The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
The only unifying theme on the left is hatred of Western civilization. What do trans activists, radical feminists, illegal immigrants, and Muslim fraudsters have in common? Only a desire to destroy the most successful nations in history out of greed, bitterness, and envy.
Quoting @wil_da_beast630: You guys will LITERALLY ride for any scum opposed to mainstream America.
Sure - we have some gross political crooks on squad too, but this really is amazing. Somali fraudsters ("How important IS it for a school to spell 'learning' correctly?!")....international narco-traffickers ("THAT is now confirmed - but all we've found so far is weed bales!!!")....male illegal alien human traffickers of girls ("Kilmar belongs in his HOME!!!")....plain Black criminals who try to kill cops (Michael Brown, Jacob Blake, Rayshard Brooks, get the encyclopedia out)....transgender male rapists in women's prison, etc.
I would ask what the goal is, but who cares. We'll break it and make it stop.
This is why I don’t get it when people say transhumanists have to cheer on current trans treatments. I’d love to get to a point where our bodies are totally malleable via technology. Be a woman, or a giant squid, or a cloud of nanobots. But the current approaches suck.
Quoting @ArtemisConsort: One of the most harmful trans community memes is “the button”
They say that if you would push a button that magically and painlessly changes your sex, you’re trans, and therefore should probably use the actually existing very clumsy treatments that are nothing like the button.
One of the most harmful trans community memes is “the button”
They say that if you would push a button that magically and painlessly changes your sex, you’re trans, and therefore should probably use the actually existing very clumsy treatments that are nothing like the button.
Unclear. Maybe, maybe not. There are measurement issues regarding this in sexology. I’ve personally slept with some women who identified as L and had never been with a male before me, but of course my own experiences aren’t dispositive (and I was trans at the time).
This is such an important point: how other people see you, in their private thoughts, is not in your control. Many people, not just trans people, need to internalize this. Forcing others to pretend does not make them actually feel it.
Quotes a post by A1184; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I’m all for the transhuman future where we can choose to be either sex, or a third sex, or an octopus, or a swarm of nanobots. But we aren’t there yet, and current trans treatments aren’t really a step along that path.
As Justice Sotomayor correctly notes, the rate of suicide attempts by transgender people is tragically high. But the best-quality studies indicate that transgender medical treatments do not reduce it. And some, particularly genital surgery, probably increase it.
Just as there is a general factor of intelligence g (scores on all cognitive tests positively correlate) there is a general factor of psychopathology p (scores on all mental illness tests positively correlate). Transgender identity loads onto p. So transgender people have rather poor mental health outcomes on average. Just as with people low in g, much ink is spilled trying to blame this on systemic factors when the most likely explanation is that similar basic traits produce both transgender identity and mental illness.
This is vile. I’ve been as critical of the trans movement as anyone. This is not criticism. This is naked sadism. It’s bad political strategy and it’s bad for your soul. Don’t do this. Don’t tolerate it when other people do it.
Quotes a post by T09778; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Hard to get accurate stats, since many countries don’t track the size of the overall trans population. Best data I’m aware of comes from the UK, and shows the sex crime rate is substantially higher than for normal men. People quibble, suggest various adjustments, but no plausible adjustments could make the MtF rate lower than the male rate, let alone anything close to the female rate.
Imagine a population in which only one person is a prisoner, and that prisoner is in jail for sex crimes. This is a weird thing to look at. Would it be better if more trans people were in prison for murder? You want to adjust to the overall population, not the prison population.
This is a bad way to frame this true finding. The proportion of trans prisoners who are sex offenders is much less relevant than the overall per capita trans rates of sex offense (which are high!)
That could be true. I’d love to see some trans advocates come out strongly against recognizing post-conviction transitions. But they are pathologically unable to ever deny anyone’s “validity”
“Parent” refers both to a social role and a biological status. “Woman” refers only to a biological status. Even trans activists would never say a female soldier or firefighter who still identifies as female is a man. They don’t think it’s a social role. They’ll also say things like “trans women don’t owe you femininity”. For them, it’s based solely on self-ID. Parenthood does not work like that, under either definition. If you neither produced nor raised a child, no one would say you can simply identify as a parent.
That’s a plausible theory for what makes people homosexual, but the majority of trans people are not homosexual and do not show a cross-sex brain shift.
One of the silliest talking points of the pro-trans movement is “sure, men pretending to be trans might be a threat, but real trans women aren’t.” How do you tell those groups apart? Without a measurement to distinguish them, the distinction means nothing.
Gay people were (mostly) just asking to be left alone. Sure, we subsidize HIV medication, but that doesn’t noticeably impact most people’s lives. The trans movement makes positive demands: you must call us what we say, think of us as we wish to be thought of, reorganize all of society around our inner feelings about ourselves. The median American is a social libertarian: do what you want, as long as you’re not imposing on anyone else.
Quotes a post by T06644; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.