), Gen Xers (68%) and those without a college degree (67%). The rate of opposition on the left was 36%, compared with 65% of independents and 90% of those on the right. Ninety-two percent of right-wing men were opposed.
https://benryan.substack.com/p/most-americans-dont-think-minors
Opposition to bans of gender-affirming care for minors was strongest among those on the left, at 67%, compared with 54% of independents and 36% of those on the right.
In the New York Times poll released in January, here is how respondents weighed in on minors’ access to gender-transition treatments: https://benryan.substack.com/p/most-americans-dont-support-top-trans
Presented with three options, 40% said that politicians should not focus on transgender issues, while 25% said they should focus on restricting gender-affirming care and 29% said they “should focus on protecting transgender individuals.”
https://benryan.substack.com/p/most-americans-dont-think-minors
Fifty-four percent of respondents said they knew a trans or nonbinary person.
Asked whether they favored or opposed “the right of transgender individuals under age 18 to have access to gender affirming care,” 63% were opposed and 37% were in favor. However, when asked where they stood on lawmakers banning or restricting such access, the respondents were more evenly split, with 52% opposed and 48% in favor.
https://benryan.substack.com/p/most-americans-dont-think-minors
Responding to the question, “In general, do you favor or oppose the right of transgender adults to have access to gender-affirming care?” 53% were in favor and 42% were opposed. Younger voters were more likely to be in favor, including 61% of Gen Z respondents, compared with about half each of Millennials, Gen Xers and Boomers. There was a dramatic split by political affiliation, with 83% of those on the left in favor, compared with 56% of dependents and just 25% of those on the right. Interestingly, 13% of LGBTQ respondents were opposed, including 23% of Black LGBTQ respondents and 8% of transgender respondents.
Research by @[private account] at @[private account] found that even after sustained estrogen treatment, trans women maintain a competitive advantage in women's sports. https://x.com/benryanwriter/status/1871579834570145912
Quoting @benryanwriter: The Mayo Clinic’s @[private account]: “There are profound sex differences in human performance in athletic events determined by strength, speed, power, endurance, and body size such that males outperform females. These sex differences in athletic performance exist before puberty and increase dramatically as puberty progresses. The profound sex differences in sports performance are primarily attributable to the direct and indirect effects of sex-steroid hormones and provide a compelling framework to consider for policy decisions to safeguard fairness and inclusion in sports.”
In 2023, @[private account] reported for BMJ that the trans care guidelines for adolescents cannot be called evidence based. https://www.bmj.com/content/380/bmj.p382
Gender transition surgeries in minors are not rare. I reported:
How Harvard Teed Up the False Claim That the 'Vast Majority of Minors Getting Gender-Affirming Surgeries Are Cis Kids'
https://benryan.substack.com/p/how-harvard-teed-up-the-false-claim
An opaquely written Harvard study and linked press release prompted false reporting that gynecomastia surgeries for boys are vastly more common than gender-affirming surgeries for trans kids.
Erin Reed writes in @[private account]: "The right has seized on the shooting as its own Reichstag fire, accelerating a campaign to target transgender existence – now with the full weight of the Trump administration behind it."
After critics fault Democrats for taking maximalist positions on trans issues that have alienated the center, @TheNation takes maximalist positions on trans issues in a screed at least partially blames liberals for what it characterizes as a genocidal right-wing campaign to “exterminate trans people.”
The essay, which blames the liberal media in particular, dismisses critiques of trans women’s inclusion in women’s sports and of the safety and wisdom of pediatric gender-transition treatment as “myths”.
On the latter point, it links to an @[private account] FAQ that downplays the irreversibility of cross-sex hormones; falsely claims that gender-transition surgeries are rare in minors; falsely claims that all major medical associations support such treatment for minors (the ASPS does not endorse it); and falsely characterizes trans care treatment guidelines for all ages as “evidence based” (they are not—see @[private account]’s 2023 BMJ article on the subject).
As for concerns about trans women in women’s sports, I’m not sure how it can get around the fact that such concerns are supported by research suggesting that even after taking sustained estrogen treatment, trans women maintain a competitive advantage.
The essay has been a huge hit on Bluesky, which is a progressive bubble. It provokes the question of whether those who forbid any objections to the central aims of trans activism might be alienating people who might otherwise have been their allies.
Nowhere in the @MotherJones article does it specify that the McMaster systematic reviews were specifically focused on youth pediatric gender-transition treatment and that @SEGM_EBM distinguishes between the ethics of providing blockers and cross-sex hormones to minors and providing cross-sex hormones to able-minded adults. Instead, the article routinely refers more generally to "trans care," leaving the reader with the false impression that SEGM is concerned at all with the medical choices of able-minded adults.
Nor does the article address a key context: the potential harms of gender-transition treatment among minors, in particular fertility loss. Instead, the article focuses narrowly on what it presumes is SEGM's position: that low-quality evidence simply means "bad, ban it." But SEGM's position pairs the low quality of the evidence with the potential harms and asks difficult questions about the ethics of potentially erasing a child's fertility for a treatment that is not for a fatal condition such as cancer.
The article also leaves out any mention of moderate quality evidence under the GRADE system, and the demand among the skeptics the article derides for researchers to at least strive for evidence of that caliber when proposing treatment as radical as rerouting the puberties of adolescents into the opposite sex's.
It is curious that the article notes that Guyatt has critiqued the WPATH treatment guidelines, since McMaster has also sought to torpedo years of work a member of his lab has done on an independent SEGM commission to analyze those guidelines.
Lastly, the article mocks a separate article for suggesting that Guyatt's team bended the knee to activists. And then it describes how he capitulated to what he said was terrible behavior by activists and did their biddings.
Quoting @jessesingal: If I were Henry Carnell I would at least Google the GRADE definitions before writing a long article about this subject! This is not what low-quality means in the GRADE scheme. Bad but predictable article by MoJo.
Patients, parents accuse UPMC of discrimination in halting gender-affirming care
Hospital says 'we empathize deeply with the patients and families affected' and pledge to support patients 'within the bounds of the law'.
ive teens and children who say they were forced off of their gender-affirming care treatment plans when UPMC Children’s Hospital of Pittsburgh ceased such treatment for those 18 and younger earlier this year filed a complaint with the Pennsylvania Human Relations Commission, alleging the denial amounts to sex- and disability-based discrimination.
The sealed complaint was filed Tuesday by the Women’s Law Project and Philadelphia-based Berger Montague on behalf of five patients who’d previously received gender-affirming care at Children’s Hospital: Three adolescents who are under 18 and represented by their parents, in addition to two 18-year-old patients.
Attorneys said the complaint alleges the hospital continues to offer the same treatments, including puberty blockers and hormone therapy, to cisgender youth, or children who are not transgender.
UPMC stopped offering certain gender-affirming services — including hormone therapy and puberty blockers — earlier this year, citing the potential for prosecution.
Anita says: “On no planet in any galaxy am I gonna tell Black people, brown people, queer & trans people, disabled people, elders, parents with autistic children, or millions of other marginalized groups to show grace & empathy to those who put them in direct fire of suffering, even to death, under this regime.”
This category includes nearly a majority of Democrats. https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2025/02/26/americans-have-grown-more-supportive-of-restrictions-for-trans-people-in-recent-years/
Debunking podcaster Michael Hobbes also suggests that the fairness issue can still be solved absent barring trans inclusion in the female category:
Quoting @benryanwriter: Debunking podcaster Michael Hobbes routinely suggests that policies for trans inclusion in sport haves already essentially neutralized the question of whether such inclusion is fair. He ignores research suggesting that even sustained estrogen treatment does not erase the advantage of male puberty.
In a popular post on Bluesky about Kamala Harris’ concerns about trans inclusion in sports, Jesse Gender writes that such an attitude is based in “sexist bs” and claims that sex segregation is not observed to protect the female category, but to “defund women athletics & to build and propagandize the western idea of women as weak.”
“Jesus christ. It angers me deeply how not a single damn person in power who wants to at least pretend like they give a shit shout trans people will read even one damn book about the history of sex segregation in sports, cause you’d see how it’s all just sexist bs.
“It is so damn obvious the trans sports issue is a drummed up nonsense moral panic masquerading as “common sense” - but if you look deeper for two seconds you see how the whole point of sex segregated sports is to defund women athletics & to build and propagandize the western idea of women as weak.
“I’m earnestly done living in this sexist, racist, homophobic, transphobic, ableist culture. Not even for myself. I’m tired seeing so many people who have so much they want to give be ground down or killed. So many of us just want to give love. Fuck this poisoned culture. We all deserve better.
“But most of the people in power can’t be bothered to do a damn thing when we see literal images of genocide daily and an entire world is traumatized with images on a scale never seen before and so many cry out to have it stopped - so what do I expect? Anyways, Free Palestine. Fuck ICE. Trans Rights.”
This is a picture of Lia Thomas soaring above all the other swimmers at the NCAA Championships. But debunking podcaster Michael Hobbes writes as if the trans inclusion policies NCAA put in place had already solved the fairness issue. Or perhaps that they could have been more stringent. But it is not clear that they could have been any more stringent.
Debunking podcaster Michael Hobbes routinely suggests that policies for trans inclusion in sport haves already essentially neutralized the question of whether such inclusion is fair. He ignores research suggesting that even sustained estrogen treatment does not erase the advantage of male puberty.
9 state attorneys general pledge to support transgender youth: 'We have your back'
Nine Democratic state Attorneys General have vowed to do "whatever it takes" to defend the rights of transgender youth as the school year begins.
A new video campaign from the National Women's Law Center features Rob Bonta (California), Anthony Brown (Maryland), Andrea Campbell (Massachusetts), Charity Clark (Vermont), Keith Ellison (Minnesota), Letitia James (New York), Kathy Jennings (Delaware), Dana Nessel (Michigan), and Dan Rayfield (Oregon) each stating "I promise to fight for trans students."
"We will continue to hold this federal administration accountable, fighting to protect your rights, to protect access to health care, and so much more," the AGs take turns reciting. "When it comes to keeping trans youth safe, we will do whatever it takes. We are protecting our hospitals and clinics to provide the care that you may need. We won't look away if students are facing hostile learning environments, and we will hold schools accountable under our state laws."
The @[private account] and the @Heritage Foundation are seeking to classify a certain element of the trans population as a unique violent threat.
I wrote for @unherd about the actual science behind this supposition that there is some sort of connection between trans identity and violence:
Quoting @benryanwriter: The truth about trans violence
We need research, not demonisation, by me in @UnHerd.
Before the authorities identified Tyler Robinson as Charlie Kirk’s alleged assassin, and before the information broke that Robinson may have lived with a transgender partner, the Right-wing podcaster @SCrowder Steven Crowder released internal law-enforcement messages suggesting the shooter had engraved what Crowder asserted were transgender ideology references on his bullets. A Wall Street Journal report soon echoed the claim (which ultimately proved misleading; one message referred to the so-called furry sexuality), and the online Right jumped to associate the crime with the stereotype of the deranged and homicidal trans person, a longtime bogeyman among conservatives.
Then, on Monday, @[private account] of the @FreeBeacon reportedthat the FBI is investigating a series of social-media posts published in advance of Kirk’s assassination that “appeared to indicate foreknowledge” of the shooting. Several of those accounts appear to be run by transgender individuals, and at least one of them apparently followed Robinson’s trans roommate on TikTok, Sibarium reported.
Among the most hyperbolic polemics on the Right about this quickly shifting story are those from Daily Wire pundit @MattWalshBlog, who took to X over the weekend to declare: “Transgenderism is a death cult.” He added that “trans militants” are “inherently violent” and insisted that the “threat they pose is very serious”. Then there was @DonaldJTrumpJr, who before the shooter was identified, said in an interview with Fox News, “I can’t frankly name a mass shooting in the last year or two in America that wasn’t committed by a transgender lunatic that’s been pumped up on probably hormones since they were 3-year-olds.” (Donald Jr.’s grasp of the age a minor might start hormone therapy, even at the outer limits, is wildly inaccurate.)
It’s obviously tempting for some on the Right to claim Kirk’s murder as a general indictment of trans people — and equally, for their opponents on the Left, to fervently deny any connection between violence and trans identities. A better society, however, would tread carefully. Science on trans issues has indeed been politicised, not least by trans activists, but this is no reason to give up on it. Everyone is left poorer by each side’s rigidity and refusal to examine the facts.
See the thread for the link to the full piece:
In the wake of Charlie Kirk’s assassination, The Heritage Foundation urges the FBI to “designate ‘Trans Ideology-Inspired Violent Extremism’ (‘TIVE’) as a Domestic Terrorism threat category and use the full toolkit of the FBI to prevent future attacks inspired by this ideology.”
C2 false claimshand-codedpolitical enemyshooter attributionviolence terror
FBI Readies New War on Trans People
“We’re looking at the entire web”
@kenklippenstein reports.
The Trump administration is preparing to designate transgender people as “violent extremists” in the wake of Charlie Kirk’s murder, two national security officials tell me.
“We're looking at the entire spider web for any of these attacks,” FBI director Kash Patel told the House Judiciary Committee on Wednesday, when asked about shootings by trans individuals.
“They,” Attorney General Pam Bondi saidafter the Kirk murder, are “putting this crazy ideology in our schools,” echoing the growing view of many in Trump’s inner circle that a “cult of gender ideology” is behind an explosion of violence by some as yet unidentified “radical left.”
Two days before Kirk was killed, Donald Trump condemned “transgender insanity.” Then in an interview about the shooting, he blamed “the radicals on the left,” saying: “they want transgender for everyone.”
“They are cynically targeting trans people because the shooter’s lover was trans,” one senior intelligence official tells me. “The administration has convinced itself that the Charlie Kirk murder exposes some dark conspiracy.”
The senior official explains that there is no process per se for dealing with trans people as a “threat group,” but feels that trans individuals will be increasingly targeted under the banner of “violent extremism.”
Under the plan being discussed, the FBI would treat transgender suspects as a subset of the Bureau’s new threat category, “Nihilistic Violent Extremists” (NVEs).
Assemblyman Zohran Mamdani, the leading candidate for NYC mayor, denounces Mayor Eric Adams regarding his position on trans inclusion in bathrooms, saying, “Awful and dangerous to hear the Mayor echo the transphobic bigotry coming from the Trump administration. It's completely at odds with the values of our city and another reason why his single, disgraced term in office cannot end soon enough.”
I wrote for @UnHerd about the common use of the right to use the stereotype as the deranged, dangerous transgender person as a political boogeyman. See the thread.
Quoting @Con_Tomlinson: It's time for a complete and total ban on cross-sex hormones.
They cannot change your sex.
They turn men with perverse fetishes into derranged bioweapons, and women trying to escape sexual trauma into androgynous osteoporotic goblins.
These people need to spend a long time in an asylum — some of them, indefinitely.
A new study has details that suggest that adopting a transgender identity in childhood may in some cases be a product of social influence. Among children who identify as transgender who were followed for many years, 23% of their female siblings also started identifying as trans. @SEGM_EBM notes that this is a remarkable trend.
Quoting @benryanwriter: The latest study touches on another hot-button issue in the field—the question of external influences. Citing earlier researchers, the authors reference the “common idea in the literature…that parents in some way contribute to or facilitate gender nonconformity in their children”. They express scepticism on the grounds that most of the siblings of trans children “are cisgender”.
“Presumably, if parents were encouraging gender nonconformity in general, we might see a higher rate of transgender identity among the siblings.”
But Zhenya Abbruzzese, co-founder of the Society for Evidence-Based Gender Medicine, which is sceptical about medical transition in the young, interprets the data differently. She points out that “remarkably, 23% of female siblings [of trans children] became transgender-identified during the study.” This is a much higher figure than the percentage of natal males (9%) or females (10%) in the non-sibling group who came out as trans during the study, or the percentage of male siblings who did (9%). It also coincides with a period of rapid rise in the number of young people identifying as transgender. The majority of them, often 60% or more according to studies, were born as women.
The latest study touches on another hot-button issue in the field—the question of external influences. Citing earlier researchers, the authors reference the “common idea in the literature…that parents in some way contribute to or facilitate gender nonconformity in their children”. They express scepticism on the grounds that most of the siblings of trans children “are cisgender”.
“Presumably, if parents were encouraging gender nonconformity in general, we might see a higher rate of transgender identity among the siblings.”
But Zhenya Abbruzzese, co-founder of the Society for Evidence-Based Gender Medicine, which is sceptical about medical transition in the young, interprets the data differently. She points out that “remarkably, 23% of female siblings [of trans children] became transgender-identified during the study.” This is a much higher figure than the percentage of natal males (9%) or females (10%) in the non-sibling group who came out as trans during the study, or the percentage of male siblings who did (9%). It also coincides with a period of rapid rise in the number of young people identifying as transgender. The majority of them, often 60% or more according to studies, were born as women.
The main finding is that many children who transitioned young retained stable gender identities over time. The average child in this study transitioned aged six and a half, and was last contacted by Dr Olson’s team seven years later. Fully 82% of them had been unwavering in their gender identity. The other 18% had experienced at least one identity change, entailing either a re-identification with their natal sex or—more frequently—coming out as “gender diverse”, a category that is neither cisgender nor a transgender boy or girl (and is more commonly labelled “non-binary”).
For @TheEconomist, @JesseSingal writes:
How stable are the gender identities of younger children?
A study finds that one in five who switch gender change their mind.
"The main finding is that many children who transitioned young retained stable gender identities over time. The average child in this study transitioned aged six and a half, and was last contacted by Dr Olson’s team seven years later. Fully 82% of them had been unwavering in their gender identity. The other 18% had experienced at least one identity change, entailing either a re-identification with their natal sex or—more frequently—coming out as “gender diverse”, a category that is neither cisgender nor a transgender boy or girl (and is more commonly labelled “non-binary”).
"The fact that nearly a fifth of children in the group did not maintain a stable new gender identity ought to give advocates of irreversible medical interventions pause. It also complicates another finding of Dr Olson’s. In 2022 she published an earlier study of the same cohort in Pediatrics, another journal. Then, just 7% of the children who had transitioned early had an identity change over a five-year period. Taken together the two studies suggest that with time, a significant number of children are likely to develop different feelings about their gender identities. The current cohort was last surveyed at 15, still years shy of young adulthood."
Gretchen Felker-Martin is back on Bluesky after being suspended for her jubilant remarks over Charlie Kirk’s death. Here she addresses getting fired from her job writing the DC Comics Red Hood series. She asserts that multiple other contributors to DC have committed heinous acts with impunity. She says:
“One thing I'll say about DC not only canceling Red Hood, but recalling the first issue and refunding stores for buying it, is that you can still get Neil Gaiman's work through them. They still work with Otto Schmidt. Eddie Berganza worked there for years AFTER the formation of a policy that no women were to be around him at any time for any reason due to his habitual sexual harassment and assaults. Frank Miller released one of the most savagely Islamophobic comics of all time, HOLY TERROR, and still works with DC. There are pedophiles, war criminals, confessed sexual predators on staff.
“You can still buy all their work. Being a rude, abrasive loudmouth while trans is the only unforgivable sin to these people.”
Ken White, aka @[private account], suggests that Republicans are demonizing transgender people as a test case for a broader deconstruction of personal liberties, drawing a direct parallel to the methods of the Nazis.
Nancy Mace and @[private account] have both called for institutionalizing trans people.
Quoting @benryanwriter: Rep Ronnie Jackson weighs in on transgender mental health, claiming trans people should be taken off the internet and barred from communicating with one another.
Rep Nancy Mace @NancyMace calls for transgender people to be institutionalized.
https://bsky.app/profile/donlemonofficial.bsky.social/post/3lyy6u2h4f22e?utm_source=substack&utm_medium=email
Rep. Nancy Mace @NancyMace, a Republican, just called trans people "the most egregious, the most vile, violent people on earth." She said they "are mentally ill and should be in a straightjacket with a hard, steel lock on it."
"The trannies can f off," said Mace, who is running for governor in South Carolina and has made pushing back against transgender people and their advocacy goals as a central pillar of her political identity.
Quoting @benryanwriter: The truth about trans violence
We need research, not demonisation, by me in @UnHerd.
Before the authorities identified Tyler Robinson as Charlie Kirk’s alleged assassin, and before the information broke that Robinson may have lived with a transgender partner, the Right-wing podcaster @SCrowder Steven Crowder released internal law-enforcement messages suggesting the shooter had engraved what Crowder asserted were transgender ideology references on his bullets. A Wall Street Journal report soon echoed the claim (which ultimately proved misleading; one message referred to the so-called furry sexuality), and the online Right jumped to associate the crime with the stereotype of the deranged and homicidal trans person, a longtime bogeyman among conservatives.
Then, on Monday, @[private account] of the @FreeBeacon reportedthat the FBI is investigating a series of social-media posts published in advance of Kirk’s assassination that “appeared to indicate foreknowledge” of the shooting. Several of those accounts appear to be run by transgender individuals, and at least one of them apparently followed Robinson’s trans roommate on TikTok, Sibarium reported.
Among the most hyperbolic polemics on the Right about this quickly shifting story are those from Daily Wire pundit @MattWalshBlog, who took to X over the weekend to declare: “Transgenderism is a death cult.” He added that “trans militants” are “inherently violent” and insisted that the “threat they pose is very serious”. Then there was @DonaldJTrumpJr, who before the shooter was identified, said in an interview with Fox News, “I can’t frankly name a mass shooting in the last year or two in America that wasn’t committed by a transgender lunatic that’s been pumped up on probably hormones since they were 3-year-olds.” (Donald Jr.’s grasp of the age a minor might start hormone therapy, even at the outer limits, is wildly inaccurate.)
It’s obviously tempting for some on the Right to claim Kirk’s murder as a general indictment of trans people — and equally, for their opponents on the Left, to fervently deny any connection between violence and trans identities. A better society, however, would tread carefully. Science on trans issues has indeed been politicised, not least by trans activists, but this is no reason to give up on it. Everyone is left poorer by each side’s rigidity and refusal to examine the facts.
See the thread for the link to the full piece:
Why I Use Trans People’s Preferred Pronouns
Regardless of whether there will ever be any winners in the battle of the genders, I choose being kind over waging war.
https://benryan.substack.com/p/why-i-use-trans-peoples-preferred?utm_source=publication-search
Christopher Rufo @christopherrufo writes of Charlie Kirk's assassination that "more than enough evidence already exists for federal law enforcement to consider radical transgender ideologues a threat to the civil order of the United States—much like white nationalists, neo-Nazis, militant 'anti-fascists,' and other hateful groups."
Quoting @benryanwriter: For his newsletter, @christopherrufo writes:
Charlie Kirk Did It All the Right Way
He exposed the lies at the heart of radical left-wing ideologies—and paid the ultimate price for telling the truth.
First and foremost, Charlie Kirk did it all the right way. He was a conservative willing to wade into controversial territory. But he was always guided by the idea that debate is the great clarifier and that, in a democratic society, persuasion is the primary means of political change. He set up tables on campus. He debated his opponents. And he believed he could win through the ballot box.
Kirk’s death, and the subsequent reaction to it by the radical Left, underscored the arguments he had made during his time on the stage. For nearly ten years, Kirk had argued that transgender ideology, especially when paired with experimental medical procedures, would result in disaster. From the reports now emerging, it appears likely that the alleged assassin, Tyler Robinson, was radicalized online into anti-fascist and transgender politics. In their most extreme forms, both lines of thinking advocate a nihilistic embrace of violence—the antithesis of Kirk’s approach.
In fact, when he was murdered, Kirk was answering a question about the relationship between transgenderism and mass shootings, a phenomenon that seems to have accelerated in recent years. Kirk sought to engage his opponents in debate; his killer, quite possibly inspired by the trans-radical movement, sought to end that debate with a bullet.
The reaction to Kirk’s death by the mainstream Left has been equally troubling. Thousands of Americans, including students, professors, and even active-duty military members, have publicly cheered his assassination. Some have called for further violence against conservatives. Though I have covered left-wing radical movements for years, I was surprised by the number of people in the “helping professions,” including teachers and doctors, who embraced violent rhetoric.
How should conservatives respond? First, by drawing a line that Kirk himself exemplified: debate is healthy; violence is unacceptable. I’m glad to see that some institutions have terminated the employment of those who cheered on Kirk’s murder.
Contrary to the criticism that this represents a form of right-wing “cancel culture,” these firings were warranted. During the “woke” era, left-wing social media mobs sought the social annihilation of teenagers who sang rap lyrics and a Latino utility worker who cracked his knuckles the wrong way—examples of extreme and unjustified social policing. By contrast, a public school dismissing a teacher for applauding political assassination is a fair consequence.
All societies require boundaries. If there is no social sanction for celebrating violence, America will become a more dangerous place. Social trust, already fragile, will collapse.
On the question of transgender ideology, more information will emerge about Kirk’s alleged killer. But more than enough evidence already exists for federal law enforcement to consider radical transgender ideologues a threat to the civil order of the United States—much like white nationalists, neo-Nazis, militant “anti-fascists,” and other hateful groups. Some figures in the Trump administration, such as policy adviser Stephen Miller and Vice President J. D. Vance, have already indicated that they are ready to take action to enforce the law against violent movements.
Charlie Kirk sacrificed his life for truth. We should honor his legacy by standing firmly on principle, engaging in political debate, and, when necessary, enforcing the law against those who would organize violence in the name of politics.
C2 false claimshand-codedideology cultpolitical enemyshooter attributionviolence terror
For his newsletter, @christopherrufo writes:
Charlie Kirk Did It All the Right Way
He exposed the lies at the heart of radical left-wing ideologies—and paid the ultimate price for telling the truth.
First and foremost, Charlie Kirk did it all the right way. He was a conservative willing to wade into controversial territory. But he was always guided by the idea that debate is the great clarifier and that, in a democratic society, persuasion is the primary means of political change. He set up tables on campus. He debated his opponents. And he believed he could win through the ballot box.
Kirk’s death, and the subsequent reaction to it by the radical Left, underscored the arguments he had made during his time on the stage. For nearly ten years, Kirk had argued that transgender ideology, especially when paired with experimental medical procedures, would result in disaster. From the reports now emerging, it appears likely that the alleged assassin, Tyler Robinson, was radicalized online into anti-fascist and transgender politics. In their most extreme forms, both lines of thinking advocate a nihilistic embrace of violence—the antithesis of Kirk’s approach.
In fact, when he was murdered, Kirk was answering a question about the relationship between transgenderism and mass shootings, a phenomenon that seems to have accelerated in recent years. Kirk sought to engage his opponents in debate; his killer, quite possibly inspired by the trans-radical movement, sought to end that debate with a bullet.
The reaction to Kirk’s death by the mainstream Left has been equally troubling. Thousands of Americans, including students, professors, and even active-duty military members, have publicly cheered his assassination. Some have called for further violence against conservatives. Though I have covered left-wing radical movements for years, I was surprised by the number of people in the “helping professions,” including teachers and doctors, who embraced violent rhetoric.
How should conservatives respond? First, by drawing a line that Kirk himself exemplified: debate is healthy; violence is unacceptable. I’m glad to see that some institutions have terminated the employment of those who cheered on Kirk’s murder.
Contrary to the criticism that this represents a form of right-wing “cancel culture,” these firings were warranted. During the “woke” era, left-wing social media mobs sought the social annihilation of teenagers who sang rap lyrics and a Latino utility worker who cracked his knuckles the wrong way—examples of extreme and unjustified social policing. By contrast, a public school dismissing a teacher for applauding political assassination is a fair consequence.
All societies require boundaries. If there is no social sanction for celebrating violence, America will become a more dangerous place. Social trust, already fragile, will collapse.
On the question of transgender ideology, more information will emerge about Kirk’s alleged killer. But more than enough evidence already exists for federal law enforcement to consider radical transgender ideologues a threat to the civil order of the United States—much like white nationalists, neo-Nazis, militant “anti-fascists,” and other hateful groups. Some figures in the Trump administration, such as policy adviser Stephen Miller and Vice President J. D. Vance, have already indicated that they are ready to take action to enforce the law against violent movements.
Charlie Kirk sacrificed his life for truth. We should honor his legacy by standing firmly on principle, engaging in political debate, and, when necessary, enforcing the law against those who would organize violence in the name of politics.
C2 false claimshand-codedideology cultmotive displacementpolitical enemyshooter attributionviolence terror
Rep Ronnie Jackson weighs in on transgender mental health, claiming trans people should be taken off the internet and barred from communicating with one another.
Quoting @benryanwriter: The truth about trans violence
We need research, not demonisation, by me in @UnHerd.
Before the authorities identified Tyler Robinson as Charlie Kirk’s alleged assassin, and before the information broke that Robinson may have lived with a transgender partner, the Right-wing podcaster @SCrowder Steven Crowder released internal law-enforcement messages suggesting the shooter had engraved what Crowder asserted were transgender ideology references on his bullets. A Wall Street Journal report soon echoed the claim (which ultimately proved misleading; one message referred to the so-called furry sexuality), and the online Right jumped to associate the crime with the stereotype of the deranged and homicidal trans person, a longtime bogeyman among conservatives.
Then, on Monday, @[private account] of the @FreeBeacon reportedthat the FBI is investigating a series of social-media posts published in advance of Kirk’s assassination that “appeared to indicate foreknowledge” of the shooting. Several of those accounts appear to be run by transgender individuals, and at least one of them apparently followed Robinson’s trans roommate on TikTok, Sibarium reported.
Among the most hyperbolic polemics on the Right about this quickly shifting story are those from Daily Wire pundit @MattWalshBlog, who took to X over the weekend to declare: “Transgenderism is a death cult.” He added that “trans militants” are “inherently violent” and insisted that the “threat they pose is very serious”. Then there was @DonaldJTrumpJr, who before the shooter was identified, said in an interview with Fox News, “I can’t frankly name a mass shooting in the last year or two in America that wasn’t committed by a transgender lunatic that’s been pumped up on probably hormones since they were 3-year-olds.” (Donald Jr.’s grasp of the age a minor might start hormone therapy, even at the outer limits, is wildly inaccurate.)
It’s obviously tempting for some on the Right to claim Kirk’s murder as a general indictment of trans people — and equally, for their opponents on the Left, to fervently deny any connection between violence and trans identities. A better society, however, would tread carefully. Science on trans issues has indeed been politicised, not least by trans activists, but this is no reason to give up on it. Everyone is left poorer by each side’s rigidity and refusal to examine the facts.
See the thread for the link to the full piece:
Messages between Tyler Robinson and his trans partner include him saying regarding Charlie Kirk: "I had enough of his hatred. Some hate can't be negotiated out."
His mother told authorities that he'd recently shifted leftward and had become “more pro-gay and trans-rights oriented."
He refers to his partner as "my love."
Quoting @benryanwriter: The truth about trans violence
We need research, not demonisation, by me in @UnHerd.
Before the authorities identified Tyler Robinson as Charlie Kirk’s alleged assassin, and before the information broke that Robinson may have lived with a transgender partner, the Right-wing podcaster @SCrowder Steven Crowder released internal law-enforcement messages suggesting the shooter had engraved what Crowder asserted were transgender ideology references on his bullets. A Wall Street Journal report soon echoed the claim (which ultimately proved misleading; one message referred to the so-called furry sexuality), and the online Right jumped to associate the crime with the stereotype of the deranged and homicidal trans person, a longtime bogeyman among conservatives.
Then, on Monday, @[private account] of the @FreeBeacon reportedthat the FBI is investigating a series of social-media posts published in advance of Kirk’s assassination that “appeared to indicate foreknowledge” of the shooting. Several of those accounts appear to be run by transgender individuals, and at least one of them apparently followed Robinson’s trans roommate on TikTok, Sibarium reported.
Among the most hyperbolic polemics on the Right about this quickly shifting story are those from Daily Wire pundit @MattWalshBlog, who took to X over the weekend to declare: “Transgenderism is a death cult.” He added that “trans militants” are “inherently violent” and insisted that the “threat they pose is very serious”. Then there was @DonaldJTrumpJr, who before the shooter was identified, said in an interview with Fox News, “I can’t frankly name a mass shooting in the last year or two in America that wasn’t committed by a transgender lunatic that’s been pumped up on probably hormones since they were 3-year-olds.” (Donald Jr.’s grasp of the age a minor might start hormone therapy, even at the outer limits, is wildly inaccurate.)
It’s obviously tempting for some on the Right to claim Kirk’s murder as a general indictment of trans people — and equally, for their opponents on the Left, to fervently deny any connection between violence and trans identities. A better society, however, would tread carefully. Science on trans issues has indeed been politicised, not least by trans activists, but this is no reason to give up on it. Everyone is left poorer by each side’s rigidity and refusal to examine the facts.
See the thread for the link to the full piece:
Here are messages between alleged Charlie Kirk assassin Tyler Robinson and his transgender partner and roommate, whom he refers to as "my love."
Robinson says that he "did it" and that the inscriptions on his bullet casings were a "big meme" that, if he saw them on @FoxNews would cause him to "have a stroke."
"I had enough of his hatred," Robinson said of Kirk. "Some hate can't be negotiated out."
Tyler Robinson’s mother told the police that her son had moved to the left, politically, over the last year or so and had become “more pro-gay and trans-rights oriented,” according to a charging document filed by prosecutors, @[private account] reports for @NYTimes.
Ken Klippenstein reports on Tyler Robinson:
Yesterday, FBI Director Kash Patel said in an interview that Robinson “subscribed to left-wing ideology,” citing his family’s remarks to investigators. But those close to Robinson say there was a lot his family didn’t know about him.
“Their ideas are based on someone they didn't fully understand,” the childhood friend told me. Though the family was generally supportive of Robinson (a claim corroborated by his mother’s Facebook account, brimming with praise for Tyler) they didn’t seem to know about his relationship with a transgender person named Lance, the friend said.
When I asked if his family would have been accepting, the friend replied: “I don't think even Tyler knew the answer to that question, which is why he kept it so low key between themselves.”
Tyler’s bisexuality, the friend said, was coupled with openness on LGBT issues. But his wasn’t some cookie cutter lefty position on every or even most issues, his friends say.
“Obviously he's okay with gay and trans people having a right to exist, but also believes in the Second Amendment,” the friend said, referring to the right to bear arms.
The friend described Robinson as fairly typical of a young man his age from Utah: someone who loved the outdoors, was a gamer, and into guns.
“To all of us he just seemed like a simple guy who liked playing games like Sea of Thieves, Deep Rock Galactic and Helldivers 2, loved to fish and loved to camp,” the friend said. “It really did seem like that’s all he was about.”
Quoting @kenklippenstein: New Tyler Robinson posts leaked to me tell a very different story than you've heard before:
https://www.kenklippenstein.com/p/exclusive-leaked-messages-from-charlie
LINK: The truth about trans violence
We need research, not demonisation, I write for @UnHerd
https://unherd.com/2025/09/the-science-behind-trans-violence/
The truth about trans violence
We need research, not demonisation, by me in @UnHerd.
Before the authorities identified Tyler Robinson as Charlie Kirk’s alleged assassin, and before the information broke that Robinson may have lived with a transgender partner, the Right-wing podcaster @SCrowder Steven Crowder released internal law-enforcement messages suggesting the shooter had engraved what Crowder asserted were transgender ideology references on his bullets. A Wall Street Journal report soon echoed the claim (which ultimately proved misleading; one message referred to the so-called furry sexuality), and the online Right jumped to associate the crime with the stereotype of the deranged and homicidal trans person, a longtime bogeyman among conservatives.
Then, on Monday, @[private account] of the @FreeBeacon reportedthat the FBI is investigating a series of social-media posts published in advance of Kirk’s assassination that “appeared to indicate foreknowledge” of the shooting. Several of those accounts appear to be run by transgender individuals, and at least one of them apparently followed Robinson’s trans roommate on TikTok, Sibarium reported.
Among the most hyperbolic polemics on the Right about this quickly shifting story are those from Daily Wire pundit @MattWalshBlog, who took to X over the weekend to declare: “Transgenderism is a death cult.” He added that “trans militants” are “inherently violent” and insisted that the “threat they pose is very serious”. Then there was @DonaldJTrumpJr, who before the shooter was identified, said in an interview with Fox News, “I can’t frankly name a mass shooting in the last year or two in America that wasn’t committed by a transgender lunatic that’s been pumped up on probably hormones since they were 3-year-olds.” (Donald Jr.’s grasp of the age a minor might start hormone therapy, even at the outer limits, is wildly inaccurate.)
It’s obviously tempting for some on the Right to claim Kirk’s murder as a general indictment of trans people — and equally, for their opponents on the Left, to fervently deny any connection between violence and trans identities. A better society, however, would tread carefully. Science on trans issues has indeed been politicised, not least by trans activists, but this is no reason to give up on it. Everyone is left poorer by each side’s rigidity and refusal to examine the facts.
See the thread for the link to the full piece:
C1 anti-trans rhetorichand-codedshooter attributionviolence terror
However, here is @MattWalshBlog saying some remarkably incendiary things about trans people. https://x.com/MattWalshBlog/status/1966990541071307047
Quoting @MattWalshBlog: Anyone who’s been in the trenches fighting these trans militants knows that they are inherently violent. On a level far beyond any other political or ideological faction. Deranged, deeply hateful, angry at themselves and the world. Suicidal. The threat they pose is very serious.
Several of the social media accounts that published since-deleted posts that, per @[private account] of the @FreeBeacon, "appeared to indicate foreknowledge of the assassination of Charlie Kirk," appear to be from transgender people. One of them follows alleged assassin Tyler Robinson's roommate, who is trans, on TikTok. The FBI is investigating these posts, Sibarium reports.
Quotes a post by A0052; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Among the enraged responses on Bluesky to the CEO’s post saying, “Violence only begets violence” is:
“Actions indicate priorities. Jay and team have made theirs pretty clear. Bluesky will fight tooth and nail for two things: to harm and endanger Palestinians and trans people, and to defend the honor of Nazis.”
Quoting @jessesingal: Bluesky CEO just getting absolutely reamed by repeatedly refusing to toe the line (violence is good if the target is bad) over there
This argument, that there is no such thing as being transgender, often conflates the notion that it is not possible to change sex with the fact that there are people who sincerely conceive of themselves as and seek to present and be perceived as the opposite sex. One does not have to believe that it is possible to change sex to acknowledge that there are people who fall into this category and that these people call themselves transgender.
Therefore, transgender people exist.
Quoting @MegEBrock: No one should go along with pretending being transgender is real.
You are a man or you are a woman.
It’s not possible to be “transitioning” to a different sex.
Journalist and progressive activist Walker Bragman posts his latest on Blu-sky:
Rewriting Extremism: Right-Wing Seeks Nation to Mourn Charlie Kirk
The Right’s ‘martyr’ was an ideologue, a conspiracy theorist, a bigot, and an agitator who glorified violence.
Charlie Kirk, the 31-year-old Christian Nationalist podcaster and internet personality, was at Utah Valley University for one of his signature “Prove Me Wrong” debates at which he would invite college students to confront him with questions challenging his regressive political views. The outdoor event, which was organized by Kirk’s Turning Point USA (TPUSA), the dark money group he co-founded to promote right-wing ideology on college and university campuses, was set to be the first stop on a national tour. Over 3,000 people were in attendance, including Kirk’s wife and two young children, as the far-right activist was shot in the neck.
The horrific slaying by a suspect with thus far unclear motivations comes at a precarious time for the nation—one defined by extreme polarization and rising political violence. Just last month, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention campus was shot up by a radicalized individual who believed the COVID-19 vaccines were killing him and other people. One responding police officer was killed. In June, Minnesota House Speaker Melissa Hortman and her husband were assassinated by a right-wing gunman and State Senator John Hoffman and his wife were left wounded. In April, a man with anti-government views threw Molotov cocktails into the Pennsylvania governor’s mansion.
Kirk was a high profile member of the so-called New Right, a neo-fascist movement that has engulfed the Republican Party under Donald Trump. With his death has come an outpouring of support from Trump and other Republican politicians, right-wing personalities, and political operatives, who have been lionizing the fallen extremist as a champion of free speech and open debate. Some have even called him a ‘martyr,’ including Heritage Foundation president Kevin Roberts and Newsweek senior editor at large Josh Hammer.
Trump called Kirk a “Great American Patriot,” announced that he would posthumously award him the Presidential Medal of Freedom, and ordered all flags throughout the country to fly at half mast to honor him. Vice President JD Vance even escorted Kirk’s casket on Air Force Two from Utah to Arizona where his body was laid to rest.
Coupled with the hagiographic tributes has been a campaign to silence Kirk’s critics. Trump and his allies have rushed to blame The Left, with some prominent right-wing voices calling it—or for—“war.” The president vowed in a video Wednesday that his administration would “find each and every one of those who contributed to this atrocity and to other political violence, including the organizations that fund it and support it.” The State Department issued a warning that it would be reviewing the legal status of immigrants who celebrated or mocked the killing and the Pentagon implemented a “zero tolerance” for military personnel who did the same.
Others, like Sen. Dave McCormick (R-Pa.), have been trying to get Kirk’s online detractors fired. McCormick demanded the University of Pennsylvania take “decisive action” after renowned climatologist and geophysicist Michael E. Mann, director of the University of Pennsylvania’s Center for Science, Sustainability & the Media and an Accountability Journalism Institute advisor, after he reposted criticisms of Kirk on X. Olivia Krolczyk of the right-wing Leadership Institute’s Riley Gaines Center—so named for the former college swimmer turned anti-trans crusader who appeared at events with Kirk—announced that while it was ”free speech for liberals to celebrate Charlie Kirk’s death” it was also her free speech to “call their employers and let them know 💅.” On Wednesday, a website went up, http://www.charliesmurderers.com, which featured a list with pictures, social media screenshots, and personal details…
Gov Spencer Cox confirms to @CNN that Tyler Robinson lived with a transgender partner, who has been “incredibly cooperative” with the authorities.
Investigators, Cox confirmed, are looking into this part of Robinson’s life as a potential motive for allegedly killing Charlie Kirk.
Of the thousands of mass shootings in recent years, five are known to have been committed by transgender people. That is a very small percentage.
Quoting @kenklippenstein: Meanwhile here's Fox News saying "the transgender movement" is responsible for "many of the mass shootings we are seeing..." (No evidence is provided)
Axios reports that Tyler Robinson lives with a transgender person. Authorities are reportedly investigating whether Robinson’s opinions about Charlie Kirk’s attitudes toward trans people might have been a motive for allegedly assassinating him.
Charlie Kirk's alleged assassin lived with transgender partner who is now cooperating with FBI: Officials
Tyler Robinson's transgender partner is being 'extremely cooperative' with the FBI, sources tell @[private account] for @FoxNews Digital.
EXCLUSIVE: Charlie Kirk’s alleged assassin lived with his transgender partner, senior-level FBI officials told Fox News Digital.
Bureau officials confirmed that Tyler Robinson, 22, was in a "romantic relationship" with the unnamed person, who is a male transitioning to a female, and that they shared an apartment in Saint George, Utah. Those FBI officials told Fox News Digital that Robinson's partner is fully cooperating with the FBI's investigation.
One FBI official told Fox News Digital the individual has been "extremely cooperative," and said the person "had no idea" Robinson was allegedly planning to assassinate the Turning Point USA founder. The person is not currently accused of any criminal activity in connection with the assassination.
FBI officials told Fox News Digital that the FBI had text messages and other communications between Robinson and his partner that helped FBI agents zero in on Robinson. Officials said the FBI took evidence from their apartment, including computers, which has been sent to Quantico for review, Fox News Digital has learned.
The FBI declined to comment on whether Robinson's partner would be charged with a crime.
"The FBI is investigating a record number of tips," an FBI spokesperson said. "Every connection, every group, every link will be investigated and anyone involved in this matter, anywhere in the world they might be, will be brought to justice."
The apartment Robinson and his partner shared is in the same southern Utah community Robinson's parents live in. It is approximately four hours away from Utah Valley University, where Robinson allegedly shot Kirk.
Quoting @benryanwriter: The @NYPost reports: Charlie Kirk’s alleged assassin Tyler Robinson lived with transgender partner: source
Charlie Kirk’s alleged shooter Tyler Robinson was living with a transgender partner who was in the process of transitioning from a male to a female, a law enforcement source confirmed to The Post Saturday.
That individual, who has yet to be identified by the authorities, is now fully cooperating with the FBI on its investigation into the fatal shooting of the conservative activist, the source added. The relationship was first reported by Fox News’ Brooke Singman.
Text messages and other communications that the transgender individual traded with Robinson, 22, helped the feds nab the accused assassin.
Federal and state authorities revealed during a Friday press conference that a “roommate” cooperating with their investigation revealed communications from a contact named “Tyler” that described bullet casings similar to those found at the scene and discussed the “need to retrieve a rifle from a drop point.“
Meanwhile, I’m told that there’s a smallish march in Berlin against the conference put on by the Society for Evidence Based Gender Medicine @segm_ebm. Their conference in New York two years ago had no protests. SEGM scrutinizes the evidence base behind pediatric gender-transition treatment and as a consequence is seen as an enemy by transgender activists.
Mike Solana seeks to be a voice of reason against any mob mentality against transgender people:
Quoting @micsolana: I was trying not to post about this shit today but — if this is true, a trans person is actively *helping* the FBI. even if they weren't, the killer would still be the killer, most trans people would still not be killers, and all of us would still have a right to our own body.
In November, Rep Moulton infuriated many people on the opposite end of the political spectrum when he expressed misgivings about transgender girls participating in girls’ sports.
Steven Crowder still has pinned to his X profile the erroneous claim that the bullet casings from the gun Charlie Kirk’s alleged shooter used had etchings referencing “transgender and anti-fascist ideology.” Utah Governor Spencer Cox’s Friday morning press conference proved this claim, specifically about the transgender reference, was false.
The alleged Charlie Kirk shooter is not transgender.
Quoting @RonFilipkowski: Nancy Mace today: “It sounds like the shooter was a tranny, or pro-tranny.”
Law enforcement tonight: We have idea who the shooter is.
When I saw Steven Crowder publish the claim that trans issues were published on the bullet casings, I refrained from posting about it. But when @WSJ published the same claim, I reposted it. But where did WSJ get its information from? I deleted that post.
Quotes a post by T14512; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Today, the top Bluesky posts about Charlie Kirk are almost entirely expressions of rage and enmity toward him for his positions on women, gays, trans people, and Blacks. The posts characterize Kirk as a loathsome bigot.
NYT reports: Investigators eye a hunting rifle for clues to the gunman’s identity and motive.
A preliminary and unverified report circulated inside the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives found that ammunition recovered with the rifle used to kill Charlie Kirk appeared engraved with statements “expressing transgender and anti-fascist ideology.”
A senior law enforcement official with direct knowledge of the investigation cautioned that the report had not been verified by A.T.F. analysts, did not match other summaries of the evidence and might turn out to have been misread or misinterpreted.
In fast-moving investigations, such status reports are not made public because they often contain a mixture of accurate and inaccurate information.
An older-model Mauser 30-06 caliber high-powered bolt action rifle was recovered in a wooded area just off the college campus in Utah where Mr. Kirk was shot, according to five federal law enforcement officials based on the preliminary internal assessment.
Several cartridges, including what appeared to be a spent round in the rifle’s chamber, were recovered. The weapon and ammunition are being traced by A.T.F. analysts in West Virginia, but the evidence has not yet led to a person of interest, the law enforcement officials said.
On Thursday morning, investigators in Utah expressed confidence that a combination of forensic evidence from the scene and video from the university and nearby homes would soon allow them to determine the gunman’s identity. By the afternoon, the F.B.I. had posted an image of the person the bureau is seeking. The person was captured on a security camera on a flight of stairs, and was wearing sunglasses and a baseball cap. The image was somewhat blurry.
The F.B.I.’s request for help suggested that the image of the person was not clear enough to create a quick match via facial recognition software.
NYT: Mr. Kirk founded Turning Point USA, a political organization designed to rally young conservatives. He was answering questions about transgender politics and mass shootings from students at Utah Valley University on Wednesday when he was shot and killed. Authorities have not yet identified a suspect and said the investigation was ongoing.
Mr. Kirk appealed to conservative Christians who feared the growing acceptance of the L.G.B.T.Q. community in the United States. He was critical of gay and transgender rights and the separation of church and state.
He encouraged students and parents to report professors whom they suspected of embracing what some on the right refer to as gender ideology.
In 2021, he founded TPUSA Faith, which “exists to unite the church around primary doctrine and to eliminate wokeism from the American pulpit,” according to its website.
Research suggests that even after sustained estrogen treatment, transgender females maintain a competitive advantage in sports thanks to the benefits of male puberty. But even prepubescent boys are faster and stronger than girls.
Quoting @benryanwriter: A review paper published by Dr. Michael Joyner of the Mayo Clinic in December found that even prior to puberty, boys do have at least a slight advantage over girls athletically, and that this difference widens dramatically after male puberty’s onset. Research suggests that even treatment with estrogen and anti-androgen medications does not erase the athletic advantage conferred by a male puberty, Dr. Joyner found.https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39716906/ https://benryan.substack.com/p/most-americans-dont-support-top-trans
Nick Fuentes: A White Nationalist Problem for the Right
For years, conservatives hoped that the notorious white nationalist would go away. Instead, Mr. Fuentes has gained more traction, even while opposing the president, by @[private account] for @NYTimes.
Until a month or two ago, @NickJFuentes was regarded by right-wing influencers as a mosquito-like interloper whose lifeblood was attention. Ignore his openly racist and sexist rants, their thinking went, and Mr. Fuentes would eventually flitter off into oblivion.
But today an entirely different consensus has emerged on the right. The footprint of the oratorically proficient late-night streaming show host has not dwindled in the least, with his tens if not hundreds of thousands of alienated young male conservatives followers known as Groypers, a nickname derived from an alt-right meme. If anything, his anti-Israel, anti-immigrant, anti-transgender and anti-civil-rights views seem to have gained new currency during the second Trump administration.
There is now growing alarm among leading conservatives about Mr. Fuentes, who routinely tests the cultlike devotion of his young male fans by savaging their patriarchal figure, President Trump, for not being right-wing enough. In the process, he has emerged as one of the loudest voices on the right to turn on the president.
“When I was a teenager, I thought he was a Caesar-like figure who was going to save Western civilization,” Mr. Fuentes, 27, said in an interview. “Now I view him as incompetent, corrupt and compromised.”
Essentially, what he’s arguing is that there can be no middle ground for Dems on trans issues and that trans civil rights are purely a matter of personal freedoms.
This is an interesting reference, because there is a lot of overlap between the Satanic panic and the repressed memory movement; and there are those who draw parallels between the social contagion of the belief in repressed memories and the sudden, widespread adoption of trans identities in youth in the present day.
In particular, it was mostly young women who were swept up in the belief that they had repressed memories of sexual abuse. And it is mostly young women and adolescent girls who have driven the surge in trans identification in young people.
I’m not saying I have the answers about any of this. But there are those who would argue that Josh Zingher, who apparently is a political scientist, is looking at this issue from precisely the opposite vantage point of what’s actually going on. The parallel is not the crazy notion that preschools were bastions of Saran worshipping, but that American culture believed in something that was, in fact, just an artifact of larger societal psychopathologies.
At the European edition of @[private account]'s conference on transgender medicine going on now in Germany, conference-goers are advised to follow this policy on language use.
"We expect all conference participants to behave and to use language that is respectful, non-pathologising and consistent with human rights standards, taking into account its shifting and complex contextual and cultural character. Ultimately this caution applies equally to transgender health and all other formal and informal settings in which human interaction takes place."
The policy speaks to how quickly preferred terms can change and how hard it can be to keep up. For example, I'm told that while "natal sex" is verboten and considered transphobic, "sex assigned at birth" is now being challenged by "registered birth sex."
Quoting @benryanwriter: WPATH's European wing, EPATH, is having its conference in Germany right now.
Here is one abstract from Natacha Kennedy, a lecturer at Goldsmiths, University of London, who says that her survey of 97 young trans people finds that the UK puberty blocker ban is harming youth.
The Effects of the UK Puberty-Blocker Ban on Young Trans People.
This presentation looks at my own research into how the puberty-blocker ban - imposed by the UK government without any parliamentary scrutiny following the publication of the globally widely-discredited Cass Report - is affecting those young trans people impacted by it.
Following analysis of a survey of parents of 97 young trans people this research analyses interview data from those directly affected by the ban. It deploys a rigorous qualitative analysis of the data obtained through online interviews and parents’ responses to questionnaires. Given the criticism of The Cass Review great care was taken to adhere to the highest ethical standards. The qualitative nature of this research meant that it was important to ensure that saturation had been reached, something that was achieved, suggesting that the data constitute a reliable and comprehensive picture of the experiences of this group.
Supporters of the puberty-blocker ban have justified it by deploying the rhetoric of “protecting” young trans and non-binary people. Yet the results of this research show clearly that the opposite is happening; rather than being protected this group is being seriously harmed by the ban and this harm is likely to negatively affect these young people’s lives now and well into the future. It is also argued that the harm documented here will significantly exceed any major side-effects 'discovered' by the - unethical - 'trial' being conducted by the UK health service. This suggests that the validity of the Cass Review and the necessity of the puberty-blocker ban need to be challenged until it is withdrawn.
Due to the nature of some of the material included this presentation may need to have a trigger/content warning.
WPATH's European wing, EPATH, is having its conference in Germany right now.
Here is one abstract from Natacha Kennedy, a lecturer at Goldsmiths, University of London, who says that her survey of 97 young trans people finds that the UK puberty blocker ban is harming youth.
The Effects of the UK Puberty-Blocker Ban on Young Trans People.
This presentation looks at my own research into how the puberty-blocker ban - imposed by the UK government without any parliamentary scrutiny following the publication of the globally widely-discredited Cass Report - is affecting those young trans people impacted by it.
Following analysis of a survey of parents of 97 young trans people this research analyses interview data from those directly affected by the ban. It deploys a rigorous qualitative analysis of the data obtained through online interviews and parents’ responses to questionnaires. Given the criticism of The Cass Review great care was taken to adhere to the highest ethical standards. The qualitative nature of this research meant that it was important to ensure that saturation had been reached, something that was achieved, suggesting that the data constitute a reliable and comprehensive picture of the experiences of this group.
Supporters of the puberty-blocker ban have justified it by deploying the rhetoric of “protecting” young trans and non-binary people. Yet the results of this research show clearly that the opposite is happening; rather than being protected this group is being seriously harmed by the ban and this harm is likely to negatively affect these young people’s lives now and well into the future. It is also argued that the harm documented here will significantly exceed any major side-effects 'discovered' by the - unethical - 'trial' being conducted by the UK health service. This suggests that the validity of the Cass Review and the necessity of the puberty-blocker ban need to be challenged until it is withdrawn.
Due to the nature of some of the material included this presentation may need to have a trigger/content warning.
The DOJ engaging in what some would argue would be a cross between right- and left-wing politicking by proposing gun control, but limited to transgender people, under the premise that they are ostensibly all mentally ill.
Quoting @MaryMargOlohan: “Individuals within the DOJ are reviewing ways to ensure that mentally ill individuals suffering from gender dysphoria are unable to obtain firearms while they are unstable and unwell,” one source inside the Justice Department tells me.
https://www.dailywire.com/news/breaking-trump-doj-considering-gun-ban-for-transgenders?topStoryPosition=undefined&author=Mary+Margaret+Olohan&category=Exclusive&elementPosition=1&row=1&rowHeadline=Top+Stories&rowType=Top+Stories&title=BREAKING%3A+Trump+DOJ+Deliberates+Over+Gun+Ban+For+Transgenders
The main reason they probably caved is because they were scared of losing funding from Canada's version of the NIH. If you get branded as not friendly to LGBTQ issues with that agency, apparently they can bar you from receiving grant funding. It's pretty much the mirror image of what the Trump admin does with the NIH these days. Also, he was worried about his subordinates having their careers destroyed by being branded as hostile to trans people by the activists. This is a very serious threat in academia.
Malcom @[private account] is trending on X, with the video of him saying trans people have no place in women’s sports raking up millions of views.
But on Bleuskie the response is muted. The few reactions have been devoted to denouncing Gladwell as a lousy journalist and a wicked person.
Malcom Gladwell on his about-face on trans inclusion in sports:
"I was objective in a dishonest way. I let a lot of, really, howlers pass...Remember when, and I forgotten her name. She's wonderful. Sorry. I've forgotten their name. A very, very thoughtful person. They were the trans athlete on the panel, and at one point they turned to you, Ross @ScienceofSport, and they said, 'Ross, you have to let us win.'
"And it was at that moment that I realized this position has gone. This argument has gone to the furthest extreme. What the trans movement is not asking for [is] place at the table. They're not asking for to be treated with respect and dignity. What they're asking is for no one to question the considerable physical, physiological advantage they bring to the sport. And no one to question if they're going to win these races by five seconds. Suck it up. That's what they were asking, right?
"Which is, which is, you know, in other words, if a really good Caster Semenya comes along who can run 1:47 what they're saying is you just have to, like, so, so they win by 10 meters. So they win by 15, you would win by almost 100 meters, right? What they're saying is you should, you should have to live with that and that.
"Yeah, I heard that. I was like, 'This is nuts,' and yet I didn't say anything."
Quotes a post by A2592; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The Malcom Gladwell admission seems to represent a turning point in which left-leaning people are feeling freer to openly confess their concerns about some of the major positions animating the transgender advocacy project—in particular trans women's participation in women's sports and gender-transition treatments and surgeries for minors.
Public opinion, even among Democrats, has swung dramatically against these points. But believing and saying out loud a political opinion are two different things. Has Gladwell given people permission to speak in addition to thinking such opinions?
Quoting @benryanwriter: Malcom Gladwell says he is “ashamed” of having said in a previous panel discussion that trans women have a place in women’s sports. He says he was “cowed” into saying so.
“Trans athletes have no place in the female category,” he says.
It remains unclear what "technological miracles" McMaster University's Gordon Guyatt, the godfather of evidence-based medicine, is referring to. Dr. Guyatt is weathering a raging scandal over his having thrown under the bus the funder of his team's research into the quality of the evidence backing pediatric gender medicine. His team published a statement in which they also adopted trans-activist rhetoric by calling such medical interventions "medically necessary," which sharply contradicted the findings of their own research.
Quotes a post by T03939; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The success by transgender activists in bringing Dr. Gordon Guyatt, one of the godfathers of evidence-based medicine, to heel is but the latest chapter in a history of similar campaigns to topple and tarnish academics, journalists and other public intellectuals who threaten trans activists’ ambitions where vulnerable children are concerned.
In 2015, psychologist Kenneth Zucker was fired as head of a leading pediatric gender clinic in Toronto in the wake of a torrent of unsubstantiated activist allegations that his by-then out-of-fashion methods for treating gender-distressed children amounted to harmful conversion therapy.
Michael Bailey @[private account] , a psychology professor Northwestern University, and Dr. Lisa Littman @[private account], a physician-scientist, saw their papers on the theoretical phenomenon of “rapid-onset gender dysphoria,” or ROGD, pilloried by activists and trans-advocate academics. Dr. Littman’s 2018 paper was ultimately amended, while Dr. Bailey’s 2023 paper was retracted under what he insisted was censorship justified by pretext; he republished it elsewhere.
Quoting @benryanwriter: “I have some regrets in life, but my unwillingness to buckle under ideological pressure like Dr. Guyatt did isn’t one of them,” said @[private account] Bailey, who republished his paper elsewhere. “Indeed, it’s one of the things I’m proudest of.” Such bravery remains rare, and is invaluable to defend academic freedom in a field in desperate need of better research.
Bringing Guyatt to heel is but the latest chapter in a history of campaigns to attack the reputations of academics who threaten trans activists’ ambitions where children are concerned. In one notable pile-on, Michael Bailey @[private account], a pioneering psychology professor at Northwestern University, saw his 2023 paper on “rapid-onset gender dysphoria” subjected to an avalanche of scorn from trans activists and activist-academics. They ultimately succeeded in getting the paper retracted due to what Bailey insisted was unwarranted censorship based on a mere pretext.
According to sources close to the matter, McMaster also sought to cancel various independent commissions that individual university researchers received from SEGM. This has jettisoned, for example, years of work on an evaluation of the influential trans-care guidelines for adolescents published in 2022 by the World Professional Association for Transgender Health. The outstanding systematic reviews, Montante insisted, should be published. “Let the work stand for itself,” he said. Of his many dealings with SEGM, he said: “I’ve never gotten any kind of vibe or any kind of perception that this was some kind of anti-trans group.”
I report for @UnHerd on the tangled and tortured case of Gordon Guyatt, the towering figure of evidence-based medicine who has caved to transgender-activist pressure and thrown under the bus the funder of his systematic reviews of pediatric gender-transition treatment, @SEGM_EBM. He and his colleagues also contradicted their own research findings by adopting activist language touting the benefits of these interventions as “medically necessary.”
My reporting plumbs the depths of the internal tensions at McMaster University, where Guyatt is a star professor, over the mounting activist pressure. I spoke with one of the authors of the review papers, who was sharply critical of Guyatt’s decision to take sides on how his work should be used in the policy arena. This source shared with me internal emails diagramming the thought process of Guyatt and one of his key McMaster colleagues as they tried to quell the furor over their commissioned work for SEGM.
I also report on how Guyatt’s team is seeking to sink or at least divorce themselves from two other systematic reviews about youth gender medicine, and also kill an analysis of @[private account]’s trans care guidelines.
Malcom Gladwell says he is “ashamed” of having said in a previous panel discussion that trans women have a place in women’s sports. He says he was “cowed” into saying so.
“Trans athletes have no place in the female category,” he says.
Irish writer @Glinner Graham Linehan arrested over X posts on trans issues.
One said: “If a trans-identified male is in a female-only space, he is committing a violent, abusive act. Make a scene, call the cops and if all else fails, punch him in the balls.”
The writer said after questioning by police his blood pressure had reached “stroke territory” and he was taken to hospital and kept under observation, before being released on bail.
Using these words this way validates the existence of trans people while remaining scientific. I don’t know why anyone would want to use these words any other way!
Apparently, JK Rowling is referring to Chris Columbus, who directed the first two Harry Potter films.
From The Times:
"Columbus previously stated that he wanted to direct a film adaptation of the stage show, Harry Potter and the Cursed Child, using the original Potter movie cast (their characters are older in the play). Since then, alas, the JK Rowling trans controversy has made any potential adaptation impossible.
“'It’s never going to happen,' he says. 'It’s gotten so complicated with all the political stuff. Everyone in the cast has their own opinion, which is different from her opinion, which makes it impossible.' He adds: 'I haven’t spoken to Miss Rowling in a decade or so, so I have no idea what’s going on with her, but I keep very close contact with Daniel Radcliffe and I just spoke to him a few days ago. I still have a great relationship with all the kids in the cast.'”
Quoting @jk_rowling: As another man who once worked with me declares himself saddened by my beliefs on gender and sex, I thought it might be useful to compile a list for handy reference. Which of the following do you imagine makes actors and directors who aren’t involved with the HBO reboot of Harry Potter so miserable?
Is it my belief that women and girls should have their own public changing rooms and bathrooms?
That women should retain female-only rape crisis centres?
That men don’t belong in women’s sport?
That female prisoners shouldn’t be incarcerated with violent men and male sex offenders?
That women should remain a protected class in law, because they have sex-specific needs and issues?
That language should reflect reality rather than ideological jargon, especially in a medical context?
That women shouldn’t be harassed, persecuted or fired for refusing to pretend humans can change sex?
That women should not be threatened with violence and rape when they assert their rights?
That freedom of speech and belief are essential to a pluralistic democratic society?
That troubled minors, especially those who are gay, autistic and trauma-experienced, should be given mental health support instead of irreversible surgeries and drug treatments on non-existent evidence of benefit?
That gay people shouldn’t be pressured to include the opposite sex in their dating pools, nor should they be smeared as ‘genital fetishists’ when they don’t?
That cross-dressing heterosexual male fetishists aren’t actually oppressed, but having the time of their lives piggybacking off gender identity ideology?
That said ideology, and the privileged, blinkered fools pushing it because they suffer zero consequences themselves, have done more damage to the political left’s credibility than Trump and Farage could have achieved in a century?
Let me have your thoughts.
Sex is not assigned at birth. It is documented at birth. The unscientific term “sex assigned at birth” represents a mix-up between the words “sex” and “gender.” Gendered expectations are generally assigned at birth to coincide with a baby’s sex. When a person’s perception of their gender and their sex conflict, this can cause gender dysphoria. Transgender people will take hormones and sometimes also have surgery to work in opposition to their sex and to more align their body with their gender identity. I have trouble making sense of what should be controversial about any of these ways of describing sex and gender.
Quoting @sapinker: Evidence that woke isn't dead, peer review is problematic, and science needs to address deep problems in its culture: A grad student at Harvard conducted the first systematic, data-based study to document & explain the rise in gender dysphoria. His paper was rejected from a leading journal because, among other things, "Throughout the manuscript, the authors use language that is considered prejudicial and outdated (e.g., "natal sex" as opposed to "sex assigned at birth"). It is critical to follow best practice and guidelines surrounding gender inclusive language, particularly for research specifically on the topic of gender incongruence, expression, and identity."
Trump Officials Threaten to Pull Funding From Denver Public Schools
The Education Department gave Denver Public Schools 10 days to ban transgender students from using bathrooms that align with their gender identity.
Transgender politico Brianna Wu, who has been a leading voice for moderation in trans activism, decries the "level of trans rate" in the wake of the school shooting in Minneapolis by a young adult who recently transitioned. "You have people literally calling for us to be eliminated," Wu says.
Quotes a post by a private account; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
NYT reports on the Minneapolis shooting:
In a news conference, Mayor Jacob Frey of Minneapolis, a Democrat, urged the public to avoid scapegoating transgender people in the wake of the tragedy.
“I’ve heard a whole lot of hate directed at our trans community,” he said. “Anybody that is using this as an opportunity to villainize our trans community — or any other community out there — has lost their sense of common humanity.”
“We should not be operating out of a place of hate for anyone — we should be operating out of a place of love for our kids,” he added. “Kids died today. This needs to be about them.”
FACT CHECK: The president of the AMA claims that transgender youth have a 50% to 70% rate of suicide.
This is wildly false.
In fact, research indicates that suicide deaths, while elevated among youth who attend gender clinics, are rare.
Dr. Bobby Mukkamala, @[private account] president of the American Medical Association, is suggesting that the majority of transgender youth die by suicide. This is profoundly far from the truth.
Additionally, the only study ever to directly assess whether gender-transition treatments were associated with a statistically significant, independent association with a difference in suicide death in youths found no such association.
Quoting @benshapiro: 7/ CLAIM: Dr. Bobby claims that the rate of suicide for trans-identifying people is 50%+. Not thoughts of suicide, which studies show 20% of normal teenagers (unrelated to transgenderism) experience anyway, but the actual suicide rate. This is simply not true.
Blue states are seeing droves of hospitals shuttering, limiting or pausing their provision of gender-transition treatments and surgeries.
@NBCNews reports:
At least 21 hospitals have ended or restricted trans care for minors since January
The disruptions follow multiple efforts by the Trump administration to block such care for patients younger than 19.
More than 20 hospitals and health systems have temporarily or indefinitely rolled back transgender care for minors and some young adults this year amid threats of federal investigations and cuts to government funding, an NBC News analysis found.
Twelve hospitals have announced they have discontinued or will discontinue puberty blockers and hormone therapy for trans patients younger than 19. Four announced they are no longer providing transition-related surgeries to those patients; one said it discontinued gender-affirming care for teens; and four said they temporarily stopped transgender care for those under 19 after an executive order from President Donald Trump in January but resumed after a judge blocked part of the order in March.
Former NBC reporter suggests that a lack of smartphones poses an existential threat to gay and trans youth:
Quoting @benryanwriter: This defense of smartphones for kids by former NBC reporter Kat Tenbarge raises the question of how older generations of gay people concluded that they were gay absent the internet. (TV was a thing in my day.)
Note that rates of gay identification have not changed much in recent decades since the advent of childhood with the internet. What has changed is that a lot more young women identify as bisexual, albeit while largely in primary partnerships with men.
Trans identification, on the other hand, has soared among young people since the advent of smartphone-based childhoods, in particular since about 2011. Trans identification in teens and young adults is about 3-6 times higher than among older adults who were not exposed to smartphones during their formative years.
This defense of smartphones for kids by former NBC reporter Kat Tenbarge raises the question of how older generations of gay people concluded that they were gay absent the internet. (TV was a thing in my day.)
Note that rates of gay identification have not changed much in recent decades since the advent of childhood with the internet. What has changed is that a lot more young women identify as bisexual, albeit while largely in primary partnerships with men.
Trans identification, on the other hand, has soared among young people since the advent of smartphone-based childhoods, in particular since about 2011. Trans identification in teens and young adults is about 3-6 times higher than among older adults who were not exposed to smartphones during their formative years.
Government’s demand for trans care info sought addresses, doctors’ notes, texts
Legal experts said the Justice Department’s subpoenas related to medical care for transgender patients younger than 19 appear to be unprecedented, the @washingtonpost reports.
This claim by The Guardian lacks context. The growth in LGB identification in younger people is almost entirely in women identifying as bisexual. Most of them are in primary partnerships with men. Gay and lesbian identification has remained flat. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2025/aug/20/trans-people-us-data?CMP=Share_iOSApp_Other
The Guardian’s @[private account] reports that claims that social contagion drives the increase in trans issuing youth come from anti-trans advocates and some conservatives. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2025/aug/20/trans-people-us-data?CMP=Share_iOSApp_Other
The Williams Institute at @[private account] estimates that 3.3% of 13 to 17 year olds identify as transgender or nonbinary, compared with 0.8% of adults overall. That includes 2.72% of those 18-24, 1.4% of those 25-34, 0.42% of those 35 to 64 and 0.26% of those 65 and older. One quarter of people who identify as trans or nonbinary are 13-17 and 29% are 18-24.
After Bleuskie suspended the account of a trans person for saying, “I wish ill on @JK_Rowling,” more than 1,000 other accounts said the same in protest.
Riley Gaines, former swimmer turned conservative activist opposing the inclusion of trans women in women’s sports, lends her voice to ivermectin as a back-to-school supply.
Quoting @Riley_Gaines_: School is starting, fall is coming. Stay ahead of sickness and keep your immune toolbox stocked with @[private account]
Get your Ivermectin here: https://allfamilypharmacy.com/riley/
Expressions of anger and dismay toward Hugh Laurie on social media after he signed on to narrate the Harry Potter audiobooks, effectively crossing a digital picket line established to challenge @JK_Rowling’s stance on trans people.
@WSJ reported last year that efforts to cancel Rowling have had no apparent impact on the multi-billion-pound business of Potter, which is booming.
Novelist John Boyne has issued a statement after most of the novelists on the long list for the UK’s LGBTQ Polari Prize withdrew because of his positions of trans people. He says he believes in their dignity but draws a line when their needs conflict with c*s women, which he says must take precedence. He laments having people bully and make things up about him. He said he was near to a breaking point this past week. And he notes that his novels deal with the sexual abuse he suffered.
Quoting @benryanwriter: A controversy is brewing in the UK over the Polari prize for LGBTQ literature, after a so-called TERF, John Boyle, was long listed. Trans advocates are asserting he has no place on the list.
The NIH is seeking to forbid gathering data about gender identity, but gathering sex data would be okay.
Gender Data Would Be Off-Limits Under Proposed NIH Policy
By @[private account] for The Chronicle for Higher Education
The National Institutes of Health is moving to prohibit scientists from collecting data about gender, according to a draft policy obtained by The Chronicle, as part of President Trump’s order to end federal recognition of transgender people and others who identify as a gender that doesn’t align with their sex assigned at birth.
The proposed rule comes as the NIH is systematizing its aggressive crackdown on the study of gender identity, which includes canceling grants and closing an office dedicated to the topic. It was submitted for final edits and approval last week at the NIH, according to a person familiar with the matter, but had not been released as of Tuesday afternoon.
A @GLAAD senior director has written a missive lamenting social media companies abandoning content moderation policies protecting, for example, against misgendering.
She refers to Meta’s “bizarre addition of using the term ‘homosexuality’ to refer to LGBTQ people.”
It remains unclear what other word GLAAD would want @[private account] use to refer to the noun that describes being a gay person.
If you look at the quote in question, Meta is referring to the respective states of being trans and gay, not to the umbrella category of LGBTQ people. GLAAD adds a “[sic]” after the word “homosexuality,” as if it is not actually in the dictionary.
GLAAD has previously asserted that referring to the “gay community” is verboten because it is not inclusive enough. The nonprofit does, however, permit referring to the “trans community.”
For @[private account], Valerie Van-Dieman asserts that Trump’s EO demanding states crack down on addiction, mental illness and homelessness is the first in a two-step slippery slope that is poised to see transgender people imprisoned and forcibly institutionalized.
She writes that when states “do comply” with the EO “we are then just a step away from the nightmare scenario: If a state passes a law in full compliance with this order, all it would take is one more law—maybe a statute that officially designates gender dysphoria as a mental illness, or perhaps one that would criminalize affirming a trans minor’s gender—for the right to justify involuntary imprisonment and institutionalization
The Truth About Detransitioning
By Kinnon Ross MacKinnon
In its campaign against transgender rights, the Trump administration has been spotlighting stories of people who have regretted transitioning. A recent Federal Trade Commission event, titled “The Dangers of ‘Gender-Affirming Care’ for Minors,” included testimony from six people who had come to believe their gender transition hurt them more than it helped. The Department of Education marked“Detrans Awareness Day” in March. The following month, the White House orderedthe National Institutes of Health to conduct more research into transition regret (even though it has gutted $800 million in grant funding for L.G.B.T.Q. research).
I am a researcher who studies detransition — what happens when people who have undergone a gender transition decide to stop or reverse it, often halting medical treatments like hormones. I am also transgender, having begun my own medical transition with testosterone 15 years ago, when I was a 25-year-old graduate student. Under the guise of protecting children from medical harm, the Trump administration is oversimplifying detransition and using it as a political cudgel against transgender health care.
My personal experience, that of most trans people I know and a large body of research, show medical transition can help many resolve their gender dysphoria and improve their quality of life. (I live a fulfilling life as a trans man and am the proud father of a 5-year-old.) But it’s also true that a subset of people reverse course after already changing their bodies with hormones or surgeries.
Early studies, from the 1970s until the 2000s, suggested detransition among adults was rare; about 1 percent to 6 percent reversed the process or expressed regret. But somerecent studies among young people have suggested it could now be higher, 5 percent to 10 percent — an increase that has come amid a sharp rise in the number of young people seeking care at gender clinics.
The focus of my research is on why people detransition and what the field of trans health care can learn from these experiences. In conducting what I believe to be the largest study ever designed to understand detransition, surveying nearly 1,000 people about the factors that contributed to their decision, my research team heard from many people whose stories were not all that different from the speakers at the F.T.C. panel. They felt let down by treatments, sometimes terribly so. This fact should encourage medical providers to take detransition seriously, to learn more about how to support people with these experiences.
At the same time, the Trump administration’s rhetoric on detransition is dangerously myopic. We found that many people detransition not out of regret, but because they feel forced by societal factors like negative attitudes toward transgender people, attitudes that are being amplified by the Trump administration. I believe that acknowledging the full complexity of detransition — that it can unfold with ambivalence, regrets, resilience and even satisfaction — is the best path toward better care.
My study, which will be published in the coming months, found that respondents fall into four different camps.
A second group, representing about 20 percent of respondents, cited changing gender identity, but generally did not feel regret about their earlier transition. Many felt strongly that they flourished through their transition, even if they ultimately evolved in their identity and gender expression. One survey participant, who started with a masculinizing transition, recalled wondering if her original choice to take testosterone was “the wrong decision.” Ultimately, she decided it wasn’t. The experience had allowed her to mentor other queer and trans people. She liked her slightly deepened voice. “I am pretty happy with where I am, gender transition-wise,” she said.
[See gift link below for hr remainder.]
Here’s the full letter:
We are writers, editors, publishers and booksellers who stand in solidarity with the trans community. We are profoundly disappointed by the Polari Prize’s decision to include John Boyne on the longlist for this year’s Polari Book Prize.
The prize, in its own words, was founded on principles of diversity and inclusion. In a statement published on Instagram this week, it reasserted its commitment to supporting trans rights and amplifying trans voices.
John Boyne has publicly and unequivocally associated himself with trans exclusionary sentiments, most recently describing himself as a “fellow Terf” in an article for the Irish Independent, celebrating JK Rowling’s 60th birthday (John Boyne on JK Rowling: ‘As a writer, I’m in awe of her achievements. As a reader, I love her work. And as a fellow Terf, I stand four-square behind her’, 27 July 2025).
Mr Boyne’s public statements on trans rights and identity are incompatible with the LGBTQ+ community’s most basic standards of inclusion. Trans people’s existence and their right to live full public lives as they choose are matters of fact, not questions for debate.
In any year, the decision to include Mr Boyne on the longlist would be, in our view, inappropriate and hurtful to the wider community of LGBTQ+ readers and writers. That the decision has been made this year — in the context of rising anti-trans hatred and systematic exclusion of trans people from public life in the UK and across the world — is inexcusable.
We stand in solidarity with Nicola Dinan, a former winner of the Polari First Book Prize and judge for this year's First Book Prize, who has resigned from the jury. We also offer our solidarity to the other writers on the longlists, whose work doesn't deserve to be overshadowed by this decision.
We believe in the celebration of LGBTQ+ voices in UK publishing. We want there to be a literary prize that recognises the vital importance of queer and trans stories. That’s why we’re calling on the Polari Prize to formally remove Mr Boyne from the longlist, to restore the integrity of this prize as a safe, inclusive and celebratory space for the LGBTQ+ community.
A controversy is brewing in the UK over the Polari prize for LGBTQ literature, after a so-called TERF, John Boyle, was long listed. Trans advocates are asserting he has no place on the list.
In response to a report that Republicans are reprising the impactful “Kamala is for they/them” ad strategy for the midterms, Andrew Lawrence, deputy director of rapid response at Media Matters, says:
“literally the only counter argument you need is ‘jeffrey epsteins best friend wants to repeatedly inspect your childs genitals
“democrats are going to be dealing with anti-trans hate until they either
“- nut the fuck up and defend these people from bigoted attacks
“- concede to every republican attack on the issue, inevitably leading to the total eradication of trans people from all public life
“literally the only 2 options”
The @ACLU’s Chase Strangio reposted Lawrence’s assertion about the Democrats’ two options.
LINK: Leading Trans Litigator Debates Andrew Sullivan about pediatric gender medicine, and I respond
https://benryan.substack.com/p/leading-trans-litigator-debates-andrew
Shannon Minter, legal director at the National Center for LGBTQ Rights, held a spirited debate about pediatric gender medicine with Sullivan on his podcast. Then I gave critiques of their arguments.
Leading Trans Litigator Debates Andrew Sullivan about pediatric gender medicine, and I respond
Shannon Minter, legal director at the National Center for LGBTQ Rights @[private account], held a spirited debate about pediatric gender medicine with Sullivan on his podcast. Then I gave critiques of their arguments.
Link in the thread.
Journalist Walker Bragman pushes back against people on Threads urging him to back down from his absolutist stance that any argument about unfairness regarding trans females competing in girls’ and women’s sports is bigotry and must be resisted. He asserts that similar arguments have been made about black people’s athletic ability and this is just more of the same.
Bragman says: “Bigots are many things, including unoriginal.
“The same bullshit arguments are rehashed over and over.
“We don’t have the luxury of skipping those fights. We have to have them every time the political right finds a new target.
“Fight every battle for equality. All at once. Take every win we can.”
Quoting @benryanwriter: After Pete Buttigieg reiterated his sympathy for parents who have concerns about fairness with the inclusion of trans girls in girls’ sports, Bleuskie users again erupted in rage, asserting he was siding with bigotry, with some even suggesting he supported the ultimate murder of trans people.
Debunking podcaster Michael Hobbes joins others on Bleuskie in asserting that the only people who express concerns about trans girls participating in girls’ sports are transphobes. This after @PeteButtigieg expressed sympathy for such concerns.
Quoting @benryanwriter: Debunking podcaster Michael Hobbes asserts that most parents “don’t give a shit” about trans girls playing in girls’ sports. This despite polling finding that most Americans oppose such inclusion. He also asserts that sports bodies have already taken care of this issue. This despite the fact that research suggests that trans women maintain a competitive advantage in women’s sports even after sustained estrogen treatment.
Debunking podcaster Michael Hobbes asserts that most parents “don’t give a shit” about trans girls playing in girls’ sports. This despite polling finding that most Americans oppose such inclusion. He also asserts that sports bodies have already taken care of this issue. This despite the fact that research suggests that trans women maintain a competitive advantage in women’s sports even after sustained estrogen treatment.
After Pete Buttigieg reiterated his sympathy for parents who have concerns about fairness with the inclusion of trans girls in girls’ sports, Bleuskie users again erupted in rage, asserting he was siding with bigotry, with some even suggesting he supported the ultimate murder of trans people.
I sourced the survey on LGBAPQ identities from this @BostonGlobe editorial by Sandy Ernest Allen.
https://archive.is/20250804154202/https://www.bostonglobe.com/2025/08/04/metro/brown-university-trans-students-sacrificed/#selection-1489.33-1489.35
JK Rowling asserts that the dramatic shift against the main platforms of the trans-rights movement—inclusion in sports, the availability of gender-transition drugs to children—in the UK has been the product of greater awareness among the general public of the issues at play.
Quoting @jk_rowling: This shift in attitudes shown below isn't because of increased intolerance, but of an increase in understanding, and trans activists themselves bear the greatest responsibility for the change.
Five years ago, a lot of medical bodies (and trans activist organisations, lobby groups and virtue-signalling celebrities) were united in telling us that puberty blockers were completely reversible and harmless. As more and more evidence accrues showing actual and potential harm, public opinion, unlike trans activism, has shifted in line with the data.
Five years ago, the sophisticated, fashionable line was that sex difference didn't really matter in sport. Trans activists demanded that the women's category be destroyed to accommodate men who claim to be female, but the public wasn't willing to pretend they couldn't see the injustice right in front of their faces.
Five years ago, trans activists and professional lanyard- wearers were chiding us all to use preferred pronouns, because that was kind. Now the public see convicted rapists described as 'she' and 'her' by news outlets and are rightly enraged that journalists are feeding us ideological fiction instead of facts.
Five years ago, a lot of people, especially older ones, were under the impression that trans-identified men had all had full sex reassignment surgery and were sexually orientated towards other men. They didn't know that cross-dressing straight men were now asserting the right to enter all women's reserved spaces. They didn't know how few trans women have had 'bottom surgery.' They know now.
Trans activists are to blame for the hounding and persecution of non-believers, which has spilled into British courts. Women have had to fight all over again for rights they thought they'd have forever. The Cass Review brought shame on all who lobbied to continue a broadly unresearched and unevidenced medical experiment on minors. Trust in institutions, in academia, the media and the medical profession has been severely undermined. Politicians have beclowned themselves, willing to parrot self-contradictory slogans and outright absurdities rather than defend truth and freedom of speech.
The stark change in attitudes over the past five years is the direct consequence of the way trans activists set out to 'educate' us all. Giddy with the power they'd been handed by people in authority, they've tried to impose a quasi-religious, elitist, minority belief upon the whole of society. They can't complain (although, of course, they will) that the public has decided it doesn't want to buy what they're selling.
Chicago hospitals are scaling back trans care for youth. A rapid response team is stepping in.
The team has a network of practitioners in Illinois who don’t rely on payments from the federal government, which threatens to cut funding to gender-affirming care providers.
As more hospitals in Chicago cut back care for trans youth, advocates have launched a rapid response team to connect families with other doctors and cover the cost of everything from appointments to medication.
The response team has built a network of at least 30 doctors and nurse practitioners in private practice throughout Illinois who provide hormone therapy or blockers to delay puberty. It also includes roughly 10 physicians who will perform surgeries, said Asher McMaher, executive director of Trans Up Front Illinois, an advocacy organization that put out the call to providers for help.
Many of these physicians and nurse practitioners don’t rely as heavily as hospitals on federal payments — or at all. As a result, they aren’t under as much pressure as the Trump administration threatens to cut federal funding to providers offering gender-affirming care, McMaher said. But even though these private providers offer care, not all patients will be able to afford the cost if they have to pay out of pocket.
Dr. Jessica Lapinski is a family medicine physician in suburban Bloomingdale who opened her practice three years ago. More than 50% of her patients receive gender-affirming care, and since UChicago Medicine suddenly stopped this treatment for youth earlier this month, she said her phone has been buzzing with panicked parents.
Lately, Lapinski’s conversations with her patients have extended beyond their health. They ask about escape plans and safe places to live, including outside the U.S.
“It’s very heartbreaking,” she said.
Lapinski doesn’t take government-funded health insurance, including Medicaid, which covers people who are low income or have a disability. She charges a $150 monthly membership fee for a kid seeking gender affirming care, and she says she works with families who can’t afford that.
Trans journalist Mady Castigan expresses her rage toward Brown for agreeing to Trump’s terms about trans students, saying, “Brown is run by transphobic TERFs.”
Enraged, journalist Walker Bragman issues followup comments about @PeteButtigieg’s remarks about trans girls in sports.
“No, there’s no middle ground,” he says. “It’s human rights or discrimination.”
“Burned out political writer” Joshua Holland weighs in, while debunking podcaster Michael Hobbes broadcasts his assertion that there is no legitimate claim that trans girls’ inclusion in girls’ sports represents a fairness concern.
In response to @PeteButtigieg asserting that parents have legitimate concerns about fairness should transgender girls participate in girls sports, a chorus of disapproval has erupted on Bleuskie, with journalist Walter Bragman insisting that there is no such legitimate concern.
Quoting @benryanwriter: Journalist Walter Bragman issues a blistering response to @PeteButtigieg’s statement over trans inclusion in sports, calling it “craven shit” and saying Mr. Buttigieg is catering to bigots.
“To just put a fine point on it: Parents do not, in fact, have legitimate concerns about trans kids playing sports,” Mr. Bragman says.
“Just because they believe bullshit doesn’t make it legitimate.
“Fuck anti-trans bigots.”
Journalist Walter Bragman issues a blistering response to @PeteButtigieg’s statement over trans inclusion in sports, calling it “craven shit” and saying Mr. Buttigieg is catering to bigots.
“To just put a fine point on it: Parents do not, in fact, have legitimate concerns about trans kids playing sports,” Mr. Bragman says.
“Just because they believe bullshit doesn’t make it legitimate.
“Fuck anti-trans bigots.”
The Advocate reports: "Asked whether a parent concerned about their child facing a trans kid in girls’ sports 'has a case,' Pete Buttigieg @PeteButtigieg said, “Sure.” But he rejected blanket policies like the federal bans being enacted by the Trump administration, saying, “These decisions should be in the hands of sports leagues and school boards and not politicians, least of all politicians in Washington trying to use this as a political pawn.”
This statement has inspired a blistering response on Bleuskie—see the 🧵⬇️
Dylan Mulvaney, the musical theater performer turned transgender TikTok personality, who has prompted fierce backlash after, most notably, posting a beer endorsement video, will star in a one-person show off-Broadway this fall: "The Least Problematic Woman in the World."
LINK: How Harvard Teed Up the False Claim That the 'Vast Majority of Minors Getting Gender-Affirming Surgeries Are Cis Kids'
https://benryan.substack.com/p/how-harvard-teed-up-the-false-claim
An opaquely written Harvard study and linked press release prompted false reporting that gynecomastia surgeries for boys are vastly more common than gender-affirming surgeries for trans kids.
Twice this evening, I read an article that credulously referred to a research letter out of @Harvard from last year that falsely claimed gynecomastia surgeries for boys are vastly more common than gender-affirming surgeries for trans kids and that the latter surgeries are rare.
Kindly read my rebuttal, linked below.
This all makes me stop and reflect about how often certain people claim that certain media outlets publish falsehoods about pediatric gender medicine. These people blame said media outlets for the Biden Justice Department's loss in US v Skrmetti. And yet here we have Harvard itself putting out a clearly misleading study, one that all of the other media outlets that presumably never publish anything misleading on this subject parrot without question.
Do people not see the duplicity here?
California state senator Scott Wiener criticizes Kaiser Permanente, which announced today it would “pause” gender-transition surgeries for youth under age 19, for bowing to the Trump administration, saying the hospital system violates state law by denying such interventions.
Wiener also says that the Trump administration seeks to erase LGBTQ people from public life. However, overwhelmingly, the Trump administration has attacked trans identities and not gay identities or people. That said, much of the research funded by the NIH that the administration has summarily canceled has focused on gay people. As well as trans people
Quotes a post by a private account; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
For those asking whether calling someone trans is defamatory, a parallel is a lawsuit in which a woman posed for stock photography shots that were ultimately used for an HIV-related ad campaign that presented her as HIV-positive, which she was not. A key question in the case against Getty Images was whether being thought of as HIV positive would be a negative and stigmatizing thing. The woman won her lawsuit, in part because, yes, people stigmatize others who have HIV.
NEWS: French President Emmanuel Macron @EmmanuelMacron and his wife Brigitte have sued ultra-conservative media personality Candace Owens @RealCandaceO for, among other things, claiming that the first lady is transgender.
LINK: Leaked Gender-Affirmative Training, Part 6: Doubting the Need For Distress
https://benryan.substack.com/p/leaked-gender-affirmative-training-8b2
A social-worker colleague of Dr. Johanna Olson-Kennedy argues that children with cross-sex identities should not need to demonstrate distress to be taken seriously as being transgender.
Leaked Gender-Affirmative Training, Part 6: Doubting the Need For Distress
A social-worker colleague of Dr. Johanna Olson-Kennedy argues that children with cross-sex identities should not need to demonstrate distress to be taken seriously as being transgender.
Here is a preview. For the full video, see the thread.
More moderate voices on gender medicine like Laura Edwards-Leeper, who co-founded the nation’s first gender clinic and helped develop the transgender advocacy group WPATH’s standards of care, believes that Planned Parenthood is operating “beyond their scope of practice.” Her young adult patients have told her about how quickly they were able to get hormone treatments from Planned Parenthood. “It really seems that their protocol is substandard and lacks the rigor necessary for a life-altering intervention,” Edwards-Leeper said.
Planned Parenthood has also rapidly expanded its services into one of the most contested and politicized areas of healthcare, gender transitions. Its national office does not reveal numbers on these services, instead grouping them into an “other services” category in its annual report. In 2019, that category included 17,791 cases. It rose to 77,858 in 2023. With trans-identified minors, Planned Parenthood follows an “informed consent” model, which, according to its patient guidelines, enables patients to get a same-day prescription for cross-sex hormones after a 30-minute in-person or remote consultation with a staff member. No professional diagnosis is required.
Additional recent news in pediatric gender medicine:
Dr. Rachel Levine Denies Having Pressured WPATH to Remove Age Limits on Minors' Gender Treatments
https://benryan.substack.com/p/dr-rachel-levine-denies-having-pressured
Subpoenaed records indicate that the former Biden health official, once the highest-ranking openly transgender member of government, did indeed do this, and explicitly for political reasons.
Trans journalist Parker Molloy responds angrily to Gavin Newsom’s recent shift on transgender issues:
Quoting @benryanwriter: California Gov. Gavin Newsom says an interview with Shawn Ryan that he thinks the issue of gender-transition medical interventions hurt Democrats in the November election. He expresses reservations about medical transitions for younger minors in particular.
He expresses ambivalence over the science backing gender-transition treatments for children, and airs his frustration over how contradictory the different factions are who weigh in on this scientific issue.
"It is a major problem for the Democratic party," Newsom of trans issues.
NEW STUDY: A survey conducted just before Trump's inauguration found that even during that period, transgender adults were highly concerned about the potential of losing access to cross-sex hormone treatment.
In this non-representative internet survey, 6.5% of respondents expressed what the study authors characterized as active suicidal ideation as a likely reaction to losing access to such medication, and 15% expressed what the authors characterized as passive suicidal ideation as a likely response.
Out of 690 trans adults who responded to an internet survey, 489 responded to a pair of questions about concern regarding losing access to cross-sex hormones. Thirty-two percent said that they would consider "do-it-yourself hormone therapy" if they lost such access.
“This is a population that already feels that their access to care is constantly under threat, and so when you have somebody going into power that is campaigning on removing their access to care they believe it,” Teresa Graziano, a professor of nursing at the University of Vermont and lead author of the study, said in a press release. “It was startling.”
Americans also do not use condoms, but the infection rate in the US is far lower and is largely limited to small subpopulations, including gay men and transgender women. So the chance that an American will contract HIV is drastically lower.
Assistant professor at Penn to publish book asserting: “Sex Isn’t Real.”
From the description: “In Sex Isn’t Real, Beans Velocci traces the history of current high stakes attempts to define sex and to create a world devoid of trans life. Drawing on lab notes, family genealogies, medical case studies, and more, Velocci follows scientists and clinicians from the mid-nineteenth through the mid-twentieth century and across five disciplines—zoology, eugenics, gynecology, statistical sexology, and transsexual medicine—as their ideas and practices created a definitional tangle. They demonstrate how the sorting of bodies into male and female persists not despite but because of sex’s incoherence: the defining features of these categories shift to contain various understandings of anatomy and physiology, theories of race, developments in research and medical methodologies, and bodies that cannot be accounted for in a binary framework. Exposing the endless work required to produce a world in which most people have a binary gender identity that neatly fits their binarily sexed body, Velocci demonstrates that it is not cis people who fit the categories; it’s the categories that flex to make them fit.”
Quotes a post by T20728; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
A must-read by Jessica Riedl, who has been savagely—and shamefully—maligned, harassed, threatened and doxxed by an online mob, including by @Not_the_Bee (and, by extension, @TheBabylonBee), just because she came out as transgender while working as a prominent and well-respected economist:
"When the Online Mob Came After Me—and My Kids
"A Response to an Online Harassment and Doxing Campaign, by @[private account].
"Over the past few weeks, I—and my family—have been subject to an aggressive internet harassment campaign. Thousands of strangers have smeared my name, sent insane direct messages, and made more than a few death threats. Podcasters and radio hosts have slandered me with fictional tales about my private life, such as that I “abandoned my family.” My kids have been doxed by a leading website with millions of readers. What triggered this torrent of abuse?
"As a modestly public figure, I committed the unforgiveable crime of existing while transgender."
Quotes a post by T04592; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Two trans journalists, Parker Molloy and Evan Urquhart, express their disdain toward Gavin Newsom for his recent skepticism regarding many of the leading principles that animate the transgender movement:
Quoting @benryanwriter: California Gov. Gavin Newsom says an interview with Shawn Ryan that he thinks the issue of gender-transition medical interventions hurt Democrats in the November election. He expresses reservations about medical transitions for younger minors in particular.
He expresses ambivalence over the science backing gender-transition treatments for children, and airs his frustration over how contradictory the different factions are who weigh in on this scientific issue.
"It is a major problem for the Democratic party," Newsom of trans issues.
The Atlantic piece also links to this very misleading study:
How Harvard Teed Up the False Claim That the 'Vast Majority of Minors Getting Gender-Affirming Surgeries Are Cis Kids'
https://benryan.substack.com/p/how-harvard-teed-up-the-false-claim
An opaquely written Harvard study and linked press release prompted false reporting that gynecomastia surgeries for boys are vastly more common than gender-affirming surgeries for trans kids.
Researchers Found Puberty Blockers And Hormones Didn’t Improve Trans Kids’ Mental Health At Their Clinic. Then They Published A Study Claiming The Opposite. (Updated)
A critique of Tordoff et al. (2022), by @JesseSingal
https://jessesingal.substack.com/p/researchers-found-puberty-blockers
"A Strange Time to Be Trans"
"In this particular culture war, some self-described skeptics look less like truth-tellers than merchants of doubt," Writes @Harvard English professor Stephanie Burt @[private account] in @TheAtlantic
Note the referencing of the Tordoff et al study, which falsely suggested that one year of gender-transition treatment reduced youths' suicidality, despite the fact that there was no change in the mental health of the treatment group and there was dramatic loss to follow-up in the untreated comparison group.
And note the comparison of gender-transition surgeries in minors that destroy functioning (mostly mastectomies that eliminate the ability to breastfeed) to cosmetic surgeries in other minors that do not (eg: gynecomastia surgeries in boys).
California Gov. Gavin Newsom says an interview with Shawn Ryan that he thinks the issue of gender-transition medical interventions hurt Democrats in the November election. He expresses reservations about medical transitions for younger minors in particular.
He expresses ambivalence over the science backing gender-transition treatments for children, and airs his frustration over how contradictory the different factions are who weigh in on this scientific issue.
"It is a major problem for the Democratic party," Newsom of trans issues.
While the Trump administration has not explicitly targeted gay civil rights as he has with transgender rights, his administration has nevertheless sweepingly canceled NIH research grants related to gay people and HIV. As I reported for NBC in April, this is causing the entire field of LGBTQ-related research to collapse.
Quoting @unherd: ‘There was a significant spike in usage during the [Republican] convention!’
@[private account] CEO George Arison @[private account], talks with UnHerd’s @[private account] about the gay hookup app’s evolution, identity filters, whether gays are becoming more conservative, and if Trump is pro-gay.
Supreme Court Agrees to Hear Cases Involving Transgender Athletes
The court announced it would hear challenges to state laws barring transgender athletes from girls’ and women’s sports.
"It Feels Like I'm In a Body That Isn't My Own": Voices From the NYC Pride Parade Post-Skrmetti
The Bens—@benryanwriter and @[private account]—took to the streets on Sunday to speak with queer people about gender identity and transition at this historic turning point in LGBTQ history.
[Note: Please BE RESPECTFUL to the people in this video, thanks!]
“Let me tell you what puberty does to your mind: I had to slowly watch myself transform into something I hated. That does damage to children.”
That’s what a transgender person told my friend and fellow reporter Ben Kawaller on Sunday when he and I took to the streets of Manhattan to take the temperature among attendees of the LGBTQ Pride parade at this historic juncture in the transgender movement in particular.
We wanted to talk to people about how they were feeling about the state of the LGBTQ movement, which has faced a number of recent setbacks, from Trump's executive order recognizing only two genders, to the Skrmetti Supreme Court decision upholding Tennessee’s ban on gender-transition treatment for minors.
Interestingly, only one person we asked about whether children should receive such treatment thought there should be any substantial guardrails around such access: a trans woman who thought it was much better for children to wait until they were 14 or 16 “to understand what they want.” Most of the others were keen to downplay or equivocate about any risks or downsides. One of them even compared such treatment to smoking in an effort to suggest that lots of things have risks and that giving cross-sex hormones to children isn’t so exceptional.
One person had a very interesting response when I asked: Why change the body to alleviate the suffering of the mind?
“Why put a prosthetic on an amputee?” the person replied.
Penn agrees to comply with the Trump admin’s demands to keep trans women out of women’s athletics: https://titleixoffice.upenn.edu/about/title-ix-compliance-in-athletics
That's beside the point at this point as far as I'm concerned. What matters if that she came out as trans and has suffered uncanny abuse, which is shameful. Wesley has lost the plot to keep obsessing over the trans brain issue.
Cathy Young, in an opinion essay for The Boston Globe, asks whether there is room for a moderate path on transgender rights amid a highly and viciously polarized debate. She mentions, for example, how I've been viciously attacked for advocating for using preferred pronouns.
Quotes a post by T02364; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Despite the fact that the subpoenaed WPATH records show that the lead author of the Standards of Care 8 trans-care guidelines told his colleagues that the evidence backing pediatric gender transition treatment was too weak to support their recommendations, and despite the fact that WPATH suppressed at least one systematic literature review that they commissioned from Johns Hopkins when they didn't like the results, Hobbes dismisses any such revelations as the mere downstream effects of right-wing politicization.
Michael Hobbes then essentially parrots Chase Strangio of the ACLU, dismissing the subpoenaed records about WPATH's development of their Standards of Care trans-care guidelines as being cherry picked and nothing worth writing home about. That all of the revelations therein boiled down to the conspiracy theories of the right wing.
Despite the fact that, for example, the emails show the head of WPATH, Dr. Marci Bowers, conspiring with her colleagues to lie to Reuters about why they removed all the age limits on gender treatments and surgeries, Hobbes says, “nothing is actually all that incriminating here.”
https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-supreme-court-goes-full-terf/id1651876897?i=1000715066549&r=2787
This material may be protected by copyright.
https://benryan.substack.com/p/insidious-the-aclus-chase-strangio
Michael Hobbes cites a video @MattWalshBlog posted of a Vanderbilt doctor discussing trans medicine in which the doctor, as Hobbes recounts, “warned that conscientious objections" by Vanderbilt doctors "are problematic. Anyone who decides not to be involved in transition surgeries due to religious beliefs will face, quote, consequences.”
Hobbes objects to the doctor not being direct enough in what he believes she is implying. He believes, he says, she should say, "'I believe that anyone who objects to this is doing so due to bigotry,' which is correct.”
This assertion of Hobbes' presumes that there are absolutely no substantive reasons for a doctor to object to providing life-altering medical interventions to minors that might render them infertile or remove healthy body parts such as breasts such that they lose their function. It presumes that there is no substantive debate among doctors and researchers globally about these treatments and that the only objections are invidious.
Hobbes' claim thus dismisses as based in bigotry the medical authorities in five European nations that have assessed the evidence backing pediatric medicine through systematic literature reviews--the gold standard of scientific evidence--and have concluded that their nations needed to drastically restrict access to these treatments to minors, given they are experimental and the evidence backing them is wanting and uncertain.
Michael Hobbes, referring to a video, published in 2022 by @MattWalshBlog, of a Vanderbilt doctor talking about the money that gender-transition surgeries bring in, including bottom surgeries: “Bottom surgeries are essentially not performed on children," Hobbes says. "So the fact that she's talking about bottom surgeries here makes it very clear that she's talking about adults.”
This depends on your definition of "essentially." Phallopasties are not recommended by @[private account] for minors, but vaginoplasties are. Dr. Marci Bowers, a gender-affirming surgeon and a former WPATH president, recommends that trans girls get a vaginoplasty the summer before they leave for college, when they are 17 or 18.
A 2023 paper on a limited dataset of US minor patients did find evidence of one vaginoplasty in 2021. This suggests that if the study authors had access to all records in the nation, they would identify more such surgeries in minors.
Consequently, Hobbes is incorrect to presume that the Vanderbilt doctor was not referring to minors in the speech that Walsh published. It is entirely possible she was.
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10599689/pdf/cureus-0015-00000045948.pdf
For @TheAtlantic, @HelenLewis writes on the longstanding, non-evidence-based claim that pediatric gender-transition treatment is lifesaving:
But there is a huge problem with this emotive formulation: It isn’t true. When Justice Samuel Alito challenged the @ACLU lawyer Chase Strangio on such claims during oral arguments, Strangio made a startling admission. He conceded that there is no evidence to support the idea that medical transition reduces adolescent suicide rates.
At first, Strangio dodged the question, saying that research shows that blockers and hormones reduce “depression, anxiety, and suicidality”—that is, suicidal thoughts. (Even that is debatable, according to reviews of the researchliterature.) But when Alito referenced a systematic review conducted for the Cass report in England, Strangio conceded the point. “There is no evidence in some—in the studies that this treatment reduces completed suicide,” he said. “And the reason for that is completed suicide, thankfully and admittedly, is rare, and we’re talking about a very small population of individuals with studies that don’t necessarily have completed suicides within them.”
Here was the trans-rights movement’s greatest legal brain, speaking in front of the nation’s highest court. And what he was saying was that the strongest argument for a hotly debated treatment was, in fact, not supported by the evidence.
https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2025/06/transgender-youth-skrmetti/683350/?gift=KkbsgAqgmImeUM71Y0bfDGkC3IsQDoksjmIA-mA_ny4&utm_source=copy-link&utm_medium=social&utm_campaign=share
I reported on the Finnish suicide study last year for the @NYPost:
https://nypost.com/2024/02/24/opinion/a-finnish-study-is-changing-how-we-approach-trans-kids/
I have never seen any research to suggest any other means outside of potentially preventing suicide death by which prescribing puberty blockers and cross-sex hormones to minors with gender dysphoria might prevent death. I did, however, hear Johanna Olson-Kennedy theorize in The Protocol by @NYTimes that if Black trans women had transitioned during puberty and were thus able to pass better, they might be less likely to be murdered. But no one has ever studied this.
Today I:
*Got dragged by the left for saying Mamdani won the primary with a sliver of the electorate.
*Got dragged by the right for saying misgendering is bad.
*Went to the NYC pride parade and interviewed trans people about the Supreme Court decisions.
*Went to an event where there were various people who are mad at me from the left about my reporting on pediatric gender reporting and who gave me the stink eye.
*Went home to my cats, who were mad that I’d been out all day.
Actually, The Atlantic has been out front asking tough questions about pediatric gender medicine for the past seven years.
See: https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2018/07/when-a-child-says-shes-trans/561749/?gift=KkbsgAqgmImeUM71Y0bfDOrgoBc_Atmm8PuB0P8rKG8
The link to the suicide stats do not say anything about hormones being the answer to those stats; so your argument that she’s implying kids should get hormones fall flat. She’s quite evidently referring to hate from people such as yourself causing poor mental health in transgender people.
She does not mention gender transitions for minors in the essay. She does argue that trans identity is biological. You may think she’s implying that kids should be able to transition medically, but she never said so in the essay.
How anyone could conceive of this piece, which emphases that many gays feel wedded to the trans cause, while accurately pointing out that some gays feel the opposite, is “anti-trans” is truly beyond me. The headline, after all, emphasizes the connectivity, not the opposition.
Isaiah does not care about the feelings of transgender people.
Quoting @IsaiahLCarter: I don't care.
Fuck their feelings.
I don't give a fuck how "rude" or "cruel" one might think of me for living in objective truth and reality.
If I'm handed an instructions manual by some troon as to how to address them, they're getting laughed at, told to fuck off.
Sick of this shit.
Why I Use Trans People’s Preferred Pronouns
https://benryan.substack.com/p/why-i-use-trans-peoples-preferred
Regardless of whether there will ever be any winners in the battle of the genders, I choose being kind over waging war.
How to inspire a deluge of insufferable remarks: Say that you will not misgender transgender people and that people who do so are jerks.
Quoting @benryanwriter: Bravo to @MattYglesias for forbidding misgendering, which is cruel and only reflects poorly on the character of the person calling Sarah McBride “he”.
This claim of Katelyn Burns’ is false.
The New York Times’ six-part podcast on pediatric gender-transition treatment, “The Protocol,” included a lengthy interview with Dr. Marci Bowers, an American trans woman, leading gender-affirming surgeon, and the former president of the World Professional Association for Transgender Health, or WPATH.
The podcast also included lengthy excerpts from voice notes sent in by numerous transgender Americans.
Jesse Singal asks whether @GLAAD and the @ACLU will learn from what he characterizes as the consequences of their overreach on transgender activism.
Here is how the ACLU's Chase Strangio responded to the Skrmetti loss and the Times criticism of him:
https://benryan.substack.com/p/insidious-the-aclus-chase-strangio
For The Dispatch, @JesseSingal writes:
I’d go back to the campaign against the Times reporters as a prime example: Katie J. M. Baker, Azeen Ghorayshi, and Emily Bazelon allpublished careful, in-depth work that examined the new claims being made by LGBT rights groups, presented the different sides of the arguments, and treated trans people themselves with the utmost respect. They were met not with “Thank you for taking this seriously—here’s some stuff we disagree with” by groups like GLAAD, but with the sort of reputational napalming one would normally reserve for an outright Nazi. GLAAD famously even parked a truck, emblazoned with the phrase “Stop questioning trans people’s right to exist & access to medical care” outside the Timesbuilding. (“The science is settled,” a laughably false claim, was on the truck as well.)
The trans rights movement needed an Andrew Sullivan type, and instead it got Chase Strangio. Whether or not you agree with Sullivan, it’s undeniable that the average American can read one of his columns, understand it, and rarely feel like Sullivan is making wild leaps of logic or accusing them of bigotry for not accepting his arguments. The same is not true of figures like Strangio.
Quoting @jessesingal: I try to focus more on the science of the youth gender medicine debate than what activists are doing, but I couldn't resist writing a piece for The Dispatch on the disastrous and alienating recent performances of the ACLU and GLAAD.
https://thedispatch.com/article/transgender-court-skrmetti-argument/
Mere hours after publication, the president of the American Academy of Pediatrics, Susan Kressly, claimed that the review was undermined by reliance on “a narrow set of data.” A glance at the evidence synthesis (or even just the separate appendix) by anyone familiar with evidence-based medicine would show that this complaint is preposterous. The hypocrisy is blatant: the AAP @[private account] ’s policy statement for the treatment of gender-dysphoric youth is unsupported by its own citations.
Equally baseless was the statement issued by the World Professional Association for Transgender Health @[private account] the day after the review’s publication, saying it “misrepresents existing research.” If it does, why not clinch the case with some examples? Yet none were provided.
The price of speaking out no doubt contributed to the collapse of medical safeguarding in the United States. A more subtle influence is the language used by proponents of pediatric medical transition, which is euphemistic and often misleading. “Gender-affirming top surgery” sounds entirely positive, and papers over the salient fact that the breasts of physically healthy teenagers are removed. Patients who undergo irreversible surgery and later regret it are said to have “dynamic desires for gender-affirming medical interventions.” The usual words to indicate a young patient’s sex are disallowed: female children are “individuals assigned female at birth” or “trans boys,” and are never simply “girls.” This has the Orwellian effect of making plain truths impossible to state. https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamanetworkopen/fullarticle/2794550
I am hardly a fan of the current administration: I have never voted Republican, and as an academic from Cambridge, Massachusetts, I hold many of the liberal beliefs of my tribe. That includes support for the right of transgender people to live free from discrimination and prejudice.
This does not mean the L.G.B.T.Q.+ project should be shut down entirely. We need to defend our wins; we need to protect the interests of gays, lesbians and trans people. We need to greatly expand help and care for children with gender dysphoria, prevent bullying and increase mental health resources. Protecting them from often irreversible sex changes should not mean abandoning them. It should mean renewed concern, support and, above all, solid, evidence-based research on how best we can help.
Returning to a civil rights model and abandoning the quixotic attempt to end the sex binary do not mean, as some might have it, throwing trans people under the bus. Trans people are already on the bus; they are protected from employment discrimination under the 1964 Civil Rights Act. Their existing rights should be defended and expanded to public accommodations — especially the adult right to have access to gender medicine through Medicaid, which is now being threatened. Americans should back us on that. But fighting a losing battle to allow trans women to compete in women’s sports and for biological men to be in women’s intimate spaces, and to perpetuate risky, inadequately tested sex changes on children, including gay and lesbian ones, is dumb, offensive to common sense and risks a much bigger backlash.
History strongly suggests that periods of toleration of gay men and lesbians can swiftly end if the public senses an overreach. That may be where we now are. No society has ever been as free for gay men, lesbians and transgender people as the modern West today. There is no such thing as the Human Rights Campaign’s “state of emergency,” and it was absurd to say so. But for some activists, there has to be. As Francis Fukuyama put it in “The End of History and the Last Man,” “Experience suggests that if men cannot struggle on behalf of a just cause because that just cause was victorious in an earlier generation, then they will struggle againstthe just cause.”
If Mr. Trump is against childhood sex reassignment, then we must be for it. If Mr. Trump says there are two sexes, we must insist that there is a spectrum. It will be very hard to break this dynamic in such a tribal atmosphere, especially when there is genuine transphobia among some on the right. But it would be incredibly healthy if we were to allow an actual debate in the community about the direction we are headed in, and treat dissenters less like bigots and traitors. Representative Sarah McBride, the first openly trans member of Congress, echoed this sentiment on @EzraKlein’s podcast last week. But she was condemned on social media as a traitor to trans people.
Now, look at the recent results of the L.G.B.T.Q.+ movement. In the last five years, activists have actually managed to move public opinion away from their causes in many respects. In 2021, for example, 62 percent of Americans said that transgender athletes should be able to play only on teams that matched their gender at birth; by 2023, that figure had risen to 69 percent. This is not bigotry at work. This year, the very same pollster found that a solid majority of Americans — 56 percent — favor policies protecting trans people from discrimination. Americans are broadly fine with transgender people. They are fine with gay people. They just reject replacing the fact of biological sex with the phantasms of gender ideology.
One specific concern for boys who transition to girls in early puberty. “If you’ve never had an orgasm pre-surgery, and then your puberty’s blocked, it’s very difficult to achieve that afterwards,” a pioneering trans surgeon, Dr. Marci Bowers, has said. Research on this is minimal, and so caution is necessary in jumping to conclusions. But I ask myself: If there is a risk that some people will be denied sexual pleasure for their entire life because they transitioned very early, is it worth it? And how can a child understand what giving up orgasms for life might mean when he hasn’t experienced a single one? The obvious answer is that he can’t, and it’s profoundly unethical to put him in that situation. And who exactly is looking out for these kids? Certainly not the L.G.B.T.Q. organizations.
I have met many. They break your heart. And so many of the gender-dysphoric kids are gay and lesbian. Of course they are, and there are many more children who will grow up to be gay and lesbian than who will grow up to be trans. When adolescents referred to a British gender clinic were asked about their sexualityin 2012, some 90 percent of females and 80 percent of males said they were same-sex attracted or bisexual.
And how do today’s parents, teachers and doctors know for surethat a 10-year-old child isn’t, well, like me, and really is trans? How can they know for sure that the gender dysphoria isn’t instead a manifestation of being gay or lesbian and wanting to change it? How do they know for sure there isn’t another complicating personal or psychological factor? I was told not to worry. A child had to demonstrate a “persistent, consistent and insistent” trans identity for years even to be considered for medical intervention.
Kids all over the country were impacted. Your children were taught in elementary school that being a boy or a girl was something they could choose and change at will. Your daughter found herself running against a trans girl (i.e. a biological male) in athletics. Children in elementary school got to pick pronouns, and some children socially transitioned at school without their parents’ knowledge or permission. I suppose there are other ways you can resurrect the ghost of Anita Bryant, and all the homophobic paranoia that followed her, but this will probably do the trick.
Was there any debate among gays and lesbians about this profound change, a vote taken, or even a poll of gay men and lesbians? None that I can find or recall.
And, as in other “social justice” spaces, dissent was equated with bigotry. Dissenters from gender ideology are routinely unfriended, shunned and shamed. Almost all of the gay men, trans people and lesbians who have confided in me that they don’t agree with this, or think that @JK_Rowling or @Martina Navratilova have some good points, have said so sotto voce lest anyone overhear. That’s the extremely intolerant and illiberal atmosphere that now exists in the gay, lesbian and transgender space. This little community used to champion all manner of expression or argument or speech, eccentrics and visionaries. Now it’s fearful, self-censored and extremely uptight. Debate has been all but snuffed out; total uniformity of thought is demanded.
A key leader of this movement, Chase Strangio, informed us that “a penis is not a male body part. It’s just an unusual body part for a woman.” We all were suddenly expected to announce our pronouns as if everyone didn’t already know. Then neopronouns — xe/xem! — were added. The movement came up with a mantra: “TRANS WOMEN ARE WOMEN. TRANS MEN ARE MEN.” It was not an argument, nor a proposition to be explored or debated. It was a theological command. In all caps.
But abolishing the sex binary for the entire society? That’s a whole other thing entirely. And madness, I believe. What if I redefined what it is to be heterosexual and imposed it on straight people? Or changed what it means to be a man or a woman, for that matter? Then it ceases to be accommodation of a minority and becomes a societywide revolution — an overreach that would soon lead to a potent and sane backlash, against not just trans people, but gay men and lesbians as well.
As I watched all this radical change, I wondered, was I just another old fart, shaking my fist at the sky, like every older generation known to man? Why not just accept that the next gay and lesbian generation has new ideas, has moved on, and old-timers like me should just move aside?
And some of the changes are indeed welcome. The greater acceptance of trans people is a huge step forward for all of us. But then, as I told my friends (gay, trans and everyone else), I’d always believed this and always supported trans civil rights. I was glad when, five years ago, the Supreme Court gave transgender people civil rights protection in employment. I’ve also long lived in a gay world that is skewed left, and, along with my fellow gay non-lefties, I’ve long made my peace with it, or tried to.
“Queer” was a way of summing up the new regime, a clear sign that this really was a different movement than the gay, lesbian and transgender civil rights movement of the past. It’s a word that can easily trigger gay men over 40 who remember it as the last slur they once heard before being bashed in the head. But one of the striking aspects of the younger queer generation is their disdain for those who came before them.
They needed a new banner for that. So the rainbow flag, invented back in 1978 at the request of Harvey Milk, was replaced over the last few years by a new “Progress” flag, representing intersectional oppression. Black and brown stripes were added to the rainbow — for Black and brown people (and the people lost during the AIDS crisis) — and pink, light blue and white for trans people. That flag now demarcates a place not simply friendly to all types of people, as the old rainbow flag did, but a place where anyone who does not subscribe to intersectional left ideology is unwelcome.
But this huge increase in funding was no longer primarily about gay, lesbian and transgender civil rights, because almost all had already been won. It was instead about a new and radical gender revolution. Focused on ending what activists saw as the oppression of the sex binary, which some critical gender and queer theorists associated with “white supremacy,” they aimed to dissolve natural distinctions between men and women in society, to replace biological sex with “gender identity” in the law and culture, and to redefine homosexuality, in the process, not as a neutral fact of the human condition but as a liberating ideological “queerness” meant to subvert and “queer” language, culture and society in myriad different ways.
Nonetheless, the money has poured into gay, lesbian and transgender groups in the past decade. Charitable funding for such groups totaled $387 million in 2012, according to the Indiana University Lilly Family School of Philanthropy’s Equitable Giving Lab. By 2021, it was $823 million. L.G.B.T.Q.+ organizations also saw their assets grow 76 percent from 2019 to 2021 — around double the size of their increase in donations. A group like @GLAAD — founded in 1985 to combat anti-gay media bias in the depths of the AIDS epidemic — saw its funding increase sixfold between 2014 and 2023. The Human Rights Campaign @[private account] has also seen revenues soar in the past decade.
In 2023, the Human Rights Campaign @[private account], the largest gay, lesbian and transgender civil rights group in the country, declared a “state of emergency” for gay men, lesbians and transgender people — the first time in the organization’s existence. It had not declared a state of emergency when gay men were jailed for having sex in private, when the AIDS epidemic killed hundreds of thousands of gay men or when we faced a possible constitutional amendment banning marriage equality in 2004. In fact, we found out, this “emergency” was almost entirely in response to new state bills proposing restrictions on medical treatment for minors with gender dysphoria; bathroom and locker room bans; and transgender issues in school curricula and sports.
Ten years ago Thursday, the movement for gay and lesbian equality scored a victory that only a decade before had seemed unimaginable. We won equal rights to civil marriage in every state in the country. In 2020 came another stunning win. In a majority opinion written by one of President Trump’s nominees, Justice Neil Gorsuch, the Supreme Court found that gay men, lesbians and transgender men and women are covered under Title VII of the 1964 Civil Rights Act, and protected from employer discrimination.
In 2024, the Republican Party removed opposition to marriage equality from its platform, and the current Republican Treasury secretary, Scott Bessent, is a married gay man with two children. Gay marriage is backed by around 70 percent of Americans, and discrimination against gay men, lesbians and transgender people is opposed by 80 percent. As civil rights victories go, it doesn’t get more decisive or comprehensive than this.
GIFT LINK: How the Gay Rights Movement Radicalized, and Lost Its Way
By Andrew Sullivan
https://www.nytimes.com/2025/06/26/opinion/gay-lesbian-trans-rights.html?unlocked_article_code=1.R08.UNTn.rcnCfw_BTEMT&smid=url-share
On the pediatric gender-transition treatment story, the basic argument from the Bleuskie set is that it has been journalists' responsibility not to report about any problems with the science backing this medical field, because informing the public of these problems this would run counter to transgender advocacy goals.
But reporters should not be in the business of aligning with advocacy movements.
Oddly, it is the reporters who double as activists in this movement who are most likely to make false claims that reporters who do no such thing are themselves activists working in direct opposition to the advocacy movement.
Very long and nuanced NYT article suggests it was counterproductive to the trans rights movement for anyone who might have some valid questions about pediatric gender-transition treatment to be branded a transphobe.
Joshua Foust, a tenure track professor: This is transphobia.
These people are completely missing the point: that an identity that can require lifelong medication as a part of that identity is a novel issue *compared to being gay*. The context is the gay rights mission compared with the trans rights mission.
Do people think that the trans-rights movement has helped drive the Dems off a cliff?
Quoting @benryanwriter: "Along the road to Skrmetti, some believe, the L.G.B.T.Q. movement drove itself toward a cliff — and took the Democratic Party with it, chaining the Biden administration to one of the most divisive issues in American politics at a moment of shifting medical consensus and fierce polarization. 'It’s one of the biggest mistakes in the history of trans activism,' said @[private account], a trans woman who serves on the board of Rebellion PAC, a Democratic political-action committee. Strangio and other advocates for trans rights have cast Skrmetti as the case they had to bring. It may also have set their movement back a generation."
Judith Butler responds to the Skrmetti Supreme Court decision upholding Tennessee’s ban on pediatric gender-transition treatment:
In upholding Tennessee’s law banning gender-affirming care for youth, the Supreme Court sets aside the findings of every major medical association that to deny such care constitutes a harm to the health of young people. The court surmises that harm may be inflicted by such care, but instead of backing up that point with reliable studies, they pose it as a hypothetical that can only imagine or conjecture possible harm coming from such care.
This decision rests on a confusion about what is “care” and what is “harm.” Indeed, the harm that the decision does by denying care to trans and gender nonconforming youth goes unremarked except in the searing dissent authored by Justice Sotomayor: “The court abandons transgender children and their families to political whims.” After all, she points out, boys can take the same medications to become more masculine, and girls can receive the same treatments to appear more feminine. It appears that only when the treatment allows for transition from one sex to another that it becomes problematic. But if trans people are deprived of a form of care to which non-trans people have access, how is that not a problem of unequal treatment?
Since no harm is done by hormonal therapy per se, we can only conclude that the court understands departures from sex assignment and its social expectations to be the problem. The court itself does harm to the 112,400 transgender youth in Tennessee according to the Williams Institute at UCLA, but it also poses a threat to much-needed care for the estimated 1.6 million transgender youth in the United States.
The court ruled that equal protection was not violated by the Tennessee law, but luckily the decision has no effect on transgender as a protected category under sex discrimination statutes, as established by the Supreme Court’s own decision in Bostock v. Clayton. Nor does it override parental rights to decide the best health care for their children, though it sets up a new possible legal challenge. Since the Tennessee law can still be challenged on other grounds, this is not the end of the story.
But the failure of the court to trust the scientific findings of major medical associations adds to the impression that state institutions decide matters of gender, sex and sexuality on political grounds rather than reflective and thorough review. The fact that Trump’s executive order cites the “immutability” of sex, borrowing the language of the Vatican, over the research of developmental biology is but another case in point where an anti-science attitude prevails. That they fail to see the problem of inequality that Sotomayor clearly underscores is perhaps the most worrisome dimension of this decision.
Another huge difference is that Bill Clinton, facing a Republican Congress, signed the Defense of Marriage Act in 1996. A huge difference from Biden going all-in on trans issues.
The clear difference is that gay advocates took same-sex marriage to the Supreme Court and won, whereas the Biden administration and the ACLU took the fight over bans of pediatric gender-transition treatment to the highest court and lost.
A more subtle difference is that 19 years separated the Times article in question and Obergefell and only about seven years separated the first time many people had heard of gender treatments for minors (probably when Singal covered this in The Atlantic) and Skrmetti.
Lawmakers employed an incremental strategy with gay marriage, first exploring civil unions. Gay rights activists also did not insist on support of marriage as a do-or-die litmus test for their support of politicians. Obama is the most clear example of someone they had to spend a lot of time warming up (at least to get him to take a favorable stance in public). By comparison, trans activism has been more insistent on people supporting the whole package full force. Activists have heaped abuse on people with reluctance or skepticism—a with-us-or-against us method that did not have a close parallel during the gay activism of the 2000s and early 2010s. Social media could have a lot to do with this difference.
I’ve heard some griping, including from people who are angry that Roberts used the term “transgender child.” These people often do not believe there is any such thing as a transgender person, period.
Quotes a post by T16474; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
M Gessen weighs in:
https://www.nytimes.com/2025/06/19/opinion/the-supreme-court-fails-to-see-transgender-teens.html?smid=nytcore-ios-share&referringSource=articleShare
Roberts, in the majority decision, in fact, found that the question of whether the Tennessee law banning pediatric gender-transition treatment hinged on trans identity was not relevant since, he found, it hinged on diagnosis and age. So he did not provide any answer as to whether trans people would qualify as a protected class. And so it was not in his majority decision, but only in a separate concurrent decision by Barrett, that anyone said that trans people have not faced historical discrimination—a criterion for being considered part of a protected class.
Gift link: https://www.nytimes.com/2025/06/19/magazine/scotus-transgender-care-tennessee-skrmetti.html?unlocked_article_code=1.QE8.2C2S.d9s4SDK4hs4G&smid=url-share
The New York Times provides thorough reporting on a landmark Supreme Court ruling.
Activist-blogger Erin Reed reflexively denounces it all as "anti-trans" and makes unfounded claim that the paper "wanted" the court to allow bans on pediatric gender-transition treatments.
Raise your hand if you've been attacked online or off for reporting about the sudden rise in gender dysphoria in youth, including questions about social contagion as a factor. 👋
From @[private account]'s new @[private account] article on the trans activist movement:
Quoting @benryanwriter: Online and off, trans activists attacked journalists and academicswho explored whether the sudden rise in dysphoria among teenagers was linked to social media and peer influence or reported on “detransitioners” — people who abandoned a trans identity and sometimes regretted undergoing medical transition. When the journalist @AbigailShrier published her 2020 book “Irreversible Damage: The Transgender Craze Seducing Our Daughters” — casting the rise in dysphoria among teenage girls as a form of social contagion — Strangio tweeted that “stopping the circulation of this book and these ideas is 100% a hill I will die on.”
4. How Harvard Teed Up the False Claim That the 'Vast Majority of Minors Getting Gender-Affirming Surgeries Are C-s Kids'
https://benryan.substack.com/p/how-harvard-teed-up-the-false-claim
An opaquely written Harvard study and linked press release prompted false reporting that gynecomastia surgeries for boys are vastly more common than gender-affirming surgeries for trans kids.
A must-read that diagrams how Chase Strangio at the @ACLU and others in what @MattYglesias, for one, calls The Groups—the advocacy nonprofits that form a backbone of Democratic power structures—advocated for maximalist advances in trans rights and lost spectacularly.
Quoting @benryanwriter: How the Transgender Rights Movement Bet on the Supreme Court and Lost
The inside story of the case that could set the movement back a generation, by @[private account] for @NYTimes.
The solicitor general, Elizabeth Prelogar, who would argue the case before the court, was a friend and ally of Strangio’s. In 2020, as a lawyer in private practice, she worked closely with Strangio on a lawsuit challenging Idaho’s ban on trans athletes — the country’s first. Now, in petitioning the court, Prelogar and her colleagues made claims for gender-affirming care that even WPATH had not. “Overwhelming evidence establishes that appropriate gender-affirming treatment with puberty blockers and hormones directly and substantially improves the physical and psychological well-being of transgender adolescents with gender dysphoria,” they wrote.
L.G.B.T.Q. groups and the A.C.L.U. might have looked to state courts, seeking incremental wins without the risk of a binding Supreme Court precedent, as the movement had done for years in fighting anti-sodomy laws. They could also have waited for a case on more politically favorable ground, such as restrictions on military service or medical care for trans adults. The A.C.L.U. saw it differently. A few weeks after Sutton’s ruling, the organization petitioned the Supreme Court to review Skrmetti.
Some civil rights experts I spoke with think it was a mistake to take Skrmetti to the Supreme Court. In their view, it was highly unlikely that the court, now with an even larger conservative majority than when it decided Bostock, was prepared to expand constitutional civil rights protections to a new class of Americans — let alone on the grounds of medical transition for minors. “If you get a bad ruling on this, it could be really problematic,” Michael Ulrich, a professor of health law and human rights at Boston University, told me this spring. “If you can’t win a challenge to strike down a gender-affirming care ban, it’s going to be hard to win other cases around trans rights.”
.@[private account], a California litigator who worked for the A.C.L.U. early in his career, told me he believed that his former colleagues had misread the court. “Bostock built up the confidence of the trans rights legal movement that they could still win major cases even as Trump appointments were shifting the federal judiciary to the right,” Esper said. “But it was always a strategy that carried significant risks, and we’re seeing that play out now.”
“So, fine,” [Chase] Strangio explained. “Say it’s assigned sex at birth, say it’s whatever you want — but it’s because of sex.” At oral argument, another @ACLU lawyer reassured Gorsuch [in Bostock], who was considered the key vote, that protecting trans people would not lead to social upheaval — assurances that Strangio privately chafed at but that he recognized as tactically effective. “We wanted them to apply the law,” Strangio said. “And we wanted them, particularly Gorsuch, to believe that it wasn’t a big deal.”
Online and off, trans activists attacked journalists and academicswho explored whether the sudden rise in dysphoria among teenagers was linked to social media and peer influence or reported on “detransitioners” — people who abandoned a trans identity and sometimes regretted undergoing medical transition. When the journalist @AbigailShrier published her 2020 book “Irreversible Damage: The Transgender Craze Seducing Our Daughters” — casting the rise in dysphoria among teenage girls as a form of social contagion — Strangio tweeted that “stopping the circulation of this book and these ideas is 100% a hill I will die on.”
More than 20 L.G.B.T.Q. rights groups signed on to the messaging plan. The A.C.L.U. did not. Strangio, working on an A.C.L.U. team suing North Carolina, objected to the framing. According to two people present for the discussion, Strangio disputed that a trans woman could be “born with a male body” or “born male”; in his view, a trans woman was born a woman just like any other woman. There was no such thing as a “male body,” Strangio told his colleagues: “A penis is not a male body part. It’s just an unusual body part for a woman.” Before the advertisement aired, Strangio elaborated on his critique in an article in Slate. “Many advocates defend the use of the ‘born male’ or ‘born with a male body’ narrative as being easier for nontransgender people to understand,” Strangio wrote. “Of course it is easier to understand, since it reinforces deeply entrenched views about what makes a man and what makes a woman. But it is precisely these views that we must change.”
In 2016, North Carolina passed legislation requiring people to use bathrooms and locker rooms reserved for their “biological sex,” setting off the country’s first major clash over transgender rights. When a coalition of L.G.B.T.Q. groups began planning an ad campaign, message testing showed that most people were unfamiliar with the movement’s terminology and the physical realities of being trans; the phrase “assigned male at birth” left audiences confused and skeptical. To win them over, the coalition created ads featuring a trans woman with long hair and conventionally feminine clothing. In a spot that first aired on Fox News, the woman is barred from a restaurant bathroom by an angry manager, who backs down after two other women — messaging “validators” the audience could relate to — intercede. “I was born with a male body,” the trans woman says in a voice-over. “But inside, I always knew I was female.”
Like Chase Strangio, the younger people going to work at L.G.B.T.Q. groups [and the @ACLU] leaned further left than their older colleagues. Often identifying as queer — a label that could connote radical politics as much as any sexual or gender identity — they resented the incremental, assimilationist politics that had won the right to same-sex marriage. They sought to deconstruct assumptions about what was normal — to dismantle bourgeois institutions, not seek inclusion in them. Strangio wrestled with how to achieve justice for trans and other marginalized people through a system he believed was designed to subjugate them. In interviews and on social media, he has described himself as “a constitutional lawyer who fundamentally doesn’t believe in the Constitution,” an L.G.B.T.Q. activist who felt his movement was overly devoted to gay white men with “social power and capital and political power” and to the “fundamentally violent institution of civil marriage.” The turn to trans rights would ultimately reopen an old fissure in the L.G.B.T.Q. movement: whether to seek civic equality — or liberation.
By [the late 2010s], practitioners like Olson-Kennedy were arguing that trans-identifying children — even those whose dysphoria might be entwined with other mental-health problems — didn’t need extended psychological assessments any more than trans adults did. (“I don’t send someone to a therapist when I’m going to start them on insulin,” she told The Atlantic in 2018.) Some doctors and activists went further. In a 2019 journal article, the trans bioethicist Florence Ashley argued that trans people, including “older teenagers,” should not require a formal diagnosis of dysphoria before gaining access to cross-sex hormones. Rather than relieving supposed distress, Ashley wrote, patients might be seeking “gender euphoria” or “creative transfiguration,” which “sees the body as a gendered art piece that can be made ours through transition-related interventions.”
"Along the road to Skrmetti, some believe, the L.G.B.T.Q. movement drove itself toward a cliff — and took the Democratic Party with it, chaining the Biden administration to one of the most divisive issues in American politics at a moment of shifting medical consensus and fierce polarization. 'It’s one of the biggest mistakes in the history of trans activism,' said @[private account], a trans woman who serves on the board of Rebellion PAC, a Democratic political-action committee. Strangio and other advocates for trans rights have cast Skrmetti as the case they had to bring. It may also have set their movement back a generation."
"'I didn’t pick this fight around trans rights,' Anthony Romero, the @ACLU’s executive director, told me in an interview not long before the decision."
How the Transgender Rights Movement Bet on the Supreme Court and Lost
The inside story of the case that could set the movement back a generation, by @[private account] for @NYTimes.
That is your opinion. And I think that regardless of who it is, not using someone’s preferred pronouns is cruel and a shame.
https://open.substack.com/pub/benryan/p/why-i-use-trans-peoples-preferred?r=7wxo1&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web&showWelcomeOnShare=false
But it’s the Roberts decision that is the official word of the court, and he said that the question of the quasi suspect class didn’t have relevance, since the case didn’t hinge on transgender status, rather on diagnosis.
That is a potential outcome, yes, as I wrote last fall: https://nypost.com/2024/10/19/us-news/pain-confusion-compassion-how-the-us-has-reached-a-trans-tipping-point/
WPATH Weighs in on Skrmetti:
“Today’s Supreme Court ruling is a dangerous setback for transgender health and human rights in the United States. This decision will effectively allow states to ban evidence-based gender-affirming healthcare for thousands of transgender and gender diverse youth and their families. Furthermore, it will make it much more difficult to create an evidence base to support access to healthcare of this kind.
"A ruling like this does not change the fundamental fact that transgender youth exist, their lives are improved when they can access care and are harmed whenever the government comes in between them and the professional experts trained to provide them this care. Let us be clear – healthcare bans of any kind are rooted in stigma, misinformation, and fear and this one comes at the expense of the youth in need of this care.
USPATH and WPATH stand committed to continuing to provide best-practice guidelines to healthcare professionals around the world and in accordance with the law. And we stand ready to support practitioners, families, patients, and communities working to protect access to lawful care for transgender and gender diverse individuals.”
The @[private account] American Academy of Pediatrics weighs in on Skrmetti, claiming that the science supporting pediatric gender transition treatment is strong, despite numerous systematic literature reviews finding the science wanting and uncertain. Despite the revelation in the Alabama case over that state's ban that WPATH added the term "medically necessary" to its trans-care guidelines not because the science backed it, but to win insurance coverage, the AAP insists that this treatment is indeed medically necessary.
By Susan J. Kressly, MD, FAAP, President, American Academy of Pediatrics
“The Supreme Court ruling in United States v. Skrmetti will have profound and far-reaching consequences for the health and well-being of transgender youth across this country and for the doctors who care for them. To be clear—regardless of today’s legal ruling—the science still supports gender-affirming care, children will still need it.
“Nothing in this decision explicitly bans such care.
“The American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) remains unwavering in our support for transgender and gender-diverse youth and their access to the same standard of compassionate, evidence-based care as every other child.
“Gender-affirming care is medically necessary for treating gender dysphoria and is backed by decades of peer-reviewed research, clinical experience, and scientific consensus. Too often mischaracterized as exclusively involving surgery and hormones, this care is provided thoughtfully and with the involvement of multidisciplinary teams of physicians, mental health professionals, families, and most importantly, young people themselves. Denying patients access to this care not only undermines their health and safety, it robs them of basic human dignity.
“The ruling also sets a dangerous precedent for legislative interference in the practice of medicine and the patient-physician relationship that is at the core of our health system.
“The AAP stands firmly with pediatricians and families making healthcare decisions together and free from political interference. We remain committed to advancing care that protects the health, safety, and dignity of all children. “
My legal sources say that the Supreme Court ruling about pediatric gender-transition treatment does not have sweeping implications for trans rights more broadly and still leaves open many legal avenues for trans people to challenge discrimination. Thus, this take is hyperbolic:
My legal source at Duke Law School says that the court has left open the question of whether transgender people belong to a quasi-suspect class warranting higher legal scrutiny.
Addressing the question of Bostock’s application outside of employment contexts, the majority found that the law “does not alter the court’s analysis.” To assess for discrimination barred by the statute, that 2020 decision applied a test in which changing the person’s sex would change the outcome of the dispute. But in the case of the Tennessee ban, the court found that this test did not, in fact, change the outcome; children would still be banned from receiving drugs for the purpose of transitioning their gender if they were the opposite sex.
However, the court issued a notably restrained ruling in this context, declining to address whether Bostock’s reasoning “reaches behind the Title VII context.” This should limit the reach of this decision.
“Lawyers working to secure trans rights can continue to use Bostock based reasoning where the language of the law allows it,” Ms. Coleman said.
In her concurring opinion, Justice Barrett – whose status as the reliably conservative vote Trump hoped for has come under increasing scrutiny – effectively reasserted her conservative bona fides by writing that transgender status is not a protected class, in part because of its mutability, given that some people detransition, meaning they revert to identifying and presenting as their biological sex.
“Nor is the transgender population a ‘discrete group,’” as required to be recognized as a protected class, Justice Barrett wrote. “Instead,” she continued, “like classes we have declined to recognize as suspect, the category of transgender individuals is ‘large, diverse, and amorphous.’”
In keeping with the court’s historical and steadfast reluctance to add new protected classes—it declined to do so when it legalized gay marriage in 2015, and has refused to recognize disability as a protected class, for example—the majority decision did not designate trans people as members of such a class.
The Skrmetti ruling, for which the Supreme Court’s six conservative members comprised the majority, the justices ruled that another landmark Supreme Court decision, Bostock v. Clayton County did not alter their thinking. Justice Neil Gorsuch wrote for the majority in that 2020 case that Title VII of the 1964 Civil Rights Act barred employment discrimination based on gender identity and sexual orientation because it’s impossible to discriminate on these bases without taking a person’s sex into account. Liberal litigators, including at the ACLU, have in Skrmetti and other cases sought to expand transgender civil rights by applying the court’s reasoning in Bostock in various other contexts.
Chase Strangio, co-director of the @ACLU’s LGBTQ and HIV Project, said in the statement: “Today’s ruling is a devastating loss for transgender people, our families, and everyone who cares about the Constitution. Though this is a painful setback, it does not mean that transgender people and our allies are left with no options to defend our freedom, our health care, or our lives. The Court left undisturbed Supreme Court and lower court precedent that other examples of discrimination against transgender people are unlawful.”
In a statement, the @ACLU, which originated the lawsuit over the Tennessee ban, asserted that “the decision is based on the record in and context of the Tennessee case and therefore does not extend to other cases concerning discrimination based on transgender status.”
The court’s decision, however monumental, will not necessarily have sweeping implications for transgender-related litigation more broadly, according to Doriane Lambelet Coleman, a law professor at Duke University and the author of On Sex And Gender: a Commonsense Approach. She said that the court has left as an open question whether transgender people should be recognized as a protected class, for whom a higher level of legal scrutiny under the 14th amendment is warranted.
The Supreme Court on Wednesday upheld a Tennessee law that bars minors from undergoing medical treatments to develop secondary sex characteristics of the opposite sex. The landmark ruling deals a bruising blow to the transgender rights movement, which in recent years has placed advocating for and protecting children’s access to gender-transition medications at the forefront of its increasingly demoralized civil-rights mission.
LINK: Supreme Court’s Decision To Uphold State Ban on Medical Gender Transitions for Minors Is a ‘Devastating Loss for Transgender People,’ @ACLU Says
https://www.nysun.com/article/supreme-courts-decision-to-uphold-state-ban-on-medical-gender-transitions-for-minors-is-a-devastating-loss-for-transgender-people-aclu-says?member_gift=CUZ5qwd3crq4pmz-xrd
The landmark ruling deals a devastating blow to the transgender advocacy movement, but is not necessarily expected to compromise gender identity-related litigation in other domains.
Supreme Court’s Decision To Uphold State Ban on Medical Gender Transitions for Minors Is a ‘Devastating Loss for Transgender People,’ @ACLU Says
🧵⬇️I report for The @[private account] The landmark ruling deals a devastating blow to the transgender advocacy movement, but is not necessarily expected to compromise gender identity-related litigation in other domains.
In a concurring opinion, Justice Barrett asserted that transgender people do not qualify for protected-class status under the 14th amendment in part because of the mutability of transgender identification, given that people can detransition.
An NIH page, taken down since the start of the Trump administration, referenced the AP stylebook on the matter:
Both pregnant women and pregnant people are acceptable phrases. It is not always necessary to avoid the word women by substituting phrases like birthing people, or people with uteruses, especially in public health content. Gender neutral terms like pregnant patients, pregnant people, birth parent, or other wording as applicable (e.g., pregnant teens), present an inclusive alternatives. Use judgement and context to determine whether to use pregnant women, pregnant people, pregnant patients, or other inclusive descriptors. Specific phrasing like people with uteruses can be helpful when writing NOFOs or advertising studies to ensure only eligible participants are enrolled for the specific research conducted.
Using more limited and specific language is sometimes important. For instance, if discussing a study that only involves pregnant cisgender women, gender-specific language (pregnant women) would be most accurate to reference that study’s findings. If the word women is preferable, but transgender and nonbinary people are also referenced, phrasing like women and other pregnant patients can provide an inclusive alternative.
The sanguine findings of the new study are surprising due in no small part to the widely publicized perspective of Dr. Marci Bowers, who is the United States’ most prolific gender-affirming surgeon, about the potential impacts of puberty blockers on transgender minors. Until recently, Dr. Bowers served a term as the president of the World Professional Association for Transgender Health, or WPATH, the activist-medical organization whose ‘Standards of Care’ guidelines form the backbone of the U.S. trans care in particular. Dr. Bowers is on record saying that she has observed that among natal males in particular, early pubertal suppression can apparently lead to serious sexual dysfunction, including a lack of sensation in the genitals and an inability to orgasm. https://benryan.substack.com/p/suppressing-puberty-not-tied-to-higher
The Amsterdam University Medical Center press release, sure enough, oversells the findings, claiming the study showed: “Puberty blockers do not cause problems with sexual functioning in transgender adults.” There is simply no way that a single survey study conducted an average of 14 years after these people started gender-transition treatment could have reached a conclusion that the authors had ruled out a causal relationship between puberty blockers and sexual functioning. And despite a barrage of systematic literature reviews finding the scientific evidence behind pediatric gender medicine wanting an inconclusive, the release claims that “puberty blockers have been proven to contribute to the mental well-being of transgender young people.”https://benryan.substack.com/p/suppressing-puberty-not-tied-to-higher
A small survey study of Dutch transgender adults group who as minors received puberty blockers and cross-sex hormones to treat gender dysphoria has found that rates of sexual satisfaction and dysfunction among them are not substantially different from trans people who started hormones as adults.
https://benryan.substack.com/p/suppressing-puberty-not-tied-to-higher
Aside from being based on only 70 people, the study, which was published Tuesday in The Journal of Sexual Medicine, has various notable limitations. So its findings are hardly definitive. But as the first study of its kind, it sheds at least some light on a prevailing mystery about the long-term impacts of pediatric gender-transition treatment. And it calls into question one of the primary arguments against the use of these drugs in minors: that they can lead to lifelong sexual dysfunction.
LINK: Suppressing Puberty Not Tied to Higher Sexual Dysfunction in Trans Adults, Small Study Finds
https://benryan.substack.com/p/suppressing-puberty-not-tied-to-higher
The first of its kind, this survey study of 70 Dutch adults who received puberty blockers and cross-sex hormones as minors calls into question one of the top criticisms of such pediatric treatment.
Suppressing Puberty Not Tied to Higher Sexual Dysfunction in Trans Adults, Small Study Finds
🧵⬇️⬇️The first of its kind, this survey study of 70 Dutch adults who received puberty blockers and cross-sex hormones as minors calls into question one of the top criticisms of such pediatric treatment.
Debunking podcaster Michael Hobbes is egregiously misrepresenting Rep. Sarah McBride’s painstakingly nuanced take on transgender politics in the @EzraKlein interview.
How many more times do we have to explain that relying on a survey of people who **currently identify as transgender** is not a good way to assess the overall reasons that people detransition, because by definition it will exclude people who detransitioned and stayed that way.
In these leaked training videos, Dr. Johanna Olson-Kennedy expresses her disdain for the DSM-5's criteria for diagnosing gender dysphoria in children.
https://benryan.substack.com/p/leaked-trans-care-training-videos?utm_source=publication-search
These training videos by Dr. Johanna Olson-Kennedy may quickly become relics from another time now that he pediatric gender clinic is shutting its doors. https://benryan.substack.com/p/leaked-trans-care-training-videos
Ohio state representative Gary Click, who marshaled that state's ban of pediatric gender-transition treatment, responds to the federal judge ordering the release of three years of World Professional Association for Transgender Health, or @[private account], conference videos:
Quotes a post by T31598; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
When the Debunkers need Debunking
As she argues that those expressing skepticism about pediatric gender-transition treatment are furthering misinformation, trans activist-blogger Erin Reed pushes her own false claims.
Reed claims certainty that regret rates are under 1%, when the truth is detransition and regret rates remain unknown.
Reed also continues to credulously cite Tordoff et al. She falsely claims that the study showed a causal impact of gender-transition drugs on minors, as opposed to just an association. And she fails to recognize that the study's untreated comparison group had severe loss to follow-up, calling into question whether these treatments actually reduced suicidality as the study claimed.
NEWS: An Alabama judge has ordered WPATH to publish videos of its 2021, 2022 and 2023 conferences, which remain fiercely guarded from the public eye, as well as a 2023 training video. The World Professional Association for Transgender Health is an activist-medical organization whose trans-care guidelines form the backbone of care standards for adults and children in the US.
As part of the civil case over Alabama’s ban on pediatric gender-transition treatment, Alabama’s attorney general subpoenaed WPATH records, which have proved pointedly embarrassing to the organization. In particular, they demonstrated that WPATH leadership was aware of how weak the evidence based behind pediatric gender-transition treatment was and sought to paper it over. It also worded its trans care guidelines in a way to steel providers against lawsuits, apparently coordinating with the ACLU in the process, and to gain insurance coverage.
Trans activists have been savaging the Pissed Off Lawyer, accusing the account of being a traitor and seeking to cater to X fandom by deciding to detransition. Many detransitioners report being shunned by their friends in the trans community after announcing their detransition.
Quoting @legaltweetz: I’m detransitioning. My name will still be Hendrix. My birth name carries a lot of abuse with it, so Hendrix stays. I will block anyone using my prior name.
I was not talked into this or groomed. This is what I want. I made the choice to transition as an adult, and the buck stops here. I won’t be suing anyone, nor am I angry about it.
However, after a lifetime of trauma due to being a female & 15+ years of endometriosis, I disconnected from my female body completely. More gatekeeping could have caught this instead of an ALL affirmation model. This is why I find the informed consent model to be flawed after 7+ years of transition.
New Hampshire governor signs "parents' bill of rights" that, among other measures, requires taht schools “promptly” with “accurate, truthful, and complete disclosure regarding any and all matters related to their minor child.” LGBTQ groups have asserted this would lead to forced outing of students who disclose a transgender identity at school.
Efforts to boycott @JK_Rowling's Harry Potter intellectual property over her vocal stance on trans issues and women's rights have been unsuccessful.
Quoting @benryanwriter: The Wall Street Journal reported last year that the controversy surrounding @JK_Rowling’s views on gender has not impacted the business of Potter. It continues to boom.
Erin Reed and Alejandra Caraballo express their rage at @HelenLewis, who has written critically about pediatric gender-transition treatment and has called for compromises when trans inclusion impacts single-sex spaces.
Why I Use Trans People’s Preferred Pronouns
https://open.substack.com/pub/benryan/p/why-i-use-trans-peoples-preferred?r=7wxo1&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web&showWelcomeOnShare=false
Regardless of whether there will ever be any winners in the battle of the genders, I choose being kind over waging war.
It’s been a long wait for the Times’ pediatric gender medicine podcast! It drops June 5.
Introducing ‘The Protocol’
Coming June 5: A six-part podcast exploring the origins of medical treatment for transgender young people, and how the care got pulled into a political fight that could end it in the United States.
Since 2021, nearly half the states in the U.S. have passed bans on medical treatments for transgender minors. The Trump administration is now targeting the care, and in the coming weeks, the Supreme Court is expected to weigh in.
“The Protocol” is the story of youth gender medicine — where it came from, who it was meant to help, and how it got pulled into a political fight that could end it altogether.
The decline in approval of gay marriage doubtfully has much to do with gay men’s behavior or Republicans’ unique knowledge or disapproval of such behavior than it does to do with a spill-over effect from disapproval of the demands of transgender activism, in particular sports inclusion and pediatric gender-transition treatment.
And on the flip side, there are those who unkindly claim, for example, that trans women are not women in any way shape or form and have no right to be conceived of, treated as, or addressed as such in any context. This faction seeks to rob trans women of their dignity by dismissing them as men in drag. This is boorish and extremist behavior that betrays an appalling lack of empathy for the plight of people who seek to mitigate the pain of gender dysphoria and to live authentically by changing their bodies to more closely resemble those of the opposite sex with which they identify. https://benryan.substack.com/p/yes-we-need-both-the-term-biological
These are confusing times. And we must have both of these terms—“biological sex” and “cisgender”—at our disposal to provide clarity, when warranted, and to distinguish between people’s sex and gender identity. Yes, this applies even to people who insist that they have no gender identity or, nonsensically, that there is no such thing.
https://benryan.substack.com/p/yes-we-need-both-the-term-biological
We’ve seen a lot of muddying of the waters between sex and gender identity in the discourse coming from both major factions squaring off about this combustible and catastrophically politicized culture-war issue.
There has been a parade of people of late, for example, who claim, “Transgender women are biological women.” See: the cyclist Veronica Ivy on Trevor Noah’s show. This is a preposterous suggestion that erases the most basic of biological realities. If a transgender woman were a biological woman, she would have no need to take estrogen; because the ovaries she was born with, absent having them removed or some sort of hormonal disorder, would manufacture the required hormone level on autopilot. A transgender woman takes these hormones to change her body to be more feminine, because she is, in fact, a biological male who identifies as female.
LINK: Yes, We Need Both the Term “Biological Sex” and the Word “Cisgender”
https://benryan.substack.com/p/yes-we-need-both-the-term-biological
An ode to qualifiers, which bring clarity during confusing times amid the ideological—and rhetorical—battles over transgender identity.
Some people have gotten it into their heads that the term “biological sex” is an intrinsic, bigoted dog whistle that is only ever meant to degrade the integrity and dignity of trans people.
And on the flip side, we have the people who froth at the mouth at the mere whisper of the word “cisgender,” which they say is the key to Pandora’s box of gender-bending horrors. Free-speech champion Elon Musk notoriously banned the word from X.
Both of these camps are being wildly unreasonable, stubborn and close-minded.
Yes, We Need Both the Term “Biological Sex” and the Word “Cisgender”
🧵⬇️An ode to qualifiers, which bring clarity during confusing times amid the ideological—and rhetorical—battles over transgender identity.
Show me the study that I have just stated doesn’t exist. I covered the subject here: https://nypost.com/2024/02/24/opinion/a-finnish-study-is-changing-how-we-approach-trans-kids/
The term “biological sex” is *not* intrinsically a dog whistle!
The term is now a necessity in everyday discourse about transgender people to distinguish between people’s sex and their gender identity.
There is a lot of muddying of the waters between these two things in the discourse from all sides of this issue. Some people will, for example, falsely claim that trans women are “biological women.” Others will unkindly claim that trans women are not women in any way shape or form and are just men in drag, robbing these people of their dignity.
As a qualifier “biological” helps clarify when someone’s sex is not the same thing as how they present if they have engaged in some form of gender transition.
In many contexts, someone’s biological sex is not relevant or necessary to know.
But it is important to know if someone’s biological sex differs from their presented gender identity in, for example, medical contexts in which doctors need to know, say, whether to test someone for pregnancy or testicular cancer.
It is also often important to know someone’s biological sex when determining fairness in sports inclusion and determining policies about women’s single-sex spaces, such as prisons or domestic violence shelters.
California changes high school track and field championship rules amid Trump threats over trans athletes
As California continues to face threats from President Donald Trump's administration over state policies allowing trans athletes in girls' sports, the state organization that oversees high school sports announced a change that aims to ensure girls are not displaced from winning a medal.
The California Interscholastic Federation on Tuesday announced a new pilot entry process for the upcoming Track and Field Championships, allowing a "biological female" student-athlete to compete who may have otherwise been displaced from gaining entry to the competition by a trans athlete.
Neither of these people are accurately representing how Cass or any other major critic of pediatric gender-transition treatment has scrutinized the fact that almost all kids who start puberty blockers go on to take cross-sex hormones. For one, blockers were long sold as a “time to think.” But if everyone wound up thinking the same thing in the end, were they really weighing their options? As Hannah Barnes wrote in her book, Time to Think, psychological assessments that are 95% accurate are unheard of. Secondly, critics worry that by preventing the children from experiencing a sexual awakening from their endogenous puberty, by giving blockers to youth, doctors may be preventing them from realizing their gender dysphoria stemmed from being gay, not being trans.
The surge in trans identification in natal adolescent girls began in about 2012 to 2014. Littman’s first paper on the subject was in 2018. So not that much time has passed since the beginning of the era during which researchers might have studied this.
Archconservative @MattWalshBlog, never one to pass up the chance to monetize uttering something certain to provoke outrage and upset, says that the only joy that trans people can hope to realize is at the moment before they die by suicide from leaping off a building. Or perhaps he is referring to their being defenestrated?
Quotes a post by A0478; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
“Cross sex hormone treatment affects each of the cells of the body,” Dahlgren explained. Research showed trans women (“natal males”) have a substantially higher risk of ischemic stroke, venous thromboembolism (VTE) – which includes deep vein thrombosis and pulmonary embolism – and heart attacks. After eight years of oestrogen use, trans women had a risk of VTE nearly 17 times higher than other biological males, and 13.7 times than biological women. Studies have also suggested that females who take testosterone, have an increased risk of heart attacks.
Seemingly most relevant to Wes Streeting’s decision-making, is the outlined additional danger of starting hormone treatments while still in childhood. “If the treatment is started in young years, many years with daily treatment with cross sex hormones will increase the risk of cardiovascular disease… and stroke… [and] can decrease fertility, impair liver function and increase the risk of cancer in both genders,” hormone expert Dahlgren wrote. She also noted the lack of long-term data: “The consequences of prescribing cross sex hormones in individuals under the age of 18 years are that the body and the brain are permanently marked/changed with both known and more unforeseen consequences.”
I also obtained a video of Dr. Dan Karasic, a professor emeritus of psychiatry at @[private account] and a leader at WPATH, griping about Sunday’s panel as he waited for Monday’s panel on gender medicine to begin. The video is below. Note that the woman on Dr. Karasic’s right is Colleen Coyle, general counsel for the APA. The man is Dr. Michael Meyers, a professor of clinical psychiatry at SUNY-Downstate Health Sciences University in Brooklyn, and the two panels’ moderator.
In the video, Dr. Karasic alleged that right-wing billionaires are funding the effort to discredit pediatric gender medicine, including by backing the Society for Evidence Based Gender Medicine (@[private account]) and @DoNoHarm. He complained that the APA was egregiously lending gender-medicine skeptics legitimacy by putting on the skeptics’ panel. The sound quality in the video is terrible (I did try to tidy up the sound), so it’s hard to make out what the three of them were saying. But toward the end, Dr. Meyers said, “Years ago, we decided never to debate a Scientologist.”
Dr. Karasic may be familiar to readers from his appearance in the WPATH Files, which I reported on last year: "In one WPATH message-board exchange, a Canadian nurse practitioner said she was struggling over whether a severely mentally ill patient should start cross-sex hormones. Dr. Dan Karasic, of the University of California, San Francisco, who was the lead author of WPATH’s Standards of Care 8 mental health chapter, scoffed at her hesitancy."
I contacted Dr. Karasic to ask if he would like to comment on the recording of him. He replied:
"I do not want to comment directly on the contents of the audio recording, as I believe it was illegally recorded. We were in a meeting room rented by a private organization, which posted that recording was not permitted. In California it is not permitted to surreptitiously record people who have the expectation of privacy, as I did as an audience member in this space in which recording was forbidden. I attended the conference not as a speaker or in any official capacity. While seated and waiting for the Monday session to start I expressed my displeasure that there were no microphones for questions, as there had been no audience microphones at the session the day before. This is a departure from most academic sessions in which free audience discussion is encouraged.
"The audience at the session on Sunday, by opponents of APA recommendations on transgender care, featured an audience which attended respectfully. On Monday, by contrast, [activist] Ms. [Jamie] Reed @JamieWhistle disrupted Dr. Leibowitz's talk, by recording and broadcasting it.
"Ms. Reed is part of a well-funded group that harasses their perceived enemies. Previously other members of her group fabricated a claim that I said something at a conference, which was actually a mischaracterization of something said by an audience member. This false tweet by Ms. Reed's organization led to my receiving death threats and harassment. Despite my expressing concerns about the death threats after the false tweet, Ms. Reed continued to promote the falsehood on social media. I ask that Ms. Reed and her colleagues cease harassing me and other healthcare providers."
Note that Ms. Reed was kicked out of the conference on Sunday. Someone else with her activist organization, the LGB Courage Coalition, taped the Monday session and live streamed it, much to Dr. Leibowitz’s consternation.
Provided Dr. Karasic’s remarks, Ms. Reed replied:
"On May 19th, Mr. Dan Karasic decided to loudly and publicly voice his complaints to the APA Legal General Counsel Colleen Coyle and the panelists in a public, open room. His lack of judgment and arrogance was startling. This was an open space and not an appropriate venue for such accusations regarding the previous day’s panel; he had no idea who was sitting around him and showed a real lack of decorum. Instead of acknowledging how he created a hostile environment before the panel began, he made unsubstantiated claims about our organization’s finances.
"The @LGBCourage Coalition is a grassroots organization of LGB adults committed to promoting evidence-based medical care for all, ending the medicalization of gender nonconformity, safeguarding homosexual rights, and building pathways back for LGB individuals who have undergone medicalization. We operate through grassroots donations, primarily from LGB adults and parents with affected children. We are not aware of a "false tweet" that Mr. Karasic is referencing."
Military commanders told to identify troops for medical checks under Trump administration’s transgender ban
WASHINGTON (AP) — Military commanders will be told to identify troops in their units who are transgender or have gender dysphoria, then send them to get medical checks in order to force them out of the service, officials said Thursday.
A senior defense official laid out what could be a complicated and lengthy new process aimed at fulfilling President Donald Trump’s directive to remove transgender service members from the U.S. military.
The new order to commanders relies on routine annual health checks that service members are required to undergo. Another defense official said the Defense Department has scrapped — for now — plans to go through troops’ health records to identify those with gender dysphoria.
Instead, transgender troops who do not voluntarily come forward could be outed by commanders or others aware of their medical status. Gender dysphoria occurs when a person’s biological sex does not match up with their gender identity.
Never trust someone who tells you that they know what proportion of people who transition detransition. The truth is we are not sure, and that knowledge is hampered by poor follow-up in studies as well as high loss to follow-up. Also, because the population of youth identifying as trans has changed so dramatically in the past 12 years, we can’t say at what rate this new, much larger cohort might detransition.
Quoting @againstgrmrs: Gay guy who believes kids are born trans gets obliterated by common sense. Why oppose brain scans to confirm it before medical transition, especially after admitting that’s how you’d know? 🧐
Wild clip. One of the best you’ll see today 🔥
In Britain, attitudes about transgender people's cross-sex access to bathrooms and sports has rapidly soured.
Is this a reaction to pressure from trans activists, or people responding to activism opposing trans activists' aims, or both? Which has played a bigger role?
Quoting @epkaufm: 10/ Stunningly, attitudes on trans went ‘backwards’ after 2022, the first cultural reversal for the liberal left in a century. For a movement used to being in the vanguard of history, this is an existential crisis (UK data via @YouGov, points for years 2021-24)
Dennis, go find something better to do with your time. All of you should are hounding about this are just sending a toxic message to trans men that people hate them and want them to crawl into a hole.
I dunno, but if that guy with the enormous mustache on the show calls himself gay after fancying the trans guy with the little mustache, that’s fine and all these people making such a fuss need to find something better to do.
Being transgender does not require being the opposite sex. It just requires feeling that one is transgender. The absolutists have a lot of trouble undermining trans existence for this reason. They can’t find an in, a way to say these people don’t exist.
This person belongs to a kind of linguistic denialist sect in which people will say, “There’s no such thing as being transgender!” To which I reply: “Except that there is. If someone identifies as transgender, they are transgender.”
There is in fact something known as presenting as male. It is what many transgender men do. Pretending this does not happen does not erase the fact that it does.
Quotes a post by T22461; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Yes, exactly. They forbid any cognitive dissonance or compromise. This is also known as extremism.
https://benryan.substack.com/p/why-i-use-trans-peoples-preferred
It's also nobody's business to tell gay men that they have to find trans men attractive lest they be deemed bigots. If they define being gay as only being into biological males, that is also their business. No one should force them to expand their own sexual orientation.
Agreed. If a gay man is attracted to a trans man, it's because that man is presenting as male. This doesn't transform the gay guy into a bisexual man. And it's nobody's business to tell that man he can't identify as gay anymore.
Quotes a post by T23144; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I have largely avoided them. But if I were a young trans man into guys, wondering if I would be accepted, I would feel a tight knot in my stomach right now. This is all such a shot across the bow. But I bet a lot of gay guys are open to dating trans men. Maybe not the majority, but enough to give one opportunities.
The most hysterical irony is that the article culminates in a cri de coeur on behalf of trans rights. But Alejandra Caraballo wouldn’t know that, because she only read the cryptic headline.
“Beyond respecting patients’ identities, assisting them to speak and connect with their loved ones is crucial. This may involve offering to help talk to both biological and chosen family members and friends about how best to communicate and explore this delicate space. Open and curious questions work well: introducing yourself with your pronouns, asking without judgment about their sexual orientation and gender identity, or simply saying, “I can take better care of you if I know what matters to you. Can you tell me what I need to know?” Reinforce these words with a pin, sign, or badge pull stating, “You are safe with me.” A single supportive and respectful patient-clinician relationship can have profound impact. The empathy and validation of just one accepting health care professional can cut the risk of transgender youth suicide by more than 30%.8”
Quotes a post by T17393; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The reason they're hounding this subject is because they are sex absolutists. This is the polar opposite of the sex-is-a-spectrum position. They do not believe that a transgender person is in any way shape or form the opposite sex. So even if a gay man conceives of a trans man as male and is attracted to him because he perceives him as male, this means nothing to the sex absolutists. They want to police sex boundaries and to forbid anyone from conceiving of themselves as the opposite sex and anyone else from conceiving that about them.
They see this as a righteous cause, because, they think, non-trans people are always threatened by trans invasion into their spaces. But what threat do trans men pose to gay men? This guy on the show is totally fine with dating a trans guy. If he wasn't, he could've said no. This might've hurt the other guy's feelings and disappointed him. But sadly, that is life.
STUDY: Conversion therapy bans tied to lower suicidality in LGB youth
A new study finds that following state bans of conversion therapy of gay and trans minors, the rate of youth reporting seriously considering suicide declined; the decline was greater for lesbian, gay and bisexual youth.
A new study of teenage natal females finds that those who identify as transgender are less likely to use condoms and more likely to become pregnant than those who identify as female.
The Trump administration just canceled an NIH grant that sought to address this disparity.
It is no one's business but a gay man's to determine how he defines his sexual orientation. If he's into trans men and thinks of himself as a gay man, then he is one.
Women who spend a lot of their energy stirring up rage about trans people have no purchase in this discussion.
There are words that mean things and a trans man is a natal female who identifies and often presents as male. Some gay men are into these people. That is their choice.
Activist-blogger Erin Reed is not having the Washington Post's editorial supporting the HHS report on pediatric gender medicine. Despite the fact that the report was based on an umbrella systematic literature review, which analyses all the analyses of the science, Reed dismisses it as "pseudoscience."
Reed writes:
On Sunday, the Washington Post editorial board published an op-ed that appeared to fully embrace the anti-trans pseudoscience promoted in the recent report from RFK Jr.’s Department of Health and Human Services. This is the same department that has overseen some of the most disastrous public health responses in recent memory, stacked key positions with conspiracy theorists, and pushed disinformation on everything from autism to vaccines. Ironically, the Post has criticized these failures in other reporting—but when it comes to transgender health care, the editorial board seems unwilling to apply the same scrutiny, leaving readers uninformed about the report’s dangerous, evidence-defying recommendations.
“Rather than say doctors have been performing interventions for which the evidence of effectiveness is inadequate, |Trump| said they are “maiming and sterilizing a growing number of impressionable children” based on “Junk Science.” … This hyperbole is not helpful to anyone, especially not young people and their families. What’s needed instead is better evidence and reasoned discussion about the trade-offs involved in intervening with the biological process of puberty in children who experience gender dysphoria… The good news is that the executive order provided some of what is too often missing in the debate over transgender medical care for children,” reported the Washington Post Editorial Board in an article titled, “Good questions about transgender care.”
The Washington Post editorial board describes the HHS report—laden with disinformation and distortions about transgender care—as “careful” and “thorough.” While the op-ed concedes that the report was born out of executive orders that deny transgender people even exist, it fails to grapple with the obvious: the report was constructed to reach a predetermined conclusion. There is no world in which the study’s authors could have released any report affirming transgender healthcare’s importance, given the executive order that made it possible and those in charge of selecting the authors, whose names were kept anonymous. The editorial calls for “neutral, unbiased studies” on transgender health care, yet in the same breath treats a 400-page screed—designed explicitly to justify banning that care—as if it meets that standard. The contradiction is as glaring as it is dangerous.
Almost none of the content from the HHS report actually makes it into the Washington Post editorial. The piece largely ignores the avalanche of criticism from scientists, medical experts, and transgender people over the report’s glaring falsehoods. Nowhere in the editorial will readers learn that the report endorses thoroughly discredited theories like “rapid onset gender dysphoria” and “social contagion” to explain trans identity. It deadnames some of the earliest known transgender patients—seemingly out of spite—and classifies social transition, something as simple as a haircut and a new name, as a medical intervention requiring regulation. It leans heavily on fringe, debunked studies and repeatedly cites known anti-trans ideologues like Jesse Singal, Ray Blanchard, Paul Hruz, James Cantor, Michael Laidlaw, and Quinten Van Meter—figures courts and experts have ruled unqualified to speak on transgender health care. None of this, nor the hundreds of factual distortions and pseudoscientific claims littering the report, are addressed in the Post’s editorial.
On the rare occasions the Washington Post editorial acknowledges criticism of the HHS report, it does so by dismissing those critics as mere “activists.” Take, for example, the paper’s defense of the report’s anonymous authorship and lack of transparent review—an unprecedented move for a document claiming scientific credibility. The editorial suggests their anonymity was justified to shield them from backlash for promoting “a greater emphasis on psychotherapy,” writing: “Presumably, one reason they kept their names secret was because the underlying issue is so heated and polarized: A fierce activist backlash awaits anyone who calls for greater emphasis on psychotherapy in treating gender dysphoric youth. (Critics deride this approach as ‘conversion therapy.’)” In this telling, anyone defending trans people is cast as an ideologue… which includes the American Academy of Pediatrics, the American Psychological Association, experts at Yale, and more. Meanwhile, an anonymous, Trump-commissioned screed—produced under an executive order declaring that transgender people don’t exist and referring to their care as “mutilation”—is framed as the work of “thorough skeptics.” The rhetorical game is obvious, and dangerous.
It’s telling that the Washington Post entirely misrepresents what’s actually happening inside the HHS report and the broader Trump administration. There is no “greater emphasis on psychotherapy” here—there is only psychotherapy, and not in any neutral or therapeutic sense. What the report promotes is not mental health support, but conversion therapy dressed up in rebranded language. “Gender Exploratory Therapy,”the euphemism used throughout, is widely recognized by transgender people and medical professionals as a form of conversion therapy—its name as misleading as “crisis pregnancy centers,” which mask anti-abortion extremism behind the veneer of medical care. Just as those centers are designed to delay care until it’s no longer accessible, Gender Exploratory Therapy is engineered to stall transition indefinitely, pressuring patients until they no longer identify as transgender. Therapists practicing it never provide letters for transition and are affiliated with groups that actively lobby against trans rights in bathrooms and schools. This is not a neutral alternative. And yet, the Washington Post editorial board either fails to understand that—or worse, chooses not to.
The Post seems capable of recognizing the rot inside RFK Jr.’s HHS—when it comes to vaccines, to autism, to measles outbreaks. But when it comes to transgender people, suddenly the standards slip. Suddenly, the same department pushing anti-vax pseudoscience is recast as thoughtful, and its anonymous authors as brave truth-tellers. Why? Because trans lives make for easy outrage clicks, and the Post, under Jeff Bezos, is increasingly positioning itself to win a right-wing audience. This is a paper that used to lead on trans health coverage—now it’s playing footsie with extremists. Ever since it refused to endorse a presidential candidate and watched its readership crater, something fundamental has shifted. Truth was one of the first casualties. And today, transgender people are paying the price.
After dodging the question about whether he supports trans females participating in girls and women’s sports, Democratic Senator Chris Murphy of CT tells @[private account] that he does support it “in my community,” but can’t impose that preference elsewhere.
Good questions about transgender care
The authors of a new HHS report make a case against pediatric gender transition, by the @[private account] board at the @WashingtonPost.
President Donald Trump never chooses careful, neutral language when he can bring out his flamethrower. In January, when his administration issued an executive order on pediatric medical gender transition, it was titled “Protecting Children from Chemical and Surgical Mutilation.” The text proceeded in the same vein: Rather than say doctors have been performing interventions for which the evidence of effectiveness is inadequate, he said they are “maiming and sterilizing a growing number of impressionable children” based on “Junk Science.”
This hyperbole is not helpful to anyone, especially not young people and their families. What’s needed instead is better evidence and reasoned discussion about the trade-offs involved in intervening with the biological process of puberty in children who experience gender dysphoria.
The good news is that the executive order provided some of what is too often missing in the debate over transgender medical care for children. It directed the secretary of health and human services to publish a review of the existing literature on best practices within 90 days, and this review is now out.
The HHS document concurs with other systematic reviews, including Britain’s Cass Review report, that the existing research is inadequate to validate medical interventions for gender dysphoric youth. In studying the use of hormones, puberty blockers and surgery, researchers should have started with small, randomized, controlled trials and, if those were successful, gradually expanded the patient population through more such trials to establish effectiveness and refine best practices. Instead, encouraging results from small trials that were neither randomized nor controlled helped fuel a growing number of interventions at clinics around the world, where practice may vary significantly from the studied protocol.
Subsequent research has been marred by various methodological flaws, including inadequate study of how patients fare years or decades after they begin treatment. Variations in practice among pediatric gender clinics and shifting patient populations limit the usefulness of what research exists.
More concerning is the possibility that some researchers have not published all their results — including findings that turn out not to support their hypotheses.
Discovery documents in a lawsuit over Alabama’s restrictions on pediatric medical transition suggest that the World Professional Association for Transgender Health interfered with systematic reviews it commissioned from a research team at Johns Hopkins University. According to the HHS report, “WPATH’s policy appears to have effectively blocked the planned and completed research — including critical evidence appraisals — from being developed into publishable manuscripts.” And in October, Johanna Olson-Kennedy, director of the gender clinic at the Children’s Hospital of Los Angeles, told the New York Times that she had delayed publishing the results of an NIH-funded study she conducted in part because she feared that its results would be “weaponized.”
The HHS report lays out these concerns in clear and careful language, and describes the ethical quandaries involved in intervening in the sexual development of minors, who might not be mature enough to give fully informed consent.
Critics who dispute the report’s conclusion raise valid concerns about its process. The 90 days allotted to produce such a report is a remarkably short time. To be sure, the authors drew on earlier reviews that came to similar conclusions about the strength of the evidence. But they also declined to publish their names, and their anonymity stands to weaken their credibility with the public.
Presumably, one reason they kept their names secret was because the underlying issue is so heated and polarized: A fierce activist backlash awaits anyone who calls for greater emphasis on psychotherapy in treating gender dysphoric youth. (Critics deride this approach as “conversion therapy.”)
What is clear is that, with many gender transition procedures ongoing and fierce debate over their effectiveness, better research is needed, and the government should be called on to support this work.
Better research means randomized and controlled studies that compare the effectiveness of the medical path with that of the best alternative psychotherapies. Today’s clinicians should be involved in this effort — after all, they have gained a wealth of clinical knowledge and have demonstrated their strong interest in helping children with gender dysphoria — but the research should be overseen by people who have no personal stake in the findings. In return for funding the work, the government should demand specific outcome measures in advance and prompt publication of data.
Given the weakness of the evidence that has been gathered to date, no one can predict what rigorous research will show. It is already obvious, however, that children dealing with gender dysphoria deserve better information and less disagreement over the path forward.
Clocking in at more than 400 pages, including appendixes, the HHS report is a careful, thorough and definitely skeptical tour through the subject, including the history of gender medicine, the evolution of pediatric interventions, the evidence for pediatric medical transition, and the ethical conundrums that researchers and practitioners face. Critics have been scathing about what they see as the report’s bias and shortcomings. But it makes a legitimate case for caution that policymakers need to wrestle with.
Charles Barkley takes stance on transgender athletes: ‘Men should not play sports against women’
"Men should not play sports against women. If anybody thinks that, I think they're stupid."
It is evident and also made explicit that the Trump admin has made vague, sweeping claims that the research in question is related to DEI or trans stuff, even when by any reasonable metric, in many cases it absolutely is not.
One of the sources for the piece above is a major academic advocate in the transgender space. I’ve interviewed him many times over the years. To his credit, he dismissed the demands from activists to blacklist me and said he’d just ask me himself what the story was with my gender medicine reporting. Imagine that!
A new paper focuses on how to address transgender and nonbinary minors' "embodiment goals" and concludes "that standard medical therapies [puberty blockers and cross-sex hormones] are ethically justified and that novel therapies can be ethically acceptable when carefully considered in the context of an individual youth’s care plan and taking into account the available theoretical, clinical and research evidence as well as the potential benefits and potential risks."
Are gay men doing enough to support trans women? Four community voices give their take
Dani St James, India Willoughby, Ella Morgan and Mzz Kimberley give their take in our regular Foursight feature
Mzz Kimberley (she/her)
Actress/singer
Gay men are a red flag. It’s devastating. But let’s not get it twisted — there are wonderful gay men who do understand our struggles. They recognise the shared challenges of marginalisation, the importance of solidarity. But there are others who cling to traditional, rigid views of gender and sexuality. Ironically, these same men will corner your boyfriend at the bar, proudly informing him you’re “really a man”. When rejected, they don’t realise they could have endangered your life for the sake of a failed attempt at a quick shag. These men strive to conform to the very social constructs that have long oppressed all marginalised people, seeking validation from the same systems that demean them.
Then there are those who parrot so-called ‘gender-critical’ rhetoric and transphobic talking points and reduce our existence to mere ideology. They’re often the men who once despised lesbians yet are now united in a shared mission to erase trans women.
Unfortunately, there’s too much division and hostility within our ranks. Some want to dictate how others should think and behave, only to create more fractures.
Nowhere in this criticism of the HHS report on pediatric gender-transition treatment does gender-affirming surgeon Blair Peters acknowledge that it is a report about children, not adults. Instead, he frames the matter as pertaining to “trans people” in general.
Kellan Baker runs the Whitman-Walker Institute, so his PhD has everything to do with his work. He has every right to be referred to as Dr. Baker, and anyone who insists otherwise is just denying reality in the same way that they often accuse transgender people of denying reality.
Transgender medicine is based on the metaphysical belief of patients that they either are or should be the opposite sex. Doctors seek to reconcile this by changing the patient’s body to align it with how they believe their sex is or should be. Therefore the medical field is based on metaphysics. Therefore it is logical that a philosopher should be a coauthor of a massive HHS report analyzing the field of pediatric gender medicine.
Florence Ashley is herself essentially a philosopher and is a widely influential figure in trans medicine, incidentally.
Quotes a post by T08261; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
In which Whitman-Walker’s Kellan Baker tells a brazen falsehood that WPATH’s trans care guidelines were based on multiple systematic literature reviews, despite the fact that the adolescent chapter said that in WPATH’s opinion, such a review was impossible to conduct about minors. And despite the fact that WPATH commissioned many such reviews about trans care, but then suppressed them when they were unhappy with the results. They picked Baker, a WPATH member, to write one of only two SRs that ever saw the light of day.
And yet Science magazine allows Baker to make these claims with no objection.
Quotes a post by T31015; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The Whitman-Walker Institute's Kellan Baker told @[private account]'s @[private account] of the HHS report on pediatric gender medicine, "A mere 90 days is not enough time to conduct a thorough review" and that WPATH spent more than a decade compiling multiple systematic literature reviews to develop its Standards of Care 8 trans-care guidelines, published in 2022. (Left screenshot.)
Dr. Baker is not telling the truth, not about pediatric gender care.
Here's what the SoC 8's adolescent chapter actually said on the subject (right screenshot): "a systematic review regarding outcomes of treatment in adolescents is not possible." And so it provided a "short narrative review" on the subject instead. (Other evidence-based medicine experts have asserted that such a review most definitely is possible. To wit, many have been produced since 2019.)
Dr. Baker was the lead author of one of two of the WPATH systematic reviews on trans care that it commissioned from Johns Hopkins University. The HHS report's umbrella review downgraded it as unreliable due to potential bias and excluded it from its analysis for not distinguishing between adolescents and adults. (The HHS analysis was only about minors.)
Documents subpoenaed by the Alabama attorney general revealed that Dr. Baker was among those in WPATH leadership who suppressed several other systematic literature reviews that Johns Hopkins produced on their behalf when they didn't like the results.
Recently, I reported on a memo that was leaked to me that Dr Baker and other pediatric gender-transition treatment advocates marshaled and sent to like-minded organizations in which they advised on how to combat Trump's attacks on these health care practices. They advised against engaging people in debates about the science in the field, which they asserted were only ever made in bad faith.
UCSF is holding a "Transgender Medicine, Surgery, and Mental Health Care Clinician Training Institute, a Pre-Conference to the 2025 Transgender Health Summit," on May 29 and 30.
This schedule of sessions provides an interesting window into how leaders in this field conceive of training and education of other practitioners:
If there is a field that calls itself pediatric gender medicine, therefore there is such a field, even if people think it should be called something else.
Same holds for trans identities. They exist because people identify as trans, even if other people think that one cannot or should not identify as the opposite sex.
I can't tell you how many people get into fisticuffs with me over these very simple concepts.
There is this curious subset of people who, in addition to denying that there are transgender identities, will go even further to say that there is no such thing as the field of gender-transition medicine. I don't know where to go with that level of denial.
Quotes a post by T27203; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
As someone else pointed out, isn’t much of the transgender movement based on philosophy established by Judith Butler? And isn’t pediatric gender-transition treatment an effort to medicalize that philosophy? How is this at all controversial?
Quoting @benryanwriter: Correct. From Wikipedia: “Metaphysics is the branch of philosophy that examines the basic structure of reality.”
More lies from Caraballo about Jesse. Anyone who has read his Atlantic article will recall that it was deeply rooted in interviews with transgender youth.
This is an apparent contradiction that adults such as myself have trouble reconciling with: that there is an apparent element of adolescent culture today that, at least in certain communities, values and valorizes trans over gay identities.
Erin Reed is thus incredulous at the suggestion in the new HHS report on pediatric gender-transition treatment:
The HHS reports says the research on pediatric gender medicine is of poor quality, per all the systematic literature reviews. WaPo says that trans advocates say that it’s the report that is poor quality research.
Kellan Baker, executive director of the Institute for Health Research and Policy at Whitman-Walker, issued a statement through an independent PR agency, also slamming the HHS report:
https://benryan.substack.com/p/the-effort-to-discredit-hhss-massive
"This report is pure politics masquerading as science. Rather than following the recommendations of every major US expert medical association, including the American Medical Association and the American Academy of Pediatrics, it pushes the dangerous and discredited practice of conversion therapy to try to force transgender people to change a fundamental, deeply rooted part of who they are. The ultimate goal of this report is to impose a political agenda in place of science and to insert the federal government where it does not belong—between healthcare providers and the families and patients they care for."
Dr. Baker is incorrect that all medical associations back pediatric gender-transition treatment. The American Society of Plastic Surgeons quite notably has not endorsed it, as I reported last summer.
https://benryan.substack.com/p/top-plastic-surgeon-wont-commit-to
Also, Dr. Baker joins a long tradition among transgender activists of playing the conversion therapy card when combatting efforts to promote psychotherapy over gender-transition drugs to treat gender dysphoria. These advocates will claim, often without evidence, that anything short of their preferred methods of caring for gender-dysphoric children is conversion therapy, meaning a deliberate and often forced or coerced effort to change an individual’s gender identity.
As @JesseSingal reported, the HHS report’s authors are actually arguing that many of the psychological impacts of gender dysphoria, such as depression and anxiety, can be treated through psychotherapy. Therefore, the report asserts that recommending mental health counseling for gender-dysphoric youth is sound, evidence-based practice. By contrast, the report asserts, prescribing puberty blockers and cross-sex hormones and providing gender-transition surgeries to minors is not based on sound evidence and can come with with significant risks, including infertility and sexual dysfunction.
Dr. Baker was one of the architects behind the leaked memo that I reported on in February that advised supporters of pediatric gender medicine on how to combat Trump’s attacks on the field. The memo recommended avoiding any attempts by others to engage in debates over the science behind this field, claiming that such arguments were invariably made in bad faith. This despite the fact that Dr. Baker was among the group of leaders at the World Professional Association for Transgender Health (WPATH) who suppressed systematic literature reviews of gender medicine after the findings were not to the group’s liking as they drafted their 2022 revision to WPATH’s trans-care guidelines.
https://benryan.substack.com/p/leaked-lgbtq-groups-memo-on-combatting
LINK: The effort to discredit HHS's massive report on pediatric gender medicine is fast underway
https://benryan.substack.com/p/the-effort-to-discredit-hhss-massive
The 409-page report is a surprisingly dispassionate document, given it was published at the behest of the Trump administration, which has engaged in an outright assault on transgender people.
The effort to discredit HHS's massive report on pediatric gender medicine is fast underway
🧵⬇️The 409-page report is a surprisingly dispassionate document, given it was published at the behest of the White House, which has engaged in an outright assault on transgender people.
The British Medical Association slams the UK Supreme Court ruling that a woman is a biological woman:
"This meeting condemns the Supreme Court ruling defining the term 'woman' with respect to the Equality Act as being based on 'biological sex', which they refer to as a person who 'was at birth of the female sex', as reductive, trans and intersex-exclusionary and biologically nonsensical.
"We recognize as doctors that sex and gender are complex and multifaceted aspects of the human condition and attempting to impose a rigid binary has no basis in science or medicine while being actively harmful to transgender and gender diverse people. As such this meeting:
"i: Reiterates the BMA's position on affirming the rights of transgender and non-binary individuals to live their lives with dignity, having their identity respected.
"ii. Reminds the Supreme Court of the existence of intersex people and reaffirms their right to exist in the gender identity that matches their sense of self, regardless of whether this matches any identity assigned to them at birth.
"iii. Condemns scientifically illiterate rulings from the Supreme Court, made without consulting relevant experts and stakeholders, that will cause real-world harm to the trans, non-binary and intersex communities in this country.
"iv. Commits to strive for better access to necessary health services for trans, non-binary and gender-diverse people."
This point of @[private account]’s isn’t simple, it’s simplistic. It is a facile and just plain incorrect interpretation to blame Jesse Singal for Republicans’ actions. As if they ever needed or sought his permission for any of their campaigning about trans issues.
Or, @[private account] might ask how the violent activist reaction to Jesse Singal’s well-balanced, respectful and circumspect 2018 Atlantic article on pediatric gender-transition treatment only alienated many people and caused them to question the trans activist movement as a whole.
Trans identification in young people is not a niche issue. There has been exponential growth in trans identification with each successive year, as evidenced by this chart breaking down the proportion of each age with such an identity. Notice the explosion among people who hit adolescence after the onset of smartphone-based social media apps (about 2012).
Quotes a post by T21810; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Noah Kulwin says he remains proud of having encouraged Jesse Singal to commit s—cide over his trans reporting and says he’s sorry that more people haven’t encouraged me to do the same.
I often wonder how people who talk like this get ahead in this world.
Quotes a post by T13008; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Jesse Singal's reporting on pediatric gender medicine was never political; your claim that he sought some sort of GOP political victory is a scurrilous projection on your part. It was everyone else who politicized his reporting, for example by telling lies, like you have, that he is "anti-trans." The reporting was always about shining a light on a series of medical practices that come with substantial risks to children but that have not been thoroughly studied.
Quotes a post by T21810; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Leaked Gender-Affirmative Training Videos, Part 5: Olson-Kennedy On Trans People Meeting Cis Expectations
https://benryan.substack.com/p/leaked-gender-affirmative-training-017
The prevailing theme of this video is Dr. Johanna Olson-Kennedy's exasperation over all the hurdles that trans youth have to jump through to make cisgender people happy.
If the American public has any interest in preventing and treating sexually transmitted infections, including HIV, monkeypox, syphilis and gonorrhea, then the federal government will fund research about men who have sex with men, which is the term used in public health research for such individuals, because not all men who have sex with men identify as gay or bisexual. MSM have vastly higher rates of STIs than heterosexuals. (Cue people with the bright idea to just tell them not to have sex.)
But the Trump administration has, in a matter of weeks, all but destroyed federal funding of research into gay and transgender health and well-being alike, as I reported for NBC News.
Quoting @dcexaminer: Biden administration spent millions on studies, programs related to ‘men who have sex with men’ https://trib.al/8pWJtIw
An academic doctor made a skeptical remark about pediatric gender-transition treatment and was made to pay a heavy price, financially and career-wise. He sued and has received a hefty settlement.
https://open.substack.com/pub/bariweiss/p/doctor-fired-for-trans-comments-gets-settlement
Both sides of the trans debate in the UK are accusing the other of misogyny, I see.
Quoting @ScotNational: Blatant misogyny lies at the heart of the so-called gender-critical movement. I say this because its entire belief of what it means to be a woman is built on outdated tropes and shifting sands. // Mhairi Black
Worth revisiting this thread on people saying that trans women are biological women, in light of the UK Supreme Court ruling defining women as those who were biologically born women:
Quoting @benryanwriter: Prominent transgender people who have asserted that trans women are “biological women.”
A thread🧵
From transsexuality to gender diversity
Hacking’s looping theory as an explanation for the sharply increasing number of adolescents seeking gender affirming medical care
Over the past decade there has been a surge in the number of young people seeking medical treatment to change their gender. What makes looking for explanations difficult is the problem that concepts such as transgender are moving targets: they are constantly changing. This study tries to solve this by applying Ian Hacking’s ‘looping theory’ on the historical development of these concepts. Hacking examined how classifications and labels influence self-perception and behavior, and vice versa, how the classified people fight for acknowledgement and a change of labels. Four socio-historic periods are identified, describing the interactions between political institutions, medical and health organizations, academic centers, advocacy groups, (social) media and the people involved. This study shows that the increase in medical transitions can partly be explained by the changing concept of trans into a non-medical identity label, with self-identification as the single defining characteristic. The result was a broadening of the eligible population.
NEWS: The UK Supreme Court rules that the legal definition of a woman is based on biological sex
Judges say the "concept of sex is binary" while cautioning that the landmark ruling should not be seen as victory of one side over another
Transgender people still have legal protection from discrimination, the court adds.
Jack Turban seems to imply as much, but hasn't been quite that explicit. He says that because trans people are oppressed, this impedes their sporting success as it is.
Emma Vigeland has said she doesn't care if it's unfair, that inclusion trumps all.
Both sides of the vitriolic debate over trans inclusion in sports and in single-sex spaces accuses the other of misogyny. One says it’s misogynistic to allow natal males in women’s spaces, and the other says it’s misogynistic to insist on strict gender roles. The other side says that it’s regressive to suggest that if someone is gender nonconforming, they need to change their body to effect the opposite sex, because archaic gender boundaries govern this dynamic.
Quoting @legaltweetz: I wrote this a year ago today and it came true:
Transphobia is rooted deeply in misogyny. The overarching goal of the current movement against trans people is a return to a patriarchal society. Where men are men & women are virtuous child bearers. This harms all groups, including women’s right to abortion access. Along with being deeply rooted in white supremacy.
The current movement against trans people is scapegoating an entire group for the greater existential anxieties of people. Instead of focusing on climate change, war, & rising inflation, people can scapegoat trans people for all of their problems. An easy target for their greater anxieties.
This will lead to authoritarian rule if it doesn’t stop. Transphobia will ultimately lead to fascism. Women’s rights will be lost & white supremacy & Christian nationalism will take over.
No, it wasn't. It was him yelling. He brought on one expert to talk about fairness in sport, a transgender woman. He didn't bring on, say, @[private account] from the @[private account].
John Oliver has a new, 42-minute follow-up video to his previous spot on cross-sex participation in sports. He said he stood by everything he previously said, even as he acknowledged that there was at least room for discussion that at the elite level trans women held an advantage
Quoting @benryanwriter: John Oliver, in arguing how the Dems should respond to the trans kids issue, falsely claims “there is no evidence” trans kids “pose any threat” to fairness in sports.
There absolutely is evidence that trans females have a competitive advantage.
This is a surprising move. After conservatives lavished criticism on Biden's assistant secretary of health at HHS, Rachel Levine, for being transgender, Trump has nominated a doctor for that spot who specializes in penile implant surgery and has treated trans people.
Debunking podcaster Michael Hobbes (né Mike Baab) makes demonstrably false claims here about Jesse Singal's writing compared with what Trump has said about trans kids in his executive orders. (There's a typo in the quote tweet. It should read "Trump" and not "Trunk.")
Quoting @benryanwriter: Debunking podcaster Michael Hobbes falsely claims that Singal is parroting Trump. Trunk has sought to ban gender transition treatment for people under 19, period. He is not interested in improving the evidence base.
Over on the other social media app, you'll find the predictable parade of activists falsely accusing @JesseSingal of a long history of animus toward trans people and making vague claims of dishonesty on his part that they fail to substantiate in any way.
Quoting @benryanwriter: For @[private account], @JesseSingal calls on @[private account], the new @[private account] head, to reform youth gender medicine with the aim of producing better evidence, rather than banning it and destroying the field.
Nature has published guidance that @[private account] leadership sent to grant management staff yesterday on how to manage grant applications and rejections. It provided sample language for responding to requests for grant application updates: “It is the policy of the NIH not to prioritize [select one of the following: diversity, equity and inclusion (DEI) research programs, gender identity, vaccine hesitancy, climate change or countries of concern, e.g., China or South Africa.]”
It is very clear from the roster of hundreds of canceled grants that the NIH has taken a sweepingly broad view on what constitutes DEI, such as studying an intervention to reduce HIV infections in Black gay men, who have by far the highest rate of infection. Grants that only mention transgender people in passing have also been canceled. Consequently, numerous grants focusing on gay populations have been swept up into the effort to purge the federal government of trans- and DEI-related research.
My sources have painted a dire picture of a lost generation of researchers focusing on gay and transgender populations and those living with and at risk for HIV.
The NIH has cancelled hundreds of research grants in recent weeks, under the guise of banning attention to transgender and what the Trump administration considers DEI matters. Many of these cancellations have eliminated research into HIV and health disparities among gay people.
Quoting @benryanwriter: Here is a 14-page list of canceled research grants. https://taggs.hhs.gov/Content/Data/HHS_Grants_Terminated.pdf
LINK: Leaked Gender-Affirmative Training Videos, Part 3: The Parents' Path to Acceptance
https://benryan.substack.com/p/leaked-gender-affirmative-training
Johanna Olson-Kennedy's colleague, Darlene Tando, schools other mental health professionals on how to guide parents from resistance to acceptance of their child's transgender identity.
Leaked Gender-Affirmative Training Videos, Part 3: The Parents' Path to Acceptance
🧵⬇️: Johanna Olson-Kennedy's colleague, Darlene Tando, schools other mental health professionals on how to guide parents from resistance to acceptance of their child's transgender identity.
The letters sent to grantees about why they are being canceled make vague allusions to transgender people or DEI, even if the grants have almost nothing to do with either.
Then what would we call transgender people? Are we to refer to them at all?
Quoting @JamesEsses: We need to stop using the term ‘trans’ altogether.
A ‘trans woman’ makes about as much sense as a ‘human horse’ or an ‘adolescent geriatric’.
People often point to the scant number of transgender athletes in the NCAA. This elides what a lot of parents are seeing in their kids’ middle and high school teams: a new generation in which trans identification and cross-sex sports participation has become increasingly common.
Quotes a post by T02439; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Is the answer to supposedly bad science supported the @[private account] sweepingly canceling grants, sometimes apparently because of certain verboten keywords like "transgender" or "equity"?
Or is the answer engaging in careful and cautious review to identify wasteful spending?
Quotes a post by T17693; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
California Gov. Gavin Newsom listens as conservative radio host Michael Savage says that the trans activist movement lost women in particular when kids started getting “brainwashed” about trans issues in school. “The people had had enough,” Savage says.
This person accuses one of the leaders in pediatric medicine, Johanna Olson-Kennedy, of "malicious incuriosity" about the reason for the surge in transgender identification in youths.
Quotes a post by T01040; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
World Pride will be held in DC in June. This is doubly awkward to say the least. Not only has the Trump administration issued an assault on transgender rights in particular, but the Supreme Court is set to rule in June on whether Tennessee's ban on gender-transition treatment for minors is legal. Could watchers believe that SCOTUS will likely uphold the law, which would unleash a torrent of upset during LGBTQ Pride month.
NEW IN FREE-SPEECH ON CAMPUS: Harvard professor says any professor who joins groups that oppose the gender-affirming care method of treating gender dysphoria in kids should be fired, @[private account] student paper reports
"Timothy McCarthy, a human rights activist and professor at @Harvard University, told WSN that the tactics employed by organizations like @[private account] and @Genspect are part of a longer history of spreading misinformation about trans identity. McCarthy said that while a level of suspicion and inquiry into medical practices is healthy, the purpose of questioning the validity of gender-affirming care is oftentimes intended to 'poison the waters' and raise concern around the common practice.
"McCarthy said that if any professor at any university, including Harvard, were found to be a member of organizations like Therapy First and Genspect, they should be removed and stripped of their academic titles.
"'There’s a particular place in hell for academics who use their academic expertise and power to distort and do violence to people in the world,' McCarthy said."
Writer @[private account] calls for a "sane middle" for transgender issues and rights, decrying extremism and bullying.
"It would certainly not look like bullying, dehumanizing or mocking transgender people, or subjecting them to a blanket military ban. It wouldn’t look like winding back the clock on decades of recognition of transgender people’s ability to live as they wish and enjoy basic respect: America is a free country in which the presumption should be that everyone decides for themselves on their version of the good life.
"But a sane middle would also (as in countries like the United Kingdom and Sweden) move towards stringent safeguards for any gender transition interventions for underage patients. Such a movement would recognize the need to protect single-sex female sports while creating equitable options for transgender people to participate in athletics. It would mean a return to some objective medical criteria for legal transition for adults rather than self-ID, and a pulling back from rhetoric that denies biological sex or demands unquestioning recognition for any self-declared gender identity. And, above all, it would involve open debate rather than dogma in an area of human life that is still so little understood."
LEAKED: Trans-Care Training Videos By Beleaguered Top Gender-Clinic Doctor, Part 1
I am publishing 12 hours of videos of Dr. Johanna Olson-Kennedy and colleagues in which they train mental-health providers on treating children who identify as transgender.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4AqWRme67rU
The gender dysphoria criteria, Dr. Olson-Kennedy notes, include a:
https://benryan.substack.com/p/leaked-trans-care-training-videos
1. Strong desire to be the other gender.
2. Strong cross-dressing desire. On this point, Dr. Olson-Kennedy expresses profound disdain, saying that the cross-dressing question is different for masculine- and feminine-presenting people, because of the patriarchy and misogyny and our feelings about people who perceived as men wearing women’s clothing. She scoffs at the fact that natal males are referred to as cross-dressers but natal females are not.
3. Strong preference for cross-gender roles in make-believe play or fantasy play. A lot of times kids will tell her about the video-game avatars that they use, through which they explore their questions about their gender. Back in the day, this was about playing house.
4. Strong preference for toys, games or activities of the other gender.
5. Strong preference for playmates of the other gender.
6. For boys, a strong avoidance typically masculine toys and activities and rough-and-tumble play—which Dr. Olson-Kennedy says is very 50s.
7. Strong dislike of one’s sexual anatomy. Dr. Olson-Kennedy objects, saying, “Your brain is actually the biggest sexual organ in your body.” She says that there are many problems with these diagnostic criteria, but that observing them becomes a necessity to obtain insurance coverage.
8. Strong desire for primary or secondary sex characteristics of the opposite sex.
Gender dysphoria, according to the DSM, must be associated with clinically significant distress or impairment in school or other areas of functioning.
For pre-pubertal children, Dr. Olson-Kennedy says, “these diagnostic criteria are not super useful.”
In later videos, she and her colleagues will express their disapproval of the requirement that the child be distressed to qualify as gender dysphoric and therefore for gender-transition treatment.
Not everyone who has this experience of gender dysphoria or incongruence during childhood is going to stay transgender, Dr. Olson-Kennedy says. There are lots of males who like dresses and dolls.
Gendering can be traumatic to everyone, Dr. Olson-Kennedy says. The gender-affirming care bans (which today have swept through half the states) are only “adding to the trauma for trans youths,” she says.
https://benryan.substack.com/p/leaked-trans-care-training-videos
She charts the neural development of children, noting how by age six there is a surfeit of neural pathways in children’s brains. (I had to cut out this part due to sounds that might reveal the identity of the person who taped the session.) Then, during adolescence, synaptic pruning pares them back—the use-it-or-lose-it phenomenon at play. Trans kids, she says, have neural pathways that are established vis-à-vis the trans experience—from being told, overtly or covertly, that they are not okay.
“This is a chronic experience of trauma,” she says.
She goes through case studies of children presenting as transgender at very young ages, including one natal boy who was so adamant about being a girl and frustrated about being denied this reality that the child would fly into rages at night, destroying things around the nursery.
Then she shows a cartoon—a true story—about a mother coming to terms with her young natal boy identifying as a girl. “Now I have a daughter,” the mom says. “A really happy one. I do miss my baby boy. Sometimes I wonder where he is. He is like a dream I had.”
“Gender essentialism,” meaning “sex equals genitals,” which often starts when parents learn the sex of a baby in the womb, Dr. Olson-Kennedy says, is wrong. “It erases trans experience and trans people,” she asserts. “It creates a chronic environment that’s skeptical and, now, increasingly hostile, that creates a scenario whereby people have to prove their gender before they can be affirmed either socially, legally and certainly medically.” And it supports a hierarchy in which cisgender people (non-trans people) hold supremacy. https://benryan.substack.com/p/leaked-trans-care-training-videos
“Mostly, gender is like an onion,” Dr. Olson-Kennedy says. “It has all of these layers.”
“Sometimes gender makes us cry and sometimes we cut it up and put it in spaghetti sauce,” she says.
https://benryan.substack.com/p/leaked-trans-care-training-videos
Dr. Olson-Kennedy is keen to note that shoe-wear for girls and women is often not comfortable—the dreaded heels.
https://benryan.substack.com/p/leaked-trans-care-training-videos
She goes through physical differences in faces that are typical for men vs. women. She refers to men as “people with XY chromosomes” and points out that, for example, they tend to have an Adam’s apple.
Sexual and romantic attraction is often conflated with gender identity, she says.
Today, children's clothing and toys are highly gendered, Dr. Olson-Kennedy notes with withering disapproval. These differences signal to children what is expected of them based on what she calls their assigned sex at birth. https://benryan.substack.com/p/leaked-trans-care-training-videos
Dr. Olson-Kennedy goes through the basics of what gender identity is and how we all have one. The majority of those who are registered as male at birth identify as male, and same for females, she says. Gender expression doesn’t just include hair, clothing and name. There are myriad other ways of expressing gender that give people around us cues.
https://benryan.substack.com/p/leaked-trans-care-training-videos
Then she walks through the beginning of gender-transition treatments with synthetic hormones in the 1930s. However, “Trans people have existed since people,” she says. In the old days, people expressed their trans identity through clothing and their occupation.
Dr. Olson-Kennedy is keen to emphasize that the numbers they have seen have nevertheless been small. “In the largest clinic in the county, we are still not seeing thousands and thousands of people every year,” she says.
https://benryan.substack.com/p/leaked-trans-care-training-videos
Language is important when talking with these patients, she says. She asks her patients which language for their body parts feels most comfortable to them.
In her office, Dr. Olson Kennedy says, she has a “gender abacus” for anatomy, gender identity, gender expression and sexual/romantic attraction, which she provides to her patients to help them express where they believe they lie on these respective spectrums. She does this because she found that families were conflating gender identity with gender expression. “I actually don’t think that female and male are the ends, like some sort of linear relationship to each other,” she says. But for “non-community members,” she says, this is how they think about gender.
Referrals to Dr. Olson-Kennedy's gender clinic in Los Angeles, she notes, took off in 2015. After that time, the sex ratio inverted, with more natal girls than natal boys presenting to the clinic. Nonbinary identification has also increased, she says. https://benryan.substack.com/p/leaked-trans-care-training-videos
Video number 1: Johanna Olson-Kennedy on the gender basics
https://benryan.substack.com/p/leaked-trans-care-training-videos
Dr. Olson-Kennedy opens the video by charting the recent shift in transgender visibility in popular media, which she says has improved dramatically in recent years. Previously, transgender people were frequently presented as sex workers, according to at GLAAD analysis. But these days, TV has benefited from the likes of Jazz Jennings and shows like Transparent and Pose that center on the transgender experience, Dr. Olson-Kennedy says. Having stories about youth in the media in particular, she says, has influenced the seeking of gender-transition treatment by young people.
She expresses concern that the trans kids whose stories have been told in the media are generally white. This is reflective, she says, of the disproportionately white patient population at gender clinics in the U.S. and Europe. “It is important for all of us to think about what those barriers to care are for other communities and work really hard to dismantle those barriers.”
This remark speaks to a common dichotomy among advocates in this medical field: They will at once characterize the number of children receiving these treatments as low (as Dr. Olson-Kennedy does a bit later in the video), emphasizing that the political firestorm over this population is disproportionate to its size, while also decrying how few kids are receiving the treatment.
Since 2021, Dr. Olson-Kennedy says, we’ve seen a “problematic” visibility of trans youth as states have moved to ban these treatments. She shows a Google search she conducted of “transgender youth care” the night before. “All of these six headlines, and there’s many more,” she says, “are negative, and they speak to moves being made to ban access to care.”
LINK:
LEAKED: Trans-Care Training Videos By Beleaguered Top Gender-Clinic Doctor, Part 1
https://benryan.substack.com/p/leaked-trans-care-training-videos
I am publishing 12 hours of videos of Dr. Johanna Olson-Kennedy and colleagues in which they train mental-health providers on treating children who have gender dysphoria or otherwise identify as trans.
Subscribe to my newsletter to receive all the videos as I publish them.
LEAKED: Trans-Care Training Videos By Beleaguered Top Gender-Clinic Doctor, Part 1
I have obtained 12 hours of videos of top pediatric-gender-clinic physician Dr. Johanna Olson-Kennedy and her colleagues, including her husband, providing training to mental-health providers on how to treat minors who have gender dysphoria or otherwise identify as transgender or nonbinary.
This is the first of 12 installments I will post during the coming weeks of these videos. Subscribe to my newsletter (link in bio) to receive all of them as I publish them.
A 19-year veteran of the pediatric gender medicine field and one of its leading physician-researchers and advocates, Dr. Olson-Kennedy is the medical director of the gender clinic at Children’s Hospital Los Angeles. According to figures she provided during this particular video, annual referrals to her clinic surged from just 25 in 2010 to 436 in 2022—following a similar pattern seen in clinics throughout the Western world.
The past six months have been challenging for Dr. Olson-Kennedy, to say the least.
Dr. Olson-Kennedy is the principal investigator on a National Institutes of Health grant for a long-running research project concerning pediatric gender-transition treatment, one that has received over $10 million to date. In October, The New York Times reported that she has withheld null findings from a study of puberty blockers funded by this grant, doing so for political reasons. The grant is now the subject of a probe by congressional Republicans. In November, however, she asserted in a sworn deposition in a civil case that the Times had mischaracterized her words.
In December, Dr. Olson-Kennedy was sued by a former patient, Clementine Breen, who reported that the gender doctor prescribed her puberty blockers at age 12—on her first appointment, without a psychological assessment—and testosterone at age 13, and then referred her to receive a double mastectomy at age 14. Ms. Breen, now 20, has since detransitioned, reverting to presenting and identifying as a woman.
The Trump administration has unleashed an onslaught against the field of pediatric gender medicine, seeking to wipe it off the map. In recent weeks, the NIH has been canceling research grants related to transgender people, including those conducted with animal models. There is currently a preliminary injunction in place to block the president’s executive order that would freeze federal funds to hospitals that provide gender-transition interventions to those under age 19. Prior to the injunction, Dr. Olson-Kennedy’s clinic had “paused” new cross-sex hormone treatments for youth, only to lift the pause a couple of weeks later.
It remains unclear whether the grant for which Dr. Olson-Kennedy is the top investigator has been canceled. But it is no longer listed on the NIH site where active grants are described.
I reached out to Dr. Olson-Kennedy and her co-principal investigators on the grant to ask about its status. I did not hear back.
Prior to the October Times article, Dr. Olson-Kennedy was perhaps best known by the general public for a previous leaked video in which she was giving a training in 2018 to mental health care providers on how to write referral letters for minors seeking gender-transition surgeries. In the video, she expresses exasperation with what she sees as hand wringing over whether natal girls will later regret having their breast removed during adolescence. (At least 1,000 such surgeries have been conducted annually in recent years.)
She says: “What we do know is that adolescents actually have the capacity to make a reasonable, logical decision. And here’s the other thing about chest surgery. If you want breasts at a later point in your life, you can go and get them!”
Ms. Breen recently reported that she was undergoing reconstructive surgery to provide herself with new breasts. However, it is very unlikely she will ever be able to breastfeed should she have children.
Dr. Olson-Kennedy is also newly the president of USPATH, the U.S. branch of the medical-activist group the World Professional Association for Transgender Health. WPATH, which despite is name is largely a U.S.-based organization, has been besieged by damaging publicity over the past year, in particular after internal documents subpoenaed by Alabama’s attorney general revealed that its leadership was aware that the evidence behind pediatric gender medicine was weak and sought to paper over this fact.
12 hours of leaked Olson-Kennedy training videos
The 12-hour training in what is known as the gender-affirming care method for minors who identify as trans or nonbinary took place in late April 2024—a few weeks after Britain published the Cass Review, which found that this medical field is based on “remarkably weak evidence.” The training was led by Dr. Olson-Kennedy; her husband, Aydin Olson-Kennedy, who has a doctorate in social work and is a transgender man; and licensed clinical social worker Darlene Tando.
I obtained the videos a few months ago.
The training videos are a window into not just the methods of these individuals, but their overall attitudes about gender dysphoria and transgender and nonbinary identification in children. A prevailing attitude they share is one of indignation and irritation with a medical system that demands that children betray a substantial level of distress before they are granted gender-transition medications. Overall, these three favor less gatekeeping and less pathologizing of the mental states and internal lives of the children in their care. If a gender-incongruent child arrives in their care absent any particular distress about their identification as the opposite sex, they believe that that child should be granted the opportunity to medically transition by taking puberty blockers and cross-sex hormones if the family wishes.
I have edited the videos to snip or crop out images that would identify the participants in the training, whether because of Zoom-chat questions that pop up in the right-hand corner of the screen, or moments when a matrix of the participants is visible. You can watch the video at the beginning of this Substack. Otherwise, I wrote a summary below:
Rep. Mary Miller, an Illinois Republican, leans into asserting that Rep. Sarah McBride, a transgender-woman Democrat from Delaware, is male in the wake of the dust-up over a Republican colleague referring to McBride as "Mr. McBride" in a congressional meeting today.
Quoting @RepMaryMiller: Tim “Sarah” McBride is a biological man and always will be.
I spoke with an actual expert in men who want to be castrated last year and he expressed his horror at how his cautious and nuanced approach to this pathology was tossed out the window in favor of an identity-based approach when @[private account] wrote the notorious Eunuchs chapter in its 2022 revision to its trans-care guidelines, the Standards of Care 8.
Ingle also wrote: “All roads now lead to the NCAA championships in March, where Thomas could become swimming’s first transgender All-American champion.”
On this point, he was correct. Thomas came in first in the 500-yard women’s freestyle in 2022. This photo would do more than anything to turn the public against trans inclusion in women’s sports.
Telling people that their eyes deceive them about the unfairness of trans inclusion in sports and that instead they are bigots—is this a winning strategy?
Quoting @benryanwriter: What's remarkable is that even after recent polling showing that the general public overwhelmingly opposes trans girls in girls' sports, Parker Molloy's policy is still to just call everyone bigots. Will that win anyone over?
What's remarkable is that even after recent polling showing that the general public overwhelmingly opposes trans girls in girls' sports, Parker Molloy's policy is still to just call everyone bigots. Will that win anyone over?
Here's where the progressives and trans activists have lost the general public:
People take one look at Lia Thomas in the pool, and their brains scream: "Unfair!" Below is an image of Thomas off the starting block, way up higher than all the women Thomas is competing against.
But then Parker Molloy comes along and tells people who look at this picture and see unfairness and denounces them as transphobic. And so these people start to tune out all the other accusations of transphobia, which now have less merit in their minds. Some of them even begin radicalize.
I don't think adult trans activists have any idea how common trans girls' participation in youth sports has become. This means that everyday parents all over the nation are steadily turning against the trans movement when they visit their 7th grader's soccer game or their 12th grader's track meet.
Quoting @benryanwriter: Research indicates that even after undergoing lengthy testosterone suppression and estrogen treatment, natal males who identify as female hold a competitive advantage in women’s sports. This is not just about height. It’s about muscle strength, shoulder and hand size, oxygen processing, etc.
And there are teenage boys who can bear Katie Ledecky, one of the most unbeatable long-distance swimmers in history.
The worst thing about this whole “90 minutes, no intermission” thing in theater these days is you can’t leave at intermission.
We saw an off-Broadway play about a pregnant trans man whose sister was about to publish a paper about how they’d discovered the gene for gender dysphoria and how to eliminate it in infants.
Tension ensured between the siblings and his nonbinary partner. It was interrupted intermittently by a maudlin account of the early days of Adam and Eve. (Not Adam and Steve, in case you were wondering.)
Was this potentially profound plot well executed?
No.
It’s always weird when I get the exact same accusation about my supposed biases, but from the opposite sides of the trans debate. All because I said, “This study is garbage.” I can’t keep track why these people think I want everyone to die.
Quotes a post by A2532; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Beware the dreaded confidence interval! It can come for your claims about left-handedness prevalence and how its supposedly an analogy for trans identification prevalence in children.
Quotes a post by T00517; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Perhaps the best study available to assess whether gender transition surgery in adults impacts mental health outcomes was conducted on a massive set of data from Sweden. It compared transgender people who had surgery with those who didn't and found no difference in outcomes. This study that Dr. Haim calls a bombshell is a comparatively weak study.
Quotes a post by A0873; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
This study is not a bombshell. It is a weak study with a lot of limitations that render their findings almost meaningless.
The criterion for including data on trans adults who underwent gender-transition surgery in the analysis was they had to have no other psych diagnoses before the surgery. Given the very high rate of psych diagnoses in this population, that’s a major red flag.
Then the question was what proportion of them had a psych diagnosis in their file about two years after the surgery, compared with a matched control group of trans people who didn’t get surgery.
It’s entirely possible that:
a) The surgery group did have mental health problems before surgery that just weren’t noted in their chart. And then after the surgery, they spent more energy looking at those other problems and that is what prompted the new diagnoses.
b) People who were more distressed (but for whatever reason had no psych diagnoses prior to surgery) were more likely to get surgery.
Also note that this study was not about minors.
Quotes a post by A0873; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
This protester doesn’t realize that in his speech before Congress, Trump did not mistake transgenic mice for “transgender mice.” He was referring to animal-model research into cross-sex hormones.
https://open.substack.com/pub/benryan/p/trump-claimed-the-nih-spent-8-million?r=7wxo1&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web&showWelcomeOnShare=false
Turban also claims in his Substack that the conclusion of some of these assessments will be that gender transition treatment is not right for particular children. But he makes no such suggestion in his recent paper on how to conduct these assessments. The first thing he states in a bullet point list of what these assessments should entail is that they are not meant to determine whether a child is “truly trans.” (Scare quotes his.)
The question so many want to ask about the reports of a population of children who will attempt suicide if not affirmed as the opposite sex is:
Where was this substantial population of youths a generation ago?
And if they secretly, or unconsciously, harbored these dire feelings, how did they survive into adulthood?
And why have we not seen a surge of people over age 35 coming out as transgender over the past 10 years?
Why has the surge in gender dysphoria and trans identification only occurred among children and young adults?
And why is the surge predominantly among natal girls?
And why do these young people have such a high rate of other psychiatric conditions and autism, especially compared with the very, very small population of gender dysphoric youth who expressed a cross-sex identification a generation ago?
Being transgender is centrally a mental state, not a medical one. You cannot make a mouse transgender, because they lack the cognition to have a gender identity.
The body of the article distinguishes between what Dem politicians say on this topic (largely, they are on lockstep, save Moulton and Suozzi) and what the Democratic voters think (largely, they disagree with the politicians at large and want trans girls out of girls' sports).
Quoting @robkhenderson: You read the top-rated comments on this article all say this isn't an "extraordinary break from fellow Democrats" because most ordinary Democrats always thought transgenderism went too far. Somehow a small group of lunatics created the illusion of consensus. Truly fascinating.
NEWS: The >$10 million NIH grant for which Dr. Johanna Olson-Kennedy is the principal investigator and that has been following youth receiving gender-transition treatment is no longer listed on the NIH's pages of active grants. This doesn't necessarily mean the grant has been killed. But the NIH has been axing grants related to transgender identity, and this is probably the most prominent of its kind.
You will recall that the NYT reported that Olson-Kennedy said that she withheld publishing null findings from a study funded by this long-term grant of puberty blockers, for political reasons. She has since asserted this is false in a sworn deposition.
This grant has also produced the Chen et al (2023) paper of 315 youth who received cross-sex hormones, among whom 2 died by suicide during the 2-year follow-up period.
I think it's an extraordinary break from leading Democratic politicians. We've seen remarks from Tom Suozzi and Seth Moulton. But Newsom is the biggest player to take this stand.
Everyday Dem voters, on balance, believe that trans girls should not participate in girls' sports.
The reason why I for one did not cover this study is because it has so many limitations, its conclusions border on meaningless.
It looked at medical records of adults (18 and older) with gender dysphoria who received gender-transition surgeries but who had no mental health (MH) diagnoses prior to surgery, and then looked at the proportion who had MH diagnoses in their chart about 2 years after surgery. They compared those figures with those pertaining to adults with gender dysphoria but did not have gender-transition surgery who were matched by sex, age, race and ethnicity. They also compared trans masc people who got surgery but did not have a GD diagnosis with trans femme people who got surgery without a GD diagnosis.
First of all, I find it curious that many people with gender dysphoria would not at least qualify for other MH diagnoses. So that immediately makes me wonder about the validity of these findings. And as the paper suggests, it's possible that after people had surgeries, their gender dysphoria improved and/or they started focusing on other MH issues, which could lead their care providers to input other MH diagnoses into their chart. It's not that these were new issues, it's just that the providers had not noted them in the chart before. Or it's possible that getting surgery means you interface with health care providers more often and thus are more likely to have a MH diagnosis written in your chart just by virtue of having more care appointments.
And of course there is the likelihood that people with MH problems are more likely to seek surgery in hopes that it will help with those problems.
And as I mentioned, perhaps those MH problems had not been noted in their chart until after surgery because their care had been focused more intently on the gender dysphoria in particular.
The main thing that I get from this paper are that trans masc people (natal females) who get surgery have much higher depression and anxiety than trans feminine people (natal males) who get surgery (see Table 3. Note that Cohort E is trans masc people and Cohort F is trans femme).
Quoting @libsoftiktok: The Oxford Academic Journal of Sexual Medicine released a new study on the effects of "gender-affirming surgery" on people with gender dysphoria.
After analyzing over 100,000 patients, they concluded that those who received surgery had an increased risk of mental health issues and substance use disorders.
Wonder why the mainstream media isn't covering this...
What is more important to society: inclusion or competitive fairness in sports?
And what happens when trans inclusion leads to the exclusion of a c-s woman, such as when there is one spot left on the team or one scholarship and the trans woman gets it?
It’s a fair question if estrogen and testosterone suppression makes a trans woman weaker. But this does not erase the advantages of male puberty.
The question is more nuanced if the trans woman had pubertal suppression at the immediate onset of puberty and then went through a female puberty through estrogen treatment.
I would be interested to know how this is a purely moral issue, one favoring trans inclusion, from your perspective when research indicates that trans females maintain a competitive advantage in girls’ and women’s sports.
Quoting @benryanwriter: A review paper published by Dr. Michael Joyner of the Mayo Clinic in December found that even prior to puberty, boys do have at least a slight advantage over girls athletically, and that this difference widens dramatically after male puberty’s onset. Research suggests that even treatment with estrogen and anti-androgen medications does not erase the athletic advantage conferred by a male puberty, Dr. Joyner found.https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39716906/ https://benryan.substack.com/p/most-americans-dont-support-top-trans
The attacks from the far left on Gavin Newsom for breaking with Dem orthodoxy and backing the exclusion of trans females from girls and women’s sports has been savage. Presumably if activists cannot scare other Dems away from following suit, the issue will be lost on the left.
So is it “morally repugnant” as @drvolts claims, for @mattyglesias to back trans-girl exclusion from girls’ sports if their inclusion is unfair to c-s girls, per scientific research? Is inclusion more important than fairness?
I would be very interested to know why David Roberts thinks it is fair to include trans girls and women in girls and women’s sports.
The difference between the trans sports question and past battles over interracial and same-sex marriage is that there was never any rational scientific support for opposition to those rights. But research does indicate that trans women maintain a competitive advantage in women’s sports. @mattyglesias @drvolts
Yes, there are mouse studies meant to examine the effects of gender-transition drugs. But unlike what Trump claimed on Tuesday, they don’t turn mice trans.
Quoting @benryanwriter: Staffers of the @WhiteCoatWaste Project sleuthed around in federal records and produced a nine-page roster of 10 NIH grants totaling $10 million for which at least part of the research in question went toward animal-model research, including in mice, of cross-sex hormones.
https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/12/Transgender-mice-WCW-12-2024-v2.docx.pdf
This included all the studies the White House mentioned in their release on Wednesday, plus the following (click the hyperlinks to access the original federal information on the grants):
$442,000 for: “Molecular Mechanisms of Hormone-Mediated Sex Differences in WoundHealing”
$66,000 for: “Cross-Sex Steroid Therapy and Cardiovascular Risk in the TransgenderFemale”
$1.1 million for: “GHB Toxicokinetics: Role of sex hormone dependent monocarboxylatetransporter regulation and potential for altered overdose risk in transgender men and women.” GHB is better known as the “date rape drug” and is also popularly used recreationally for sex by gay men and trans women in particular.
$49,000 for: “Understanding how chromosomal makeup and cross-sex hormoneadministration affect wound healing in mice”
https://benryan.substack.com/p/trump-claimed-the-nih-spent-8-million
Fact check on Trump's claim about transgender mice:
Trump Claimed the NIH Spent $8 Million 'Making Mice Transgender,' Which Is Actually Partly True
https://benryan.substack.com/p/trump-claimed-the-nih-spent-8-million
The @[private account] has given numerous grants to researchers who have used animal models, including mice, to study the impacts and safety of cross-sex hormones. But nobody is "making mice transgender."
Fact check on Trump's claim about transgender mice:
Trump Claimed the NIH Spent $8 Million 'Making Mice Transgender,' Which Is Actually Partly True
https://benryan.substack.com/p/trump-claimed-the-nih-spent-8-million
The @[private account] has given numerous grants to researchers who have used animal models, including mice, to study the impacts and safety of cross-sex hormones. But nobody is "making mice transgender."
Quoting @libsoftiktok: CNN just quietly edited their "fact check" article after they reported that Trump's statement on spending $8 million for making mice transgender was "false."
It sounds so crazy that they thought Trump made it up…
It’s 100% true and now even CNN is forced to admit it
I don't think you read my essay.
Trump Claimed the NIH Spent $8 Million 'Making Mice Transgender,' Which Is Actually Partly True
https://benryan.substack.com/p/trump-claimed-the-nih-spent-8-million
The NIH has given numerous grants to researchers who have used animal models, including mice, to study the impacts and safety of cross-sex hormones. But nobody is "making mice transgender."
Trump Claimed the NIH Spent $8 Million 'Making Mice Transgender,' Which Is Actually Partly True
https://benryan.substack.com/p/trump-claimed-the-nih-spent-8-million
The NIH has given numerous grants to researchers who have used animal models, including mice, to study the impacts and safety of cross-sex hormones. But nobody is "making mice transgender."
Trump Claimed the NIH Spent $8 Million 'Making Mice Transgender,' Which Is Actually Partly True
https://benryan.substack.com/p/trump-claimed-the-nih-spent-8-million
The NIH has given numerous grants to researchers who have used animal models, including mice, to study the impacts and safety of cross-sex hormones. But nobody is "making mice transgender."
Gavin Newsom breaks with Democrats on trans athletes in sports
The Democratic California governor made the stunning remarks in his debut podcast with conservative guest @CharlieKirk11.
https://www.politico.com/news/2025/03/06/gavin-newsom-breaks-with-democrats-on-trans-athletes-in-sports-00215436
There's a new game show, and it's called:
"Are You Better At Deciphering Judith Butler Than a Transgender Mouse?"
Quoting @benryanwriter: But on the question of whether any NIH scientist had ever turned a mouse trans, CNN is actually right and the White House is wrong. In an article CNN posted on Wednesday, it reflected on the transgender-mouse NIH grants that the White Houses diagrammed in its release: “The studies were meant to figure out how these treatments might affect the health of humans who take them, not for the purpose of making mice transgender.”
https://benryan.substack.com/p/trump-claimed-the-nih-spent-8-million
That’s precisely it. There’s no such thing as “turning a mouse transgender.” Because for any animal to be transgender, it would require a sophisticated enough, humanoid cognition to be able to conceive of their gender identity in the first place. (Cue people yelling at me that there’s no such thing as gender identity in humans either. Sorry folks, there is.) I’m sorry, but mice are simply not clever enough to decipher Judith Butler’s famously opaque sentences.
I wrote about the "transgender mice" thing from Trump's speech: https://x.com/benryanwriter/status/1897643621446234286
Quoting @benryanwriter: LINK: Trump Claimed the NIH Spent $8 Million 'Making Mice Transgender,' Which Is Actually Partly True
https://benryan.substack.com/p/trump-claimed-the-nih-spent-8-million
The NIH has given numerous grants to researchers who have used animal models, including mice, to study the impacts and safety of cross-sex hormones. But nobody is "making mice transgender."
@[private account] @[private account] I wrote about the "transgender mice" thing from Trump's speech: https://x.com/benryanwriter/status/1897643621446234286
Quoting @benryanwriter: LINK: Trump Claimed the NIH Spent $8 Million 'Making Mice Transgender,' Which Is Actually Partly True
https://benryan.substack.com/p/trump-claimed-the-nih-spent-8-million
The NIH has given numerous grants to researchers who have used animal models, including mice, to study the impacts and safety of cross-sex hormones. But nobody is "making mice transgender."
I wrote about the "transgender mice" thing from Trump's speech: https://x.com/benryanwriter/status/1897643621446234286
Quoting @benryanwriter: LINK: Trump Claimed the NIH Spent $8 Million 'Making Mice Transgender,' Which Is Actually Partly True
https://benryan.substack.com/p/trump-claimed-the-nih-spent-8-million
The NIH has given numerous grants to researchers who have used animal models, including mice, to study the impacts and safety of cross-sex hormones. But nobody is "making mice transgender."
I wrote about the "transgender mice" thing from Trump's speech: https://x.com/benryanwriter/status/1897643621446234286
Quoting @benryanwriter: LINK: Trump Claimed the NIH Spent $8 Million 'Making Mice Transgender,' Which Is Actually Partly True
https://benryan.substack.com/p/trump-claimed-the-nih-spent-8-million
The NIH has given numerous grants to researchers who have used animal models, including mice, to study the impacts and safety of cross-sex hormones. But nobody is "making mice transgender."
The reaction to Trump's "transgender mice" claim on the left and in @[private account] in particular echoed the response to Trump’s assertion during his Sept. 10 debate with Kamala Harris: “Now she wants to do transgender operations on illegal aliens that are in prison.” Certain reporters presumed that such a bonkers claim couldn’t possibly be true. And so they didn’t bother to fact check Mr. Trump’s claim before declaring it false.
https://benryan.substack.com/p/trump-claimed-the-nih-spent-8-million
Except that it was true. As @KFile Andrew Kaczynski reported for @CNN the day before the debate, Ms. Harris had responded to a 2019 @ACLU questionnaire given to Democratic presidential candidates by saying that she supported taxpayer dollars going to gender-transition surgeries for ICE detainees. (Such surgeries are extremely rare in this context.) This would continue to haunt Ms. Harris throughout the campaign and is one reason why leading moderate Democrats recently called for a moratorium on candidates filling out questionnaires that might serve as purity tests.
So that brings us to Trump’s March 4 speech. You can see how this game of political telephone apparently caused his speech writers to include the misleading, yet essentially accurate line about $8 million in spending on what he called transgender mice.
repeated this claim on Laura Ingraham’s @FoxNews show on Feb. 20. As she enthused that @ElonMusk and @DOGE were ferreting out waste in federal spending, Ms. Mace said, “And I just uncovered the other day, you know, over $10 million spent on making animals trans.” https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y7hI1ahne_w
On Feb. 6, @RepNancyMace held up the @WhiteCoatWaste Project’s dossier in Congress. As reported in @FoxNews: https://www.foxnews.com/politics/10m-taxpayer-funds-spent-creating-transgender-animals-last-year-nancy-mace
So how did these mouse studies end up in Trump’s speech?
The @WashingtonExaminer published an article centered around the transgender-mice dossier from the @WhiteCoatWaste Project on December 21. The conservative news outlet’s take on the matter was similar to what Trump’s would be. The Examiner tumpeted the sensationalistic headline: “Biden administration spent millions creating transgender animals to experiment on.”
https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/news/investigations/3267269/biden-administration-spent-millions-dollars-creating-transgender-animal-for-studies/
Staffers of the @WhiteCoatWaste Project sleuthed around in federal records and produced a nine-page roster of 10 NIH grants totaling $10 million for which at least part of the research in question went toward animal-model research, including in mice, of cross-sex hormones.
https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/12/Transgender-mice-WCW-12-2024-v2.docx.pdf
This included all the studies the White House mentioned in their release on Wednesday, plus the following (click the hyperlinks to access the original federal information on the grants):
$442,000 for: “Molecular Mechanisms of Hormone-Mediated Sex Differences in WoundHealing”
$66,000 for: “Cross-Sex Steroid Therapy and Cardiovascular Risk in the TransgenderFemale”
$1.1 million for: “GHB Toxicokinetics: Role of sex hormone dependent monocarboxylatetransporter regulation and potential for altered overdose risk in transgender men and women.” GHB is better known as the “date rape drug” and is also popularly used recreationally for sex by gay men and trans women in particular.
$49,000 for: “Understanding how chromosomal makeup and cross-sex hormoneadministration affect wound healing in mice”
https://benryan.substack.com/p/trump-claimed-the-nih-spent-8-million
Then there’s the fact that many people do not think animal-based research is ethical. That includes the @WhiteCoatWaste Project, a nonprofit devoted to combatting the use of animals in research. It appears that this organization can be credited with first bringing this whole “transgender mice” brouhaha to the fore.
However, @[private account] is also wrong to dismiss in their ALL CAPS HEADLINE the fact that Trump’s statement about transgender mice, while misleading, was actually onto something. The body of the magazine’s article only proved this.
But on the question of whether any NIH scientist had ever turned a mouse trans, CNN is actually right and the White House is wrong. In an article CNN posted on Wednesday, it reflected on the transgender-mouse NIH grants that the White Houses diagrammed in its release: “The studies were meant to figure out how these treatments might affect the health of humans who take them, not for the purpose of making mice transgender.”
https://benryan.substack.com/p/trump-claimed-the-nih-spent-8-million
That’s precisely it. There’s no such thing as “turning a mouse transgender.” Because for any animal to be transgender, it would require a sophisticated enough, humanoid cognition to be able to conceive of their gender identity in the first place. (Cue people yelling at me that there’s no such thing as gender identity in humans either. Sorry folks, there is.) I’m sorry, but mice are simply not clever enough to decipher Judith Butler’s famously opaque sentences.
With their trademark acerbic flair, the White House communications folks scoffed in their press release about the transgender mice: “The Fake News losers at CNN immediately tried to fact check it, but President Trump was right (as usual).”
https://www.whitehouse.gov/articles/2025/03/yes-biden-spent-millions-on-transgender-animal-experiments/
On Wednesday, @[private account] insisted in a banner headline: “TRUMP DECRIED MILLIONS SPENT ‘MAKING MICE TRANSGENDER.’ IT WAS CANCER AND ASTHMA RESEARCH.”
https://benryan.substack.com/p/trump-claimed-the-nih-spent-8-million
As they scrolled through the list of $8 million in cumulative NIH grants that the White House insisted in a Wednesday press release proved Trump had told no lies about transgender mice, Rolling Stone focused on one study concerning asthma and another on chronic lung disease.
https://www.rollingstone.com/politics/politics-news/trump-transgender-mice-medical-research-1235289439/
Then the magazine reported that the Trump administration did, in fact, report a couple of research endeavors that at least followed a transgender theme:
At his bombastic speech before Congress on Tuesday evening, President Donald Trump boasted that @ElonMusk and the @DOGE gang had exposed $8 million in federal funding “for making mice transgender.”
https://benryan.substack.com/p/trump-claimed-the-nih-spent-8-million
This predictably sent progressive fact checkers into a tizzy. They were apparently too incredulous that Trump might be onto something so, well, silly to actually check their facts before they pounced.
One immunologist on X insisted that the president had daftly confused “transgender” with “transgenic” where these mice are concerned. Transgenic mice, which are widely used in scientific research, are genetically engineered to have, for example, a humanoid immune system for studying HIV.
https://x.com/dr_andrealove/status/1897117512145502261
Additionally, former Senator @[private account] posted on X that political scientist @[private account] had told him about Trump’s supposed mixup between transgender and transgenic rodents. The SNL alumnus was quite certain that there was nothing to this whole transgender-mice business. https://x.com/alfranken/status/1897416828994904438
Quotes a post by T26092; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
LINK: Trump Claimed the NIH Spent $8 Million 'Making Mice Transgender,' Which Is Actually Partly True
https://benryan.substack.com/p/trump-claimed-the-nih-spent-8-million
The NIH has given numerous grants to researchers who have used animal models, including mice, to study the impacts and safety of cross-sex hormones. But nobody is "making mice transgender."
Trump Claimed the NIH Spent $8 Million 'Making Mice Transgender,' Which Is Actually Partly True
I write 🧵⬇️ The @[private account] has given numerous grants to researchers who have used animal models, including mice, to study the impacts and safety of cross-sex hormones. But nobody is "making mice transgender."
Science needs more shrimp on treadmills
The National Institutes of Health isn’t funding too much silly science. It’s not funding enough, I write for the @WashingtonPost @[private account].
To hear @realDonaldTrump, @ElonMusk and their allies tell it, the federal government’s apparatus for doling out scientific research grants is a woke slush fund for silly scientific studies that offer nothing in the way of solutions to the world’s problems.
In his address to Congress on Tuesday, the president praised Musk and his U.S. @DOGE Service gang for exposing “$8 million for making mice transgender.”
During the Senate confirmation hearing on Wednesday for Jay Bhattacharya @[private account] to serve as @[private account] director, Sen. @RandPaul (R-Kentucky) sneered at what he dismissed as “frivolous studies,” such as whether lonely rats use more cocaine.
@[private account] (R-Iowa) in November groused about studies examining the velocity of panda poop and the puzzle-solving skills of elephants.
In her capacity as head of the Senate’s @[private account], Ernst also made mincemeat of the perennial favorite of science-funding cynics: The $1.3 million shrimp on a treadmill, which became the poster critter for silly science in 2011 after another Republican senator made a fuss over it.
The researchers behind that study have long since explained that the treadmill was actually but one small — and inexpensive — component of a wider National Science Foundation grant to examine the health of shrimp and crabs. Nevertheless, the treadmill tale makes routine resurgences, including in a runaway post on X by a conservative influencer, @[private account], last month.
As for the mice, Trump was referring to a roster of recent @[private account] grants to study the safety and impacts of cross-sex hormones in animals.
Silly science is fruitful fodder for memes and snarky headlines. But more often than not, these studies are, in fact, merely baroque examples of what’s known as edge science — or research based on relatively novel ideas.
Such out-of-the-box, exploratory studies typically lead to dead ends. But edge science remains the bedrock of the scientific endeavor. It’s where scientists germinate many of the ideas that, while they might take decades to bear fruit, can lead to paradigm-shifting scientific breakthroughs.
Just as savvy venture capitalists fund scores of start-ups run by eccentric geniuses, in hopes of ultimately boasting windfall-generating equity in the PayPal-like unicorn among them, so should our nation’s grant-making apparatus support sufficient edge science to keep fueling innovation and fostering the cures and solutions of tomorrow. Public investment is invaluable because the profit timelines of such research are usually too protracted to attract sufficient private capital investment.
The Ozempic revolution, after all, owes its success to research into Gila monster venom, which, following four decades of investigation, finally gave rise to the GLP-1 agonist class of drugs that hold promise in transforming public health and are already shifting the economy.
So, if silliness be the proxy for edge science, play on — give us excess of it.
[To read the full editorial, see the gift link in the thread below.]
The really weird thing about this @[private account] article is that if you actually read it, midway through they finally admit that there were at least a couple of studies that, while not about turning mice trans, included mouse models to study cross-sex hormones.
Quoting @benryanwriter: Rolling Stone has it wrong. There has been quite a bit of NIH-funded research that has used animal models, including mice, to assess the impacts of cross-sex hormone treatment.
Trump was wrong to claim that these studies were meant to turn the mice transgender, per se. that would require that mice have the humanoid cognition to have a gender identity in the first place.
In reference to Trump’s claim about NIH-funded researcher making mice transgender:
Quoting @benryanwriter: I conferred with Justin Goodman, Senior Vice President, Advocacy and Public Policy
@WhiteCoatWaste Project, which started all this talk of "transgender mice." He showed me the following spreadsheet of studies that include studies of cross-sex hormones using animal models. Note that it's clear that not all the money in these studies went to animal model research.
No, I don’t agree at all. This was a reference to studies of mouse models of treatments for trans people. This wasn’t just flubbing the word transgenic. You can look up the studies yourself, I linked to them.
Right, Trump’s wording was misleading. But he wasn’t simply confusion transgender with transgenic or referring only to studies that were unrelated to gender-transition treatment.
The real question is whether there should be animal-model research to study the impacts of drugs that many transgender people already receive. Republicans decry the lack of solid safety data on pediatric gender-transition treatment, and yet they seek to cancel studies that could address this dearth of knowledge.
Here is the off-base @[private account] article:
https://www.rollingstone.com/politics/politics-news/trump-transgender-mice-medical-research-1235289439/
The Washington Examiner recently published a nine-page list of animal-model research of cross-sex hormone treatment. It was compiled by the @WhiteCoatWaste Project, a nonprofit that opposes animals in research.
https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/12/Transgender-mice-WCW-12-2024-v2.docx.pdf
Rolling Stone has it wrong. There has been quite a bit of NIH-funded research that has used animal models, including mice, to assess the impacts of cross-sex hormone treatment.
Trump was wrong to claim that these studies were meant to turn the mice transgender, per se. that would require that mice have the humanoid cognition to have a gender identity in the first place.
It is very misleading to call them “transgender mice,” or to say that scientists “made them trans,” but yes, there has been a lot of NIH-funded research using animal models, including mice, to study the impacts of cross-sex hormones.
Quoting @benryanwriter: As it turns out, yes, Trump was not exactly making it up when he said that DOGE had identified "$8 million for making mice transgender." No, these grants were not for making mice develop cross-sex identification. They were to study the impacts and safety of cross-sex hormones in animal models, including mice. The point is to help researchers better understand and protect the health and well-being of the many people who either seek to undergo or undergo cross-sex hormone treatment because they identify as transgender or otherwise suffer from gender dysphoria.
I would argue that a more precise way to characterize this research is that investigators used animal models, including mice, to study the impacts and safety of cross-sex hormones. You can’t turn a mice transgender, so to speak, because that would require the mouse having the humanoid cognition to have such a thing as a gender identity.
I conferred with Justin Goodman, Senior Vice President, Advocacy and Public Policy
@WhiteCoatWaste Project, which started all this talk of "transgender mice." He showed me the following spreadsheet of studies that include studies of cross-sex hormones using animal models. Note that it's clear that not all the money in these studies went to animal model research.
The White House and Trump are mischaracterizing these studies as for making mice transgender, whereas they actually use mouse models to study the impacts of cross-sex hormones. But here are the citations in any case. https://www.whitehouse.gov/articles/2025/03/yes-biden-spent-millions-on-transgender-animal-experiments/
As it turns out, yes, Trump was not exactly making it up when he said that DOGE had identified "$8 million for making mice transgender." No, these grants were not for making mice develop cross-sex identification. They were to study the impacts and safety of cross-sex hormones in animal models, including mice. The point is to help researchers better understand and protect the health and well-being of the many people who either seek to undergo or undergo cross-sex hormone treatment because they identify as transgender or otherwise suffer from gender dysphoria.
Quoting @benryanwriter: Here is what Trump was referring to: https://blog.whitecoatwaste.org/2024/12/21/wcw-investigation-10m-wasted-to-create-transgender-mice-and-monkeys/
Here is the roster of animal-model studies of cross-sex hormone use funded by the federal government that Trump was referring to, including studies in mice.
https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/12/Transgender-mice-WCW-12-2024-v2.docx.pdf
I haven't been able to find links confirming the claim that $8 million was spent trying to make mice transgender per se. But it does make sense, nevertheless, that researchers would test the safety and health impacts of cross-sex hormone use in an animal model.
A lot of people have presumed that Trump meant to refer to transgenic mice when he said tonight that DOGE has identified "$8 million for making mice transgender."
There has actually been at least some NIH funding for mouse models of gender-transition treatment, including:
$735,113: "Microbiome mediated effects of gender affirming hormone therapy in mice."
$299,940: "Gender-Affirming Testosterone Therapy on Breast Cancer Risk and Treatment Outcomes"
$199,930: "A Mouse Model to Test the Effects of Gender-affirming Hormone Therapy on HIV Vaccine-induced Immune Responses"
All this said, it's entirely possible that Trump confused "transgender" with "transgenic." Transgenic mice are genetically engineered to serve as models for studying myriad diseases in humans.
I am frequently called a misogynist by the gender criticals and a transphobe by the trans activists. I suspect this is a common experience among the few of us who report about pediatric gender medicine as if it were not a wildly politicized issue and was, in fact, a science story
Quoting @SwipeWright: I am frequently called "woke" by MAGA people and "MAGA" by woke people. I suspect this is a common experience for classical liberals.
In New Hampshire, @[private account] testifies in favor of HB377, a bill to ban pediatric gender-transition treatment.
Mr. Price, 20, recalled his time identifying as a girl, including when his pediatrician told his father, in front of Mr. Price, "Would you rather have a dead son or a live daughter?" (There is no research that backs the oft-repeated claim that these treatments are tied to a lower suicide death rate. The one study that directly analyzed this connection found none.)
He said that 1/6 of the boys in his high school identified as trans by graduation and that his girlfriend is also a detransitioner. They fear that the testosterone she took will prevent her from carrying a pregnancy to term. Regardless, she will never breastfeed because of the double mastectomy she received.
"I sit in front of you as a 20 year old man. But for three years, I thought I was a girl.
"I received my bachelor's degree in music last December, with additional coursework at Harvard University and statistics.
"I remember being 14, I was sitting in my pediatrician's office explaining to him that I was transgender and that my father wasn't affirming my new identity. So my pediatrician asked my father, 'Would you like a dead son or a living daughter?' I was in the room when he asked this question.
"There is no other situation when a doctor is allowed to suggest suicide like this to a patient, and quite frankly, it's medical malpractice. If you ask parents of trans identified kids and other dtransitioners, you'll discover that this is a common line used to manipulate parents due to consenting to these procedures, despite being referred to my local gender clinic three times by three separate doctors, the emotional blackmail and my gender dysphoria diagnosis, my father refused me to take refused to take me to be medicalized. And I hated him for it at the time, but now I am deeply grateful, and it's not just me.
"3% of my generation identifies as transgender. Between the time I left my high school in 10th grade and my class graduated, 1/6 of the boys in my class started identifying as trans. Many of them medicalized.
"My girlfriend is a detransitioner, and I can't do much more than pray that if and when we decide to have kids, that despite the double mastectomy, which precludes her from ever breast feeding, and the four years of cross sex hormones she was given, starting from when she was a minor, that she is able to carry a pregnancy to term.
"The other side believes that if you don't give trans identified kids puberty blockers, cross sex hormones and surgeries, they will kill themselves. That is a damned lie. I am living proof of that.
"I was not put on hormones, I was not operated on, and I have grown up to be a healthy and happy 20 year old man.
"I have also talked to parents with detransitioner children who killed themselves after realizing they regretted what they had done to their bodies. What would you say to those parents?
"The other side of this issue has both psychological and economic incentives to oppose this bill. Imagine if you will having administered cross sex hormones or puberty blockers referred children to have such procedures. What would you do if you were presented with the evidence that what you were doing wasn't helping your patients, but indeed permanently harming your patients?
"I know I would have a very hard time accepting that transgender health care is a multi-billion dollar industry. Though estimates vary, the lifetime cost of providing a trans identified individual with hormones and surgeries exceeds $100,000 on average. What would you do if you were a hospital administrator or doctor who made a million dollars for every 10 patients you treated? If you were serious about protecting families in the health of children, you must vote for this bill. Thank you very much."
Why I Use Trans People’s Preferred Pronouns
https://open.substack.com/pub/benryan/p/why-i-use-trans-peoples-preferred
Regardless of whether there will ever be any winners in the battle of the genders, I choose being kind over waging war.
There are like 125 comments on my newsletter piece about why I use trans people’s preferred pronouns and a couple hundred on my X post about how the term “trans woman” refers to a natal male who identifies as female, not vice versa. I guess I should read them…
Quoting @mysteriouskat: I have to be honest. I hate looking in the replies sometimes. People can be so cruel, rude, racist, empty... It makes me think worse of humanity. But if I stop reading comments altogether, I also won't see the insightful comments, thoughtful disagreements, etc... All of which are so important. So, I guess the price to not living in a vacuum, is getting to see the worst, besides the best.
This is a simple concept to learn. I refuse to believe otherwise. Period. People are just pretending to be confused because they don’t want to acknowledge trans identities.
I know very well why they object. And as I have made clear, I disagree with their order of priorities.
https://benryan.substack.com/p/why-i-use-trans-peoples-preferred
You can pretend that the standard term, "trans woman," means a woman who identifies as male all you want. But you are in a distinct, and clearly defiant, minority.
Just look it up in the dictionary:
Also:
Why I Use Trans People’s Preferred Pronouns
https://benryan.substack.com/p/why-i-use-trans-peoples-preferred
Regardless of whether there will ever be any winners in the battle of the genders, I choose being kind over waging war.
A trans woman is a natal male who identifies and presents as female, period.
I don't understand why this is so hard for people to comprehend.
People who insist that a trans woman is a woman who identifies as a man, in my opinion, do so because they do not want to ever suggest that being transgender is a valid identity.
I ask you this: Why in the world would a natal male go to all the trouble to transition to female only to accept being referred to as a trans man?
And is it considerate of anyone to call such a person a trans man, when they clearly want to be known and referred to as a woman?
People who insist that they are confused by the term "trans woman" to refer to a natal male who identifies as as female seem to have missed the last decade of discourse on this subject, in which people such as Laverne Cox and Caitlyn Jenner have consistently and constantly been referred to as trans women in the media. This is not a difficult concept to learn. Just think of playing "opposites day" when you were a kid.
I do not accept that people cannot learn these terms and understand what they mean.
Quoting @JournalismSEEN: It’s not accurate to say ‘trans females’ when you mean men.
It’s better to be accurate than to have to rely on a set of clues in the hope that people will be sufficiently versed in your lexicon to follow them to the answer - men.
Because it’s not accurate, it’s not impartial.
Rep @NancyMace says she’s lost half her hair recently due to PTSD stemming from sexual assault.
@[private account] suggests that being an anti-trans bigot may be causing Rep Mace undue stress and spurring hair loss.
During the current congress, Rep Mace has campaigned zealously against Rep Sarah McBride, the first openly transgender member of Congress, using the Capitol ladies’ rooms.
Quotes a post by a private account; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Regardless of where they place transgender issues in their order of priorities, the American public broadly supports Trump’s various executive orders pertaining to transgender people, in particular restricting sports according to sex rather than gender identity. https://open.substack.com/pub/benryan/p/most-americans-dont-support-top-trans?r=7wxo1&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web&showWelcomeOnShare=false
Regardless of where they place trans issues in their order of priorities, the American public broadly supports Trump’s various executive orders pertaining to transgender people, in particular restricting sports according to sex rather than gender identity.
Quoting @JordanUhl: Trans issues ranked 22 out of 22 among issues of importance for voters last year. Saying this is why Democrats will "lose every election" isn't rooted in any actual data and only reflects personal animus.
Erin Reed is under the mistaken impression that I’ve ever or would ever come out for or against anything such as this. That’s not my job, that is what an activist does. She is an activist, I am not. And I reported for NBC last month about the CDC scrubbing trans from its website.
The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention will no longer process transgender identity data in order to comply with President Trump’s executive order, agency representative Melissa Dibble told STAT on Tuesday.
Sexual orientation data is unaffected and “will be processed per usual protocols,” Dibble added.
The decision will likely affect a number of federal health surveillance systems, including the National HIV Behavioral Surveillance Among Transgender Womenand the Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance System. There is a major dearth of data on trans and nonbinary people in the U.S., so these survey systems that include them serve as critical resources for researchers.
Does this piece of mine calling upon the APA to examine the science behind pediatric gender medicine fit into Jeff Bezos' narrow vision of opeds about personal liberties and free markets? I really don't know. https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2024/05/03/transgender-puberty-blockers-science-cass-report/
Here's my essay on why I use trans people's preferred pronouns: https://x.com/benryanwriter/status/1894597827042435134
Quoting @benryanwriter: LINK: Why I Use Trans People’s Preferred Pronouns
https://benryan.substack.com/p/why-i-use-trans-peoples-preferred
Regardless of whether there will ever be any winners in the battle of the genders, I choose being kind over waging war.
LINK: Why I Use Trans People’s Preferred Pronouns
https://benryan.substack.com/p/why-i-use-trans-peoples-preferred
Regardless of whether there will ever be any winners in the battle of the genders, I choose being kind over waging war.
Why I Use Trans People’s Preferred Pronouns
Transgender civil rights are engulfed in a war of words—and a war over words.
First came the era of Peak Woke, when pronoun declarations became de rigueur in progressive circles and the very meanings of the words “male” and “female” were run through a postmodern nebulizer. Sex was now a spectrum and Ketanji Brown Jackson could only demur when asked to define the word “woman” during her Supreme Court confirmation hearing. “I’m not a biologist,” she protested. Meanwhile, actual biologists, most notably Colin Wright @SwipeWright and Carole Hooven @[private account], were summarily canceled for stating that sex is binary.
Riding—and guiding—the pendulum of public sentiment as it swings furiously in the other direction, Donald Trump has unleashed a shock-and-awe counter-offensive against what her derides as “gender ideology.” Through a fusillade of executive orders, the president has sought to eradicate the very words used to characterize transgender identity throughout the federal government, schools, medical research, health care and sports. By fiat, sex is now binary and cannot be changed.
It was Hamlet who summed it up best when he said, “Words, words, words.”
As a reporter who has positioned himself within the sometimes lonely, circumspect spot between the fearsome factions warring over pediatric gender medicine, I am routinely subjected to slings and arrows from either side about my word choices.
Transgender activists and their allies excoriate me for using terms such a “gender-distressed child” instead of “trans child” or “gender-transition treatment” instead of “gender-affirming care.” They insist the words I employ are transphobic dog whistles, rather than purposefully neutral terms that don’t come pre-baked with any declarations about the wisdom of cross-sex hormone treatment or the essential nature of gender identity.
And from the no-less-determined opposing crowd—the gender-critical, trans-exclusionary radical feminist, or TERF, set—I am subjected to a ceaseless barrage of demands that I refer to transgender people only with the pronouns of their biological sex. Even in the sentence I just uttered, I have committed a grave offense; for the TERFs oppose the use of any qualifiers of a person’s sex, such as cisgender woman or biological male. To utter such adjectives, they say, is to validate a vast ideological project whose aims are anathema. There are only men and women and never the twain shall meet.But as much as the woke left claims I’m a shill for the gender critical crowd, and as much as the woke right is under the fanciful impression that they can work me as a puppet, I do not belong to, nor do I have any wish to belong to, any activist club.
These determined factions—they are, simply put, the “woke left” on one side and the “woke right” on the other—are signature examples of the horseshoe theory of political polarities. Despite having opposite political goals, they share similar tactics. Both fixate on identity politics, are beholden to ideological purity tests, and engage in aggressive language policing to advance their cause in this wildly politicized battle of the genders.
But as much as the woke left claims I’m a shill for the gender critical crowd, and as much as the woke right is under the fanciful impression that they can work me as a puppet, I do not belong to, nor do I have any wish to belong to, any activist club.
I may write critically about pediatric gender medicine and the evidence base behind it. But that effort is distinct from my steadfast belief in treating people with basic human dignity.
That is why I call transgender women “she.” It is simply the kind thing to do.
Cue cynical sneering from the gender-critical crowd. For they subscribe to the slippery slope theory. As soon as we validate a biological male as female with a feminine pronoun, they say, this upends reality and flings open the door for men to invade women’s spaces.
I disagree.
Using a trans woman’s preferred pronouns need not amount to a sweeping philosophical declaration about whether sex can be changed and whether she should be permitted to undress in a woman’s locker room. Demanding so-called “right-sex pronouns” wrongly prioritizes ideological purity over kindness and turns every mention of a trans person into an act of war.
Here’s the thing: I don’t just believe, I know for a fact that sex is binary. Sex is defined by whether a person’s body is geared around producing the small or large gamete, regardless of whether the body is ever actually fertile. (Yes, even people with differences of sex development, formerly called intersex conditions, are one of either sex. And there is no third sex.) And I know that sex unchangeable, just as I know that the surgery I underwent for testicular cancer three years ago didn’t reduce me to half a man. Trans people change their bodies to present as the opposite sex in an effort to make themselves feel more comfortable in their own skin.
It is far more important to me to honor a trans person’s preferred pronouns than to get hung up on any cognitive dissonance emanating from the subterranean conflict between their biological sex and their gender identity and presentation.
Sadly, I’ve lost transgender friends due to my reporting about pediatric gender medicine. They think I am motivated by animus to cover the subject as I do. In one particularly distressing incident, I had the daughter of a family friend seek to eject me from her mother’s book party because she claimed my very presence made her trans friends unsafe. (I refused to leave.)
But I’ve also been fortunate enough to gain new trans friends thanks to my work in this field. Even as a gay man who had to reconcile with his sexuality during the height of the AIDS crisis and all virulent homophobia of that era, these new friends have taught me new lessons about living authentically in the face of adversity.
I will never treat them with such disrespect as not to refer to them as they wish to be referred.
But I also believe it is important to listen to women and other feminists who are concerned about women’s safety in single-sex spaces and fairness in sports. Unlike with same-sex marriage, which posed no true imposition on heterosexuals, trans women’s needs in particular can indeed conflict with those of cisgender women in the context of bathrooms, locker rooms, prisons, domestic violence shelters and competitive athletics.
I believe these conflicts should be subjected to civil debate. But I disagree that my calling a trans woman “she” means I am foreclosing upon such debate, that I am dismissing the needs of women, or that am any less of a feminist myself.
Accusing people of misogyny who refer to a trans woman as “she” is as counterproductive as smearing anyone who raises concerns about pediatric gender medicine as a transphobe. Such invective doesn’t help anyone’s cause. It doesn’t help anyone reach consensus. It just causes a reactionary effect, driving people to dig in their heels, and can even radicalize people.
All this calls for compromise. It calls for dialogue and not invective. And it calls for choosing words carefully and conscientiously in an effort to turn down the heat in this woefully combustible debate.
"Trump has also issued several executive orders about sex and gender. The most popular is a Feb. 5 order titled "Keeping Men Out of Women's Sports," which ends federal funding for any educational institution that allows transgender women to participate in female sports programs or enter female locker rooms in schools. This policy is popular with 65 percent of adults, per an Echelon Insights poll from Feb. 10-13, and with 64 percent per a Feb. 9-11 YouGov poll. On average, it is net positive by 32 points. Similarly, the public approves of a Trump order to officially recognize only two sexes and remove references to "gender" (replacing them with "sex") from all official federal business.
"However, the public opposes the president's efforts to remove transgender people from military service, with 41 percent approving in the average poll and 49 percent disapproving."
Trump's approach to LGBTQ issues is the element of his second term for which he maintains broadest support—by a remarkably wide margin, ABC reports.
He has focused almost entirely on transgender issues; I have found nothing to suggest he is currently attacking gay rights.
On the @PodSaveAmerica episode with @BillMaher, @[private account] said the gov't should not usurp a parent's right to make medical decisions about their trans child. And yet in this decision, the parent's right to know that their child is ID'ing as trans at school has been usurped.
Quoting @JonathanTurley: The 1st Circuit just held that parents have no right to know about their 11-year-old changing gender in school. https://www.ca1.uscourts.gov/sites/ca1/files/opnfiles/23-1069P-01A.pdf This "unwritten policy" was viewed as overriding parental rights. The decision is defended as a reflection of our "pluralistic society"...
What can go wrong when you trust the AI summary of a contentious medical issue: The AI summary can feed off of misreporting on the subject. No, the American Society of Plastic Surgeons did not say what is in that AI summary in the quote tweet. They said the following:
"ASPS has not endorsed any organization's practice recommendations for the treatment of adolescents with gender dysphoria. ASPS currently understands that there is considerable uncertainty as to the long-term efficacy for the use of chest and genital surgical interventions for the treatment of adolescents with gender dysphoria, and the existing evidence base is viewed as low quality/low certainty. This patient population requires specific considerations.
"ASPS is reviewing and prioritizing several initiatives that best support evidence-based gender surgical care to provide guidance to plastic surgeons.
"As members of the multidisciplinary care team, plastic surgeons have a responsibility to provide comprehensive patient education and maintain a robust and evidence-based informed consent process, so patients and their families can set realistic expectations in the shared decision-making context.
"Guided by evidence
"It's important to note that, as an organization and specialty guided by evidence, the Society's stance on this issue has remained consistent: More high-quality research in this rapidly evolving area of healthcare is needed.
"To that end, ASPS efforts in this area include capturing clinical data on gender surgery procedures for adults and the development of practice resources to better aid members in implementing best practices in offering gender-surgery services when higher quality evidence is available. ASPS supports transgender patients' constitutional protections and right to dignity, privacy and humane medical care.
"Further, it has always been the Society's position that members should be able to provide medical care without fear of government-sanctioned penalties and criminalization – and ASPS opposes any attempts at legal encroachment into the practice of medicine."
Quotes a post by T18559; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I wrote about this new study in September:
Controversial Gender Researchers Launch Long-Term Study of Gender Dysphoric Youth and Their Parents
https://benryan.substack.com/p/controversial-gender-researchers
Branded as gender heretics by the pediatric gender-medicine establishment and transgender-rights activists, Michael Bailey, Dr. Lisa Littman, and Kenneth Zucker say they "won't be intimidated."
Quotes a post by T05373; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I presume she preemptively blocked me because of my trans-kids reporting.
Quoting @benryanwriter: Fun fact: Moira Donegan has blocked me. I had never heard of her until today. So when I saw she had blocked me on another thread, I looked up her writing, and the first thing I found was this essay about maternal mortality.
Alternatively, you could start from a position of grace in which you do not presume that transgender people's primary objective is manipulating you.
Quoting @Heminator: Trans people should be treated with reasonable dignity; however, using "preferred pronouns" not only reinforces a harmful delusion, but you're conceding power to that person. If they can emotionally blackmail you into denying their sex, they can get you to agree to worse.
I'm constantly amazed by people who come to me with a straight face and pretend they can't understand what I mean when I say a "trans woman." I have no patience for such nonsense.
I’ve been clear that the science indicates that trans females maintain a competitive advantage in girls’ and women’s sports. It is not my place to decide what people do with this information.
Once I actually mistakenly thought that a person I was interviewing for an article was a transgender woman, when she was not. This made for an interesting moment when I was fact checking! She was actually very amused by my mistake and took it in stride.
My position, which I will go into greater detail in my substack, is that calling a trans woman “she” need not be a philosophical declaration about her right to single-sex spaces and about whether sex can be changed.
I have made clear before that I don’t just believe, I know that sex is binary and unchangeable; trans people do what they can to change their bodies to effect the opposite sex to make themselves feel more comfortable in the world. That’s why they’re called “cross-sex hormones.” (I am opposed to calling it “HRT” in the context, since you can’t replace something that wasn’t there to begin with.)
Observing preferred pronouns is a courtesy. And it is very important to me to be polite to people.
I would hope that each side of this contentious debate might be willing to be open to some compromises. But as I suggested, I also want to be sensitive to the needs and concerns of women.
Being kind is more important than being medically accurate. Just because I call a trans woman she does not mean I am saying they are a biological woman. I am not making sweeping philosophical statement. I am making an important point about not being cruel.
I’ve decided to write an essay for my newsletter entitled, “Why I Use People’s Preferred Pronouns.”
Maybe it’ll cause a mass exodus of subscribers. To that I would say: Good. I’ve been cleaning house on here and blocking extremists on both sides of the aisle on the subject of transgender people.
Yes, I may write critically about pediatric gender medicine and the evidence base behind it. But that effort is distinct from my steadfast belief in treating people with basic human dignity.
I’ve lost transgender friends due to my reporting. But I’ve also been fortunate enough to gain new trans friends. These are brave people who have survived a lot to live their lives as authentically as they can and to mitigate the pain of gender dysphoria. I will never treat them with such disrespect as to not refer to them as they wish to be referred.
I also believe it is important to listen to women and other feminists who are concerned about single-sex spaces. I believe this should be an ongoing conversation about meeting the sometimes conflicting needs of different groups people.
But I disagree that my calling a trans woman “she” means that I am dismissing the needs of women concerned about single-sex spaces or am any less of a feminist myself.
All this calls for compromise. It calls for dialogue and not invective. Accusing people of transphobia who raise concerns about gender medicine or single-sex sports is as counterproductive as accusing someone who calls a trans woman “she” of misogyny. Such accusations only cause people to dig in their heels anyway. They don’t help anyone reach consensus. They serve to radicalize people.
Please, everyone, turn down the nastiness. Observe basic human decency for everyone concerned.
(There, now I have a rough draft.)
It means people identify as the opposite sex, which many people do. Therefore those words have meaning and people do identify as the opposite sex. This used to be called being transsexual. Now it is called being transgender. People who deny all this are the ones who are not acknowledging reality.
Quotes a post by T31252; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The counter argument is: “But if a person identifies as a cat, they are not a cat.”
Indeed, but you cannot say that person does not identify as a cat if in fact they do.
Transgender people identify as the opposite sex, therefore identifying as the opposite sex exists.
Much of the recent surge in trans identification has been in natal females who first began expressing such an identity and complaining of gender dysphoria following the onset of puberty. This stands in sharp contrast to the historically predominant phenotype: a very small population of males who first began expressing such feelings at a very young age; most grew up to be gay.
Both those statements are accurate. A trans identity, while metaphysical and subjective, is a real thing. People identify that way, therefore it exists.
There are only two sexes. This does not mean that there is no such thing as being transgender or that people cannot or do not take hormones and have surgeries to align their body with their trans identity. But to have this discussion we must remain grounded in science.
Quotes a post by T04133; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
X is a hellscape. One of the most galling aspects for me these days are the sanctimonious pronoun police who parade around me claiming I am guilty of all manner of villainy for observing preferred pronouns; and then they claim all trans women are misogynistic perverts.
Quoting @TheFP: Yesterday morning, like I do every morning, I woke up and immediately opened Twitter (a.k.a. X), where the first thing I saw was Elon Musk reacting positively to a post alleging that actor Tom Hanks is a pedophile. Then I saw that Lord Miles—a conservative travel influencer best known for visiting Afghanistan during the Taliban’s reconquista in 2021—has come to believe that another right-wing influencer, this one anonymous, is “not an Anglo Saxon and therefore should be ignored.” When I scrolled on, I saw someone telling the self-described misogynist and accused human trafficker Andrew Tate, whose father was black, that he’s a “mongrel half breed.” Then, my coffee was done!
For those of you who are offline, it is important you understand how bad things have gotten on X. Since Trump’s win in November, the extreme right has completely taken over the platform, and every day they’re getting high on their own supply, expressing opinions that the average American, including Trump voters, would find alienating, insane, or offensive.
—@[private account]
Axios’ @MarcACaputo reports that Trump is targeting the @AP because of conservative objections to its widely observed journalism style guide.
Among the AP guidance conservatives find objectionable:
Warning against "all views" in transgender coverage: AP's "Transgender Coverage Topical Guide" says to avoid "false balance — giving a platform to unqualified claims or sources in the guise of balancing a story by including all views."
Using the phrase "gender-affirming care": AP says the term, commonly used by advocates and physicians, refers to "a swath of mental and medical treatments (such as counseling, hormones or surgery) that help bring a person's gender expression (such as voice, appearance or anatomy) in line with their gender identity."
Quoting @MarcACaputo: President Trump’s decision to limit AP reporters' access is as much fight over the Gulf of America as it is a protest of what White House advisers say is years of liberal word choices that AP’s influential stylebook has spread across mainstream media
https://www.axios.com/2025/02/17/trump-ap-gulf-america-mexico
In part, this ruling seems to gets out ahead of the Skrmetti case before SCOTUS by finding the EO discriminates based on sex (although focusing on the 5th rather than 14th amendment) , but also suggests that the EO is written vaguely enough that simply by virtue of being transgender, a child couldn't get puberty blockers for cancer treatment.
Brianna has made it very clear that she has no interest in making women uncomfortable and that she believes that trans women should have to essentially earn the right to enter women's spaces. She supports assimilation, not demanding that the world re-orient itself around the demands of trans women, regardless of what sex/gender they appear or pass as. So you might find if you listen to her that there isn't as much daylight between what you're suggesting and her actual positions.
2020 was peak left-wing DEI-woke: pronouns in bio, land acknowledgments, punctuality is white supremacy, etc.
We are now seeing peak reactionary right-wing woke: banning DEI words, erasing trans identity, white men reasserting power.
What will the backlash to that look like?
A CDC web page on HIV and health equity includes this disclaimer from the Trump camp that disavows the existence of trans identity: “Per a court order, HHS is required to restore this website as of 11:59PM ET, February 14, 2025. Any information on this page promoting gender ideology is extremely inaccurate and disconnected from the immutable biological reality that there are two sexes, male and female. The Trump Administration rejects gender ideology and condemns the harms it causes to children, by promoting their chemical and surgical mutilation, and to women, by depriving them of their dignity, safety, well-being, and opportunities. This page does not reflect biological reality and therefore the Administration and this Department rejects it.”
Many think the Trump administration, after going after trans people, will come for the gays next. I’ve found it interesting that in general, gays have not been on their list of targets. They are not on the verboten words lists, for example.
What do y’all think. Are gays next?
NEWS: Judge blocks Trump’s gender-affirming care executive orders nationwide
A federal judge Thursday blocked parts of two executive orders issued by President Trump that collectively seek to restrict gender-affirming care.
U.S. District Judge Brendan Hurson at the conclusion of a hearing found a group of transgender teens and LGBTQ organizations that sued were likely to prevail on all of their claims that the orders are without authority and amount to illegal and unconstitutional discrimination.
“Stopping care in the middle of receiving it, any care, really, casts doubt on whether in fact the goals are to protect the recipients of the care,” said Hurson, an appointee of former President Biden.
It adds to a series of court orders across the country in recent days temporarily blocking Trump’s actions, ranging from orders restricting birthright citizenship to transferring incarcerated transgender women to male facilities to Trump’s firing of the head of a whistleblower office.
Under Hurson’s new ruling, various federal agencies are temporarily prohibited from withholding or conditioning funding based on a health care facility providing gender-affirming care anywhere in the country.
The plaintiffs — a group of transgender teens, their parents and two organizations, PFLAG and GLMA: Health Professionals Advancing LGBTQ+ Equality — raised alarm that hospitals across the country quickly moved to cancel appointments after Trump issued two executive orders as part of what his administration has called a crackdown on “gender ideology.”
A colorful procession of locals support Worcester, Mass., becoming a “Sanctuary City for Transgender and Gender Diverse People.” They express their fear of and antipathy toward the Trump regime.
This member of the pronoun police thinks I’m “a clown” for calling transgender women “she”.
A lot of people such as this man cannot see past their fixation on this one point, and consequently miss all the other reporting I’ve published on this issue.
This pronoun campaign is an example of the woke right, in which the right wing is as obsessed with and as totalitarian about policing language, especially regarding identity, as the woke left.
I have made abundantly clear that I do not agree that using someone’s preferred pronouns necessarily amounts to a grand philosophical statement regarding where someone falls on the gender essentialism debate. At a baseline, it is simply polite.
And all journalists working in any kind of non-ideological news use preferred pronouns. I am not suggesting this is why I do so, but if I did not use preferred pronouns, my career in left-wing media would basically end.
Most importantly, preferred pronouns are about showing everyone a baseline and consistent level of respect. Not using someone’s preferred pronouns is disrespectful and rude. And I do not tolerate that.
Any requests for me to change my pronoun policy will be rejected out of hand. People who make a fuss about my policy will be blocked.
Have a nice day.
Quoting @SethDillon: What you claim to be concerned with are "incorrect" claims Reed has made — chief of which is his false claim to be a woman. You affirm this false claim with your language, then call it pronoun policing so you can distract from the fact that you're being a clown.
The talking-points memo put out by MAP about winning the war of words about pediatric gender medicine claims that minors who receive gender-transition treatment only do so after receiving “extensive evaluation” by a multidisciplinary team, which, the memo says, takes place over a significant period of time.
https://benryan.substack.com/p/leaked-lgbtq-groups-memo-on-combatting
While a rigorous patient-evaluation process might be the standard that WPATH has set for clinics to follow in its trans-care guidelines, there is considerable evidence that multiple clinics either never follow this standard, or at least sometimes do not.
As I wrote in the @[private account]:
https://www.nysun.com/article/trumps-justice-department-wont-pull-out-of-supreme-court-case-about-gender-treatments-for-minors-paving-way-for-landmark-decision?member_gift=CUZ5qwd3crq4pmz-xrd
As the Sun previously reported, since 2018, it has been the policy of Boston Children’s Hospital only to provide children and their parents a single, two-hour assessment appointment with a psychologist before deciding whether to refer the child to endocrinology for puberty blockers or hormones.
https://www.nysun.com/article/shocking-and-reckless-top-gender-clinic-assesses-children-for-gender-altering-medical-treatments-in-just-2-hours-lawsuit-lays-bare?lctg=1442179895&recognized_email=editors-group%40nysun.com&newsletter-access&utm_source=MG&utm_medium=email-newsletter&utm_campaign=Evening%20Sun%20%202024-10-31
A 2022 Reuters investigation identified seven pediatric gender clinics that said they would prescribe such drugs to minors on the first appointment if they saw no “red flags.”
https://www.reuters.com/investigates/special-report/usa-transyouth-care/
And in December, Dr. Johanna Olson-Kennedy, one of the top pediatric gender doctors in the nation and a lead investigator on a $10 million National Institutes of Health grant to research these interventions, was sued by a former patient to whom she allegedly prescribed puberty blockers on the first appointment without providing the patient, who was 12 years old, with a psychosocial evaluation, as advised by WPATH’s trans-care guidelines.
https://benryan.substack.com/p/detransitioner-sues-johanna-olson
Dr. Olson-Kennedy is the president of WPATH’s U.S. branch, USPATH. But she has spoken out against the WPATH guidelines’ demand for conducting detailed assessments before putting children on gender-transition drugs. So has Dr. Jack Turban, a child and adolescent psychiatrist at the University of California, San Francisco and vocal advocate of pediatric gender medicine.
https://www.nysun.com/article/from-the-face-of-pediatric-gender-medicine-comes-a-quietly-radical-manifesto?lctg=1542199750&recognized_email=tips%40nysun.com&newsletter-access&utm_source=MG&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=Morning%20Sun%20%202024-08-02
Kellan Baker, executive director of The Institute for Health Research & Policy at the Whitman-Walker Institute, is listed as the primary contact on the document. He and Ms. Goldberg did not return a request for comment.
https://benryan.substack.com/p/leaked-lgbtq-groups-memo-on-combatting
Dr. Baker was a member of the team at the World Professional Association for Transgender Health, the influential U.S.-based activist-medical organization that commissioned a lengthy roster of systematic reviews about transgender care from evidence-based medicine experts at Johns Hopkins University. According to internal @[private account] communications that were subpoenaed in the federal case over Alabama’s ban of gender-transition treatment for minors, WPATH suppressed many of these reviews when the findings were not to their liking. They ultimately only permitted the publication of two of them.
https://www.supremecourt.gov/DocketPDF/23/23-477/328275/20241015131826340_2024.10.15%20-%20Ala.%20Amicus%20Br.%20iso%20TN%20FINAL.pdf
https://www.economist.com/united-states/2024/06/27/research-into-trans-medicine-has-been-manipulated
Dr. Baker was the lead author on one of those reviews. It looked at studies of treatment with cross-sex hormone treatment among both adolescents and adults and found it was associated with various psychological benefits. But similar to all other such reviews about pediatric gender medicine in particular, the review found that the certainty of such conclusions was “limited by high risk of bias in study designs, small sample sizes and confounding with other interventions.”
https://academic.oup.com/jes/article/5/4/bvab011/6126016?login=false
The apparent lead author of the talking-points memo about winning the information war about pediatric gender medicine is Sean Lund, managing director of messaging research programs at MAP. This is according to the meta data on the PDF of the memo.
https://benryan.substack.com/p/leaked-lgbtq-groups-memo-on-combatting
Mr. Lund is also the apparent lead author of the document: “TALKING ABOUT Curriculum Censorship: Transgender Youth Participation in Sports, Medical Care Bans: Public Education Messaging Overview.” It is a comprehensive primer on how to combat efforts to: censor LGBTQ-related subjects and materials in schools, restrict youth sports by biological sex, and ban gender-transition treatment for minors.
https://www.lgbtmap.org/file/public-education-trans-youth.pdf
A companion document from MAP focusing just on the medical interventions provides similar guidelines to the new talking-points memo, some of it word for word (see the attached images).
https://www.mapresearch.org/file/talking-about-medical-care-bans.pdf
Note that the MAP document’s claim, that rate of detransitioning among those who have undergone cross-sex hormone treatment as a minors is “extremely rare,” is not supported by evidence. The truth is that the detransitioning rate remains unknown due to limited loss to follow-up in the available cohort studies, as the Cass Review indicated.
https://cass.independent-review.uk
It is worth noting that the MAP document, like the new memo, explicitly discourages any discussion of the science in this field—and then offers an unscientific claim as a means of deflection in the event that a discussion does turn down that path.
Kellan Baker, a coauthor of this secret memo, knows that answer better than anyone, given he was on the WPATH team that secretly suppressed the Johns Hopkins systematic reviews of trans care that they had commissioned when they didn't like the results.
One of the authors of the talking-points memo about how to advocate for pediatric gender-transition treatment is Kellan Baker, of the Whitman-Walker Institute. Dr. Baker was on the WPATH team that suppressed the Johns Hopkins systematic literature reviews of trans care that they had commissioned when they didn’t like the results. So it is notable that he is now instructing other advocates of pediatric gender-transition treatment not to discuss the scientific evidence in this field, but is claiming that those who ask about the evidence only do so in bad faith. https://benryan.substack.com/p/leaked-lgbtq-groups-memo-on-combatting?utm_content=post
This person is misrepresenting what I said. The question is not whether trans people can play on sports teams or enter bathrooms. It is whether they can play on sports teams and enter bathrooms according to their gender identity, or have to do so according to their natal sex.
Quotes a post by T33292; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The hyperlink in Chu's assertion that Trump seeks to eliminate all trans people goes to Chu's article in which the writer asserts that kids should be able to have gender transition surgeries at any age for any reason.
Guess what word is not in this editorial by Pamela Paul, to which Andrea Long Chu links in her claim that Paul said that we are "mutilating" kids:
"Mutilating."
It is disingenuous to claim that Paul used such inflammatory language.
https://www.nytimes.com/2024/02/02/opinion/transgender-children-gender-dysphoria.html
The question at hand is not whether trans people are permitted to play sports, but whether they are permitted to play on the team aligned with their gender identity. Same holds true with the bathroom debate.
Quoting @AyannaPressley: Let me say it again:
Trans people deserve to play sports.
Trans people deserve health care.
Trans people deserve access to bathrooms.
Trans people deserve to be treated like human beings.
This Congresswoman loves you and will always have your back.
I read this article on trans families fleeing the nation. It centers on a mom who apparently has more than one trans kid. The article never says anything about the kids' trans-related needs—are they on meds? how old are they?—and why they have this sudden need to escape to Scotland. The reader is expected to simply take on faith that this is a rational choice that any mother would make and that despite all the upheaval and financial hardship, this will yield a net positive for her family.
https://www.rollingstone.com/culture/culture-features/trans-youth-trump-leaving-u-s-1235256729/
I've been thinking about this dichotomy in which certain activists have seized upon research suggesting that only a small fraction of trans kids take blockers or hormones, which they say supports the notion that all of the fuss over trans kids is a moral panic.
Several things:
1. Let's just say those figures are accurate, and only <10% of trans kids take blockers or hormones. But at the same time that certain activists have been blaming the world for fixating on such a small group, they have also been decrying how difficult it is to get this medical care. They are calling for that number to be much higher. This is an irreconcilable contradiction, people.
2. Those same voices say that the low figure of medication use proves that the assessments are comprehensive before these kids get blockers or hormones. And yet some of those same people call for the end of assessments and define assessments as basically just asking the kid what their gender identity is and whether they want meds, and then making sure they're ready.
3. If we are talking about such a small percentage of trans kids being on meds, and if the only reason the number is small is because only a small percentage of them want to be on meds and also there isn't capacity to treat all of those kids immediately, then the typical story of a trans kid is not that they go on meds, but that they go through life not even wanting them. And yet predominantly, all the focus on trans kids is about the desperate need for them to obtain these meds. But these kids are at least supposedly edge cases even among trans kids.
4. And if the population of kids who want and get these meds is so small and is such a small percentage of all trans kids, then all these articles we read about families fleeing states or the country to try to get access to meds are only the edge cases. And the truth is that most families will be fine without any access to meds. So why are there so few articles about kids who don't need or want meds?
So many of these things are contradictory! They can't all be true.
In fact, it appears that most of the @ManhattanInst colleagues of @[private account] who have responded publicly to her coming out as transgender have been quite supportive. @EmmaVigeland appears to be pointing to an edge case, at least within the public chatter.
Quoting @EmmaVigeland: A Manhattan Institute fellow who previously worked on multiple Republican campaigns and as Senator Rob Portman's chief economist comes out as trans, and this is how her conservative colleagues are reacting.
Here are passages from Jack Turban’s book about trans females in sports competition. He is very dismissive of the notion that they would harbor any advantage and is keen to assert that they are at a systemic disadvantage because they are subjected to stigma. I’d be very interested to hear thoughts from @[private account] and other experts in this field about these pages.
Sapir’s chart calls into question the Harvard press release’s claim that these surgeries are “rarely” performed on minors. That release quotes Dai arguing that legislation that bans gender-affirming surgery in minors—26 states have passed such laws since 2021—is “rooted in bias and stigma against TGD identities and seeks to address a perceived problem that does not actually exist.”
https://benryan.substack.com/p/how-harvard-teed-up-the-false-claim
Putting aside whether such surgeries are a problem or a solution, it’s quite clear that a substantial number are performed annually. And multiple analyses have indicated such surgeries were quickly becoming more common during the years leading up to state bans starting to kick in.
A study published in Sept. 2023 in the journal Cureus analyzed data from the American College of Surgeons National Surgical Quality Improvement Program Pediatric database, covering 2018 to 2021 and looking at Americans under age 18. The authors found a swift growth curve in the annual number of gender-affirming surgeries for trans minors. Almost all the procedures were chest masculinization surgeries (CMS). Keep in mind this study relied on an even more limited set of data than the Harvard group did, so the actual numbers are especially small.
How Many Gender-Affirming Surgeries Have There Actually Been in Minors?
https://benryan.substack.com/p/how-harvard-teed-up-the-false-claim
@LeorSapir, a fellow at the conservative think tank the Manhattan Institute, published a non-peer-reviewed analysis in the City Journal on Aug. 12 that appears to get closer to the true number of trans minors getting gender-affirming surgeries. Sapir reported:
“A new analysis by the Manhattan Institute, using a more up-to-date all-payer national insurance database from 2017 to 2023, found evidence of 5,288 to 6,294 “gender-affirming” double mastectomies for girls under age 18. This includes 50 to 179 girls who were 12.5 or younger at the time of their procedure.”
Sapir’s conservative estimate for the number of such surgeries conducted in 2019 among minors with gender dysphoria is about 9-fold higher than the figure the Harvard team reported:
Over and over this past week, I see journalists credulously parroting the wildly misleading and incomplete findings of this same @Harvard research letters to come to the false conclusion that gender-transition surgeries in minors are very rare.
How Harvard Teed Up the False Claim That the 'Vast Majority of Minors Getting Gender-Affirming Surgeries Are Cis Kids'
https://benryan.substack.com/p/how-harvard-teed-up-the-false-claim
An opaquely written Harvard study and linked press release prompted false reporting that gynecomastia surgeries for boys are vastly more common than gender-affirming surgeries for trans kids.
Readers of the LGBTQ media outlet Them could be excused for harboring the false belief that out of all surgeries that affirm the gender of minors in the U.S., the vast majority are gynecomastia operations on cisgender (non-transgender) boys to remove breast growth. (The idea is that by surgically removing a physical characteristic that makes boys appear more feminine, the operation affirms their male identity.) A Them article published June 28 falsely claims that for minors, gender-affirming surgeries among these cis boys dwarf such operations among transgender people under age 18.
The reporter from Them apparently followed the combined lead of an opaquely written research letterand a misleading and opaquely written associated press release.
In its headline, the press release, issued by Harvard’s public health school, proclaims, “Gender-affirming surgeries rarely performed on transgender youth”—an almost certainly false claim given the limitations of the research letter’s data set, as well as the findings of other researchers (more on those a bit later on).
The research letter was published in JAMA Network Open on June 27 and written by a team out of Harvard, Boston Children’s and Brown University. It sought to compare how common gender-affirming surgeries were based on whether individuals were adults or minors and whether they were what’s known as transgender and gender diverse (TGD) or were cisgender. They examined what the Harvard-issued press release characterized as a “nationally representative pool of medical insurance claims” from 2019.
This pool included data on 47.4 million adults age 18 and older and 22.8 million minors. This is a fraction of the overall U.S. population of either group. U.S. medical databases are always limited and never able to capture the full incidence of any medical procedure, because they never cover all Americans. For this study, the authors also couldn’t capture surgical procedures paid for out of pocket. So the true figures are likely much higher (a more recent investigation found much higher figures; more on this later).
Looking at data on trans and gender diverse people, the study found evidence of 2,664 gender-affirming surgeries in adults and 85 such surgeries among minors in 2019. A total of 59.7% (1,591 of 2,664) of the surgeries in TGD adults and 96.4% (82 of 85) of the surgeries in TGD minors were chest-related procedures. The investigators did not break this down according to whether these were double mastectomies (known as “top surgery,” conducted on trans males), breast augmentations (for trans females), or other procedures. But at least in minors, such surgeries are overwhelmingly mastectomies, according to other research I’ll go into later on.
Here’s where the Harvard research letter gets opaque: Without specifying that they are going on to discuss a category of surgeries that are distinct from chest-related gender-affirming surgeries, the authors then write:
“Of the 636 breast reductions among cisgender male and TGD adults, 507 (80%) were performed on cisgender males. Of the 151 breast reductions among cisgender male minors and TGD minors, 146 (97%) were performed on cisgender male minors.”
I was baffled as to why the researchers broke down their numbers this way. Why make an apparent differentiation between top surgery and breast reductions? So I emailed the authors and heard back from Dannie Dai, a research data analyst in the department of health policy and management at Harvard’s public health school. Dai said that in order to make an even comparison between trans and cisgender individuals’ surgeries, they “needed to select a gender-affirming surgery that is commonly covered by insurance for minors and adults of cisgender and TGD identity. The only gender-affirming surgery that met this criteria was breast reduction surgery.”
This begs the question of why the study authors made this comparison in the first place when they knew that it would leave out the vast majority of gender-affirming surgeries among trans minors. Plus, they might’ve imagined that their findings would be misinterpreted.
A breast reduction surgery is sometimes sought by natal females who identify as nonbinary and who wish to reduce the size of but not completely eliminate their breasts. Such surgery is thus distinct from a double mastectomy. Despite this crucial distinction, neither the research letter nor the Harvard press release clarified the matter. Here’s how the press release describes the figures:
“For teens ages 15 to 17 and adults ages 18 and older, the rate of undergoing gender-affirming surgery with a TGD-related diagnosis was 2.1 per 100,000 and 5.3 per 100,000, respectively. A majority of these surgeries were chest surgeries. When considering use of gender-affirming breast reductions among cisgender males and TGD people, the study found that cisgender males accounted for the vast majority of breast reductions, with 80% of surgeries among adults performed on cisgender men and 97% of surgeries among minors performed on cisgender male teens.”
Notice how the release makes no clear indication that midway through this passage, it is switching to discussing a different category of surgery. Readers are likely to presume that chest surgeries and breast reductions are synonyms. And the passage also makes no mention of the specific sums of the different types of surgeries.
Plus, neither the press release nor the research letter state the major limitation—one that calls into question whether the investigators’ tallies of surgeries are anywhere close to the true national figures—that the medical-claims database on which the investigation relied only covered a fraction of the U.S. population.
Let’s dispel the myth propagated by both the press release and the Them article that the “vast majority” of gender-affirming surgeries in minors are conducted on cisgender boys. (Note that the press release in question is dated July 8, and thus was published after the Them article. I haven’t been able to find a version of the release published prior to the article; perhaps the press-release copy that prompted the article went out only via email. It’s possible the Them article was written based on a somewhat different press release than what is currently on the Harvard web site; but the article makes clear it drew a quote from Dai from a press release.)
Let’s combine the 82 chest-related gender-affirming surgeries conducted on TGD minors in 2019 with the 5 breast-reduction surgeries and compare that sum with the 146 gynecomastia surgeries conducted in cisgender boys. Out of 233 total surgeries, that would break down to 87, or 37%, among TGD minors, and the remaining 62% would be among cisgender boys.
I would hardly characterize a figure under two-thirds as the “vast majority”.
But such a comparison between the TGD and cisgender kids is still misleading, because trans kids make up small minority—perhaps 1.4%—of all minors. If adjusted for differences in the estimated sizes of the TGD vs. cisgender minor populations, the surgical rate in trans kids would dramatically dwarf that of the cisgender kids.
NEWS: Michigan health system halts gender-affirming care for minors after Trump order
At least one Michigan health system is halting gender-affirming services for young patients, following an executive order signed by President Donald Trump.
The federal order, signed Jan. 28, said the U.S. will not fund, sponsor, promote, assist or support the transition of a child (younger than 19) from one sex to another. All laws that prohibit or limit these procedures will be “rigorously enforced.”
Shortly after the issuance, Corewell Health -- formerly Spectrum and Beaumont -- said it would stop beginning any new hormone therapy regimens for minor patients seeking gender-affirming care. The system did not previously perform gender-affirming surgeries on minors, according to a system spokesperson.
“Our team will continue monitoring federal changes to rules and regulations,” Corewell Health said in a statement. “We remain committed to providing the highest quality health care to all the patients we serve.”
Access to gender-affirming care for adults won’t change at Corewell. Minors will also continue to have access to hormone therapy to treat conditions like fibromyalgia and endometriosis, which use similar treatments.
Trump’s order claimed medical professionals across the country are “maiming and sterilizing” a growing number of impressionable children through irreversible medical interventions, possibly leaving them with regret and expensive medical bills.
Specifically, the order references puberty blockers, which delay the onset or progression of puberty; sex hormones like estrogen, progesterone or testosterone, which can be used to align an individual’s physical appearance with their gender identity; and surgical procedures.
Not all gender-affirming care is permanent. Puberty blockers called gonadotropin-releasing hormone (GnRH) analogues pause puberty until a person stops taking them, according to the Mayo Clinic.
Delaying puberty for youth who have gender dysphoria has been associated with reduced depression, anxiety, and thoughts or actions of self-harm.
Following Trump’s order, University of Michigan Health said it’s assessing the potential impacts of the order on its healthcare services and the communities it serve. It will “continue to prioritize high-quality, accessible care while ensuring compliance with the law.”
U-M Health has a program to help transgender, gender nonconforming and nonbinary adults access and obtain quality gender-affirming medical care, as well as gender care for youth services.
“Our team believes that identifying with a gender that is different from one’s sex is a normal part of the human experience, and that people with all gender identities, including agender, non-binary and gender queer identities, deserve equal access to the highest quality care,” U-M Health wrote on its transgender services webpage.
A spokesperson for McLaren Health, which has hospitals throughout the state, said their system already didn’t offer gender-affirming services. Other health systems didn’t immediately respond to messages from MLive about the executive order, or declined comment.
People who come at me with these tiresome complaints about my word choice when I’m writing about transgender issued get blocked. I do not wish to hear from them, ever. They bring nothing to the table.
Quotes a post by T00402; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Trump Signs Order Barring Trans Females From Girls' & Women's Sports
https://benryan.substack.com/p/trump-signs-order-barring-trans-females
At an exuberant ceremony in the White House, President Trump signed an executive order that bars natal males from girls' and women's sports. It applies to K-12 schools and universities.
Jack Turban writes in his book that because trans women are disadvantaged in general in life, which impedes their overall sports abilities, therefore they should be given concessions that prioritize inclusion in sports, at least until they reach parity.
There is indeed an epidemic of suicidality and self harm among transgender and other gender-distressed young people, who often have multiple other psychiatric diagnoses on top of gender dysphoria.
Suicide deaths among them, while elevated, thankfully are rare.
Vigeland has made clear her position, that she does not care if there might be an advantage among trans women; inclusion is the primary goal. https://x.com/benryanwriter/status/1887574501644509235
Quoting @benryanwriter: The @[private account]'s @EmmaVigeland has made clear that even if it were true (which science indicates it is) that trans women (natal ♂️ ID'ing as ♀️) have an advantage in women's sports, she doesn't care.
"Trans women should be able to compete without question," she said last year.
The full @EmmaVigeland quote:
"You're a bad mom, if you can't explain that there are people along a gender spectrum, and it's not this binary, like, I mean, I hear this all the time: 'My daughter plays sports. What am I going to tell to her? You know, it's not fair to her to compete with this kind of person.'
"Honestly, I have a sports podcast. I love sports as much as anyone. Trans women should be able to compete without question, in women's sports, because there are a lot of instances where there are athletes who, and just there's not even evidence to show, that this is the case.
"But just take their assertion at face value for a second that this is some unfair advantage. I mean, there, there's an unfair advantage all the time in sports that's actually quite, that's the nature of sports that some people are physically or more gifted, or they have, like, a better mentality. We should have banned Yao Ming from basketball because he's just too tall. It's not fair to everybody else."
The @[private account]'s @EmmaVigeland has made clear that even if it were true (which science indicates it is) that trans women (natal ♂️ ID'ing as ♀️) have an advantage in women's sports, she doesn't care.
"Trans women should be able to compete without question," she said last year.
Quoting @EmmaVigeland: "Let’s recreate the Tim Walz photo op, but instead of feeding children in school how about we drive some trans kids to suicide"
My coverage of the crucial Finnish study, which is the only study ever to directly assess whether prescribing cross-sex hormones to gender dysphoric youth is independently associated with a difference in the suicide death rate.
They found it was not.
https://nypost.com/2024/02/24/opinion/a-finnish-study-is-changing-how-we-approach-trans-kids/
A defiant @EmmaVigeland of @[private account] states a fact: trans people have high suicidality. What she doesn't say is that suicides in youth with gender dysphoria (GD) are elevated, but nevertheless rare. A Finnish study found the elevated rate was tied to other psych issues, not GD.
Quoting @EmmaVigeland: "Let’s recreate the Tim Walz photo op, but instead of feeding children in school how about we drive some trans kids to suicide"
Vigeland’s discourse on this issue has been rigidly ideological. She said on her show that she doesn’t care if it’s unfair that trans females have an advantage in sports; inclusion is more important.
A recent NYT poll found very similar figures. The sports issue is where trans activism has lost most Americans, who don’t think natal males who identify as female should be allowed in girls’ and women’s sports.
Quoting @KFILE: CNN's @ForecasterEnten found that **79%** of Americans oppose transgender athletes in female sports yesterday, including 67% of Democrats.
https://x.com/therecount/status/1887249343981253000
Trump Signs Order Barring Trans Females From Girls' & Women's Sports
https://benryan.substack.com/p/trump-signs-order-barring-trans-females
At an exuberant ceremony in the White House, President Trump signed an executive order that bars natal males from girls' and women's sports. It applies to K-12 schools and universities.
Most Americans Don't Support Top Trans-Activist Goals, NYT Poll Finds
https://benryan.substack.com/p/most-americans-dont-support-top-trans
A Times opinion poll found that the majority of Democrats think women's sports should be restricted according to sex, not gender identity, and that minors shouldn't have access to transition drugs.
The scientific reality is that males have an advantage over females in sports and this advantage is not entirely erased by suppressing testosterone and treating with estrogen.
Two thirds of Dems, per a recent poll, don't think trans women should be allowed in women's sports.
Journalists are advised by suicide prevention groups not to sensationalize suicide or to ever attribute it to a single cause. And yet with the trans-kids debate, all bets are off.
Despite the fact that the literature backing the claims that these policies cause suicide is deeply questionable, writers and talking heads such as @EmmaVigeland only lean into the suicide claim.
Where is all the talk about how such sensationalizing of suicide might cause suicides by priming kids to believe that it is expected they will kill themselves?
Quoting @EmmaVigeland: "Let’s recreate the Tim Walz photo op, but instead of feeding children in school how about we drive some trans kids to suicide"
Most Democrats support keeping trans females (natal males who identify as female) out of girls’ and women’s sports. Republicans are capitalizing on this to pluck off people from the left and usher them into their coalition.
Quotes a post by A2493; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Trump Signs Order Barring Trans Females From Girls' & Women's Sports
https://benryan.substack.com/p/trump-signs-order-barring-trans-females
At an exuberant ceremony in the White House, President Trump signed an executive order that bars natal males from girls' and women's sports. It applies to K-12 schools and universities.
Trump signs an executive order that would withhold federal funds from K-12 schools and universities that admit transgender females (natal males) to girls’ and women’s sports.
Quoting @benryanwriter: BREAKING: Trump has signed an executive order to "ban men from competing in women's sports."
"The war on women's sports is over," Trump said at the White House.
Trump said men "beat up" and "injure" women in sports, referring to transgender females in girls and women's sports. That's @Riley_Gaines_ behind him. @BillboardChris (who is Canadian) is also there.
The executive action says that all schools that receive taxpayer dollars will be investigation for violation of Title IX if they allow natal males to compete in girls' and women's sports. This includes public K-12 schools and almost all universities.
"We've gotten the woke lunacy out of our military and now we're very importantly getting it out of women's sports," Trump said.
He said the left has inculcated a "militant transgender ideology."
"Female athletes have been forced onto the front lines and men claiming to be women have claimed more than 3,500 victories," he said.
He ticked off various victories from transgender women, including in weight lifting.
He said that his "landslide" victory (he did not achieve one; the vote was extremely close) was due to these issues, making reference to the massive investment by Republicans in campaign ads attacking Harris over her support of transgender treatments and surgeries.
He noted the presence at event of Senators: @MarshaBlackburn, @[private account] ("I love his new haircut!"), @[private account] and @SenTuberville; and Govs @[private account], @[private account] @[private account] @[private account].
During a protracted name-checking ceremony, Mr. Trump prompted the most enthusiastic applause of all for @[private account], who tied for fifth place with Lia Thomas, who is transgender, in the 200 freestyle final at the NCAA Women’s Championships in March 2022. Ms. Gaines was ultimately compelled to give up her spot on the podium in favor of Ms. Thomas, much to her chagrin. Considerably media-savvy, Ms. Gaines has since become the most prominent female athlete to campaign against the inclusion of transgender females in girls’ and women’s sports. https://benryan.substack.com/p/trump-signs-order-barring-trans-females
Recent polling by The New York Times suggests that the majority of Americans, including two thirds of Democrats, agree that women’s sports should not permit inclusion by natal males who identify as female. https://benryan.substack.com/p/most-americans-dont-support-top-trans
The executive order further asserts:
https://benryan.substack.com/p/trump-signs-order-barring-trans-females
(a) The Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy shall, within 60 days of the date of this order:
(i) convene representatives of major athletic organizations and governing bodies, and female athletes harmed by such policies, to promote policies that are fair and safe, in the best interests of female athletes, and consistent with the requirements of Title IX, as applicable; and
(ii) convene State Attorneys General to identify best practices in defining and enforcing equal opportunities for women to participate in sports and educate them about stories of women and girls who have been harmed by male participation in women’s sports
The new executive order states: “Many sport-specific governing bodies have no official position or requirements regarding trans-identifying athletes. Others allow men to compete in women’s categories if these men reduce the testosterone in their bodies below certain levels or provide documentation of ‘sincerely held’ gender identity. These policies are unfair to female athletes and do not protect female safety.”
https://benryan.substack.com/p/trump-signs-order-barring-trans-females
Science backs up this claim of a lack of fairness, although more research is needed. A recent review paper by Dr. Michael Joyner @[private account], an expert in exercise science at the @[private account], found that boys have an advantage over girls in sports even prior to puberty. This advantage magnifies dramatically after puberty. He further found that sustained treatment with cross-sex hormones does not fully eliminate this typical advantage.
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39716906/
At the heart of the battle over whether trans females should be included in girls and women’s sports is the question of whether Title IX of the Education Amendments Act of 1972 defines sex according to natal sex at birth, or whether it observes a more expansive definition—one that the Biden administration sought to instill—that includes gender identity as well.
https://benryan.substack.com/p/trump-signs-order-barring-trans-females
The judicial branch will invariably be compelled to answer the question that the Daily Wire’s @MattWalshBlog Matt Walsh, an influential force in conservative activism and politics, posed in a satirical 2022 documentary:
“What is a woman?”
With an eye toward proudly presiding over the 2028 Los Angeles Olympics, Mr. Trump said that Secretary of State Marco Rubio would seek to bar transgender women from competing in women’s categories at the Olympics by informing the International Olympic Committee “that America categorically rejects transgender lunacy.” Indeed, the text of his executive order calls on the committee to amend its standards to keep women’s sports restricted to biological females.
https://benryan.substack.com/p/trump-signs-order-barring-trans-females
Mr. Trump further said that he had directed the Secretary of Homeland Security Kristi Noem “to deny any and all visa applications” by any natal males seeking to enter the nation to compete in women’s sports.
“The war on women’s sports is over,” Mr. Trump said at an exuberant and boisterous ceremony in the White House.
https://benryan.substack.com/p/trump-signs-order-barring-trans-females
This was, in fact, the opening salvo of a new phase of the ongoing legal and political war regarding this combustible issue over inclusion and fairness in sports.
“On day one, I made it official, and I’m making it official policy of United States that there are two genders,” Mr. Trump said. “What might they be? Men and women.”
The president characterized transgender women as “men” and said that they “beat up” and “injure” women in sports. To make his point, he included as a guest at the ceremony Payton McNabb—a woman who was seriously injured by a volleyball “kill shot” made by a transgender player.
We estimate that the financial cost of fully implementing President Trump’s ban
on transgender service members would be $960 million.
5) We derive our estimate by multiplying the number of transgender service
members (12,800) by the average per-person cost of recruiting and training a
replacement for each service member who is discharged ($75,000).
6) By comparison, the RAND Corporation has found that the military’s total annual
cost of providing transition-related health care is, at most, $8.4 million.
7) The average annual cost of providing transition-related care for the entire
population of transgender troops is $656 per transgender service member per year,
because most transgender personnel do not require transition-related care during
their military careers.
8) The upshot of our analysis is that implementing President Trump’s transgender
service ban would cost $75,000 per person in order to accrue an annual savings of
$656 per person. For the military as a whole, fully implementing President
Trump’s ban would cost $960 million in pursuit of saving $8.4 million per year.
https://palmcenterlegacy.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/08/cost-of-firing-trans-troops-3.pdf?utm_source=substack&utm_medium=email
NEWS: Trump issues executive order to ban trans people from the military, stating that "adoption of a gender identity inconsistent with an individual’s sex conflicts with a soldier’s commitment to an honorable, truthful, and disciplined lifestyle, even in one’s personal life."
PRIORITIZING MILITARY EXCELLENCE AND READINESS
EXECUTIVE ORDER
January 27, 2025
By the authority vested in me as President by the Constitution and the laws of the United States of America, and as Commander in Chief of the Armed Forces of the United States, and to ensure the readiness and effectiveness of our Armed Forces, it is hereby ordered:
Section 1. Purpose. The United States military has a clear mission: to protect the American people and our homeland as the world’s most lethal and effective fighting force. Success in this existential mission requires a singular focus on developing the requisite warrior ethos, and the pursuit of military excellence cannot be diluted to accommodate political agendas or other ideologies harmful to unit cohesion.
Recently, however, the Armed Forces have been afflicted with radical gender ideology to appease activists unconcerned with the requirements of military service like physical and mental health, selflessness, and unit cohesion. Longstanding Department of Defense (DoD) policy (DoD Instruction (DoDI) 6130.03) provides that it is the policy of the DoD to ensure that service members are “[f]ree of medical conditions or physical defects that may reasonably be expected to require excessive time lost from duty for necessary treatment or hospitalization.” As a result, many mental and physical health conditions are incompatible with active duty, from conditions that require substantial medication or medical treatment to bipolar and related disorders, eating disorders, suicidality, and prior psychiatric hospitalization.
Consistent with the military mission and longstanding DoD policy, expressing a false “gender identity” divergent from an individual’s sex cannot satisfy the rigorous standards necessary for military service. Beyond the hormonal and surgical medical interventions involved, adoption of a gender identity inconsistent with an individual’s sex conflicts with a soldier’s commitment to an honorable, truthful, and disciplined lifestyle, even in one’s personal life. A man’s assertion that he is a woman, and his requirement that others honor this falsehood, is not consistent with the humility and selflessness required of a service member.
For the sake of our Nation and the patriotic Americans who volunteer to serve it, military service must be reserved for those mentally and physically fit for duty. The Armed Forces must adhere to high mental and physical health standards to ensure our military can deploy, fight, and win, including in austere conditions and without the benefit of routine medical treatment or special provisions.
Sec. 2. Policy. It is the policy of the United States Government to establish high standards for troop readiness, lethality, cohesion, honesty, humility, uniformity, and integrity. This policy is inconsistent with the medical, surgical, and mental health constraints on individuals with gender dysphoria. This policy is also inconsistent with shifting pronoun usage or use of pronouns that inaccurately reflect an individual’s sex.
Sec. 3. Definitions. The definitions in the Executive Order of January 20, 2025 (Defending Women from Gender Ideology Extremism and Restoring Biological Truth to the Federal Government) shall apply to this order.
Sec. 4. Implementation. (a) Within 60 days of the date of this order, the Secretary of Defense (Secretary) shall update DoDI 6130.03 Volume 1 (Medical Standards for Military Service: Appointment, Enlistment, or Induction (May 6, 2018), Incorporating Change 5 of May 28, 2024) and DoDI 6130.03 Volume 2 (Medical Standards for Military Service: Retention (September 4, 2020), Incorporating Change 1 of June 6, 2022) to reflect the purpose and policy of this Order.
(b) The Secretary shall promptly issue directives for DoD to end invented and identification-based pronoun usage to best achieve the policy outlined in section 2 of this order.
(c) Within 30 days of the date of this order, the Secretary shall:
(i) identify all additional steps and issue guidance necessary to fully implement this order; and
(ii) submit to the President through the Assistant to the President for National Security Affairs a report that summarizes these steps.
(d) Absent extraordinary operational necessity, the Armed Forces shall neither allow males to use or share sleeping, changing, or bathing facilities designated for females, nor allow females to use or share sleeping, changing, or bathing facilities designated for males.
(e) Within 30 days of the issuance of the respective updates, directives, and guidance under subsections (a), (b), and (c) of this section, the Secretary of Homeland Security shall, with respect to the Coast Guard, issue updates, directives, and guidance consistent with the updates, directives, and guidance issued under subsections (a), (b), and (c) of this section.
Sec. 5. Implementing the Revocation of Executive Order 14004. (a) Pursuant to the Executive Order of January 20, 2025 (Initial Rescissions of Harmful Executive Orders and Actions), Executive Order 14004 of January 25, 2021 (Enabling All Qualified Americans To Serve Their Country in Uniform), has been revoked. Accordingly, all policies, directives, and guidance issued pursuant to Executive Order 14004 shall be rescinded to the extent inconsistent with the provisions of this order.
(b) The Secretary and, with respect to the Coast Guard, the Secretary of Homeland Security, shall take all necessary steps to implement the revocations described in subsection (a) of this section and ensure that all military departments and services fully comply with the provisions of this order.
Sec. 6. Severability. If any provision of this order, or the application of any provision to any person or circumstance, is held to be invalid, the remainder of this order and the application of its provisions to any other persons or circumstances shall not be affected thereby.
Sec. 7. General Provisions. (a) Nothing in this order shall be construed to impair or otherwise affect:
(i) the authority granted by law to an executive department or agency, or the head thereof; or
(ii) the functions of the Director of the Office of Management and Budget relating to budgetary, administrative, or legislative proposals.
(b) This order shall be implemented consistent with applicable law and subject to the availability of appropriations.
(c) This order is not intended to, and does not, create any right or benefit, substantive or procedural, enforceable at law or in equity by any party against the United States, its departments, agencies, or entities, its officers, employees, or agents, or any other person.
THE WHITE HOUSE,
January 27, 2025.
There is so much hand wringing and squabbling over prepubescent children. But I've seen quite a bit of new data over the past couple of weeks that has led me to believe that prepubescent gender dysphoria and transgender identification likely remains very rare in the US and the UK. Most of the numbers I've seen suggest that the vast majority of kids who get a GD diagnosis and who otherwise present at a gender clinic do so after they hit puberty. The typical age at diagnosis is 15 or 16 years old.
Consequently, puberty blockers aren't really a major factor in the decision making at that point. This suggests that all the handwringing over puberty blockers as a discrete intervention may have been rather misplaced. The real question centers on the ethics of giving cross-sex hormones to a teenager who has already pretty much finished their endogenous puberty and yet is not yet an adult legally and cognitively capable of making their own choices.
Quoting @benryanwriter: Diagnoses of gender dysphoria were almost entirely among those age 11 and older and increased the most steeply among 17 and 18 year olds. By 2021, 0.42%, or about 1 in 240, of 17 to 18 year olds had such a diagnosis, a figure that was somewhat higher among natal girls and somewhat lower among natal boys. (By comparison, a recent analysis found that about 1 in 1,000 privately inured U.S. 17 year olds were receiving cross-sex hormones between 2017 and 2022; the figure was higher for girls and was probably higher overall in 2022 in particular.)
https://benryan.substack.com/p/gender-dysphoria-surges-50-fold-in
Between 2011 and 2015, the increase in gender dysphoria diagnoses in the English youth was comparable among natal boys and girls. But then natal girls peeled away from the boys and began to receive the diagnosis at much higher rates. By 2021, of all people age 18 and under, 0.083% had such a diagnosis—the equivalent of 10,291 young people. This compared with what would have been 192 youth with such a diagnosis in 2011—a more than 50-fold increase.
And note, that, no, there is no major "catch-up" effect in older populations, in which they come to identify as trans just as much as their younger peers, but just take a lot longer.
You can see from this chart that the children who hit puberty around 2012 to 2015 suddenly saw a dramatic upswing in transgender identification among them compared with people who were even a few years older than them.
That period of time would prove transformative to adolescent psychology in myriad ways beyond just trans identification. This was when social media apps became ubiquitous. As @JonHaidt documents in The Anxious Generation, adolescent mental health, especially among girls, took a nosedive around then.
The big intellectual battle is over whether these apps helped children discover their true selves, or whether the apps drove children to adopt inauthentic identities as a coping mechanism in the face of the stress and anxiety that social media apps caused young people.
Quoting @benryanwriter: This graph is particularly interesting, indicating exponential growth in trans identification in adulthood based on how recently someone was born. The numbers started to swoop up for those born in 1990 or later:
The New York Times quite famously reported in October reported that, whereas a 2022 report from UCLA’s Williams Institute found that 1.4% of teens identified as trans, a new Centers for Disease Control and Prevention survey conducted in 2023 found that 3.3% of high school students identify as trans and an additional 2.2% are questioning their identity. There may be differences in how the questions were asked in these respective surveys that may have skewed the results; it’s hard to know if this represents and actual doubling of youth trans identification in such a short time.
https://www.nytimes.com/2024/10/08/health/transgender-teenagers-cdc-survey.html
https://williamsinstitute.law.ucla.edu/publications/trans-adults-united-states/
https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/73/su/su7304a6.htm
https://benryan.substack.com/p/gender-dysphoria-surges-50-fold-in
This graph is particularly interesting, indicating exponential growth in trans identification in adulthood based on how recently someone was born. The numbers started to swoop up for those born in 1990 or later:
Another study, published in July, looked at the rates of adults who reported identifying as transgender between 2014 and 2022 in the nationally representative Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance Survey. It found that during that time trans identification:
▶️Nearly quintupled in 18-24 year olds
▶️Quadrupled in 25-34 year olds
▶️Stayed flat or declined in those age 35 and older
Also:
▶️By 2022, 2.8% of 18-24 year-old adults identified as trans, up from 0.6% in 2014.
▶️In contrast to the previous study I just mentioned, this one found that the increase was driven by those identifying as trans men or gender non-conforming; identifying as a trans woman did not change significantly among young adults and declined significantly among all adults.
▶️The increase in identifying as trans was larger among White individuals than among Black or Hispanic individuals.
https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s13178-024-01001-7
https://benryan.substack.com/p/gender-dysphoria-surges-50-fold-in
A study published in December 2023 analyzed such trends in a database concerning those with employer-based health insurance, only examining people age 18 and older and covering 2014 to 2021. It found that the overall rate per 100,000 of having a transgender-related diagnosis increased from 13.4 to 114 (0.1%) during that time—an 8.5-fold increase.
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38109739/
https://benryan.substack.com/p/gender-dysphoria-surges-50-fold-in
Let's take a look at various U.S. studies tracking the rise of gender dysphoria and transgender identification in both youth and adults in recent years. Recent studies regarding the U.S. population suggest that the surge in transgender identification and gender dysphoria diagnoses has been a phenomenon that is largely limited to adolescents and young adults. Some, but not all, analyses suggest that the growth has been especially strong among young natal females. https://benryan.substack.com/p/gender-dysphoria-surges-50-fold-in
She was saying that Republicans are hypocrites for saying they care about women when it comes to trans sports participation while they ban abortion and women bleed in parking lots.
“Trans girls are girls,” says @AOC, slamming a bill that passed the House that would restrict women and girls’ sports by sex and not gender identity. She called Republicans hypocritical for expressing concern about women while they support abortion bans.
Rep. Bob Onder, a Republican, says he supports the law. He inaccurately says that trans people are "dominating" many sports. This is an exaggeration. But he accurately says that transgender women maintain an advantage in women's sports in general.
The U.S. House is currently debating the ban on transgender students participating in sports, and entering locker rooms, according to their gender identity rather than their biological sex.
https://live.house.gov
The essay from the academic legal and public health experts essentially reiterates the arguments of the @ACLU and the Justice Department, saying that the Tennessee ban is sex-based discrimination and arguing that transgender people should be considered a quasi-suspect class such that discrimination against them should be subjected to heightened legal scrutiny.
They made something of an error citing the recent Trevor Project study on state laws restricting transgender rights being tied to suicide attempts in trans youths. That study primarily looked at sports bans and did not parse those from bans pertaining to gender-transition treatment. So it is a bit of a stretch to report that it found that the bans on the treatment were tied to suicide attempts.
The essay does not mention the systematic literature reviews in Scandinavia, but does discuss UK's Cass Review. Nevertheless, it refers to a "consensus among major medical organizations of the importance of the availability of gender-affirming care." This overlooks the fact that the American Society of Plastic Surgeons has not endorsed this treatment.
They authors state: "Labels such as high quality and low quality refer to research methodology, not the value of the data, with RCTs typically labeled high quality and observational research as low quality. But these labels can shift based on study specifications such as limitations, replicability, and magnitude of effects." This overlooks that the crucial question is whether studies can produce results that are likely to represent an accurate reflection of what can be expected in clinical practice. For higher quality studies, the connection between the results and real world practice is more clear and certain; for lower quality studies, these connections are hazier.
The essay criticizes various expert witnesses that testified when the Tennessee case was in the lower courts and notes that the one among them who has experience treating trans kids, Stephen Levine, stated that gender-transition treatment is "sometimes appropriate."
"But relying on testimony from such nonexperts," they write, referring to people such as @[private account], should not provide adequate justification, even under this more deferential form of judicial review. Those who emphasized the medical complexities of gender-affirming care during oral argument would do well to be skeptical of individuals with no medical knowledge or experience on the issue."
The criticism of nonexperts fails to note that one of the most prominent experts testifying against these bans, Yale's Meredith McNamara, has also never treated a transgender child. She testified in a sworn deposition in Alabama that she had only ever referred two children out to a gender clinic in her career as a pediatrician.
NYT reports: At “Meta’s offices in Silicon Valley, Texas and New York, facilities managers were instructed to remove tampons from men’s bathrooms, which the company had provided for nonbinary and transgender employees who use the men’s room and who may have required sanitary pads.”
For one story I did, I was providing very rare major national coverage of a group’s pet public health cause. Because they were all on the same listserv, they were able to coordinate to all refuse to talk to me—scores of them. Two of them broke ranks and talked to me off the record. One of them explained to me that even if any of them wanted to talk to me and didn’t have a problem with my trans reporting or didn’t think their qualms should override their desire to get press for their cause, if they went against the group, they’d be excommunicated from it. In other words, maintaining ideological purity in public takes priority in these dynamics. This is also known as groupthink.
I’ve been reporting a story for a major outlet about a group that’s desperate to draw attention to a particular cause in hopes that the Biden admin will attend to it by Jan 20. But all but one of the advocates refused to speak to me because of my trans reporting. They prioritized blacklisting me—and not being associated with me—over their cause. I question their priorities and who they think they’re helping vs hurting by giving me the silent treatment.
NEWS: A federal court ruled in the favor of the Tennessee attorney general and vacated the Biden administration's Title IX rule nationwide. The rule had sought to equate gender identity with sex when considering trans inclusion into women's sports in particular.
The fact that @GLAAD insists it is not acceptable to refer to the "gay community"—they claim people may only refer to the "LGBTQ community"—and yet the nonprofit does permit reference to the "trans community" suggests the organization sees a hierarchy within the LGBTQ acronym.
Quoting @benryanwriter: GLAAD does permit people to speak of the “trans community,” but not the “gay community,” which they say should never be made reference to. Only the “LGBTQ community” is permitted when speaking about groups of gays.