The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
Most of America disagrees with you about childhood transition. Most of America disagrees with you about men in women’s spaces (I know you’ll word-lawyer this point). Labelling the majority as pathological is a losing, flailing strategy. I’m detrans, I have many trans followers. I’m the center, like it or not. I’m highly permissive in terms of individual expression. I’m not a Christian nationalist or a 2nd wave zealot. I’m a normal person tired of lies. You want to pretend to be the new center on trans issues but your positions are extreme. Very few Americans support childhood transition, and for good reason. The best meta-studies find it has no or negative benefit. There is no such thing as “true trans”. There are prenatally feminized gay boys who will mostly come to identify as gay men, and AGPs like you who can choose to transition or not as adults.
Trans discourse is one of the lowest-average-quality topics because almost everyone is wrong. Obviously gender ideology is silly, but most GC narratives (“internalized homophobia” etc) are also inaccurate for the large majority of trans-identified people.
Actually the tide is turning in our favor, and has been for some time. And by the numbers, Trump’s most persuasive election ad was an anti-trans one. You can’t use social pressure as your argument when you hold the minority position.
When I was trans, I felt that being included by women was a privilege, not a right. I tried very hard to be non-threatening and appropriate, to not dominate conversations, to make people glad I was there. Almost none seem to have this attitude. Pure entitlement and narcissism.
Even the “subby” ones push it into everything. It’s possible (and common) to have submissive fantasies but to be aggressive and demanding about it. I see this also in non-trans-ID male subs.
@[private account] Homosexuals show a cross-sex shift in a variety of traits, but this applies to both trans-ID and non-trans-ID homosexuals and most trans people are not homosexual. I remember reading that when I was trans and really grappling with it. Most don’t seem to care about evidence.
The problem seems to be the cultural norm that excluding anyone at all is evil. So in practice, there are no limits. Part of what soured me on trans issues was that, when I was trans and in the community, lots of trans women were really sexually aggressive and pushy in a way I have almost exclusively seen from men, and no one would acknowledge that this was male-coded behavior from males. “Women can be that way too!” Okay but 1. it’s drastically less common, and 2. if we deny all sex differences, what is there to transition to?
If being trans has nothing to do with “brain sex” (90% of MtFs are not neurally feminine-shifted)
And nothing to do with medical transitioning (some people can’t afford it you bigot!)
And nothing to do with behavior (trans women don’t owe you femininity!)
Then what is it?
What does the phrase “trans women are women” mean? They know they aren’t literally female. So what does it mean? Women in what sense? I am a detransitioner and I still have no clue what the content of this slogan is supposed to be.
This implies there is such a thing as “true trans” and that surgery correlates with it. Both of these claims are false. How about this? Your sex is your sex. Any body mods you get are your business, but they should not alter your legal sex status.
By this description and by temperament, I should be a Democrat. My political conversion centered women’s safety (trans issues, importing dangerous low-HC immigrants, civilizational collapse due to anti-capitalism and the horror show that would ensue afterwards).
Brianna Wu
I’m writing this because I see Brianna being promoted as a reasonable transsexual. This is not accurate, and sanewashing him will lead to children being harmed. He claims to be an “old school true transsexual centrist”. He is in fact an autogynephilic extremist.
First, let’s unpack the concept of a “true transsexual”. This term does not really have a scientific meaning. The most scientifically supported classification of male-to-female transitioners is Ray Blanchard’s two type model.
The first type are homosexual transsexuals (HSTS). These will show female-typical behaviors and preferences from an early age, tend to transition younger, and show shifts towards the female average in many physical and psychological traits. This is likely due to prenatal under-masculinization. They will be shorter, have a more naturally feminine build, have female-typical digit ratios, brain fMRI results shifted towards the female cluster, female-typical rates of violent crime, and female-typical hobbies and interests. This type matches more closely what people think of when they say “true transsexual”.
The second type are autogynephiles (AGPs). These are heterosexual men with a cognitive trait that causes them to internalize their sexuality. They are attracted to women, but this is aimed at themselves, so they feel ugly in male bodies and excited/satisfied by the thought of having a female body, wearing women’s clothes, occupying traditionally feminine roles, etc. Even though they are orientationally heterosexual (not turned on by pictures of naked men, when measured in laboratory conditions) they sometimes have sex with men to fulfill their desire to occupy a female sexual role. They sometimes even marry them. But they exhibit none of the natural feminization that HSTS do. They have male-typical brain scans, male-typical height and digit ratios, male-typical (or worse) levels of criminality, and male-typical interests. They have very high rates of autism and personality disorders, and high average IQs. I myself am an autogynephilic MtFtM detransitioner.
Brianna Wu transitioned at the age of 28. Let’s go through his pre-transition life.
His college classmates describe him as eccentric, offputting, creepy, and likely autistic. He told several of them that he had amnesia, either due to being stabbed in the head or because of a bicycle accident. He claimed to have worked for George W. Bush, when in reality he was a low-level RNC staffer. When the student newspaper wouldn’t publish one of his comics, he screamed at them and hurled racial slurs. Clearly a personality-disordered individual.
Wu began his transition in 2005 and had genital surgery in 2008. Since then, Wu has repeatedly claimed to have been born female. Forum posts from the time reveal his obsession with tricking men into having sex with him without revealing his trans status which, if you’ve seen pictures of him, is not plausible. He went to great lengths to cover up any information about his pre-transition life. He also lies about having a college degree when in fact he failed to graduate from several colleges. His hobbies include car repair and arguing on the internet. He is 6’4”. He has admitted to being bisexual. He is very obviously a mentally ill autistic autogynephile.
Today, after finally admitting to being trans, Brianna purports to be a centrist activist for trans issues. But his positions are not centrist. He believes males like him should have access to women’s spaces, and believes in childhood transition for “true transsexuals” like him. First, he is not HSTS, he is very obviously AGP. Second, most feminized boys who exhibit gender nonconformity grow up to be happy as gay men. Childhood transition is not justified for either kind of male dysphoric psychology. The best evidence reviews show no benefit and many find evidence of harm.
Brianna is a deranged extremist. Please stop normalizing him.
There should be no policy whatsoever regarding trans adults. Existing (sex-based) law and policy can apply, adults can choose to modify their bodies as they wish, though we need to stop lying to them that it will improve their mental health. Leave kids alone.
The norms of so-called civil discourse really amount to “my emotions count and yours don’t”
Being flooded with hordes of illegals makes you unhappy? Sorry bud, gonna need a peer-reviewed paper.
A trans person feels sad? Reorganize all of society immediately!
People don’t like being condescendingly lectured to about bullshit social justice narratives. Drop all DEI, drop the trans issue, drop mass immigration, drop “police reform”, and campaign on 10% more redistribution and you’ll at least be a serious party again.
If I could kill one thing in our politics, it would be arguments based on identity. “As a disabled black trans woman” shut the fuck up and make your point on its merits.
Being in the “trans community”, I saw a lot of really unapologetic male-coded behavior and even abuse. No one would acknowledge that this was male-coded. I always did my best to fit in with women, to be polite and grateful for inclusion. Too many didn’t see it that way. They believed they were entitled to inclusion with no restrictions or requirements. They behaved horribly. And the community enabled and covered for this behavior. I took 🍄🟫 and had this crisis moment where I saw that different types of humans are different, that the leftist refusal to acknowledge that was leading to real physical harm, and that they didn’t care because being nice was more important to them.
This is why I thought it relevant to bring up your bias. Nowhere have I suggested legally restricting trans medicine for adults. I want to provide information and argue for my position. I want them to make informed decisions, and I want to push the culture in a good direction. None of this is anti-freedom. All of my positions and statements are compatible with a libertarian view. You clearly aren’t motivated by freedom per se. You want to maximize the number of trans women produced. Nothing else makes sense of your replies to me.
I hate drag. I’ve always hated drag. I hated it when I was trans and progressive, I hate it now as a detrans rightist. It seems to be ugly on purpose. A crime against beauty.
Quotes a post by T09740; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
@[private account] Some of the GC movement definitely bleeds into pure anti-maleness, but it’s also perfectly reasonable to not want men changing next to women. I think his take applies to a minority of anti-trans sentiment.
I was on hormone replacement therapy for 4.5 years. I got facial surgery and breast augmentation. When I identified as trans, my dysphoria was intense. Now I don’t feel dysphoria. Yes n=1, but I firmly believe dysphoria can be treated without transition, at least for many people.