The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
The Biden administration apparently withdrew its proposed rule about trans kids’ participation in sports to make it harder for the Trump administration to rewrite it. Read about this development here:
Quoting @benryanwriter: LINK: Nondiscrimination on the Basis of Sex in Education Programs or Activities Receiving Federal Financial Assistance: Sex-Related Eligibility Criteria for Male and Female Athletic Teams; Withdrawal https://public-inspection.federalregister.gov/2024-30921.pdf
The first example she provides to support her claim refers to emails exchanged by people who are not journalists. And the second makes reference to a listserv of journalists that most certainly does not include anyone high fiving one another about how to wreck trans people.
I don’t have to tell you that when asked, the examples Katelyn Burns provides do not support her remarkably bold claim that there is a group-chat cabal of journalists cheering one another on in ruining transgender people.
Dollcast is actually seeking to stake a moderate position on trans issues. You should check it out.
Quoting @benryanwriter: "The Plot to Destroy Ben Ryan!"—My Conversation With @[private account] and the 'Dollcast' Gals
Brianna Wu, the ‘Gamergate’ survivor and Democratic operative brought me onto her podcast,@[private account], to have a wide-ranging conversation about my coverage of pediatric gender medicine; how difficult it is to thread the needle on this topic as a circumspect science reporter; and surviving the onslaught of anger and attacks over my work on social media.
In particular, Brianna asked me about what it was like when Media Matters @[private account]'s @AriDrennen dragged me on X this past spring with a wildly dishonest post about me; and what it is about my personality that permits me to withstand that level of scrutiny from her and activists such as Alejandra Caraballo. (Brianna said she wouldn't ask Caraballo on her show, as she's too argumentative and hostile, but that she would consider getting @RepNancyMace to come on.)
Also featured in the conversation are Taftaj, Schyler Bogert and Kelly Cadigan @[private account] @[private account] @[private account].
I was particularly glad to meet Kelly, because I had been quite shocked by a video she made that went viral this summer in which she said that all gay men would be better off transitioning. During our conversation, she explained what that video was about, and I saw how I had misjudged her.
You can also access this via my newsletter (link in bio) in both video and podcast form.
Apparently, if the Biden administration had left in place its incomplete rule about trans participation in sports under Title IX, that actually would’ve made it easier for the Trump admin to rewrite it. This way Trump has to start from scratch.
Quoting @benryanwriter: Department of Education Withdraws Proposed Rules On Single-Sex Sports Participation By Gender Identity
https://benryan.substack.com/p/department-of-education-withdraws
In April 2023, the Biden administration proposed rules that would have largely barred policies forbidding students from participating in single-sex sports according to gender identity rather than sex.
No, Michael Hobbes was not right about this one just because some of the families at Boston Children's had kids receiving counseling by the hospital's gender clinic for many years before they hit puberty. Most kids wind up in a clinic like that during adolescence, having only recently started identifying as trans and expressing their gender dysphoria.
Quoting @benryanwriter: I stand by my reporting that:
Michael Hobbes Is Wrong About Whether Kids Are Being Rushed Onto Gender-Transition Drugs
https://benryan.substack.com/p/michael-hobbes-is-wrong-about-whether
Is Amy Tishelman, one of the leaders in pediatric gender medicine, "anti-trans" because she is concerned that her former employer, Boston Children's, only provides minors a two-hour assessment to see if they should go on transition drugs? https://x.com/benryanwriter/status/1870151336001470524
Quoting @benryanwriter: A leader in transgender health explains her concerns about the field
Amy Tishelman, the former research director of @[private account]’s transgender clinic, spoke with the @BostonGlobe after winning a lawsuit against the hospital.
Dr. Tishelman said:
▶️Most minors coming into pediatric gender clinics today only first report gender dysphoria after the onset of puberty, in stark contrast to the typical patient of yesteryear that helped establish the Dutch model that prompted this global field. About two-thirds of these kids are natal girls, which is also a sharp departure from the past.
▶️The reasons for these demographic shifts remain unknown.
▶️These shifts may be a reflection of services being offered to kids who always needed them, and they're coming out of the woodwork. Or it could be that it's especially hard to be a teenage girl these days. Or social contagion might be at play. Or adopting a trans identity could be a coping mechanism after being sexually abused. "All of these hypotheses could be true, and they’re not necessarily mutually exclusive. But we don’t really know," Dr. Tishelman said.
▶️"Assessment should not be a way to talk trans people out of being trans," she said.
▶️"In terms of the idea that it’s controversial — people mistaking their transness for trauma, for example — the fact is that there are some small numbers, but growing numbers of people saying just that. I thought I was trans. I went on gender-affirming hormones. I had breast reduction surgeries. And it harmed me. I realized in the end it was all because I had another issue going on in my life and nobody asked me about these other things," she said.
"There are former patients who were seen with minimal evaluation who have now come forward across the country with lawsuits against their former providers. We’re being informed by patients themselves that they should have had more of an assessment."
▶️"Some people call it a readiness assessment. I’ve never been happy with that way of characterizing it. I feel like an assessment should encompass more than just, Should a person get medical intervention or shouldn’t they?" she said.
▶️A two-hour assessment, with one hour with the kid and one hour with the parents, is too short because there may be family conflict that goes unaddressed and unresolved.
▶️Tishelman is concerned about the weak state of the research in pediatric gender medicine. "Hindsight is 20/20, but it’s so unfortunate that clinics around the country sprung up without a priority on collecting data and conducting research," she said.
▶️Because of a lack of long-term follow-up in this field, we don't know how former pediatric patients are doing as adults.
▶️"I don’t want to restrict access to treatment or ban access to treatment. I’m talking about the processes to get to treatment. But I have been worried that the lack of caution that some people in our communities perceive, and the rushed way we may do assessments in this field, might feed these bans, or feed people’s fears," she said.
A leader in transgender health explains her concerns about the field
Amy Tishelman, the former research director of @[private account]’s transgender clinic, spoke with the @BostonGlobe after winning a lawsuit against the hospital.
Dr. Tishelman said:
▶️Most minors coming into pediatric gender clinics today only first report gender dysphoria after the onset of puberty, in stark contrast to the typical patient of yesteryear that helped establish the Dutch model that prompted this global field. About two-thirds of these kids are natal girls, which is also a sharp departure from the past.
▶️The reasons for these demographic shifts remain unknown.
▶️These shifts may be a reflection of services being offered to kids who always needed them, and they're coming out of the woodwork. Or it could be that it's especially hard to be a teenage girl these days. Or social contagion might be at play. Or adopting a trans identity could be a coping mechanism after being sexually abused. "All of these hypotheses could be true, and they’re not necessarily mutually exclusive. But we don’t really know," Dr. Tishelman said.
▶️"Assessment should not be a way to talk trans people out of being trans," she said.
▶️"In terms of the idea that it’s controversial — people mistaking their transness for trauma, for example — the fact is that there are some small numbers, but growing numbers of people saying just that. I thought I was trans. I went on gender-affirming hormones. I had breast reduction surgeries. And it harmed me. I realized in the end it was all because I had another issue going on in my life and nobody asked me about these other things," she said.
"There are former patients who were seen with minimal evaluation who have now come forward across the country with lawsuits against their former providers. We’re being informed by patients themselves that they should have had more of an assessment."
▶️"Some people call it a readiness assessment. I’ve never been happy with that way of characterizing it. I feel like an assessment should encompass more than just, Should a person get medical intervention or shouldn’t they?" she said.
▶️A two-hour assessment, with one hour with the kid and one hour with the parents, is too short because there may be family conflict that goes unaddressed and unresolved.
▶️Tishelman is concerned about the weak state of the research in pediatric gender medicine. "Hindsight is 20/20, but it’s so unfortunate that clinics around the country sprung up without a priority on collecting data and conducting research," she said.
▶️Because of a lack of long-term follow-up in this field, we don't know how former pediatric patients are doing as adults.
▶️"I don’t want to restrict access to treatment or ban access to treatment. I’m talking about the processes to get to treatment. But I have been worried that the lack of caution that some people in our communities perceive, and the rushed way we may do assessments in this field, might feed these bans, or feed people’s fears," she said.
The reflexive effort to label anyone seeking to discuss these nuanced positions as a "transphobe" shuts down debate and only foments a backlash. In some people, such attacks on their character, in fact, radicalizes them and makes them less supportive of various trans rights.
This is true. Gay marriage posed no imposition on anyone else's marriage. But trans rights can stand in conflict with women's rights when it comes to inclusion in single-sex spaces and women's sports leagues.
https://x.com/rwlesq/status/1870138609120301398
Quotes a post by T15100; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Sweepingly branding people as "anti-trans" vs "pro-trans" elides the fact that most Americans apparently hold nuanced views on transgender people and associated civil rights.
Is someone "anti-trans" if they support trans people's protection from discrimination in employment and housing and adults' access to and insurance coverage of gender-transition treatments and surgeries, but are concerned about minors receiving puberty blockers and cross-sex hormones without a thorough biopsychosocial assessment as advised by @[private account]?
Is someone "anti-trans" if they support the right for younger children to participate in single-sex sports leagues according to their gender identity, but not once they've hit puberty, or perhaps they support restrictions only in more competitive or elite sports settings?
Quotes a post by a private account; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I asked @JK_Rowling if she could rewrite her first tweet wading into the trans debate from five years ago, how she might change it. She said she wouldn’t change a thing:
Quoting @jk_rowling: Nothing. It's all there. I love gender non-conformity, I always have and always will. At the same time, sex is real, sex-based offending is real, and I'll always stand with the vulnerable against an elitist ideology that has caused untold damage.
Author @JK_Rowling marks five years since she started speaking out about the intersection of trans issues, feminism and single-sex spaces. I recommend checking out The Witch Trials of JK Rowling by @[private account] via @TheFP.
Quoting @jk_rowling: Five years ago today and my only regret is that I didn't speak out sooner. To every girl and woman who's paid a heavy price for fighting to retain their rights and boundaries, to every person striving to halt an appalling medical experiment on minors, I salute you. We will win.
I had an amazing time discussing transgender issues and pediatric medicine with the smart and savvy gals from Dollcast. Thanks to @[private account] for having me on.
I was especially glad to meet Kelly Cadigan. Brianna has a mission to build bridges and heal wounds. She helped me understand that Kelly's rather infamous video in which she gushed that all gay men should transition to become heterosexual women was meant as ironic performance art. I was quite upset by that video, so it was nice for me to work this out with Kelly and better understand where she's coming from. I told her I wished I'd had that context, because out of that context, the video came across as quite divisive and hurtful.
We also talked about what it's been like for me to be inundated with hate and dragged on social media, which has only become more topical since we taped this episode, given all the death threats that have surged on that other social media site of late. In particular, we discussed my being dragged by a tweet in May by Ari Drennen of Media Matters, in which she falsely led the public to believe I was some sort of deranged pervert fetishizing trans women and not the gay man that I have openly been for nearly 30 years.
Quotes a post by a private account; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
A study asked 295 British people aged 13–22 who identify as trans: “How has the COVID pandemic changed or affected your own understanding of your gender identity?”
The most common reply was: “time for identity development.”
https://www.eurekalert.org/news-releases/1068274
https://dx.doi.org/10.1111/bjdp.12536
“Many of the same people who embraced us while we were trans, who are quick to condemn homophobia, have turned their backs on us, calling us “transphobes” and “TERFs” (trans-exclusionary radical feminist), sending threats, and comparing us to Nazis both online and in the street. It’s no wonder so few of us speak up.”
NEWS: A lawsuit to block the Affordable Care Act's Section 1557 from barring health care discrimination against gay and trans people has failed.
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the 5th Circuit has vacated a lower court's decision favoring the plaintiffs who sought to block this rule from applying to gay and trans people, finding that they did not have standing to sue.
The lower court's decision had found that Section 1557 did not bar health care discrimination based on sexual orientation or gender identity; it found that 1557 should only bar discrimination against people's biological sex and not take into account their gender identity, if that is different from their biological sex.
I was just in a long thread with a bunch of sex researchers about this question today. It's complicated. It sounds like for some youth with gender dysphoria, yes, puberty does see their GD resolve. But was this because of the mere passage of time? The flush of sexual feelings that lead someone to conclude they're gay and not trans? Realizing that puberty wasn't the scary thing they thought it was? It's all very complicated and hard to tease out. One thing that has become clear to me this week is that this claim that we know that if kids with GD persist into the onset of puberty, their GD is unlikely resolve--that has never been supported by much research. And yet it's become the party line.
"It selectively cites three European reviews critical of gender-affirming care, while ignoring the consensus of leading medical organizations—including the American Academy of Pediatrics, the American Psychological Association, the American Medical Association, the Endocrine Society, and the World Professional Association for Transgender Health—all of which support such care."
▶️While WaPo hyperlinks to three European reviews, there have, in fact, been a half-dozen systematic literature reviews of pediatric gender-transition treatment. All of them have found the evidence backing such interventions weak and inconclusive.
▶️This has lead the health authorities in the UK and four Scandinavian nations to reclassify such treatment as experimental, and to sharply restrict access, in some cases to research settings only.
▶️The Cass Review found that WPATH and the US medical societies that endorse such interventions have engaged in "circularity," which is a more polite term for "citation laundering." WPATH made claims that were not supported by strong evidence in its 2013 Standards of Care 7. Then other US medical societies referred to those claims. And then it its SoC 8 in 2022, WPATH referred to those other societies, not mentioning that the claim they were referring to originated with WPATH. The near unanimity in these organizations is in part a product of the same people cross-pollinating their ideas from one organization to the next.
Activist-blogger Erin Reed has published a guest article:
"Washington Post Editorial Board Misleadingly Attacks Care Of Trans Youth"
In, fact, many of the claims in this essay challenging WaPo are themselves misleading.
I will go through them in this 🧵⬇️
Texas transgender care whistleblower's lawyers believe unsealed court docs prove DOJ never had a case
Dr. @[private account] has been the subject of an ongoing criminal case brought by the DOJ. The case will go to trial in mid-February. Unsealed court documents indicate the DOJ was in possession of information that disproved the HIPAA violations from the start, according to lawyers on the case and court documents reviewed by @FoxNews Digital.
Notice how almost all the growth in the referrals of gender dysphoric kids to Children’s Hospital Los Angeles has been in natal girls. What is the reason for this common surge over the past decade, as seen across the Western world?
Researchers in this field often attribute this surge to a reduction in stigma toward trans identity, but continuing stigma toward effeminacy in natal males. These researchers are often keen to dismiss social contagion as a factor.
And yet even in adults, there is no surge in trans identification in natal males. And effeminacy in males is often celebrated in pop culture, dating back to Boy George and David Bowie and continuing with Drag Race and Queer Eye.
There is no signs of natal males catching up to natal females in trans identity later in life. All the surge is in children, adolescent and young adult natal females.
What do you think?
Quoting @benryanwriter: This is a screenshot from a training webinar that the subject of the detransitioner lawsuit against Children's Hospital Los Angeles, Johanna Olson-Kennedy, gave earlier this year. This is the number of referrals to their youth gender clinic per year. As you can see, the clinic only got going with substantial numbers of children about TEN years ago, not 30.
You can also see from the screenshot above that almost all the growth in the patient population over the past 10 years has come from natal girls.
What is the reason for this recent surge in trans identification in natal girls?
There is only one peer reviewed study that assessed whether pediatric gender-transition treatment was associated with a difference in the suicide death rate in youth. It found there was no such association. https://nypost.com/2024/02/24/opinion/a-finnish-study-is-changing-how-we-approach-trans-kids/
Why do the trans activists brutalize reporters like Jesse Singal?
Quoting @benryanwriter: Most importantly, the purpose of their ceaseless campaign of intimidation and calumny is to scare away other reporters. They also seek to make editors too afraid to publish any work that challenges the @GLAAD-approved party line on pediatric gender medicine. These activists are the same people who disparage me for publishing my work on this subject in a small conservative publication, The New York Sun. But they know very well that they themselves fostered the poisonous climate across liberal media that has made editors in left-leaning publications too afraid to publish my work. https://benryan.substack.com/p/it-is-wrong-to-call-for-the-murder
A must read by @[private account]:
Oregon officials, experts grappled behind the scenes with youth gender-affirming care guideline
Records show how state medical advisors decided questions around youth transgender care were outweighed by a state law ensuring access.
People such as trans activists Alejandra Caraballo and Mallory Moore may have succeeded brilliantly at scaring away other journalists with these tactics. But they have not scared me away from covering pediatric gender medicine. And they will not. I will continue to report about this important and vital subject. https://benryan.substack.com/p/it-is-wrong-to-call-for-the-murder
Alejandra Caraballo has also repeatedly claimed that I am a “chaser,” which is a colloquial term that refers to a man who has a sexual fetish for transgender women. I have been an openly gay man since I was 17 years old and have no interest in women or trans women. The fact that I have been compelled to say this in public to defend myself, 29 years after coming out of the closet, dismays me to say the least. https://benryan.substack.com/p/it-is-wrong-to-call-for-the-murder
🧵When I first began looking into reporting about pediatric gender medicine myself, an editor with whom I was discussing possibly publishing an article cautioned me about doing so. “They will make your life miserable,” this editor said, referring to trans activists. I said I was well aware, but that I had decided this was important to me. There is a void in the slice of journalism that concerns itself with covering pediatric medicine with circumspection, with only a handful of brave reporters working in this space. I told the editor wanted to join them. And I have. v
🧵Since Mr. Singal joined Bluesky last week, transgender activists and their allies have responded with such brutal and deranged hostility that some of them have actually taken to calling for his death. This shameful discourse should alarm anyone who believes in a liberal society that still benefits from the free press that the MAGA movement has worked so hard to denigrate and squelch. That such violent rhetoric should come from the left is a prime example of the horseshoe theory of politics, in which extremists on opposite ends of the political spectrum come to resemble one another, such as in their endorsement of elements of totalitarianism or in excusing, championing or fomenting politically motivated violence. https://benryan.substack.com/p/it-is-wrong-to-call-for-the-murder
NBC covers the lawsuit against Johanna Olson-Kennedy:
https://www.nbcnews.com/nbc-out/out-news/ucla-student-sues-california-doctors-says-was-fast-tracked-transgender-rcna183815
British trans activist Mallory Moore also suggested that I should be murdered:
Quoting @benryanwriter: British trans activist Mallory Moore quite clearly calls for people to murder me in this post.
Please search for it on the other site and report it.
This is profoundly antisocial behavior.
I was the one who exposed her for being centrally responsible for much of the misinformation about the Cass Review after its publication.
More on the battle between @[private account] and The Young Turks:
@EmmaVigeland: “The final IM of the day, Billy: ‘TYT [@[private account]] is no better than the right they went after the most vulnerable, first, trans people like myself. I can't even count how much money I donated to that place, only to be betrayed. And the unhoused were easy targets. So they started with us punching down and expecting people to cheer them on for it. Trans viewers left on mass, and we were ignored. I'm glad everyone is finally catching up and ditching them.’ That's another thing, is that they raised millions from an audience as constant fundraising like Democrats.’
@[private account]: “Constant fundraising.”
Vigeland: “Yes. So unethical. Very unethical. All right, guys with that said, you know, when Sam's [@SamSeder] away, we're supposed to be chill. Yeah, well, I don't know if that's possible.”
Here is what I’ve learned from articles like this and @ezraklein’s podcast: Democrats have often outsourced their operations to nonprofits that are beholden to small groups of wealthy donors and are unaccountable to voters. Their priorities are much farther to the left than the typical Dem and thus alienate people. eg: @GLAAD and their rigid stance on trans issues, such as the outright refusal to permit any dialogue about the science behind gender transition drugs for children, and the bullying and intimidation of journalists who report about this subject.
Quoting @jonathanchait: Rogé Karma has written the definitive piece on how Democrats made a generational error on immigration policy and the Latino vote https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2024/12/democrats-latino-vote-immigration/680945/
Senator Ed Markey, Democrat of Massachusetts, pledges to fight for trans kids in the face of Republican efforts to cut off coverage of medical transitions for minor children of military families.
Quotes a post by T07584; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Puberty blockers permanently banned in Northern Ireland to block supply loophole
Trans activists had planned to use province as ‘gateway’ to supply drugs to the rest of UK
The Trump campaign and other Republican groups spent an estimated $215 million lambasting Kamala Harris and the Democrats for their support for medical interventions for transgender people.
Quoting @kenklippenstein: It’s cool that we just had a presidential election where healthcare basically never came up
Hobbes says there is "not a single confirmed case" of a child being rushed onto transition drugs. And yet the article he is citing points to two: "Two of the parents echoed Tishelman’s concerns. One father, who brought his transgender son to the clinic in 2021, said the assessment struck him as a 'rubber-stamping process.'" https://www.bostonglobe.com/2024/12/03/metro/transgender-medicine-boston-childrens-families-gems/
Caraballo has suggested this many times. @AriDrennen got a viral tweet going in the spring based on the false suggestion that I am a deranged pervert obsessed with these trans women sexually. It is ridiculous to have to make clear to people that I have been openly gay since 1996.
Same with this investigation about the AAP:
https://www.nysun.com/article/the-aap-files-inside-feud-within-american-academy-of-pediatrics-torn-over-transgender-issues-about-groups-decision-to-hold-meeting-in-anti-lgbtq-florida-of-ron-desantis?member_gift=CUZ5qwd3crq4pmz-xrd
As for writing for outlets “no one has ever heard of,” per Alejandra Caraballo:
Washington Post
https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2024/05/03/transgender-puberty-blockers-science-cass-report/
Only one study has ever directly assessed whether gender transition treatment is tied to a difference in the suicide death rate in young people: this one out of Finland; they found it wasn’t. All the other studies rely on surrogate markers—suicidality. https://nypost.com/2024/02/24/opinion/a-finnish-study-is-changing-how-we-approach-trans-kids/
Brianna Wu is a big advocate of safeguarding around cross-sex hormone prescriptions, which she feels is for everyone’s own good, including the integrity—and, ultimately, legality—of trans medicine.
Quotes a post by a private account; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
WPATH leaders’ emails subpoenaed by the Alabama attorney general revealed that they added the “medically” necessary label at numerous points throughout their trans-career guidelines to help them secure insurance coverage and win lawsuits, absent scientific justification.
Quoting @CaitlinPacific: Important:
“Medically necessary” is a term of art having to do with health insurance. It doesn’t mean “or else the patient will die.”
It means that the billed treatment fits into parameters of established forms of care for the condition.
A Culture-War Battle Convulses a School Panel in Liberal Manhattan
@[private account], a right-wing activist, introduced a resolution about transgender students’ participation in sports. The fallout has derailed a parent council in one of Manhattan’s largest school districts.
UCSF Child psychiatrist Jack Turban weighs in on U.S. v Skrmetti:
The Supreme Court Asks Who Should Decide about Medical Interventions
Neither judges nor state lawmakers are in a good position to analyze complex medical literature
Jack Turban MD
The U.S. Supreme Court held oral arguments yesterday in U.S. v. Skrmetti, a case examining whether Tennessee’s ban on medical treatments for transgender youth discriminates based on sex.
As a physician, one major theme jumped out at me from oral arguments. Several of the justices seemed to imply that, because medical science is complicated, they shouldn’t be the ones deciding if a law related to medicine discriminates. They seemed to say that they should throw up their hands and leave it to state legislators to decide.
As Justice Jackson highlighted, this is a scary prospect. The reason the Equal Protection Clause exists is to prevent states from attacking politically vulnerable people, like transgender people, from being targeted by majority groups. Given the surge of anti-transgender legislation in recent years, it’s hard to imagine that Equal Protection legal analysis isn’t absolutely essential here. It has long been the role of the courts to protect vulnerable groups from state legislatures.
But I do sympathize with the justices to a degree. The reality is that neither the court nor state legislatures are in a good position to make decisions about complicated medical issues. The analysis of a body of medical research quickly becomes complex. It can involve sorting through hundreds of research studies, and it can be difficult even for doctors outside that particular area of expertise to unpack.
Given the complexity of medical literature, it’s also easy for people to mislead. For example, during the Skrmetti oral arguments, the ACLU’s Chase Strangio had to explain to the court that Tennessee’s assertion that 85% of young people identifying as trans will later change their mind about being trans wasn’t relevant to this case. The figure was from a study of prepubertal children who can’t access gender-affirming medical interventions under current guidelines. Studies of adolescents who have accessed treatment under medical guidelines (which require kids to be older) have found regret rates more on the order of a few percent. And as some of the liberal justices pointed out, all areas of medicine have a risk of regret (something a lay person could easily miss when discussing topics like this). Regret risk isn’t something unique to gender-affirming care.
The people in the best position to make decisions about medical care for children are teams of medical professionals, the adolescent, and their guardians. Current guidelines for gender-affirming medical care for transgender adolescents emphasize the need for involvement of a physician specializing in hormone prescribing, a mental health professional, the adolescent, and the adolescent’s legal guardians. This is the team that should be making medical decisions – these people know the adolescent best and can weigh the risks and benefits of a particular treatment for that particular child. State lawmakers and judges, who have never met that child and have rudimentary knowledge of this area of medicine, are perhaps among the worst situated to make that decision.
That isn’t to say that doctors shouldn’t be regulated at all. But there are already guardrails in place to ensure that doctors act appropriately and in line with medical consensus and evidence. Medical malpractice laws exist for this very reason, and medical boards routinely regulate the practice of medical professionals. Tennessee’s law was unnecessary, and it simply made it so that appropriate medical care could no longer be prescribed in the instances where it’s appropriate and likely to help. One of the plaintiffs in the case, for example, had regular vomiting and considered being mute due to his gender dysphoria. Lawmakers who never met him and didn’t understand the nuances of his medical care should not have taken away his treatment.
Now that Tennessee has acted in the way that it did, I acknowledge that the justices are in a tough situation here. Once they rule whether the law discriminates based on sex (it seems clear it does, since it allows some medications like estrogen for one sex, but not the other), they are faced with going through a large body of medical evidence to determine if the state had a valid justification for passing its law (laws that discriminate based on sex must withstand something called “intermediate scrutiny” to be allowed to stand).
Plaintiffs in the case have on their side the fact that all major medical organizations oppose bans like Tennessee’s. Tennessee on its side has misleading claims that European nations have banned care like they did (none actually have) and sketchy reports from political scientists at right-wing think tanks. I have to say that once they start digging through the evidence, the answer may actually become clearer than they think. But given the right-wing investment in attacking medical expertise and generating reports to question mainstream science through their think tanks, it will be a lot of work to sort through it all.
The best-case scenario here is for the Supreme Court to shut down this law and put medical decision-making back where it belongs: with parents, their children, and their medical professionals (regulated by existing malpractice laws and medical boards). But only time will tell how they decide to wade into the complex arena of medical science.
Jack Turban MD is a pediatric psychiatrist and author of the book Free to Be: Understanding Kids & Gender Identity. His writing has appeared in The New York Times, The Washington Post, The Los Angeles Times, CNN, and Scientific American, among others.
Former USPATH head Erica Anderson told the San Francisco Chronicle:
https://www.sfchronicle.com/politics/article/lawsuit-transgender-health-care-19964425.php
Dr. Johanna Olson-Kennedy told ABC in 2011 of children with gender dysphoria: “These kids have a suicide rate that is astronomical compared to any other group.”
https://benryan.substack.com/p/detransitioner-sues-johanna-olson
Two recent studies, one in England and the other in Finland, recently found that the suicide rate among gender-distressed minors is elevated compared with their age-matched peers; and yet suicide deaths among them are nevertheless rare.
In Wednesday’s oral arguments at the U.S. Supreme Court over Tennessee’s ban on pediatric gender-transition treatment, ACLU litigator Chase Strangio, a trans man, said that “completed suicide is thankfully and admittedly rare” among children who identify as transgender.
What’s more, the Finnish study, which I covered for The New York Post and which no one during the Supreme Court’s oral arguments seemed to be aware of, is the only study to date to assess whether there is independent, statistically significant association between receiving gender-transition treatment and a difference in the suicide death rate among young people. The study authors found there was not.
This is the only study that ever sought to directly assess whether gender transition treatment is tied to a difference in young people’s suicide death rate. I was the only reporter to cover it for a major outlet:
https://nypost.com/2024/02/24/opinion/a-finnish-study-is-changing-how-we-approach-trans-kids/
In 2021, Dr. Joanna Olson-Kennedy told a trans-health FB group that she and a group of others worked hard to try to dissuade 60 Minutes from running a segment on detransitioners. Now she has been sued by one, accused of medical negligence.
Pain, confusion and compassion: How the US has reached a trans ‘tipping point’
https://nypost.com/2024/10/19/us-news/pain-confusion-compassion-how-the-us-has-reached-a-trans-tipping-point/
The AAP Files: Inside Feud Within American Academy of Pediatrics, Torn Over Transgender Issues, About Group’s Decision To Hold Meeting in ‘Anti-LGBTQ’ Florida of Ron DeSantis
https://www.nysun.com/article/the-aap-files-inside-feud-within-american-academy-of-pediatrics-torn-over-transgender-issues-about-groups-decision-to-hold-meeting-in-anti-lgbtq-florida-of-ron-desantis?member_gift=CUZ5qwd3crq4pmz-xrd
Cass Review Author Denounces As 'Baseless' And 'Cynical' Dissidents' Claim That She Touted Abigail Shrier's Scathing Polemic On Trans Kids
https://benryan.substack.com/p/cass-review-author-denounces-as-baseless
New Evidence Challenges Institutionalized Belief That Transgender Teens Become Transgender Adults, Undermining Core Defense of Medical Gender Transitions for Minors
https://www.nysun.com/article/new-evidence-challenges-institutionalized-belief-that-transgender-teens-become-transgender-adults-undermining-core-defense-of-medical-gender-transitions-for-minors?member_gift=CUZ5qwd3crq4pmz-xrd
Psychiatrists learned the wrong lesson from the gay rights movement
Advocates for puberty blockers don’t have science on their side.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2024/05/03/transgender-puberty-blockers-science-cass-report/
‘Damning’ Information About Trans Medical Group Expected To Reach Supreme Court, as Justices Consider Challenge to Ban on Gender Treatments for Minors
https://www.nysun.com/article/damning-information-about-trans-medical-group-expected-to-reach-supreme-court-as-justices-consider-challenge-to-ban-on-gender-treatments-for-minors?lctg=0&recognized_email=editors-group%40nysun.com&newsletter-access&utm_source=MG&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=Morning%20Sun%20%202024-07-10
A landmark Finnish study is changing how we approach transgender kids
https://nypost.com/2024/02/24/opinion/a-finnish-study-is-changing-how-we-approach-trans-kids/
The WPATH Files: Report Derides Influential Trans-Medicine Group As ‘Unethical’
https://benryan.substack.com/p/the-wpath-files-report-slams-influential
Leaked Files From Influential Transgender Medicine Group Cause Uproar, Could Imperil Liberal Efforts To Undo State Bans on Gender-Transition Treatments for Children
https://www.nysun.com/article/leaked-files-from-influential-transgender-medicine-group-cause-uproar-could-imperil-liberal-efforts-to-undo-state-bans-on-gender-transition-treatments-for-children?lctg=1430021928&recognized_email=editors-group%40nysun.com&newsletter-access&utm_source=MG&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=Morning%20Sun%20%202024-03-12
Beleaguered World Health Organization Wades Into Transgender Debate and Is Met With Uproar Over Plans To Develop Guidelines on Trans Healthcare
https://www.nysun.com/article/beleaguered-world-health-organization-wades-into-transgender-debate-and-is-met-with-uproar-over-plans-to-develop-guidelines-on-trans-healthcare?lctg=$%7BRecipient.RecipientId%7D&recognized_email=$%7BRecipient.EmailAddress?url%7D&newsletter-access&utm_source=MG&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=Evening%2520Sun%2520%2520$%7B.now?date?string.iso%7D
Sued Over Policies on Transgender Children, American Academy of Pediatrics Pulls Forthcoming Book, Takes Steps To Protect Emails From Prying Eyes
https://www.nysun.com/article/sued-over-policies-on-transgender-children-american-academy-of-pediatrics-pulls-forthcoming-book-takes-steps-to-protect-emails-from-prying-eyes
Named in Clementine Breen's medical-negligence lawsuit over her adolescent gender-transition treatment are: Susan P. Landon, a psychotherapist (left photo, center); Dr. Johanna Olson-Kennedy, a gender doc (left photo, right); and Dr. Scott Mosser, a gender-affirmation surgeon (right photo). Featured on the left in the left photo is Aydin Olson-Kennedy, who is a trans man, a psychotherapist in the pediatric gender field, and is Johanna's husband.
All four are members of @[private account]. To read the full story, see:
Quoting @benryanwriter: LINK: Detransitioner Sues Johanna Olson-Kennedy, a Top Pediatric Gender Medicine Doctor, For Medical Negligence
https://benryan.substack.com/p/detransitioner-sues-johanna-olson
Dr. Olson-Kennedy, a leading @[private account] member is the most prominent doctor yet to be sued by a detransitioner.
Clementine Breen, who is suing top pediatric gender doctor Johanna Olson-Kennedy for medical negligence after she oversaw her adolescent gender-transition treatment and "top" surgery, has sought to "go out and get" breast reconstruction. She told @BillboardChris that she has had more difficulty securing that surgery than she did obtaining the double mastectomy that Dr. Olson-Kennedy urged her to get at age 14.
It was performed by Dr. Scott Mosser, who never met Ms. Breen until the day of the operation. She is suing him as well.
Both doctors are leading members of @[private account], the controversial quasi-activist-medical organization that advocates for trans care.
Quoting @benryanwriter: 🧵 Dr. Olson-Kennedy is perhaps most well known to pediatric gender medicine outsiders because of an undercover video taken in 2018 of a lecture she gave to mental health providers instructing them on how to write letters to help minors obtain insurance coverage for gender-transition interventions. During the lecture, she expressed evident exasperation with prevailing concerns that gender dysphoric minors who have a double mastectomy might later regret the operation.
https://benryan.substack.com/p/detransitioner-sues-johanna-olson
“What we do know is that adolescents actually have the capacity to make a reasoned, logical decision,” she said. “And here’s the other thing about chest surgery: If you want breasts at a later point in your life, you can go and get them.”
Ms. Breen, Dr. Olson-Kennedy’s former patient who is suing her, has tried to go out and get breast reconstruction. But she told @BillboardChris that she has had a much harder time securing the surgery for that than she did when it came to her original mastectomy.
I knew the Olson-Kennedy suit was coming down the pike when I wrote this. So it informed my reporting even though I was not allowed to speak publicly about the suit until today. https://nypost.com/2024/10/19/us-news/pain-confusion-compassion-how-the-us-has-reached-a-trans-tipping-point/
🧵 Dr. Olson-Kennedy also has a history of doubting the value of the biopsychosocial assessments that WPATH recommends for minors before they receive gender-transition treatment or surgeries. She shares this in common with @[private account] child psychiatrist Jack Turban, who suggested in his recent book that the assessments were worthless and should be done away with.
There is, for example, a 2019 podcast interview that Dr. Olson-Kennedy gave to members of the controversial gender clinic Gender GP, which has provided gender-transition treatment to British minors via telemedicine from abroad. Marianne Oakes, the organization’s lead counselor, said in reference to guardrails around gender-transition treatment: “I feel the system is geared up to protect c-s people from making a mistake rather than actually caring for the trans people.”
https://benryan.substack.com/p/detransitioner-sues-johanna-olson
To which Dr. Olson-Kennedy replied: “A hundred percent, absolutely.” She continued: “I always say what is there in that concern?…What does it mean to make a mistake? What does that mean? So we’re gong to accidentally make someone trans?” She attributed such concern about the potential harms of pediatric gender-transition treatment to what she called “c-s fragility.” And she said that these worries are what “drives people to create huge and unmanageable and often inaccessible assessment periods” for minors seeking gender-transition treatment.
Dr. Olson-Kennedy continued: “It never takes into account autonomy of humans—that let’s talk about what it would mean if we just let people move forward and we affirm and believe what they were telling us, right? At the end of the day, who is responsible for that? The person that made that decision.”
In Ms. Breen’s case, her lawsuit against Dr. Olson-Kennedy and her colleagues disagrees. It asserts that those adults were responsible for what became of Ms. Breen’s childhood and seeks to hold them accountable.
🧵 Dr. Olson-Kennedy told ABC in 2011 of children with gender dysphoria: “These kids have a suicide rate that is astronomical compared to any other group.”
https://benryan.substack.com/p/detransitioner-sues-johanna-olson
Two recent studies, one in England and the other in Finland, recently found that the suicide rate among gender-distressed minors is elevated compared with their age-matched peers; and yet suicide deaths among them are nevertheless rare.
In Wednesday’s oral arguments at the U.S. Supreme Court over Tennessee’s ban on pediatric gender-transition treatment, ACLU litigator Chase Strangio, a trans man, said that “completed suicide is thankfully and admittedly rare” among children who identify as transgender.
What’s more, the Finnish study, which I covered for The New York Post and which no one during the Supreme Court’s oral arguments seemed to be aware of, is the only study to date to assess whether there is independent, statistically significant association between receiving gender-transition treatment and a difference in the suicide death rate among young people. The study authors found there was not.
🧵 In a video of a 2015 lecture Dr. Olson-Kennedy gave, she said:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pO8v--tztSg
“Surgery, chest surgery for trans guys as minors, is critical. And it’s available! It’s not nearly as difficult as genital reconstruction, because it doesn’t have anything to do with sterilization. The difficulty of genital surgery is that it is surgical sterilization and people get super worked up about that. And that is the barrier that we have to overcome. And I think we’re going to. But chest surgery is not that.”
https://benryan.substack.com/p/detransitioner-sues-johanna-olson
🧵 Dr. Olson-Kennedy is the leading investigator on a multifaceted, long-running $10 million National Institutes of Health study of the care and treatment of youth who identify as transgender.
https://benryan.substack.com/p/detransitioner-sues-johanna-olson
As @JesseSingal reported in The Atlantic in 2018, a 2017 paper indicated that the youngest patients receiving cross-sex hormones at Dr. Olson-Kennedy’s clinic during the years prior were 12 years old.
Also in 2017, Dr. Olson-Kennedy sought and received approval for her NIH-funded research to reduce the minimum age for prescribing cross-sex hormones to children from 13 to eight years old.
The red is when I posted saying that it's polite to use trans people's preferred pronouns and that "c-s" is not a slur, but is a necessary qualifier when discussing trans people to differentiate them from others. And no, just "woman" is not clear enough.
Oops, I did it again!
A little hard to say where she’ll fall. But it’s very doubtful she would ever seek to make transgender identity a quasi-suspect class. But she could surprise us and rule with Gorsuch and the liberals that this was sex discrimination. Otherwise it’ll be her and maybe him with the other 4 conservatives for upholding the 6th circuit.
Elon weighed in an hour before Chase Strangio at the ACLU was set to be the first openly transgender person to present oral argument before the Supreme Court:
LINK: Supreme Court Appears Likely To Uphold State Law Banning Gender Treatments for Minors: Ruling Would Deal a Major Blow to Transgender Activists
https://www.nysun.com/article/supreme-court-appears-likely-to-uphold-state-law-banning-gender-treatments-for-minors-ruling-would-deal-a-major-blow-to-transgender-activists?member_gift=CUZ5qwd3crq4pmz-xrd
Supreme Court Appears Likely To Uphold State Law Banning Gender Treatments for Minors: Ruling Would Deal a Major Blow to Transgender Activists
🧵⬇️I report for the @[private account]: During oral arguments held Wednesday, Chief Justice Roberts expressed wariness about the judicial, rather than legislative, branch solving disputes over medical regulation.
Transgender, gender-diverse preteens less physically active than peers
https://www.eurekalert.org/news-releases/1066582
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.annepidem.2024.11.004
Transgender 11- and 12-year-olds take 1,394 fewer steps per day
Toronto, ON – Transgender and gender-diverse preteens are about 15% less physically active than their cisgender peers, new research finds.
Transgender 11-12 year-olds take, on average, 1,394 fewer steps per day compared to cisgender adolescents, a difference that equates to about 12% of the daily physical activity recommended for adolescents. The study was published in Annals of Epidemiology.
“Transgender adolescents may experience stigma and discrimination that discourage their participation in team sports or physical activity,” explains first author, Jason M. Nagata, MD, an associate professor of pediatrics at the University of California, San Francisco. “Physical activity may instead be replaced by more time spent online, where they might find more accepting and supportive environments.”
Researchers assessed gender identity beyond transgender or cisgender. They asked the preteens how much they felt their gender identity aligned with their assigned sex, as well as the degree of satisfaction they felt with their assigned sex.
“Binary measures of gender don’t capture the complex and evolving understanding of gender that these young teens experience,” says co-author Kyle T. Ganson, PhD, assistant professor at the University of Toronto’s Factor-Inwentash Faculty of Social Work. “Our study highlights the importance of considering nuanced gender identities when addressing physical activity disparities in young people.”
Researchers used data from 6,038 preteens in the nationwide Adolescent Brain Cognitive Development (ABCD) study, the largest long-term study of brain development in the United States. The children answered various questions assessing their gender identity, felt gender, gender non-contentedness, and expression of gender norms, while wearing a Fitbit device that tracked their daily steps.
“Given the lifetime benefits of physical activity, a concerted effort should be made to promote physical activity, exercise, and participation in sports among transgender and gender-diverse adolescents,” Nagata said.
How An Inability to Clearly Define ‘Sex’ vs. ‘Gender’ Has Left Democrats In a Mess
Language matters. By insisting there’s no difference between 'sex' and 'gender' and that sex is “assigned at birth,” progressives have alienated many people from the transgender cause.
https://benryan.substack.com/p/how-an-inability-to-clearly-define
Avatars of Dem Alienation: Liberal Parents Wary About Their Kids’ Trans Identities
Almost all the distressed parents who tell me they think their kids’ trans identities are not authentic are liberals who find themselves drifting away from the Democratic party.
https://benryan.substack.com/p/avatars-of-dem-alienation-liberal
I routinely receive messages from parents whose adolescent children have begun identifying as trans. They speak as if they have lost their children to a cult. Sometimes, in the cases of divorce, the child's trans identification further drives a wedge between them and their ex.
What else could a word like that imply but that the assigning of sex is external and potentially arbitrary? If they didn’t mean that, they would use some other term, such as the obvious one: sex. eg: “The trans woman’s sex is male but her gender is female, so she takes estrogen to reconcile this.” Just because everyone in medical literature adopts this term does not mean any of them are using their head about it.
Alberta has passed its legislation restricting gender-transition treatment for youths and other trans-related policies. https://globalnews.ca/news/10900427/alberta-transgender-bills/
I met someone today in DC who said they voted for Trump because they did not approve of the Democratic party’s stance on transgender kids. This person said they were voting against Harris rather than for Trump.
It is also about whether transgender kids in particular and trans people in gender can be considered a protected class under the Equal Protection Clause. This is a very long-shot claim by the ACLU and the Justice Department. The court does not like to add new protected classes.
As usual, Alejandra Caraballo cannot say anything about me without uttering falsehoods, including by calling me an "anti-trans activist," or otherwise stretching the truth.
Nothing in my reporting about Amy Tishelman's civil trial against Boston Children's Hospital and the revelations about their pediatric gender clinic, GeMS, is contradicted by this new article from @BostonGlobe reporter Mike Damiano, who reported the exact same things I did about the trial a day after my article came out.
As Mr. Damiano reported, Dr. Tishelman "is not primarily concerned, she said in an interview, about families who have been known to GeMS for years and whose children have expressed a transgender identity since childhood. Her greater concern, she said, is about patients who first reach GeMS as adolescents and who, in some cases, have 'significant psychiatric challenges or neurodevelopmental disabilities,' such as autism. Those types of cases have become more prevalent since GeMS was founded in 2007, she said, and may require a longer psychological assessment before it is prudent to recommend medical interventions."
The bulk of Mr. Damiano's interviews appeared to be with families whose kids expressed gender dysphoria prior, or long prior, to puberty and thus were in the GeMS system for years before they had to decide about puberty blockers.
But these days, the typical gender dysphoric minor presenting at a pediatric gender clinic is a natal girl who only started identifying as trans and expressing gender incongruence after the onset of puberty. That is the type of child Dr. Tishelman is clearly concerned about. And it is the type of patient that most skeptics of pediatric gender medicine are especially concerned about.
Nowhere in Mr. Damiano's article does he contradict that the psychologist's assessment for putting a child on blockers or hormones is any longer than a single two-hour appointment. Three different GeMS staffers testified under oath that it was.
What he largely describes are children who are in the GeMS system for years before they even hit the point where they would need to be assessed for puberty blockers. He does not go into too much detail about kids who come to the clinic for the first time at age 13 to 16.
He does write, however: "Two parents said in interviews they shared Tishelman’s concerns. One of them, the father who brought his 14-year-old to GeMS in 2021, about a year after the teen came out as a transgender boy, said he supported his son’s identity. But he said that, in his view, GeMS clinicians did not sufficiently explore his son’s previous mental health struggles, including an anxiety diagnosis. The process felt like 'a conveyor belt' toward medical intervention, he said. His son is no longer a patient at the clinic."
Trans activist Julia Serano writes:
Planned Action for LGBTQ+ & Allies in Response to Democrats Capitulating on Trans Rights
As most of you are aware, since Kamala Harris’s election loss (which trans people were not in charge of nor responsible for), Democratic politicians and pundits have been signaling that they plan to throw trans people under the bus. Sadly, this came to fruition last week, when Republican congressperson Nancy Mace pressed house speaker Mike Johnson to declare: “All single-sex facilities in the Capitol and House Office Buildings—such as restrooms, changing rooms, and locker rooms—are reserved for individuals of that biological sex.”
Despite the fact that there is no evidence that trans people pose any threat in sex-segregated spaces, only a handful of Democrats spoke out against this policy change. Even worse, many lauded incoming trans congresswoman Sarah McBride for agreeing to comply with it.
As if that wasn’t bad enough, Mace (who is now selling merch as part of her anti-trans crusade) has proposed a Federal Trans Bathroom Ban that would impact Washington DC airports, museums, and federal buildings across the U.S., impacting trans workers and visitors alike. And it’s clear that Republicans will not stop there.
In “red states” where Republicans have a trifecta (governor plus both state legislatures), they have passed all sorts of anti-LGBTQ+ legislation. A quick glance at that legislation confirms that this is not about any isolated issue: Republican lawmakers who rail against trans athletes or gender-affirming care for trans youth are also pushing bans on trans healthcare for adults, “don’t say gay” bills that impact all LGBTQ+ students, drag bans written so broadly that they outlaw most LGBTQ+ performances and pride events, and attempts to censor books and digital media penned by all queer creators.
And now that they will hold a federal trifecta in 2025, they will attempt to pass all these same anti-LGBTQ+ policies and laws nationally.
Leaders on the right have publicly admitted that targeting trans people is part of a “divide and conquer” strategy to roll back *all* LGBTQ+ rights. There is no appeasing Republicans by selling out trans people, because they will not stop with us. Democrats must draw a line in the sand now! They must vociferously speak out and push back and filibuster any and all anti-LGBTQ+ policies and legislation.
Given Democrats recent reluctance on this issue, we must remind them that they *need* us. LGBTQ+ people represented 8% of all U.S. voters and voted for Harris at 86% according to 2024 exit polls. Democrats cannot win future nationwide elections without us. And if they won’t defend our basic rights to participate freely in society, then they do not deserve our votes!
The Proposed Action
I am but one person and cannot speak for our entire community. But here’s what I propose in the spirit of Queer Nation, who in the 1990s carried out myriad protests under the same banner but with no singular leader or directive.
I propose that on Tuesday, December 3rd, 2024 (the first day that both the House and Senate are back in session), all of us who are invested in this issue and have a platform (whether it be a blog, newsletter, column, podcast, YouTube, TikTok, Instagram, etc.) publish a piece with the shared title: “LGBTQ+ People Are Not Going Back.” Yes, I know, it’s a cheesy title, but it holds Democrats accountable to their own talking points and makes it clear that backsliding on LGBTQ+ rights is nonnegotiable for us.
What you write or say or express in your op-ed or article or video or podcast etcetera is up to you. I encourage you to make it personal and feel free to tailor it to your audience. My only request (other than all of us using the same title) is that you implore people to contact their Congressperson and Senators (and perhaps even local politicians) and tell them that 1) you will not tolerate any backpedaling on LGBTQ+ rights whatsoever, and 2) if they fail to strongly stand up against these attacks on LGBTQ+ rights, then you will take your vote elsewhere next election.
What does “take your vote elsewhere” entail?
Well, that’s up to each individual to decide for themselves. It could mean simply refusing to vote for them, or voting for their primary opponents, or voting third party. The purpose of this endeavor is not to dictate how you should vote in future elections, but to remind your representatives that your vote should not be taken for granted, and if they abandon LGBTQ+ people or backslide on LGBTQ+ rights, then they will pay a political price for that decision.
What if I disagree with this action?
Then don’t participate in it.
What if my representatives are Republicans?
By all means contact them too. Even if they are in a “safe red” state or district, they should know that you oppose their party’s increasing attacks on LGBTQ+ people.
What if I don’t live in the United States?
If this campaign resonates with you, by all means, feel free to join in, as many of your readers, viewers, and followers likely live here.
What if I’m not LGBTQ+ myself?
This action is for you too! Tell your representatives that you’ll refuse to support them if they throw the trans and queer people in your life under the bus. As much as I wish it weren’t true, some of these Democrats will likely take feedback from cis and straight allies more seriously than they take actual LGBTQ+ people’s perspectives.
What if I don’t have a platform?
No worries, you can like and share links to other people’s posts on whatever social media apps you use!
On the day of, I will try to make a master list of links to other people’s “LGBTQ+ People Are Not Going Back” creations so we can all boost one another. So if you plan to create one, feel free to let me know in advance and I’ll keep an eye out for it. We can also use the hashtag #LGBTQNotGoingBack to keep track of one another’s posts.
Hopefully, if enough of us participate, we can send a wake-up call to our representatives on this matter, and together begin to turn the tide on these recent assaults on LGBTQ+ rights.
The inevitable backlash
I am publicly announcing this proposed action ahead of time because I believe it’s the best way to get the most possible people to participate and to make it a democratic effort. But by doing so, bad actors will likely find out about this and they may try to disrupt our efforts. As always, I suggest a “block and move on” policy with regards to trolls and trans/queerphobes—they are not the ones we are trying to reach with this action.
Second, majority groups love to pit minorities against one another. So it’s very likely that outsiders will want to frame this campaign as being in opposition to Sarah McBride’s decision to comply with the congressional bathroom ban. Whatever you think about her decision, let’s not make this about her. She is not our leader. Let’s speak for ourselves in our own voices and defend our own basic rights.
Finally, some mainstream Democrats will likely dismiss this campaign as “divisive.” If you encounter anyone doing this, ask them what they think about the Democrats who’ve suggested that the party should abandon trans people and/or who’ve stayed silent amidst increasing Republican attacks on LGBTQ+ people—do they find those acts divisive? Probably not. Because the thing about the word “divisive” is it implies that there is a presumed and unspoken “one-ness” that is being divided. And if they believe that ignoring or rejecting LGBTQ+ rights is not divisive, but standing up for LGBTQ+ rights is divisive, well, that means they don’t see us as part of their coalition in the first place.
And if we are not a part of the Democratic coalition, then they don’t deserve our votes.
Chait weighs in on the increasingly combustible debate over what place trans rights have in the Democratic party in the wake of Harris' defeat.
Quoting @jonathanchait: Democrats can move to the center without compromising the dignity and equality of trans people https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2024/11/transgender-rights-election-public-opinon/680813/
Wednesday is the big day at SCOTUS:
A big transgender-rights case heads to America’s Supreme Court
The justices take on pediatric gender medicine, @TheEconomist reports.
https://www.economist.com/united-states/2024/12/02/a-big-transgender-rights-case-heads-to-americas-supreme-court
Here we have @JK_Rowling's take on the Jeremy Peters article in @NYTimes on the call from trans activists for moderation at this pivotal moment in the trans-rights struggle.
Quoting @jk_rowling: The rewriting of history begins.
Opponents of gender ideology haven't merely 'endured unsparing criticism'. I haven't simply been told I 'betrayed real feminism' or received a few book-burning videos.
I've been sent thousands of threats of murder, rape and violence. A trans woman posted my family's home address with a bomb-making guide. My eldest child was targeted by a prominent trans activist who attempted to doxx her and ended up doxxing the wrong young woman. I could write a twenty thousand word essay on what the consequences have been to me and my family, and what we've endured is NOTHING compared to the harm done to others.
By standing up to a movement that relies on threats of violence, ostracisation and guilt-by-association, all of us have been smeared and defamed, but many have lost their livelihoods. Some have been physically assaulted by trans activists. Female politicians have been forced to hire personal security on the advice of police. The news that one of the UK's leading endocrinologists, Dr Hillary Cass, was advised not to travel by public transport for her own safety should shame everyone who let this insanity run amok.
Lest we forget, gender apostates have been targeted for crimes such as doubting the evidential basis for transitioning children, for arguing for fair sport for women and girls, for wanting to retain single sex spaces and services, especially for the most vulnerable, and for thinking it barbaric to lock in female prisoners with convicted male sex offenders.
Now the political landscape has shifted, and some who've been riding high on their own supply are waking up with a hell of a hangover. They've started wondering whether calling left-wing feminists who wanted all-female rape centres 'Nazis' was such a smart strategy. Maybe parents arguing that boys ought not to be robbing their daughters of sporting opportunities might, sort of, have a point? Possibly letting any man who says 'I'm a woman' into the locker room with twelve-year-old girls could have a downside, after all?
Mealy-mouthed retconning of what has actually happened over the past ten years is predictable but will not stand. I don't doubt those who've turned a blind eye to the purges of non-believers, or even applauded and encouraged them, would rather minimise what the true cost of speaking out was, but 'yes, maybe trans activists went a little over the top at times' takes are frankly insulting. A full reckoning on the effects of gender ideology on individuals, society and politics is still a long way off, but I know this: the receipts will make very ugly reading when that time comes, and there are far too many of them to sweep politely under the carpet.
There is a lot less data on trans men, because until a split second ago in history, they were such a small population, they often went unaccounted for in studies. It wasn’t possible to get enough of a group together to get a statistically significant result.
One of the many reasons that I think that the word “c*sgender” is both fine and necessary (when not used to attack someone) is because I have read 1,000s of academic papers about HIV science, and the word is used constantly in them for clarity. Trans women have a high HIV rate. And when discussing them, it helps to have a qualifier to differentiate between them and other people. And no, just “woman” or “man” is not sufficient in this context. People might get confused. And you all can yell at me all you like, but I absolutely will not change my position on this or on calling people by their preferred pronouns.
Trans journalist Evan Urquhart, who tweets under Assigned Media, has told relentless falsehoods about me and my work to retaliate against my reporting about the weakness of the science backing pediatric gender medicine.
Here he is, suggesting that such behavior does not go on:
But we’re starting to get more clarity on the matter.
https://benryan.substack.com/p/on-the-american-academy-of-pediatrics
Last month, I reported for The New York Sun about the practices at Boston Children’s Hospital, which was the first hospital to establish a pediatric gender clinic in the U.S., importing the treatment model from the Dutch researchers in 2007. My reporting revealed that it has been the policy at Boston Children’s gender clinic since 2018 to provide gender-dysphoric kids and their parents only a single two-hour assessment appointment. It took a civil trial for this information to finally come to light.
Reuters conducted an investigation in 2022 that found that at 7 of the 18 pediatric gender clinics they surveyed, the staff would provide gender-transition drugs to minors after a single appointment if they “didn’t see any red flags.”
In his recent book on trans kids, Dr. Turban repeatedly strongly suggests that he thinks these assessments are worthless and should be done away with. https://benryan.substack.com/p/dr-jack-turbans-quietly-radical-bible
How many kids does this medical field impact?
https://benryan.substack.com/p/on-the-american-academy-of-pediatrics
The AAP amicus brief vastly under-reports the number of adolescents believed to identify as transgender in the United States. The authors cite the Williams Institute at UCLA Law School when stating that between 2017 and 2020 about 10% of the 1.6 million transgender people in the U.S., or 160,000, were 13 to 17 years old. This is incorrect. The report they cite estimates that there were, in fact, 300,000 trans Americans in this age range:
Scientific rigor?
https://benryan.substack.com/p/on-the-american-academy-of-pediatrics
In their opening, authors of the AAP amicus brief assert that the contents of their filing will describe the “scientifically rigorous process by which” trans-care guidelines for minors were developed and will detail the related evidence that backs pediatric gender-transition treatment.
They go on to highlight the WPATH and Endocrine Society guidelines in particular.
It's not over, it continues unabated. Just look at all the wrath directed at NYT's Jeremy Peters for writing that some trans activists are calling for a more modified tone. There are just some of us who decided to ignore it or push back against it.
The public flogging of Jesse Singal by trans activists starting in ~2016 served as a warning to other reporters not to report on pediatric gender medicine with the same critical introspection we would for any other science story. But that could only scare us away for so long.
Quoting @Bernard_Lane: Why don't more journalists write critically about the gender medicalisation of minors? Because they see colleagues getting smeared for it, that's one reason.
https://www.themonthly.com.au/issue/2024/november/steve-dow/queering-pitch
A big part of the problem on both sides of this explosive debate over women, trans women and whether trans women are women is people seem totally incapable of accepting the possibility that there can be subcategories of people and that we might need words to delineate these groups from one another.
Come up with another word if you like, but we need a word that means “not trans” that isn’t as clumsy as “non-trans” to clearly delineate groups of people when discussing trans people. And no, just saying “women” is not enough. One needs to make sure people don’t get confused.
Quoting @elonmusk: The word ‘cis’ is a propaganda slur
Are trans activists the ACT UP of the 2020s? Keith here has this response to this Times article on the call for moderation in trans activism:
Quoting @benryanwriter: Transgender Activists Question the Movement’s Confrontational Approach
Facing diminishing public support, some activists say all-or-nothing tactics are not working. “We have to make it OK for someone to change their minds.”
I am not going to call Brianna Wu or any other trans woman “he”. People like this who insist on coming into my threads thinking that if they harangue me enough I’ll suddenly stop believing there is such thing as trans identity or gender dysphoria are sorely mistaken.
Quotes a post by T17248; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
@[private account] Trans women are biologically male, identify as female, and often take hormones and have surgeries to alter their sex characteristics to present more as female. I don’t know why any of these very basic and obvious facts should be a matter of dispute.
People know very well that I think that the term “biological sex” refers to the unchanging sex that everyone is born with and is either male or female. And that if we change the meaning of the term then we cannot discuss transgender identity from a position of reality.
Another one from the @ACLU's Chase Strangio, who I will be seeing in Washington, DC, on Wednesday when he becomes the first openly transgender person to argue a case before the Supreme Court, in the U.S. v Skrmetti case.
I do not weigh in on Israel. I make no comment on anything she says about that. I only interface with her about trans politics.
We cannot discuss sports inclusion if we cannot describe reality in clear and precise terms.
I do not personally weigh in on matters of policy. But I imagine one could look for what research is available that indicates the costs v benefits of trans inclusion vs expulsion and come up with conclusion about the wisdom or lack thereof of such a policy, putting aside the question of discrimination and fairness.
I’m not positive, but I think that for some reason Bostock does not apply to the military. People with HIV, after all, were still discriminated against in the military until recently, despite the ADA of 1990 being interpreted to protect them against workplace discrimination.
If trans women were biological women, they would have no need for gender-transition treatment or surgeries. It is because they have a biological male sex but a female gender identity that they seek out these interventions. To me, these are very basic concepts that I’m surprised we cannot agree on.
If trans women were biological women, they would not be trans. Trans women are trans because their female gender identity is the opposite of their male biological sex.
It is not transphobic to make a point that agreeing upon the precise definition of terms like “biological woman” is necessary to make sense of the differences between trans and non-trans people, both in medical and legal contexts.
Quotes a post by T05708; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Meanwhile, the @[private account]' @MichaelJKnowles makes no secret that he thinks supporting the inclusion of trans girls in girls' and women's sports is an albatross for Democrats. https://x.com/michaeljknowles/status/1858001826374730136
Quoting @michaeljknowles: I, too, firmly support the Left's never giving up on "trans" inclusion in sports. In fact, I hope Democrats bring it up in every campaign ad and at every single debate!
Tensions over trans people in sports:
Activist-writer Erin Reed says the left must never give up on trans inclusion in sports, because, she says, the opponents will never be satisfied. @RepNancyMace stands firm, calling Reed a "biological male." Reed says Mace is hateful.
STUDY: Taking puberty blockers starting in early puberty and then cross-sex hormones for gender dysphoria is tied to wider shoulders in trans males (natal females) and narrower shoulders in trans females (natal males). The reverse is true for pelvis size. https://www.eurekalert.org/news-releases/1064881
The podcast version of my conversation with @[private account], who Alejandra Caraballo is determined to make the most blocked person on Bl—ky. (Having 22K block you out of 18M users is 0.1%). https://benryan.substack.com/p/brianna-wus-dire-warning-for-transgender
Almost 1M views on this fact check of @[private account]'s very incorrect take on trans participation in sports.
Quoting @benryanwriter: John Oliver, in arguing how the Dems should respond to the trans kids issue, falsely claims “there is no evidence” trans kids “pose any threat” to fairness in sports.
There absolutely is evidence that trans females have a competitive advantage.
The Washington Post's editorial board states:
Needed: A respectful debate on trans women in sportsOpinion
Rep. Seth Moulton says Democrats should be open to differing views on the subject. He’s right.
After his party’s election defeat on Nov. 5, Rep. Seth Moulton (Massachusetts) offered some blunt advice: “Democrats spend way too much time trying not to offend anyone rather than being brutally honest about the challenges many Americans face. … I have two little girls. I don’t want them getting run over on a playing field by a male or formerly male athlete, but as a Democrat, I’m supposed to be afraid to say that.”
Mr. Moulton’s remarks sparked an immediate backlash within his own political camp. His campaign manager quit. A state legislator accused him of “scapegoating transgender youth.” A city council member in Salem, Massachusetts, called for him to resign. The Bay State’s governor, Maura Healey, opined that Mr. Moulton was “playing politics with people.” Even Tufts University briefly got in on the act when David Art, chair of the political science department, reportedly called Mr. Moulton’s office and told him not to contact the university to recruit interns in the future, though Tufts quickly clarified that “we have not — and will not — limit internship opportunities with his office.”
Trans women’s participation in sports raises thorny questions about fairness — but that should not preclude Mr. Moulton from speaking his mind. Trans people deserve to be treated with dignity, and the law should protect them from discrimination in areas such as employment and housing. But the realities of human biology raise legitimate questions about any notion that trans women should always and everywhere be treated exactly like cisgender women.
In athletic competition, male puberty confers significant advantages. While those biological differences vary by skill and sport, a 2023 paper by medical researchers in the United States and Italy noted that “it is well established that the best males always outperform the best females when the sport relies on muscle power, muscle endurance, or aerobic power.” The hormone therapy that many trans women take reduces some of those advantages over time, but research into how much those advantages can be mitigated, and over what time frame, is still ongoing. Other advantages, such as height, are fixed by the end of puberty. This poses obvious fairness and safety questions.
Notice that we say “questions.” The public needs more and better research to make those decisions. But unless the data show that transitioning can fully erase the effects of male puberty, the country will also need a frank and open debate about the trade-offs between inclusion on the one hand and safety and fairness on the other.
And yet too often, efforts have been made to avoid or prevent discussion of those trade-offs by labeling debate inherently transphobic. This is not how a healthy democracy makes decisions.
However fervently Mr. Moulton’s critics disagree with him, they do not speak for the majority: A 2023 Gallup poll showed that almost 70 percent of Americans think sports participation should follow birth sex, not gender identity. Pressuring Democratic politicians to side with the minority, without giving sufficient space to the other side’s argument, is a recipe for irresolution and resentment.
Persuasion is the stuff from which long-term majorities are made. Though the battle over trans inclusion is frequently compared to the same-sex marriage debate, there are two key differences: Society had a long and robust debate over marriage equality, and there was no reasonable doubt about the merits. Same-sex marriage was already winning the debate by the time the Supreme Court decided Obergefell v. Hodges in 2015, making it legal across the country. That victory has proved durable. Since Obergefell, support for same-sex marriage has risen from 58 percent to 69 percent.
In a decade or two, we might look back and wonder how we could have ever doubted that trans women are entitled to compete in women’s sports such as swimming and boxing. But it is also possible that, after more data and more debate, history’s verdict will go to those who now argue that certain spaces, where strength and size matter most, should be reserved for cisgender women. We cannot predict whose argument will prevail. We can only say that no one — and certainly no political party — is entitled to win this debate by default.
In a recent Times interview, @[private account] said that his staff of researchers spend six weeks on each individual segment on his show. So they have more than enough time to do the research to get stories right. Consequently, it is remarkable that he gets wrong the question of fairness regarding trans girls in girls' sports.
Here’s is another thread on research indicating that trans females maintain a competitive advantage in women’s sports:
Quoting @FondOfBeetles: There have been two academic reviews of musculoskeletal changes in transwomen suppressing testosterone.
Both conclude that loss of muscle mass and strength is small, and that strength advantage over females is retained.
Citations to follow.
What’s remarkable about @[private account]’s false claims about trans females in sports is he has a staff of fact checkers. There are multiple studies indicating that even when receiving estrogen, natal males who identify as females are stronger and faster than women & girls.
John Oliver, in arguing how the Dems should respond to the trans kids issue, falsely claims “there is no evidence” trans kids “pose any threat” to fairness in sports.
There absolutely is evidence that trans females have a competitive advantage.
On Laura Helmuth's controversial tenure at @[private account], @UnHerd reports:
"The outlet published numerous articles promoting transgender medical interventions. It also published articles advocating against age restrictions for these procedures. One such article claimed that “a decade of research shows such treatment reduces depression, suicidality and other devastating consequences of trans preteens and teens being forced to undergo puberty in the sex they were assigned at birth”, a proposition that has come under international scrutiny in recent years."
https://unherd.com/newsroom/scientific-american-editor-leaves-post-after-anti-trump-comments/
How Harvard Teed Up the False Claim That the 'Vast Majority of Minors Getting Gender-Affirming Surgeries Are Cis Kids'
https://open.substack.com/pub/benryan/p/how-harvard-teed-up-the-false-claim
An opaquely written Harvard study and linked press release prompted false reporting that gynecomastia surgeries for boys are vastly more common than gender-affirming surgeries for trans kids.
A new report by @[private account] Reem Alsalen UN Special Rapporteur on Violence Against Women and Girls finds that transgender women (natal males) competing in women's sports won at least 890 medals, beating more than 600 female athletes in 29 sports. https://documents.un.org/doc/undoc/gen/n24/249/94/pdf/n2424994.pdf
Quotes a post by T23548; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
How Harvard Teed Up the False Claim That the 'Vast Majority of Minors Getting Gender-Affirming Surgeries Are C-s Kids'
https://benryan.substack.com/p/how-harvard-teed-up-the-false-claim
An opaquely written Harvard study and linked press release prompted false reporting that gynecomastia surgeries for boys are vastly more common than gender-affirming surgeries for trans kids.
Helmuth has been widely criticized for overseeing coverage at SciAm of transgender issues and the sex binary (or lack thereof, per SciAm) that critics have lambasted as ideological.
You often hear people reacting incredulously to claims that doctors are “sterilizing” transgender kids. Here are the mechanics of how such treatment poses a risk of rendering a young person infertile:
Quoting @benryanwriter: Hi @JoyceCarolOates. If a natal male in particular undergoes pubertal suppression at the early onset of puberty and then later takes estrogen, there is a good chance that they will never produce viable sperm. Their testicles will likely remain in a permanently pre-fertile state. Many natal males identifying as female receive gender-transition treatment under this schedule. This was how the original so-called Dutch model pioneered in the Netherlands in the 1990s was meant to operate.
From this paper: Desire for children and fertility preservation in transgender and gender-diverse people: A systematic review
"As PS [pubertal suppression] may be initiated from Tanner stage 2 [the early onset of puberty], spermatogenesis [the capacity to make viable sperm] may not be present at the time TGD [transgender and gender diverse] AMAB [assigned male at birth, aka natal males] adolescents start their medical transition. When continuing GnRH agonists as androgen deprivation therapy as part of their GAHT [gender-affirmative hormonal treatment, ie: estrogen] later in life, these adolescents may never develop spermatogenesis."
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/36806443/
Hi @JoyceCarolOates. If a natal male in particular undergoes pubertal suppression at the early onset of puberty and then later takes estrogen, there is a good chance that they will never produce viable sperm. Their testicles will likely remain in a permanently pre-fertile state. Many natal males identifying as female receive gender-transition treatment under this schedule. This was how the original so-called Dutch model pioneered in the Netherlands in the 1990s was meant to operate.
From this paper: Desire for children and fertility preservation in transgender and gender-diverse people: A systematic review
"As PS [pubertal suppression] may be initiated from Tanner stage 2 [the early onset of puberty], spermatogenesis [the capacity to make viable sperm] may not be present at the time TGD [transgender and gender diverse] AMAB [assigned male at birth, aka natal males] adolescents start their medical transition. When continuing GnRH agonists as androgen deprivation therapy as part of their GAHT [gender-affirmative hormonal treatment, ie: estrogen] later in life, these adolescents may never develop spermatogenesis."
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/36806443/
BREAKING: Laura Helmuth Is Out As Scientific American Editor in Chief
After issuing a tirade against Trump voters on Nov. 5, and later apologizing profusely for doing so and disavowing her words, Laura Helmuth says she has "decided to leave" @[private account].
Helmuth has been widely criticized for overseeing ideological coverage of transgender issues in particular.
Quoting @benryanwriter: After making a series of fiercely ideological and political statements on social media in the wake of Trump’s win and being pilloried for doing so, @[private account] editor in chief Laura Helmuth is now back pedaling. She claims she is committed to editorial objectivity.
Democrats will only further lose elections by scapegoating trans rights
In the post-election blame game, some are targeting trans people. It's ugly. It's also very bad political strategy.
By Michelangelo @[private account]
Pamala Paul is an odious feature on the New York Times op-ed page, an anti-trans columnist who exaggerates and distorts data to push a transphobic agenda.
Today she predictably uses all the scapegoating of trans people we’ve seen in the media and among some Democrats and some Never Trump Republicans—the attacks on the Democratic Party for being too “woke” and on the Trump campaign’s anti-trans ad as the supposed causes for Donald Trump’s win—to say that, “On Trans Issues, Voters Want Common Sense.”
But make no mistake: What Paul and others mean by “common sense” is to abandon core rights for trans people, including necessary medical care and protecting trans kids.
The finger-pointing comes as many Democratic consultants, analysts, pundits, and politicians try to cover their own asses on what happened in the election’s aftermath, and transgender people are an easy target.
Here’s the direct link to my latest essay on trans politics on the left:
Quoting @benryanwriter: LINK: How An Inability to Clearly Define ‘Sex’ vs. ‘Gender’ Has Left Democrats In a Mess
https://benryan.substack.com/p/how-an-inability-to-clearly-define
Quoting @benryanwriter: How An Inability to Clearly Define ‘Sex’ vs. ‘Gender’ Has Left Democrats In a Mess
🧵⬇️ I report: Language matters. By insisting there’s no difference between “sex” and “gender” and that sex is “assigned at birth,” progressives have alienated many from the transgender cause.
That is not the question that prompted Harris to explicitly state her position on taxpayer funding for gender transition treatment and surgeries for trans detainees, including ICE detainees. The question was specific to this subtopic.
The answer is that the @ACLU almost certainly did not perceive the answers to the transgender questionnaire as being embarrassing. This likely speaks to a bubble effect, in which liberal groups do not perceive how their own positions might prove alienating to most voters.
Quotes a post by A0773; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
These are the same people who insist that AGP doesn't exist and that the whole concept is an insult to trans women. I for one do not know the answer to these questions, mind you.
I forget how this curious theory came about. But last week something I said trip wired these people with their accusations. They are in keeping with my needing to repeatedly come out as gay after Alejandra Caraballo's insisted several times that I'm a "chaser" (a man who fetishizes trans women).
Pamela Paul echoes my own findings, writing: "In my reporting, I’ve spoken with many parents of gender-dysphoric kids, overwhelmingly liberal and Democrat, who told me they felt betrayed by Democrats and by the Biden administration on this issue. They resent being labeled “anti-trans” for questioning whether it’s right to simply accept what their children say about their gender, especially since those children often suffer from other mental health issues."
I found:
Avatars of Dem Alienation: Liberal Parents Wary About Their Kids’ Trans Identities
Almost all the distressed parents who tell me they think their kids’ trans identities are not authentic are liberals who find themselves drifting away from the Democratic party.
https://benryan.substack.com/p/avatars-of-dem-alienation-liberal
In her new editorial on transgender politics, Pamela Paul links to my reporting:
At Least 14,000 U.S. Minors Have Received Gender-Transition Treatment or Surgeries In 5 Years, With Docs Billing $120 million
https://benryan.substack.com/p/at-least-14000-us-minors-have-received
Pamela Paul: On Transgender Issues, Voters Want Common Sense
Perhaps as a threat of what’s to come, on Friday, supporters of President-elect Donald Trump recirculated a video statement on X that he made last year on transgender issues. In it, he pledges to stop federal backing for programs that support the concept of gender transition at any age and to ban gender-affirming care for minors. Any hospital that performs gender surgery on young people would be ejected from Medicare and Medicaid. He would cut federal funds to schools that tell children “they could be trapped in the wrong body,” and get a law that bars “men from participating in women’s sports.”
And it wasn’t just one video — Trump made his intentions clear throughout the campaign, and he won handily.
During the closing weeks of the election, Republican campaigns spent over $65 million on ads ridiculing, among several candidates, Kamala Harris for supporting “taxpayer-funded sex changes for prisoners” and “illegal aliens,” all ending with variations on the tagline: “Kamala Harris is for they/them. President Trump is for you.”
At campaign events Trump attacked the idea of letting transgender girls and women play on female sports teams, and implied that children were having gender surgery in classrooms.
“Can you imagine you’re a parent and your son leaves the house,” he said at a rally in Wisconsin, “and you say, ‘Jimmy, I love you so much, go have a good day in school,’ and your son comes back with a brutal operation?”
Why did Trump and his allies devote so much attention and resources to something that seemingly affects a small number of people compared with top voter concerns like immigration, the economy, crime, abortion and democracy? Maybe because it worked. According to Harris’s leading super PAC, viewers shifted2.7 percentage points toward Trump after watching one of these ads.
Clearly it helped paint Harris as a radical leftist, out of step with most of America. But as those of us who opposed Trump lick our wounds and take stock, it’s worth considering why these ads and rally cries resonated.
It is not because most Americans are bigots or haters or anti-L.G.B.T.Q. people. But many voters, including liberals and Democrats, disagree with positions Harris and the Democratic Party have taken on transgender issues. Polls show that most voters, while largely supportive of existing legal rights and protections for transgender people, have complicated views on other policies that fall under the umbrella of what’s commonly referred to as trans rights.
Trump’s charge that children are undergoing gender transition surgeries in school is obviously absurd. But his words may have struck a chord with those who disagree with school districts that have teachers and administrators hide from parents that their children have adopted new gender identities. As The Times reported last year, one mother of a 15-year-old only accidentally discovered her child’s public school had been covering up the fact that for six months, her child had been going by a new name and using the boys’ bathroom.
In recent years, the concepts of gender identity and the possibilityof being born in the wrong body have been introduced as early as elementary school. But a Washington Post poll found that 77 percent of Americans do not want teachers discussing these ideas in kindergarten through third grade and more than half oppose trans identity being talked about even in middle school.
The Democratic Party’s platform includes a pledge to defend gender-affirming care for minors. For people who are not well versed in the issue, this may sound like therapy to make children feel comfortable in their bodies; what it usually means in practice is allowing children to adopt a new name and pronouns, and in many cases, enabling them to change their bodies to resemble that of the opposite sex. This process can include puberty-blocking drugs, cross-sex hormones and, in some cases, surgery. More than 14,000 American children had gender-related medical interventions between 2019 and 2023.
While much of Europe has been pulling back from the gender-affirmation model, evidence has emerged that in the United States, proponents of this approach have let politics color science.
To cite two recent examples, one prominent advocate of gender-affirming care suppressed her own government-funded researchbecause she feared it might be “weaponized” against her agenda, The Times reported. Meanwhile, Rachel Levine, the assistant secretary of health and human services chosen by President Biden, worked to get a transgender organization to remove age limitsfrom its proposed guidelines for surgeries, including mastectomies and hysterectomies for minors, because she said they would give fuel to political foes, according to recently released court documents. After this disclosure, the Biden administration released a statement saying it opposed such surgeries for minors.
Yet the Department of Health and Human Services continues to say that gender-affirming care is “crucial” for young people and “has been shown to increase positive outcomes for transgender and nonbinary children and adolescents” — even though the most comprehensive overview of research, which assessed all major American and global studies on the subject, found scant evidence of this. Even so, all the leading American medical associations continue to back gender-affirming care.
In my reporting, I’ve spoken with many parents of gender-dysphoric kids, overwhelmingly liberal and Democrat, who told me they felt betrayed by Democrats and by the Biden administration on this issue. They resent being labeled “anti-trans” for questioning whether it’s right to simply accept what their children say about their gender, especially since those children often suffer from other mental health issues.
The number of people identifying as transgender is still tiny, but it is growing rapidly. While surveys show around 1 percent of American adults overall identify as transgender or nonbinary (meaning they choose not to identify as either sex), according to one poll, about 5 percent of adults younger than 30 now do.
Democratic politicians, the media and elite institutions frequently refer to our “evolving understanding of sex and gender.” But a majority of Americans still believe that gender is based on sex at birth.
This is not because Americans are “uncomfortable” with the existence of transgender people or need to get with the program. About 44 percent of Americans already know someone who is transgender. Indeed, polls show that people have become less supportive of progressive ideas about gender identity as they have become more widely publicized and understood. According to Pew,60 percent of Americans in 2022 said gender is determined by the sex at birth, up from 54 percent in 2017. Democrats’ opposition to allowing trans girls and women to compete in women’s sports increased to 48 percent in 2023, from 41 percent in 2021, according to Gallup, while independent voters’ opposition increased to 67 percent from 63 percent.
Rather than try to push Americans in a direction they clearly oppose, Democrats would be better off endorsing nuanced and humane alternatives. Some in the party are already seeing the value in such an approach.
“Democrats spend way too much time trying not to offend anyone rather than being brutally honest about the challenges many Americans face,” Seth Moulton, a Democratic representative from Massachusetts, told The Times last week. “I have two little girls; I don’t want them getting run over on a playing field by a male or formerly male athlete, but as a Democrat I’m supposed to be afraid to say that.”
Democrats have long been on the right side of health care, scientific progress, women’s rights, gay rights and education. This is the party that truly cares about families and aims to address their needs, especially on the more pressing economic issues that have many Americans feeling that their backs are up against a wall. But on transgender issues specifically, one way to make clear that Democrats are listening to their constituencies would be to accept a broader range of perspectives.
Trump has made already clear how extreme a position he will take, even potentially moving toward bans on gender medicine for adults. Transgender people are understandably fearful of what a second Trump administration might mean for their future.
The tenor of Trump’s vitriol could embolden real transphobes and inflame wider hate of and discrimination against transgender people as well as gay men and lesbians. The gay rights movement rightly fears a backslide. This is a scary time.
Democrats should fight these tendencies and ensure that everyone, regardless of gender identity or sexual orientation, is respected and protected under existing law. Rather than double down on beliefs and policies that are out of step with the best medical evidence, Democrats and everyone else who support transgender rights should embrace a common-sense approach from their government, their schools, their mental health care workers and their doctors. Vulnerable people are depending on it.
Over my last 2 days on social media:
▶️>1,200 people on X responded with fury to my assertion that it is impolite to call a trans woman “he”
▶️Scores of people on the newly popular other social media app put my name on circulating blacklists, accusing me of being a transphobe
Sebastian Coe pledges ‘clearcut policy’ on women’s sport in IOC pitch
Coe in contention to be elected as IOC president
Briton wants clearer rules on transgender competitors
Over the past two days, I've had the rad fems screaming at me to call trans women "he" and the far leftists saying I'm a transphobic Nazi. So go figure.
When I first started writing about trans people in my coverage of the HIV epidemic, I quickly just adopted a policy for how I wrote about it: sex was binary and objective and gender identity was on a continuum and was subjective. This all made very neat and tidy sense to me. But more recently, I've seen people come at this debate from the most baffling angles.
People lost their damn minds with me for what I said about sex being binary and gender identity existing on a continuum. But it strikes me as perfectly in keeping with acknowledging the plight of transgender people to say this. It is this very binary that so frustrates the existence of trans people—again, because they feel they are stuck on the wrong side of that binary. We cannot as a society grapple with transgender people’s place in society and promote fairness, tolerance and, hopefully, celebration of one another’s gender-identity differences if we lack a common agreement on what words pertaining to sex and gender actually mean. If these words are as fluid as a fickle teenager’s shifting identity, finding common ground will always remain elusive. https://benryan.substack.com/publish/post/151567447
Quoting @benryanwriter: How An Inability to Clearly Define ‘Sex’ vs. ‘Gender’ Has Left Democrats In a Mess
🧵⬇️ I report: Language matters. By insisting there’s no difference between “sex” and “gender” and that sex is “assigned at birth,” progressives have alienated many from the transgender cause.
The term “sex assigned at birth” has been misappropriated by progressives to apply to all people, meant to emphasize that sex is not destiny where gender identity is concerned. But this makes no sense. The whole point of a transgender identity is the person’s gender identity is misaligned with their sex, not that their sex changes along with their gender identity.
One of the biggest pile-ons I ever sustained on X was in September of last year when I said sex was binary. This was in response to a video clip making the rounds in which the trans-woman cyclist Veronica Ivy told Trevor Noah that she was a “biological woman,” and I said this made no sense.
https://benryan.substack.com/p/how-an-inability-to-clearly-define
The determination of a baby’s sex at birth is a separate question from whatever gender identity an individual might develop later in life. Should an individual develop a transgender identity, their biological sex remains highly relevant in the medical context and also unchanging. The use of puberty blockers, cross-sex hormones and gender-transition surgeries are all meant to work in opposition to that natal sex.
Presuming that sex and gender identity are one and the same, as some trans activists subscribing to postmodern and queer-theory philosophies do, belies such medical efforts to change a transgender person’s physical characteristics to make them appear more like the opposite sex. If a person’s transgender identity and their sex were the same, then there would be no need for any of those medical interventions.
How new terms about sex and gender have alienated the public
Recent exit polling suggested that many voters who swung for Trump did indeed place a relatively high value on social issues, including trans-related questions. (Inflation and immigration were the top concerns.) This suggests three things for the Democrat election post-mortem:
1) Harris’ support for taxpayer funding of gender-transition treatment and surgery for detainees in a 2019 ACLU survey haunted her.
2) Voters were responding to Dems’ general support for trans issues, not to hers in particular
3) Voters believed incorrect claims about her attention to trans issues.
Regarding point number 2, Democrats face a clear conflict with the public at large after progressives, in an effort to promote trans-related rights, rolled out a new linguistic code in recent years on how to discuss sex and gender. The public’s negative reaction to these terms is in part driven by the fact that some of them are unscientific and illogical. https://benryan.substack.com/p/how-an-inability-to-clearly-define
As for the question of single-sex spaces, most of us are taught from a very young age that the division according to sex in locker rooms and other changing areas is sacrosanct. Accordingly, profound anxieties are constructed around the threat that those boundaries might ever be violated. And as a consequence, many people recoil to say the least when they are now told, after a lifetime of observing these rules, that their objection to people with the genitals of the opposite sex entering their locker room has no merit and must not be voiced at all. To wit, young women athletes who shared locker rooms with trans-woman swimmer Lia Thomas, such as @Riley_Gaines_ were instructed to keep quiet about their concerns. https://benryan.substack.com/p/how-an-inability-to-clearly-define
In may cases, a person’s trans identity also has no substantial impact on anyone around them. What does it matter if the person selling you a pair of shoes is transgender? In the 2020 Supreme Court case Bostock v. Clayton County, conservative Justice Neil Gorsuch wrote the majority opinion that enshrined this notion into federal employment law. The case concerned a person who was fired from a job in a funeral home after transitioning from male to female. Gorsuch, Chief Justice John Roberts and the court’s four liberal members at the time found that under Title XII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, people who identify as transgender are protected from discrimination in the workplace if their gender has no bearing on their duties on the job.
https://benryan.substack.com/p/how-an-inability-to-clearly-define
You hear this expression a lot about trans people: “They just want to live their lives.” Democratic California State Senator @[private account], who is gay, recently uttered the phrase in the statehouse in Sacramento as he fought for a bill related to trans kids. This mantra could certainly have been said about gays seeking to marry before it was legal. Despite a hard-fought campaign by conservatives to convince the public that opening marriage to same-sex couples would pose a threat to the overall intuition of marriage, this was always a losing argument. Because it was simply illogical. Gays’ marriages threatened no one else’s.
https://benryan.substack.com/p/how-an-inability-to-clearly-define
Here’s the problem with @[private account]’s evidently inflexible position on this question of trans people's participation in sports: For the purpose of fairness in sports, trans girls are not girls, full stop. They are biological boys who identify as female. And because of their natal sex, they hold, on average, a competitive advantage over girls. Even prepubescent boys are stronger and faster than their female counterparts. Puberty widens this gap dramatically, to the point that there are teenage boy swimmers who post better times than Olympian Katie Ledecky, one of the most decorated female distance swimmers in history. While more research is sorely needed, the available science indicates that even athletes who have gone through a male puberty and then take estrogen still maintain a competitive advantage.
https://benryan.substack.com/p/how-an-inability-to-clearly-define
The @CNN clip blew up online, posing as it did as an avatar for the social issue that supposedly helped sink Harris’ campaign. Besieged, @[private account] added on X: “Shermichael knows exactly the language he’s using. He’s not some innocent rube—he’s a longtime GOP strategist. Saying ‘boys in girls sports’ was not some slight slip-up. It was denying that trans girls are girls, full stop.”
Over the weekend, a dispute over trans kids’ participation in sports during a @CNN panel discussionlaid bare the conundrum the left faces about trans rights. While Democrats like @[private account] and @[private account] are evidently seeking to appeal to voters who might be alienated by certain trans-related policies, others on the left betray no wish compromise in their support for policies concerning trans youth in particular.
Conservative commentator @[private account] Singleton asserted on the CNN panel: “I think there are a lot of families out there who don’t believe boys should play girls’ sports.” Liberal author @[private account] then immediately interjected, “They’re not boys.” He said, “I’m not going to listen to transphobia at this table,” and insisted that calling a trans girl a boy was “a slur.”
https://benryan.substack.com/p/how-an-inability-to-clearly-define
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aV30g4DiccQ&t=1s
Trans activists and their allies have scrambled to deflect blame and to shore up support within the Democratic party as the trans community faces what Trump has promised will be an onslaught against them during his second term. Many have pointed to Republicans’ long history of, they argue, cynically stoking animus toward minority groups—see: gays in 2004—to ride the wedge-issue train to victory. (Political scientists have since concluded that Karl Rove’s strategy of leveraging anti-gay-marriage ballot initiatives in swing states to bolster Republican turn-out was not, in fact, instrumental in securing George W. Bush a second term.)
https://benryan.substack.com/p/how-an-inability-to-clearly-define
In the wake of Kamala Harris’ devastating loss to Donald Trump, recriminations and finger pointing have seized the Democratic party. Given that Trump spent tens of millions of dollars on attack ads faulting Harris for her support of certain transgender-related policies, the party is undergoing an internal paroxysm over whether that support is an albatross worth shedding.
Two Democratic congressmen—@[private account] of New York and Rep @[private account] @[private account] of Massachusetts—said immediately after the party lost the White House that they were uncomfortable with natal boys participating in girls’ sports. The left’s support for such inclusion, they suggested, had cost Dems dearly.
https://benryan.substack.com/p/how-an-inability-to-clearly-define
How An Inability to Clearly Define ‘Sex’ vs. ‘Gender’ Has Left Democrats In a Mess
🧵⬇️ I report: Language matters. By insisting there’s no difference between “sex” and “gender” and that sex is “assigned at birth,” progressives have alienated many from the transgender cause.
I have blocked scores of people who badger me about my pronoun policy. My pronoun policy is final and will never be subject to change. People who insist on haranguing me about this and hurling accusations at me that I am wicked for calling trans women "she" will be blocked.
Rep Seth Mouton says that the backlash against his comments about natal boys identifying as trans participating in girls’ sports “has only seemed to reinforce my original point” about what he characterizes as the left’s preachiness.
One of the biggest pile-ons I ever sustained on Twitter was in September of last year when I said sex was binary. This was in response to the trans-woman cyclist Veronica Ivy saying to Trevor Noah that she was a "biological woman." People lost their minds with me. It strikes me as perfectly in keeping with acknowledging the plight of transgender people to say that sex is binary. It is this binary that so frustrates the existence of trans people, because they feel they are stuck on the wrong side of that binary. The purpose of gender-transition treatment is to try to reconcile this conflict by using hormones and/or surgery to help trans people effect the opposite sex.
The nonsensical thing about the term "sex assigned at birth" is it was coined for cases of differences of sex development, formerly known as intersex conditions. It is scientifically accurate to use the term in such cases. But the term has been misappropriated to apply to all people in the context of discerning their gender identity. It implies that a person's sex is up for debate based on what their gender identity is. But this makes no sense. The whole point of a transgender identity is the person's gender identity is misaligned with their sex. The purpose of gender-transition treatment (sometimes called sex-trait modification) is to work against a person's sex to make them appear more like the opposite sex.
The Democrats Need an Honest Conversation on Gender Identity
The party went into an election with policies it couldn’t defend—or even explain, writes @HelenLewis for @TheAtlantic.
Biden’s administration has long pushed the new orthodoxy on gender, without ever really explaining to the American people why it matters—or, more crucially, what it actually involves. His officials have advocated for removing lower age limits for gender surgeries for minors, and in January 2022, his nominee for the Supreme Court, Ketanji Brown Jackson, refused to define the word woman, telling Senator Marsha Blackburn of Tennessee, “I’m not a biologist.”
On sports—an issue seized on by the Trump campaign—Biden’s White House has consistently prioritized gender identity over sex. Last year, the Department of Education proposed regulations establishing “that policies violate Title IX when they categorically ban transgender students from participating on sports teams consistent with their gender identity just because of who they are.” Schools were, however, allowed to limit participation in specific situations. (In April, with the election looming, this part of the Title IX revision was put on hold.) Harris went into the campaign tied to the Biden administration’s positions, and did not have the courage, or strategic sense, to reject them publicly. Nor did she defend them.
The flip side to the perspective of trans adults who wished they’d medically transitioned as children are gay adults who wondered if they grew up today, whether they have would up medically transitioning.
Meanwhile, the dominant voices in pediatric gender medicine, such as Robert Garofalo of Lurie Children’s and Diane Ehrensaft of UCSF, say that assessments of gender dysphoric children should not seek to assess whether the child is “really trans.”
This biases the outcome toward medicalization and the avoiding of the endogenous puberty that might have helped a gay child make sense of and then come to terms with their sexuality.
Boston Children’s, we found out two weeks ago, only assesses kids for 2 hours before deciding whether to send the off to endocrinology.
Interestingly, both sides of the fight over the trans volleyball player have filed Title IX complaints. Eventually, the Supreme Court will very likely have to define what sex means under the Civil Rights Act. Until then, sex and gender identity will be increasingly in conflict.
You hear this expression a lot about trans people: “They just want to live their lives.” This could certainly be said about gays seeking to marry before it was legal: Their marriages threatened no one else’s. But while in many cases, a person’s trans identity has no substantial impact on anyone around them, when it comes to their entry into single-sex spaces, it does. A biological male who identifies as female and competes in elite athletics is now in competition with biological females who by nature of their sex are weaker and slower. Scholarships and other financial gains such as endorsement deals may be at stake. And so society’s acceptance in these contexts changes accordingly, because they do not agree that this is a simple matter of one person just going about their own life and having no major impact on anyone else by virtue of identifying as the opposite sex.
The reason the public is reacting so strongly to the @CNN clip is because trans girls, for the purpose of fairness in sports, are not in fact girls, full stop, as Mr Michaelson argues here and said on the show. They are biological boys who thus have a competitive advantage. Many people are happy to treat natal males who identify as female according to their expressed gender identity and not their sex. But this consideration changes when the discrepancy between the person’s sex and gender identity permits them entry into single-sex spaces reserved for females when they are in fact biologically male, and in particular if they still have a penis. These spaces are segregated for the sake of fairness, because males are stronger and faster than females and females would barely stand a chance in athletics if they didn’t have their own category. And they are segregated for females’ perceived and actual security in spaces involving nudity, such as changing areas.
Quotes a post by T13953; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
One of the comments on my latest essay is from a parent who teaches at a gender studies program at a liberal arts college. Her son identified as trans but later desisted back to identifying as male. Like many parents of such kids, she is afraid to voice her concerns.
Quoting @benryanwriter: Avatars of Dem Alienation: Liberal Parents Wary About Their Kids’ Trans Identities
🧵⬇️ I report: Almost all the distressed parents who tell me they think their kids’ trans identities are not authentic are liberals who find themselves drifting away from the Democratic party.
“Holy shit, I ruined my face.”
On Lauren Greenfield’s powerful @[private account] docuseries Social Studies, a young trans woman (a biological male) has facial feminization surgery and realizes that not only were her expectations for the changes excessive, but she has regrets.
For minors who identify as trans, the term for reverting to presenting and identifying as one’s birth sex prior to taking cross-sex hormones is desisting; after hormones the term is detransitioning. This doesn’t change just because Erin says so.
The chief concern about detransitioning is not whether a child will revert to identifying as their birth sex after socially transitioning or taking blockers; it is whether they will do so after taking hormones, given the considerable irreversible changes they cause to the body.
And Erin has now magically changed what she said earlier about some of the 3,000 GIDS people being on the waiting list. The notorious GIDS waiting list included people who applied for GIDS services but were never seen.
This cohort of 3,000 GIDS patients was only comprised of people who had made it off the waiting list and were in the assessment process as the kids sought to be sent to endocrinology. The term for this is not the waiting list, not even if @ErinInTheMorn says it is.
Also, Erin Reed characteristically misses the point when she attempts to undermine what I wrote about the Olson study on gender transition outcomes in minors. The point is not that this cohort is young but that they began a trans identification and socially transitioned very young. They also had few other psychiatric problems outside of gender dysphoria. Considering this, and the fact that they are majority natal males, they are unlike the typical minor presenting at a pediatric gender clinic today, who is typically a natal female who only began expressing a trans identity and outward signs of gender-related distress in adolescence and who has a high rate of other psychiatric conditions.
My write-up: https://benryan.substack.com/p/high-rate-of-satisfaction-with-gender
@ErinInTheMorn's fumbling attempt to correct my work:
While the Supreme Court did not accept the @ACLU’s specific complaint in the case, it has nonetheless granted the nonprofit’s request for a chance to present during oral arguments on Dec 4 over Tennessee’s pediatric gender transition treatment ban. So @[private account] will become the first openly trans person to argue before the court. The case concerns the Biden Justice Department’s claim that Tennessee’s ban violates the Equal Protection Clause. The ACLU had sought but failed to get the court to consider a due process related complaint as well. If all goes well, I will be present at the oral arguments myself.
Questions remain over NHS youth gender care, despite Cass Review
Hannah Barnes @[private account] reports: One of the services treating the Tavistock's former patients appeared to be taking cues from American healthcare guidelines.
When NHS England’s national youth gender identity clinic closed earlier this year, it had a caseload of around 650 children and young people. Amid controversy over how the clinic was run, the Gender Identity Development Service (Gids) – part of the Tavistock and Portman NHS Foundation Trust, and the only such centre for those under 18 in England and Wales – was shut down on 28 March, to be replaced by a number of regional healthcare centres. Some of the young people on its books were sent to two new NHS England gender identity hubs, based in London and Liverpool. The majority – around 400 – however, had their care moved elsewhere.
Of those, some 190 were already 17 and therefore could be transferred to adult gender clinics. The remainder – around 210 young patients – were on the “endocrine pathway” and receiving either puberty blocking drugs or hormones to help them medically transition. When pressed by the New Statesman in March, NHS England confirmed that this latter group would be cared for by a “wraparound service” provided by Nottinghamshire Healthcare NHS Foundation Trust. This service, NHSE said, would work to the same interim service specification as the new gender services, while “recognising that not all of it will apply to this patient cohort”. NHSE insisted that these children would receive psycho-social support, including mental health care.
So last week, when a job advert appeared for a clinical psychologist at that wraparound service, saying something rather different, eyebrows were raised. It seemed the provision – now called the Nottingham Young People’s Gender Service (NYGS) – was looking for a clinician whose approach would align with methods that had contributed to the Gids clinic becoming so controversial in the first place. The job ad said it was “essential” that candidates “practice [sic] in a gender affirming manner in line with” the World Professional Association for Transgender Health’s (WPATH) Standard of Care 8 (SOC-8)”.
This new survey study on gender-dysphoric youth sheds important light on the trajectory of children who receive puberty blockers and cross-sex hormones. However, the study population, which was recruited up to a decade ago, is not necessarily reflective of the overall contemporary population of minors with gender dysphoria.
The kids in the survey study are overwhelmingly white and from affluent, supportive families; they are majority natal male; they began identifying as trans very young; they socially transitioned very young, largely before grade school; and they have few other psychological problems.
This is in stark contrast to the typical minor now presenting at Western pediatric gender clinics: a natal female who only first began expressing a trans identity in adolescence and who has a high number of other psychiatric conditions.
And so, importantly, this study cannot necessarily inform how most gender dysphoric children will fair if they receive puberty blockers and cross-sex hormones to treat the condition.
This has not stopped people such as Canadian senator @[private account] from making sweeping generalizations about the study's implications for all gender dysphoric youths.
https://benryan.substack.com/p/high-rate-of-satisfaction-with-gender
NEWS: High Rate Of Satisfaction With Gender-Transition Treatment In Adolescents Who Socially Transitioned Very Young, Study Finds
🧵I report: A major ongoing survey study of kids who expressed a transgender identity and ultimately socially transitioned in early childhood found that few who started gender-transition treatment regretted it.
Also for @[private account], on why his analogy about the APA in 1973 is a poor one: https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2024/05/03/transgender-puberty-blockers-science-cass-report/
A lot of the people who oppose pediatric gender medicine, in fact, so do because they are concerned that gay children are misunderstanding their nascent sexuality as a trans identity and are receiving puberty blockers and cross-sex hormones due to a misdiagnosis. They express particular concern given that such drugs can render young people infertile and prevent them from having sexual function. They see their struggle as one for gay rights and liberation, in fact.
My article in today's @NYPost:
THE TRANS TURNING POINT
The walls are closing in on pediatric gender medicine, as the Supreme Court weighs the constitutionality of state bans on treatments for gender dysphoric children and damaging revelations threaten the identity movement.
@chloecole @mtgreenee @RepMTG @ACLU @[private account] @[private account] @Riley_Gaines_ @SullyDish @[private account]
Quoting @benryanwriter: Pain, confusion and compassion: How the US has reached a trans ‘tipping point’
I report for @NYPost. See the🧵⬇️
Trans activists have long claimed that denying gender-transition drugs to minors will lead to suicide. But since five European nations have sharply restricted access to such drugs, no credible reports of mass suicide have emerged.
There was one discredited claim, by @JolyonMaugham of @[private account]. But after it was widely repeated by people like @[private account], the claim was denounced by the NHS’s suicide czar, Louis Appleby. Maugham then vanished from X for months and later returned just as his nonprofit announced it was leaving trans advocacy altogether.
Quoting @benryanwriter: 🧵Speaking with the @NYPost, @[private account], executive director of @[private account], which prioritizes counseling for gender-distressed youths, pointed to Europe as a preview for what will become of U.S. pediatric gender medicine.
A half-dozen systematic literature reviews have found the research behind pediatric gender-transition treatment is largely weak and inconclusive. Given the medications’ risks — particularly infertility — 5 European nations have responded by sharply restricting minors' access.
For now, the American field poses a stark contrast, with most leading voices calling for no such restraint, I report for @NYPost:
https://nypost.com/2024/10/19/us-news/pain-confusion-compassion-how-the-us-has-reached-a-trans-tipping-point/
“What makes this a medical scandal is that individuals and major organizations who promote fast-tracking gender transitions are digging in their heels and calling anyone who disagrees with their approach bigots and transphobes,” said @[private account], who coined the term “rapid-onset gender dysphoria.” #ROGD
“It’s as if their loyalty is to the transition interventions and not to the long-term health and well-being of transgender-identified young people,” Dr. Littman said.
https://benryan.substack.com/p/controversial-gender-researchers @chloecole
Ms. @[private account], who is trans, said she faulted trans activists for what she characterized as their heedlessness and radical demands. “Coexistence requires compromise,” she said. “But this set of activists is not willing to give anything up in return and that’s not reasonable.” https://benryan.substack.com/p/brianna-wus-dire-warning-for-transgender
And as for the political backlash that now threatens the rights and medical care of adult trans people, Ms. Wu said, “The impulse we have to blame everything on the right wing is so convenient. We are walking face-first into a cultural firestorm.” https://nypost.com/2024/10/19/us-news/pain-confusion-compassion-how-the-us-has-reached-a-trans-tipping-point/
Journalist Andrew Sullivan, who is gay, insists that gay children are being misclassified as trans and harmed by gender-transition treatment.
“It is probably the greatest mistake that the gay rights movement has ever made,” said Sullivan of the major LGBTQ advocacy nonprofits, such as @GLAAD and @[private account], throwing their might behind pediatric gender medicine. “I really don’t know that any of these organizations will ever take responsibility.” @SullyDish
I report for @NYPost: https://nypost.com/2024/10/19/us-news/pain-confusion-compassion-how-the-us-has-reached-a-trans-tipping-point/
🧵“There’s going to be a rude awakening,” Erica Anderson @[private account], a psychologist who is trans and the former head of @[private account]’s U.S. branch, said in anticipation that university-based pediatric gender clinics will generate bad publicity that will “hit the prestige” of their academic hosts.
“Trustees of hospitals are risk-averse,” she said. “They’re not activists.”
I report for @NYPost: https://nypost.com/2024/10/19/us-news/pain-confusion-compassion-how-the-us-has-reached-a-trans-tipping-point/
🧵The surge in youth trans identification began a decade ago. And detransitioning is estimated to take 5-10 years. Consequently, many pediatric gender experts expect the number of detransitioners will swell. And even if statutes of limitation block many from suing, a growing chorus of detransitioner reports could increasingly poison public opinion, I report for @NYPost.
https://nypost.com/2024/10/19/us-news/pain-confusion-compassion-how-the-us-has-reached-a-trans-tipping-point/
“If trans people think those stories are bad today, we’re going to have 100 times more in 5 years,” @[private account], executive director of the progressive political action committee @[private account] and a democratic operative, told me. See my interview with her here: https://benryan.substack.com/p/fbb1220c-d6bc-43e6-8045-a2a79af68491
🧵“At some point the sheer weight of human suffering caused by these mistreatments will force a reckoning,” said Vernadette Broyles, president of the Child & Parental Rights Campaign.
https://nypost.com/2024/10/19/us-news/pain-confusion-compassion-how-the-us-has-reached-a-trans-tipping-point/
The pendulum toward such a reckoning in pediatric gender medicine began to accelerate earlier this year, propelled by a torrent of damaging revelations.
Britain’s scathing Cass Review found that the field of youth dysphoria medicine was based on “remarkably weak evidence.”
https://benryan.substack.com/p/cass-review-author-denounces-as-baseless
https://www.nysun.com/article/major-u-k-report-finds-pediatric-gender-medicine-is-based-on-shaky-evidence?lctg=1439941306&recognized_email=nbkotch%40gmail.com&newsletter-access=&utm_source=MG&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=Evening%20Sun%20%202024-04-10
🧵No credible evidence has emerged from Europe of the wave of suicides that many trans activists insisted would result from denying minors gender-transition medications.
https://nypost.com/2024/10/19/us-news/pain-confusion-compassion-how-the-us-has-reached-a-trans-tipping-point/
The only study to directly address whether gender-transition treatment is tied to a lower youth suicide death rate actually revealed it was not.
The finding that such treatment is not “life saving” as supporters often claim, is but one revelation that could dampen support, I report for @NYPost:
https://nypost.com/2024/02/24/opinion/a-finnish-study-is-changing-how-we-approach-trans-kids/
🧵Speaking with the @NYPost, @[private account], executive director of @[private account], which prioritizes counseling for gender-distressed youths, pointed to Europe as a preview for what will become of U.S. pediatric gender medicine.
A half-dozen systematic literature reviews have found the research behind pediatric gender-transition treatment is largely weak and inconclusive. Given the medications’ risks — particularly infertility — 5 European nations have responded by sharply restricting minors' access.
For now, the American field poses a stark contrast, with most leading voices calling for no such restraint, I report for @NYPost:
https://nypost.com/2024/10/19/us-news/pain-confusion-compassion-how-the-us-has-reached-a-trans-tipping-point/
“What makes this a medical scandal is that individuals and major organizations who promote fast-tracking gender transitions are digging in their heels and calling anyone who disagrees with their approach bigots and transphobes,” said @[private account], who coined the term “rapid-onset gender dysphoria.” #ROGD
“It’s as if their loyalty is to the transition interventions and not to the long-term health and well-being of transgender-identified young people,” Dr. Littman said.
https://benryan.substack.com/p/controversial-gender-researchers @chloecole
🧵The past three years have been painful for transgender-identified young people. Republicans have blanketed the nation with bans on gender-transition treatments for minors, often pairing them with restrictions on trans bathroom access and sports participation. The latter has become of national interest as athletes like Lia Thomas and @Riley_Gaines_ battle for each side in public.
These laws have descended many families into crisis and even drove some to flee to bluer states.
The years to come are expected to bring more turmoil for these vulnerable youths as the walls close in on pediatric gender medicine, I report for @NYPost: https://nypost.com/2024/10/19/us-news/pain-confusion-compassion-how-the-us-has-reached-a-trans-tipping-point/
LINK: Pain, confusion and compassion: How the US has reached a trans ‘tipping point’
I report for @NYPost: 🧵⬇️
https://nypost.com/2024/10/19/us-news/pain-confusion-compassion-how-the-us-has-reached-a-trans-tipping-point/
Here’s my reporting on the only study to actually address this claim that the Kaiser doctor was making five years ago to this mom. https://nypost.com/2024/02/24/opinion/a-finnish-study-is-changing-how-we-approach-trans-kids/
Brianna Wu's Dire Warning For Transgender Activists:
"The Tactics We Are Using Are Failing."
My conversation with @[private account], a survivor—of Gamergate, addiction, and childhood dysphoria—who has charted a course right down the center of trans rights.
https://benryan.substack.com/p/brianna-wus-dire-warning-for-transgender
My prediction that the damning revelations about WPATH from the Alabama case would reach SCOTUS absolutely has come to pass: https://www.nysun.com/article/damning-information-about-trans-medical-group-expected-to-reach-supreme-court-as-justices-consider-challenge-to-ban-on-gender-treatments-for-minors?lctg=0&recognized_email=editors-group%40nysun.com&newsletter-access&utm_source=MG&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=Morning%20Sun%20%202024-07-10
Therefore the oral arguments are not expected to focus much on the science behind this medical field, rather on the arcane legal question of whether trans people can be considered a so-called quasi-suspect class warranting protection under the 14th Amendment.
I read this paper today: Advancing the Practice of Pediatric Psychology with Transgender Youth: State of the Science, Ongoing Controversies, and Future Directions. It said the following about minors’ capacity to consent to gender transition treatment:
“Decisional capacity-Consistent with concerns regarding decisional capacity among peripubertal youth, there also is debate regarding the competence of pubertal TGNC adolescents to consider the implications and weigh the risks and benefits of GAH treatment and gender-affirming surgical interventions, which carry arguably higher risk due to the partially or fully irreversible nature of treatment. Developments in cognitive neuroscience suggest that adolescents are less mature than adults specifically when making decisions under conditions characterized by emotional arousal and peer pressure (Steinberg, 2013).
While emotional arousal and peer pressure are typically minimized in the context of medical decision-making, anecdotally, decisions about gender-affirming medical treatments are often made in the context of significant emotional distress associated secondary to GD. Thus, one can argue that youth may be more likely to prioritize short-term benefits (e.g., initiating hormones) over long-term risks (e.g., compromised fertility).” https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC5969520/
Briana Wu continues to chart a unique path in trans advocacy, speaking out against what she sees as trans activists’ excesses and what she characterizes as their counterproductive extremism:
Quotes a post by a private account; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Gender dysphoria is not guaranteed to be a lifelong condition for those who experience it during childhood. There is no way of knowing which child has permanent GD and which are among those, likely in the majority, who will grow out of the condition.
Also, trans men do get pregnant and have babies despite their GD. Not all need it want their ovaries removed.
New Evidence Challenges Institutionalized Belief That Transgender Teens Become Transgender Adults, Undermining Core Defense of Medical Gender Transitions for Minors https://www.nysun.com/article/new-evidence-challenges-institutionalized-belief-that-transgender-teens-become-transgender-adults-undermining-core-defense-of-medical-gender-transitions-for-minors?member_gift=CUZ5qwd3crq4pmz-xrd
Trans activists are not happy that Hilary Cass has been given a peerage. @AriDrennen of Media Matters lambasts Cass for saying that US docs are "out of date" on pediatric gender medicine while participating in an ancient British ceremony. @[private account] calls it "disgusting".
Quoting @benryanwriter: Dr. Hilary Cass, author of the Cass Review, has been made a baroness.
A study found a causal inference between: a) state laws that restrict sports participation and bathroom access by biological sex; and b) state bans on gender-transition treatment and a 7%-72% higher rate of reported suicide attempts by youth who identify as trans/nonbinary.🧵⬇️⬇️
Quotes a post by T24786; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
In Aug. 2023, the @[private account] said it would commission a systematic literature review of the evidence behind gender-transition treatment for children. But there is no sign that they have started such a review. https://www.nysun.com/article/the-aap-files-inside-feud-within-american-academy-of-pediatrics-torn-over-transgender-issues-about-groups-decision-to-hold-meeting-in-anti-lgbtq-florida-of-ron-desantis?member_gift=CUZ5qwd3crq4pmz-xrd
By declining to pull its annual conference out of Florida, the state's LGBTQ policies notwithstanding, the @[private account] has set a striking contrast to 2016, when numerous businesses pulled business out of NC and compelled the legislature to repeal its trans bathroom law.
My investigation on internal tensions at the @[private account] over transgender issues is based upon 100s of internal emails and documents I obtained via public-records requests. I have published a wide selection of these documents in this appendix:
https://benryan.substack.com/p/the-aap-files-complete-american-academy
PAYWALL-FREE LINK:
The AAP Files: Inside Feud Within American Academy of Pediatrics, Torn Over Transgender Issues, About Group’s Decision To Hold Meeting in ‘Anti-LGBTQ’ Florida of Ron DeSantis
Rachel Levine is the keynote speaker.
https://www.nysun.com/article/the-aap-files-inside-feud-within-american-academy-of-pediatrics-torn-over-transgender-issues-about-groups-decision-to-hold-meeting-in-anti-lgbtq-florida-of-ron-desantis?member_gift=CUZ5qwd3crq4pmz-xrd
The AAP Files: Inside Feud Within American Academy of Pediatrics, Torn Over Transgender Issues, About Group’s Decision To Hold Meeting in ‘Anti-LGBTQ’ Florida of Ron DeSantis
🧵My investigation for @[private account], based on hundreds of internal @[private account] emails obtained via public-records requests: "By contrast, the AAP has tapped Biden health official Rachel Levine as a keynote speaker, even after revelations that they both meddled in the drafting of another organization’s transgender-care guidelines."
New study finds that "starting in the first year after anti-transgender laws were enacted, there were statistically significant increases in rates of past-year suicide attempts among TGNB young people ages 13–17 in states that enacted anti-transgender laws, relative to states that did not, and for all TGNB young people beginning in the second year. Enacting state-level anti-transgender laws increased incidents of past-year suicide attempts among TGNB young people by 7–72%." https://www.nature.com/articles/s41562-024-01979-5.epdf
Kindly read and share my newsletter on the flaws of this @[private account] primer on reporting on trans care:
Quoting @benryanwriter: LINK:
The Association of Health Care Journalists Has Published a Highly Misleading Primer on Covering Transgender Medicine
One would hope that this leader in promoting fine health and science journalism would do better.
https://open.substack.com/pub/benryan/p/the-association-of-health-care-journalists
In a new primer on reporting accurately on transgender medicine published by the Association of Health Care Journalists, they oddly suggest that the bans of gender-transition treatment in 26 states applies to all trans people. This is false; those bans apply to minors.
Quoting @benryanwriter: 2. Omitting who the gender-transition bans target
This passage omits the crucial detail that the vast majority of state bans on gender-transition treatment concern minors, not adults. Since 2021, Republicans in 24 states have passed bans on minors accessing puberty blockers, cross-sex hormones and gender-transition surgeries to treat gender dysphoria. Two others, Arizona and New Hampshire, have only banned such surgeries for minors.
It is the more uncommon state, such as Florida, that has passed a law that at the very least complicates adult access to cross-sex hormones. That state’s law, for example, requires that only MDs write such prescriptions; whereas most trans adults get their hormones from nurse practitioners and there aren’t enough MDs to meet the demand.
https://benryan.substack.com/p/the-association-of-health-care-journalists
Here’s why your primer on reporting about trans medicine is flawed:
Quoting @benryanwriter: LINK:
The Association of Health Care Journalists Has Published a Highly Misleading Primer on Covering Transgender Medicine
One would hope that this leader in promoting fine health and science journalism would do better.
https://open.substack.com/pub/benryan/p/the-association-of-health-care-journalists
I heard back from the folks at the Association of Health Care Journalists @[private account] about the flawed primer they published on reporting about trans medicine after I sent them my newsletter outlining major errors and omissions:
Quoting @benryanwriter: The Association of Health Care Journalists Has Published a Highly Misleading Primer on Covering Trans Issues
One would hope that this leader in promoting fine health and science journalism would do better. See the 🧵for 🚨fact checks🚨. ⬇️⬇️
4. Credulously citing Tordoff, and doing so incorrectly
Jesse Singal, with a world weariness that is well-earned after having previously explained in such exacting detail why the Tordoff et al paper is deeply misleading and flawed, pointed out on X on Friday how the AHCJ primer is credulously referencing the flawed paper twice while also referencing a World Professional Association for Transgender Health (WPATH)-commissioned systematic literature review, Baker et al, that revealed the weakness of the data behind gender-transition treatment.
The Tordoff study, first off, did not concern adults, as ACHJ suggests. It was a study of 104 adolescents and young adults 13 to 20 years old, that started with some of them having received gender-transition treatment. After 12 months, 69 had started such medications.
The study authors claimed that in comparison to the untreated group, the treated youths had lower suicidality and depression. But as Singal has reported, the mental-health markers of the treatment group did not change over the 12 months. What changed was the composition of the untreated comparison group, which was plagued by considerable loss to follow-up. At the 12-month mark, just five participants in the untreated comparison group provided mental-health-related data; and this small group was especially unwell in that regard. I remains possible that those who left the study did so because they were feeling well, thus biasing the study findings.
https://benryan.substack.com/p/the-association-of-health-care-journalists
2. Omitting who the gender-transition bans target
This passage omits the crucial detail that the vast majority of state bans on gender-transition treatment concern minors, not adults. Since 2021, Republicans in 24 states have passed bans on minors accessing puberty blockers, cross-sex hormones and gender-transition surgeries to treat gender dysphoria. Two others, Arizona and New Hampshire, have only banned such surgeries for minors.
It is the more uncommon state, such as Florida, that has passed a law that at the very least complicates adult access to cross-sex hormones. That state’s law, for example, requires that only MDs write such prescriptions; whereas most trans adults get their hormones from nurse practitioners and there aren’t enough MDs to meet the demand.
https://benryan.substack.com/p/the-association-of-health-care-journalists
1. Promoting the at-times incoherent Science editorial
This editorial in Science, written by a pair of leaders in the gender-medicine field, is laden with misleading claims and a general incoherence in its arguments. I would hope that science and medical journalists would be able to detect these problems.
For example, the Science essay claims that there is “mischaracterization of [trans and gender-diverse] health science by non-expert, anti-TGD political activists as lacking supportive evidence and potentially causing harm.”
And yet in its opening paragraph, the AHCJ primer refers to Britain's Cass Review. This 388-page document, which concluded that pediatric gender-transition treatment is based upon “remarkably weak evidence,” was written by the UK’s leading pediatrician following a four-year effort. It was based on seven systematic literature reviews written by evidence-based medicine, or EBM, experts at the University of York. Those reviews joined with five other such previous reviews, also written by EBM experts, in finding that the science behind pediatric gender medicine is weak and inconclusive.
So it is highly misleading to suggest that only “nonexperts” have come to such a conclusion.
https://benryan.substack.com/p/the-association-of-health-care-journalists
As @JesseSingal pointed on Friday, a new primer on reporting about transgender health care published by the Association of Health Care Journalists @[private account] is a highly misleading and at times outright false document.
https://x.com/jessesingal/status/1834440815831089637
Quoting @jessesingal: I don't know what to say anymore, man. There are just no adults left at most of these supposed gatekeeping and quality-control institutions within journalism.
https://healthjournalism.org/blog/2024/09/heres-what-the-limited-research-we-have-on-transgender-health-tells-us/
LINK:
The Association of Health Care Journalists Has Published a Highly Misleading Primer on Covering Transgender Medicine
One would hope that this leader in promoting fine health and science journalism would do better.
https://open.substack.com/pub/benryan/p/the-association-of-health-care-journalists
The Association of Health Care Journalists Has Published a Highly Misleading Primer on Covering Trans Issues
One would hope that this leader in promoting fine health and science journalism would do better. See the 🧵for 🚨fact checks🚨. ⬇️⬇️
The Wall Street Journal recently reported that despite the blowback against JK Rowling against her positions and statements about trans issues, the Harry Potter brand remains wildly popular and profitable.
Quotes a post by T05940; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Meanwhile:
Cass Review Author Denounces As 'Baseless' And 'Cynical' Dissidents' Claim That She Touted Abigail Shrier's Scathing Polemic On Trans Kids
https://benryan.substack.com/p/cass-review-author-denounces-as-baseless
Dr. Kaltiala is a coauthor of the study that found that providing gender-transition treatment to young people isn't associated with a difference in the rate of suicide death, but that such deaths are still rare among gender dysphoric youth.
https://nypost.com/2024/02/24/opinion/a-finnish-study-is-changing-how-we-approach-trans-kids/
But Urquhart did not provide a translation of the essay, nor did not quote from it. I obtained a translation myself. I found that Dr. Kaltialia did indeed express strong reservations about the potential benefits of a medical gender-transition for young people. However, she explicitly remained open to the possibility.
She stated: “Adolescent identity development is in process and identity confusion is common among young patients of psychiatric clinics. The risk of iatrogenic damage [when a medical treatment causes harm] to youth when rushing the treatment of their gender identity disorder is great. However, if the trans youth has good mental health and a stable and supportive family life, it is shown that they will benefit from blocking puberty and hormonal treatment to change the features of their gender.” https://benryan.substack.com/p/rubbishfinlands-top-pediatric-gender
On July 30, American journalist Evan Urquhart published on his independent news site, @[private account], a scathing account of a handful of young Finnish transgender people who had sought care for gender dysphoria through the nation’s gender-clinic system. Cowritten with the Finnish writer Esa Kalliomäki, the article boldly asserted: “Former patients say rude staff, uncomfortable questions about masturbation, years of assessment with no therapeutic support, and abrupt dismissals without any treatment made the experience a living hell.” https://benryan.substack.com/p/rubbishfinlands-top-pediatric-gender
For all the background, see:
Cass Review Author Denounces As 'Baseless' And 'Cynical' Dissidents' Claim That She Touted @AbigailShrier's Scathing Polemic On Trans Kids
https://benryan.substack.com/p/cass-review-author-denounces-as-baseless
Dr. @[private account] has also been in contact with me regarding the update to my recent newsletter (https://benryan.substack.com/p/cass-review-author-denounces-as-baseless) about his back-and-forth with Dr. Hilary Cass in which I cited a fellow member of the NHS's 2020 NICE review, Richard Stephens. Dr. Davie denounced Stephens, saying Stephens is a member of a group called Bayswater. who, Dr. Davie said: "have promoted conversion therapy for trans young people. https://web.archive.org/web/20221219222600/https://www.bayswatersupport.org.uk/books/desist-detrans-and-detox/ They have also been exposed as taking a very harsh and concerning attitude to their gender diverse offspring. https://www.thebureauinvestigates.com/stories/2024-07-02/one-day-they-may-thank-us-for-that-abuse-inside-the-bayswater-support-group/. I do think his connection with the group is worthy of mention." 2/
Delaware state senator and congressional candidate Sarah McBride upbraids the Biden administration for taking a position against gender-transition surgeries for minors. A former press secretary for @[private account], McBride is the highest ranking trans politician in the U.S.
The political pressure that Admiral Rachel Levine put on @[private account] to remove age restrictions on pediatric sex-transition treatment is already starting to show up in litigation. A U.S. district court granted a stay and injunction of Florida's effort to avoid being subject to Biden administration rules requiring Medicaid coverage of such treatment, per what's known as Section 1557 under the Affordable Care Act.
In the injunction, the district court judge referred to Levine: "At times the HHS position about 'gender affirming care' seems to be political. It is no surprise to any observer that politics on both sides of this issue are prevalent. Concerning the parties here, HHS’s Assistant Secretary Levine previously urged the medical/advocacy group World Professional Association for Transgender Health ('WPATH') to drop proposed age limits for minor transgender surgery. The age limits in the proposed WPATH guidelines were 15 for mastectomies, 16 for breast augmentation or facial surgeries, and 17 for hysterectomies. Levine’s staff informed WPATH that Levine was 'confident, based on the rhetoric she is hearing in D.C., and from what we have already seen, that these specific lists of ages, under 18, will result in devastating legislation for trans care. [Levine] wonder[s] if the specific ages can be taken out.' Levine’s staff went on to tell WPATH that Levine 'was very concerned that having ages (mainly for surgery) will affect access to care for trans youth and maybe adults, too…” Levine’s staff asked WPATH to remove the age limitations in the guidance for gender transition.12 The WPATH has removed age limitations for minors on its guidance for transition surgeries.'"
Michael Joyner sued his employer, @[private account], after they disciplined him over, for one, an interview he gave to @[private account] for @nytimes in which he said that research indicates trans women hold a competitive advantage in women’s swimming in an article about Lia Thomas.
Quotes a post by T31316; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The Biden administration is not banning gender-transition surgeries. Also, that is not a correct reading of the findings in that study, which identified 146 breast reductions in boys and more than 80 chest surgeries in trans minors in the database in 2019 (this did not cover all US minors). Confusingly, the study separated what it called chest-related gender-affirming surgical procedures (82 trans minors got these) from what it called breast reductions (5 trans minors got these and 146 boys got them). An estimated 1.4% of adolescents identify as trans.
In a newly unsealed internal email, WPATH leader Jon Arcelus offered scathing words about the American Academy of Pediatrics' 2018 policy statement on the gender-affirming care method and on its own leaders' expertise in transgender care.
Quoting @benryanwriter: The AAP, according to a WPATH leader, is not a leader in caring for trans kids:
Jon Arcelus of WPATH, in an email to colleagues on Sept. 9, 2022, clearly disagreed that AAP are the experts on caring for trans kids. After the AAP pressed WPATH to remove age limits on surgeries in particular, Arcelus wrote: "The AAP guidlines that the mentioned so many times have a very weak methodology, written by a few friends who think the same."
He's referring to the 2018 policy statement, which actually has a single author, Dr. Jason Rafferty, who was still a resident when he wrote it. (It was heavily edited by committees at the AAP, note.)
Arcelus also wrote (seeming to mean "We can't write a document that looks like theirs"): "We can't not write a document that looks like theirs, as it has a one-sided narrative, extremely biased. I will be surprised in [sic] their guidelines are used at all. Looking at the AAP people in Google, they clearly see a group of trans people that I don't recognize, where gender identity appear always at childhood, that is non my experience."
He said that of following the AAP's lead and removing the age limits: "This will make a joke of our methodology and [people] will see us as weak."
Here is the AAP policy statement: https://publications.aap.org/pediatrics/article/142/4/e20182162/37381/Ensuring-Comprehensive-Care-and-Support-for
Here is a scathing rebuttal and fact check by @[private account] to which the AAP has never replied, even to make corrections in the document, which they reaffirmed with no changes last August. https://www.ohchr.org/sites/default/files/Documents/Issues/SexualOrientation/IESOGI/Other/Rebekah_Murphy_20191214_JamesCantor-fact-checking_AAP-Policy.pdf
Here is an article on the detransitioner lawsuit accusing the AAP of conspiracy for using the patient to devise a non-evidence based policy statment: https://www.nysun.com/article/lawsuits-by-regretful-detransitioners-take-aim-at-medical-establishments-support-for-gender-transition-treatments-for-minors?newsletter-access&utm_source=MG&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=Morning%20Sun%20%202023-12-06
The AAP, according to a WPATH leader, is not a leader in caring for trans kids:
Jon Arcelus of WPATH, in an email to colleagues on Sept. 9, 2022, clearly disagreed that AAP are the experts on caring for trans kids. After the AAP pressed WPATH to remove age limits on surgeries in particular, Arcelus wrote: "The AAP guidlines that the mentioned so many times have a very weak methodology, written by a few friends who think the same."
He's referring to the 2018 policy statement, which actually has a single author, Dr. Jason Rafferty, who was still a resident when he wrote it. (It was heavily edited by committees at the AAP, note.)
Arcelus also wrote (seeming to mean "We can't write a document that looks like theirs"): "We can't not write a document that looks like theirs, as it has a one-sided narrative, extremely biased. I will be surprised in [sic] their guidelines are used at all. Looking at the AAP people in Google, they clearly see a group of trans people that I don't recognize, where gender identity appear always at childhood, that is non my experience."
He said that of following the AAP's lead and removing the age limits: "This will make a joke of our methodology and [people] will see us as weak."
Here is the AAP policy statement: https://publications.aap.org/pediatrics/article/142/4/e20182162/37381/Ensuring-Comprehensive-Care-and-Support-for
Here is a scathing rebuttal and fact check by @[private account] to which the AAP has never replied, even to make corrections in the document, which they reaffirmed with no changes last August. https://www.ohchr.org/sites/default/files/Documents/Issues/SexualOrientation/IESOGI/Other/Rebekah_Murphy_20191214_JamesCantor-fact-checking_AAP-Policy.pdf
Here is an article on the detransitioner lawsuit accusing the AAP of conspiracy for using the patient to devise a non-evidence based policy statment: https://www.nysun.com/article/lawsuits-by-regretful-detransitioners-take-aim-at-medical-establishments-support-for-gender-transition-treatments-for-minors?newsletter-access&utm_source=MG&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=Morning%20Sun%20%202023-12-06
WPATH had internal dissent over its controversial eunuchs chapter in its Standards of Care 8 trans-care guidelines
Internal communications, subpoenaed and newly unsealed as part of the Alabama court case over the state's pediatric gender-transition ban, reveal such dissent. 🧵