The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
I fell for a lot of progressive nonsense, and hard. I was literally trans. But two things I can honestly say I never fell for were
1. alternative ways of knowing. Science obviously works, and it’s hard to even coherently describe an alternative. What, you aren’t taking in data or trying to parse it without contradiction? What are you even talking about? I was a new atheist technocratic progressive, and thought the extent to which other groups failed at scientific thinking was a result of disadvantage, but never that scientific thinking itself was bad. Same with everything on that smithsonian chart (being on time etc)
2. Strong anti-hereditarianism. I believed racial average differences were due to discrimination (to the extent I thought about the issue at all, which was infrequently) but the belief that *all* human cognitive differences, even within groups, are due to upbringing was always just facially absurd. There exists such a thing as a smart person, and there are aspects of it that clearly aren’t about education. They talk faster. They’re funnier. They learn *new* concepts faster. Their questions are sharper. It’s textural. It’s visceral. I didn’t know anything about psychometrics or the hereditarian debate at this point. It’s just obvious if you’ve met three humans and are honest.
Quoting @ArtemisConsort: Do these people not believe in genetics at all? Forget any racial angle, this sounds like a complete denial that genes determine anything significant about human behavior/capabilities. I guess Brock Lesnar has a giant muscly daughter because he gave her weights instead of dolls.
Trans people are murdered at a lower rate than non-trans people. So many people are living in an entirely fake nightmare world. If you’re going to make up your own reality, why not a pleasant one?
A significant amount of the trans suicide rate is attributable to comorbidities - people who identify as trans also tend to have a bunch of other mental illnesses. But based on my own experience and those of people I knew, I also think it has a causal effect on mental illness.
It really is exhausting and deranging to stake your whole identity on your ability to create a false impression in the minds of other people. It’s not healthy to think that much about what other people think about you.
Yes this is anecdotal speculation, not proof, but I believe it.
Quotes a post by T05832; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
The concept of exceptionalism diagnoses something real and important, but I don’t think it’s the entire or deepest part of the story of progressivism. Because sometimes progressives do the opposite: ignore nuances that *do* matter. Black people are poorer on average, so let’s give bonus points in admissions to this child of Nigerian immigrant doctors. You have a list of “trans woman” sex criminals? Those are just a few cases, we shouldn’t overindex on those.
The deepest level, I believe, is evasion of responsibility. This shows up at many layers of the progressive apparatus.
Obviously poorly performing minorities like narratives that absolve them of blame (though hereditarianism is not blame per se, it’s also unflattering) and promise them free stuff that they’re “owed”. Direct benefit to them, diffuse costs.
For rank-and-file White progressives, they can evade the responsibility of facing uncomfortable truths or acknowledging trade-offs. Say the platitudes, vote correctly, and you’re a good person. It’s hard to tell someone “yes your life isn’t great, but any system that would make it better would be worse overall, so we’re not helping you.” That’s tough. It’s much more comfortable to believe paradise is just over that hill, and all we have to do is wave enough protest signs around and be Decent People™️. Direct benefit to them, diffuse costs.
For politicians, they can essentially bribe client groups with handouts while telling themselves, or at least telling us, that it’s all in a good cause. Direct benefit to them, diffuse costs.
For business elites (particularly on the issue of mass immigration) they can benefit from cheaper labor while externalizing all of the costs of cultural dissolution onto everyone else. Direct benefit to them, diffuse costs.
What the authors of this piece call “exceptionalism” is a frequently used tool in the progressive toolbox, and it’s useful to have a name for it, but it is only a tool. The fundamental issue is evasion of responsibility, which is to say the externalization of costs onto other people or society as a whole, which is to say parasitism.
Quotes a post by A0762; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Math-brain
Two foundational concepts in math are the quantifiers “for every” and “there exists”
Example: “for every real number x, there exists a real number y such that x+y=0”
The outer quantifier “for every” means the statement applies to all real numbers without exception. The inner quantifier “there exists” means that, given your choice of x, there is at least one y which satisfies the statement.
“For every” statements can be disproven by a single counterexample. For example, the statement “for every prime number x, x is odd” is disproven by the fact that *there exists* the prime number 2. The fact that this is the only counterexample out of an infinite set of primes doesn’t matter. The universal claim is as false as it would be if every single prime were even.
not “for every” = “there exists” not
These are part of the basic language of set theory. And many academics who aren’t mathematicians also learn them in a logic class. But they’re a very poor grammar for thinking about the external world.
In physical and social reality, hardly any concepts are utterly precise the way they are in math. They are not defined by logical propositions, but rather by vague clouds of data points.
“Chair” is the most common example. There is no airtight, exception-free definition of a chair. Give any definition you want, and I’ll find something commonly called a chair that doesn’t satisfy it, or something not commonly called a chair that does.
This is illustrated in a (possibly apocryphal) episode between Plato and Diogenes. Plato was asked for a definition of Man and said “featherless biped”. Diogenes runs in holding a plucked chicken and says “behold, a man!”
Less humorously, math-brain is responsible for some of the dumbest arguments in politics. Consider the trans advocates who challenge any definition of sex by pointing out some 0.000001% prevalence disorder that they don’t even have. Or the people who respond to generalizations with anecdotal exceptions. Or the people who think the solution to illegal immigration is to just legalize them all. Boom! For every immigrant, that immigrant is now legal. Solved. That was your problem right? The technical legality?
The basic issue is acting as if discrete language could ever carve continuous reality* perfectly, and selectively using its failure to do so to bog down conversations when *we all know what we mean*. No one consistently does this across the board, because it would render all thinking impossible. Rather, it is a rhetorical tool for derailing substantive debate.
Don’t humor it. Don’t engage with it. Don’t get lost in the weeds. All practical categories are approximate, none are exact. If someone pretends they don’t know what you mean based on some math-brained hair splitting when they clearly do know what you mean, write them off as a liar.
*this is not a claim about the nature of fundamental physics
**despite calling this concept math-brain, I don’t think mathematicians are especially prone to it. Less so, if anything.
Gladwell is at least gesturing at a real principle: politics should be reciprocal. If you ask for something, you should also offer something. This principle, applied across the board, would be a Godsend for our politics.
That said, the trans issue has a weak bargaining position. There is no benefit to any non-trans person. So no, we don’t have to compromise. You are offering nothing, so you should expect nothing.
Quoting @salltweets: In a very, very strong field, this is one of the stupidest things ever said in response to gender ideology.
“It’s irresolvable” - @[private account]
They’re men. They compete in men’s sports & use men’s spaces. Men accommodate them.
There, solved it.
This is just the trans thing but for ethnicity.
“Well they live their lives as English”
“Englishness is socially constructed”
“What about this weird edge case that doesn’t apply to 99% of the people we’re trying to assign an artificial English identity to?”
Quotes a post by T12728; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
So far, the decline in “LGBT” is primarily in young women identifying as bisexual.
Prediction: trans identity will fall off a cliff. Bisexual identity will continue to decline. We will see small declines in lesbian identification, and very small declines in gay identification.
Model: that which is socially constructed will be most responsive to social changes. Gay is a real thing. Lesbian is too, though a lot of currently identified lesbians are not trait-lesbians. Bisexual identity among women is almost all social signaling. Bisexual, trans, and even some gay identity among men is largely driven by autogynephilia which is also real but has a highly socially mutable range of expression. A ton of guys will go back to privately fantasizing and give up on social expression of their paraphilia.
Quotes a post by T10522; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I’ll address the substance of these critiques that “the trans identity of a rapist has nothing to do with her [sic] crime”.
Rape is perhaps the most overwhelmingly, characteristically male crime. The fact that someone is a man claiming to be a woman is therefore necessarily entangled with him committing rape. This is evidence that he is not a woman even in whatever nebulous behavioral or psychological sense is meant by the concept “gender”. Obviously he is male as a fact about his biology, but he is also male in any conceivable spiritual sense.
And worse, he is demanding access to protected women’s spaces, spaces that exist precisely because things like rape are characteristically male, inextricably “gendered” behaviors. So very obviously we cannot simply ignore his trans identity or treat it as incidental.
Quoting @Slatzism: troons are currently dogpiling and threatening a girl because she isn’t “respecting” the “gender identity” of the troon who raped her sister. incredible stuff.
~All mental health problems are mutually positively correlated, allowing us to construct a p-factor of general psychopathology analogous to the g-factor of general intelligence. Then we can examine the extent to which other sociological variables are p-loaded.
Trans identity is extremely p-loaded. This could be the entire explanation for trans violence: already disturbed people self-select into being trans. As far as I’m aware, there isn’t great evidence addressing the issue of whether transition itself exacerbates violent tendencies, and it’s hard to imagine how such evidence could be collected.
But personally, it doesn’t seem implausible to me that transition does worsen mental health. It definitely did for me. It encourages you to focus on an unattainable goal to the exclusion of all else, to fixate on how others perceive you, to externalize your unhappiness onto the injustices you perceive society to be inflicting on you.
Quoting @clairlemon: We Need to Talk About Trans-Identified Killers
https://quillette.com/2025/10/16/we-need-to-talk-about-trans-identified-killers/
C3 dehumanizinghand-codedmental illnessviolence terror
Framing these as “is” claims is inherently obfuscatory, and I think it reflects their actual thoughts. They actually believe “trans women are women” is a descriptive claim, not merely an assertion of policy/social preference. They think policy should track this “fact”.
Even when right wingers are truly crazy, they still speak in sentences with content. “Lizard aliens control the government” is false, but it is comprehensible as a sentence. It has (false) content.
Mainstream liberals speak in completely vacuous platitudes. “No human being is illegal,” “trans women are women,” “healthcare is a human right.” None of these sentences even rises to the level of being false. They have no content whatsoever. They’re ritualistic chants, but people act like they’re not only arguments, but self-evidently correct ones.
“I think we should institute medicare for all” or “we should have open borders” have content. I disagree, but I can interact with those statements. “Healthcare is a human right” and “no human being is illegal” are completely empty.
They seem to be trying to repackage “ought” claims as “is” claims, but the result is something totally meaningless.
Quotes a post by A1824; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Whoever you fund to try to displace the incumbents, please be aware that there are only two fundamental attractors in modern American political/ideological space. Seemingly unrelated things are highly correlated. If someone mouths trans or race platitudes, they will absolutely institute a wealth tax given the chance, whatever they promise you on private calls.
On trans brain scans:
There are fairly significant differences, *on average*, between male and female brains. While the distributions of e.g. the size of a given brain region relative to body size overlap, we can guess someone’s sex from a brain scan with high reliability.
Some studies have shown that transgender people have brains that are, on average, more like those of the opposite sex.
Before we debunk this, it’s important to point out how limited even this faulty evidence was. Studies did not show they have brains smack-dab in the center of the opposite-sex cluster. Rather, it’s a modest shift in that direction relative to other members of their actual sex.
Now the bigger problem: these results are confounded by sexuality. Homosexuals in general show this shift in brain structure. Homosexuals are also more likely to identify as trans. But controlling for sexuality, we see *no cross-sex shift among those who identify as trans*. There are still some statistically significant brain differences, but they are not cross-sex shifts.
So unless you want to say that all homosexuals are trans, and all non-homosexual people identifying as trans are disqualified, the brain sex argument fails. Most people with cross-sex-shifted brains do not identify as trans, and most people who identify as trans do not have cross-sex-shifted brains.
On some level, trans activists know this, which is why they oppose diagnosis based on brain scan. They know that “transfem culture” looks totally different from actual female culture. Typical “male-to-female” interests include video games, programming, and political extremism. Having known plenty of these people, they don’t feel feminine or womanly on an interpersonal level either.
And, to be clear, diagnosis by brain scan would in fact be a bad idea. But not because it would unfairly exclude people who should be allowed to medically transition. It’s a bad idea because a cross-sex brain is not a reliable indicator of gender dysphoria. It is an indicator of homosexuality.
This is admittedly anecdotal, but based on my own experience I do not believe gender dysphoria is necessarily a persistent condition at all. I used to really, genuinely be dysphoric. It caused me a lot of pain. Transition did not help. In fact, it just caused me to fixate on it more. Now I don’t experience dysphoria. That’s not statistical evidence, but it is at least an existence proof.
The problem with using brain scans to diagnose gender dysphoria is the assumption that gender dysphoria is an innate, inborn condition, rather than a social contagion that some types of minds are more susceptible to than others.
The precursor conditions - typically homosexuality and autogynephilia for MtFs - are real and probably to some extent innate, but I do not believe that the resultant gender dysphoria is.
Quotes a post by A2445; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
This is worth more focus: when I was trans and a progressive, embedded in those spaces, I saw firsthand how nothing could ever satisfy them. The level of psychopathology is infinite. Even if you endorse all the right positions, you probably didn’t endorse them in the right way.
There was constant internal policing. Any time a lesbian said something referring to vaginas, it was exclusionary. Any time *another trans person* characterized the trans experience in terms of actually doing stuff (taking hormones, surgery, trying to pass) that was also exclusionary of people who didn’t do that stuff. Literally anything concrete was shouted down because it excluded someone.
This is fundamental. Any category is defined as much by what it excludes as what it includes. If you make inclusion your god, then your words must necessarily lose all meaning. Language exists to carve reality into an inside and outside. If you ban the concept of outside, you ban thought.
Quoting @ArtemisConsort: Just to illustrate the escalating hysteria of gender ideology:
Most progressives I knew would have vehemently rejected Kristol’s claim that he knows men who became women. They were ALWAYS women. How are you supposed to tell? What does “woman” mean? Shut up.
I used to be fairly immersed in the new atheist scene, and it was weird to watch people who, in the context of religion, were extreme epistemic sticklers fall for the sloppiest leftist arguments. The same people who would meticulously pick apart studies claiming to show evidence for the efficacy of prayer would accept studies on trans healthcare based on self report and with huge loss-to-follow-up as the definitive final word on the matter. The same people always hammering unfalsifiable religious claims and god-of-the-gaps arguments not only accepted but furiously preached “systemic discrimination” which maximally exemplifies both fallacies, always retreating from the advance of clear evidence and becoming ever-more vague.
Frankly it shook my faith in reason as a tool in public debate. Most people, even most smart people, even most people who’ve made a study of epistemology, deploy their knowledge as a weapon in the service of fundamentally tribal ends. The number of people genuinely trying to understand the world is vanishingly small.
Sure. I am generally anti-collectivist. That seems fine. And if we’re being quantitative, the evidence for vaccine efficacy is many orders of magnitude greater than the evidence for trans medicine which is basically at astrology levels of proof.
I don’t support mass institutionalization. I do think doctors should stop lying about the supposed mental health benefits of cross-sex hormones for dysphorics. But regardless, neither policy can be honestly described as stopping trans *people* from existing.
No policy could make the people who currently identify as trans “not exist”. You mean we deny the legitimacy of their cross-sex identities, which is not remotely the same thing.
Typical trans woman hobbies include rust programming, competitive gaming, and porn. Is that psychologically feminine? If they aren’t mental women, and they aren’t physical women, in what sense are they women?
I generally don’t assume a victim posture regarding my transition and detransition. I chose it as an adult. I fell for the propaganda. I assumed The Experts™️ were basing their advice on sound evidence, because the idea that they were just making it up was too crazy and implied too many drastic errors in my overall worldview. That’s on me. And I got out with only cosmetic damage.
But it really is a crime that doctors promote these experimental treatments as lifesaving when there is no methodologically sound evidence that they improve mental health at all, while the measurable physical health risks are well-documented. No non-politicized medical treatment would be approved based on the quality of evidence that supports transition procedures.
And even this unsupported frame - that dysphoria is a mental illness mitigated by transition - is not what trans activists are pushing. They believe they really are the opposite sex in some impenetrable metaphysical sense. I could never bring myself to believe that even when I was taking hormones. It’s all madness. We will look back on it in the future the way we look at witch burnings today.
Quoting @genspect: “I’m Developing Entirely New Side Effects From Having My Entire Biology Messed With”
Watch Jonni's account in full here: https://youtu.be/XBFiRA0efDk