The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
Again, safeguarding according to sex is based on biology, not self-perception. If you want to claim that trans-identified males pose no risk to women, you’ll have to provide evidence. But the numerous cases of trans-identified males attacking women will make that very difficult.
You’re quite wrong about that. Many trans activist do claim to have changed sex.
But as you acknowledge, they haven’t. And safeguarding has to be based on sex, not self-perception.
That isn’t evidence that trans-identified males don’t share the same patterns of criminality as other men. In fact, trans-identified males in prison are around three times as likely to be sex offenders as prisoners overall.
Just once, I’d love to see trans activists and their supporters answer @jk_rowling’s measured and cogent arguments without misrepresenting them or screaming insults.
They could start by reading her latest piece and addressing what she actually says, rather than what they imagine she is secretly thinking.
Too much to ask?
https://www.jkrowling.com/opinions/an-update-to-my-essay-of-june-2020/
It’s clear you haven’t read the article. If you had, you would know that I have not claimed anyone is “forcing” people to be trans.
Why not read the article first, then come back with a counter-argument? You’ll do a much better job once you know what you’re arguing against.
Starmer said he supported self-ID. His government has just introduced a ban on “trans conversion therapy” that amounts to state-sanctioned gay conversion therapy. He said that women can have a penis. He’s not just a cheerleader, he’s a protagonist.
Few will be surprised to hear that trans activist bullies within the BBC are largely responsible for the corporation’s ideological capture.
But will the new management actually do something about it?
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/gift/a41e892e61586cf2
If by “overlooked” you mean pandered to when they demand the erosion of women’s rights, endlessly celebrated by the media and political class, and indulged even when their activists make threats of violence, murder and sexual assault, then yes, trans people are often overlooked.
Quoting @EmilyThornberry: This Trans Day of Visibility, let's remember those too often overlooked in endless debates over trans rights: trans people.
Trans men and women deserve our love and support, not exclusion and hate.
Studies have repeatedly shown that a substantial proportion of the public is misled by the term “transgender women”.
For clarity, this headline should read: “Male athletes banned from female events at Olympics by IOC”.
You are free to invent your own private definitions of terms such as “conversion therapy” and arrogantly assume that everyone must follow suit. Trans activists have been playing those games for years. Meanwhile, people in the real world will continue to push back against these dangerous practices.
It is your right to confuse an already confusing issue further; I have no insight into your motivations for that. You are also at liberty to continue to argue against the imaginary Andrew Doyle you have created and the arguments you have invented for him. But there’s really no need to tag me in.
You are free to invent your own private definitions of terms such as “conversion therapy” and arrogantly assume that everyone must follow suit. Trans activists have been playing those games for years. Meanwhile, people in the real world will continue to push back against these dangerous practices.
It is your right to confuse an already confusing issue further; I have no insight into your motivations for that. You are also at liberty to continue to argue against the imaginary Andrew Doyle you have created and the arguments you have invented for him. But there’s really no need to tag me in.
Your misunderstanding continues, but it was baked into your original video so there’s little surprise there.
The trouble is that you began with a false premise, and errors naturally follow. You are seeking to reclassify all child transitions as “conversion therapy” and you claim that intention is irrelevant. But intention is everything. There is no such thing as the conversion of sexual orientation. A gay boy does not cease to be a gay boy because he has been “transed” any more than a gay boy who has undertaken “conversion therapy” and learns to feign heterosexuality has authentically become heterosexual.
You misrepresent those who have noticed the disproportionate impact on same-sex attracted individuals as peddling “identity politics”, when it is nothing of the kind. The impulse to “trans” those who are gender nonconforming and same-sex attracted (two features that often coincide) is rooted in an anti-gay mindset. The same is not true of the transing of heterosexual youth. As such, it is false to conflate the two. Nobody is practicing “conversion therapy” on heterosexual youth because there is no intention to convert on the basis of sexual orientation.
I know casuistry when I see it, and I can see that you are attempting to circle around this key point. But the fact remains that you are misrepresenting and/or misunderstanding the arguments of the people you are criticising. For what reason, I cannot possibly guess.
Thank you for the response, but you have misunderstood the key point. It is not that heterosexual adolescents are not suffering from these practices (a claim I’ve never heard anyone make), it is that in the case of same-sex attracted youth, it is the orientation itself that is mistaken for a misalignment of body and gendered soul.
No clinician is mistaking heterosexual attraction for evidence of dysphoria. But they are, routinely, interpreting homosexuality and its concomitant behavioural trends (gender nonconformity in youth is the most reliable predictor of homosexuality in adult life) as evidence of a trans reality. Whistleblowers at the Tavistock made clear that homophobia was a recurring motivation for parents and even staff in the transing of children. Heterophobia, not at all.
You appeal to logic, so let’s put this in logical terms. Your conclusion is a standard case of false symmetry combined with causal oversimplification. Where one hypothesised mechanism plausibly explains a large majority of cases, it does not logically follow that the remaining minority must be driven by a mirror-image version of that same mechanism. Statistical asymmetry does not require explanatory symmetry. Just because the transing of same-sex attracted youth is to some extent due to homophobia, it does not follow that the minority who are cross-sex attracted are victims of heterophobia.
It is perfectly legitimate for gay rights campaigners to point out that gay kids are disproportionately impacted by these practices - largely *because* of homophobia. And it is perfectly legitimate to point out that not all kids who are transed are gay and that they are similarly deserving of support. But it is incoherent to assume that the causes are identical. Moreover, it is crucial to expose the failings of gay rights groups for failing to oppose the medicalisation of homosexuality.