The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
On last night’s show, I spoke to Kate Coleman from @[private account] about new guidance on Scottish prison service policy, which allows trans inmates to mingle with female inmates.
“Gender ideology now stands exposed for what it is – as a threat to the rights of women and of gay people.”
Must-read piece by @Jebadoo2 for @spikedonline.
https://www.spiked-online.com/2023/12/07/kemi-is-right-trans-ideology-is-a-threat-to-gay-kids/
Labour are advocating gay conversion therapy for young people (in the form of a ban on so-called “trans conversion therapy”) and will erode women’s rights to single-sex spaces. Do you support this?
I don’t think opportunism can be denied. The stats are clear - trans identified people are hugely and disproportionately represented among sex offenders. So either trans people are more predatory, or there are a lot of opportunists…
@[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @[private account] @JohnCleese Happy to say “trans identified males”. I usually say that anyway.
“The debate has turned into: if you don’t agree with me, you are a bigot”
Terrific interview with @[private account] for the Evening Standard.
https://www.standard.co.uk/comment/freedom-speech-simon-fanshawe-stonewall-trans-b1114871.html
As I argued in this article for @unherd, it isn’t a “gotcha” to ask a politician to define terms such as “man” and “woman”, it's a means by which we can assess the honesty of the ruling class.
https://unherd.com/2022/03/have-we-reached-peak-trans/
The discourse around “conversion therapy” is mired in confusion, and it is largely the government’s fault.
“Gay conversion therapy” is the attempt to change an individual’s sexual orientation, often by coercive or abusive means.
“Trans conversion therapy” is a phrase used to undermine medical practitioners who don’t automatically follow the “gender-affirmative” approach, one that has seen the medicalisation of many gay teenagers. As such, opposition to “trans conversion therapy” is essentially an endorsement of gay conversion therapy.
So why does the government insist on conflating these two oppositional concepts?
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12520863/Plans-ban-gay-conversion-therapy-set-ditched.html
I said it wouldn’t happen at a rally. I didn’t say there wouldn’t be individual threats.
And we’ve established that Nazis have shown up at LWS rallies. It has also been established that they are opportunists who oppose LWS as much as they oppose trans people.
Okay, I'll sure you think it's totally normal that these signs appear regularly at mainstream trans activist events. And that no-one ever asks such people to leave.
It would never happen at a gay rally, and you know that.
If I remember rightly, you said she wanted to see trans people eliminated. I’ve never heard her say that, so I would never assume she believes it.
But again, I consider the entire digression a clear case of whataboutery.
Fine. You should address your concerns to her. I don’t support the sterilisation of anyone, not even criminals, so I have no idea why you’re asking me about it. As for her views on feminism, that’s none of my concern and irrelevant to my point.
My sole point was about the normalisation of violent rhetoric within the trans activist movement. I see that as a problem. You evidently don’t. I’m not sure why.
In order to assess whether violence has become normalised in the GC movement you would need to (a) show evidence of commonplace calls for violence (rather than just one or two tweets), (b) show footage of a GC event where violence was incited and/or (c) provide footage of GC activists attacking people.
All of this is readily available when it comes to the trans activist movement (who do not, in my view, represent or best serve trans people). If it is not available for the GC movement, one must assume it doesn’t exist.
C2 false claimshand-codedpolitical enemyviolence terror
Well then that's not something I'm all that interested in. If your argument is that the normalisation of violent rhetoric in the trans activist community (which you finally admitted) is comparable in the GC community, you'll have to provide specific evidence of calls for violence.
C1 anti-trans rhetorichand-codedpolitical enemyviolence terror
Again. Your argument seems to hinge on “there are some bad apples in every movement”. As an argument, this is useless, as we all know it to be true.
So let’s try one more time. If you can’t answer this without evasion, we’ll leave it there.
Given that you have seen footage of crowds at a *mainstream* trans pride event cheering and applauding when called to violence, do you accept that violent language has become normalised in the trans activist movement?
If such a reaction is not proof of normalisation, how else do you explain it?
C2 false claimshand-codedpolitical enemyviolence terror
The original point was, in fact, the normalisation of violent rhetoric in a particular movement. You are determined to ignore the evidence. That it has become normalised in trans activism (crowds cheering when called on to punch women, thousands of rape and death threats to women, images of signs calling for violence at trans rallies - none of which would ever have occurred at gay pride - as you well know) is beyond dispute. All you are doing is nitpicking one or two instances within other movements, all of which are aberrations and tell us precisely nothing, and offering bad faith misinterpretations of one prominent women’s rights activist.
Until you can learn to evaluate evidence honestly and objectively, any discussion on these issues is futile.
The truth is that you would never see calls for violence greeted with applause at a gay pride meeting or a feminist gathering. The fact that you don’t accept that violence is normalised in the trans activist movement is wilful blindness on your part. You should examine why it is you don’t want to address uncomfortable truths. Anyway, I wish you well.
C2 false claimshand-codedactivist harassmentviolence terror
You still haven’t answered my question.
If an activist calling for violence is received with cheers and applause at a mainstream trans pride event, how can you claim that violent rhetoric hasn’t been normalised in the movement? If this isn’t normalisation, what is it?
https://twitter.com/unpopulargenz/status/1677791701253906432/video/1
C2 false claimshand-codedpolitical enemyviolence terror
Thousands of people willing to use violent threats and language in an activist body of no more than thousands is a sizeable minority. It certainly suggests normalisation. Signs calling for death and decapitation would never have been tolerated at gay pride marches.
Again - when a crowd at a mainstream trans pride event cheer and applaud a call to violence, how can you possibly argue it hasn’t been normalised? What do you consider this, if not normalisation?
https://twitter.com/unpopulargenz/status/1677791701253906432/video/1
C2 false claimshand-codedpolitical enemyviolence terror
Violent rhetoric doesn't generally occur from GC feminists. I think I have seen one example. But I have seen thousands from trans activists. So yes, the evidence suggests normalisation.
If violent rhetoric hasn’t been normalised in the movement (as you claim) can you explain why the crowd in this clip - at a mainstream Trans Pride event - cheers someone calling for violence? Rather than, say, reacting with stunned silence?
Yes, you can easily make a website full of false information and bad faith interpretations. A little trickier to make a site of hundreds of screenshots and images of actual evidence if such evidence does not exist.
Violent rhetoric and threats is absolutely the norm among militant trans activists. That you seek to deny it is simply evidence that you wish it wasn’t so.
C2 false claimshand-codedactivist harassmentpolitical enemyviolence terror
I don’t believe for a second that you think that the normalised violent rhetoric of trans activists is in any way comparable to the tactics of the gay rights movement. If gay activists had behaved as TRAs do today, it’s unlikely we’d have equal rights.
Hardly mainstream. Even the pie in Bryant’s face was condemned by gay activists. Show me the widespread condemnation for this kind of rhetoric from trans activists. I’ll wait.
You honestly don't think women have been murdered by misogynists? The scale of such crimes will shock you if you choose to look into it. By contrast, murders of trans people in the UK are extremely rare, and the data show that they are the safest demographic.
Tonight on FREE SPEECH NATION…
• Activist librarians hide “problematic” books from the public
• Elon Musk pledges to offer legal support to anyone mistreated by their employer for posting or liking tweets
• Sinn Fein calls for legislation to guarantee puberty blockers for young teens with gender identity issues
• UK government advertises for “equality guru” for Falkland Islands - with its population of 3,662 humans and 500,000 sheep
• Fiona McAnena from @[private account] on the ban on trans-identified males in women’s rowing
• @JamesEsses on another bank punishing staff for gender-critical beliefs
• Barrister Anna Loutfi on the @[private account]’s campaign against indoctrination in schools
• @[private account] on the UK government and Wikipedia’s censorship of climate debate
• Comedian panellists @[private account] and @[private account]
7pm on @GBNEWS!
📺 Sky 512, Virgin 604, Freeview 236, Freesat 216, YouView 236
In this article, Matthew Parris reveals that he hadn’t done any basic reading on the issues.
And from the sounds of things, he has no intention of doing so either…
https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/war-over-trans-lobby-is-manna-for-the-right-lvzksk7s9
@[private account] @spectator No, I haven’t said anything against trans people. You’ve just ignored a multitude of gay people expressing their views. Why do you hate them so much?
Documents reveal trans charity Mermaids was helping draft NHS plans at the Tavistock.
The clinic had denied the documents existed, but released them when the information regulator threatened court action.
A clip from last night’s Free Speech Nation…
Anna Thomas was sacked from the civil service for whistleblowing after she revealed how staff at the Dept for Work & Pensions have been trained in Critical Race Theory, been instructed to assume that they are racist, and how white males were excluded from a jobseekers' event.
She has now received a £100,000 settlement from the government - and she'll be talking to me tonight on FREE SPEECH NATION.
I'll also be talking to @peterboghossian about whether wokeness is in decline, @GoodwinMJ about how immigration is destroying the Tory party's chance of electoral success, and @HJoyceGender about the witch-hunt of Baroness Falkner by trans activists.
My comedian panellists for today are @[private account] and @LeoKearse.
7pm on @GBNEWS!
📺 Sky 512, Virgin 604, Freeview 236, Freesat 216, YouView 236
We saw in New Zealand how this kind of inaccurate reporting needlessly raised the temperature.
Journalists who describe women’s rights events as “anti-trans” are engaging in wilful propaganda.
Quotes a post by T06762; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Nope, it’s got nothing to do with removing protections from trans people. Watch it again if you’re confused.
It was indeed announced that the Tavistock would close. So not a lie at all. See article.
You like calling people “liars” a lot. Very immature.
https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-62335665.amp
Tonight on FREE SPEECH NATION…
I talk to @[private account] about filming a protest by trans activists
@ThePosieParker on Let Women Speak
@[private account] on indoctrination in schools
@[private account] & @[private account] on the SNP
+ @[private account] & @[private account]
7pm on @GBNEWS!
@[private account] @[private account] America has plenty of extremes. You won't find a mainstream conservative commentator calling for trans people to be outlawed. Certainly not in the UK.
@[private account] @[private account] I don’t agree that “no one has” said anti-trans things. It’s just that JK Rowling isn’t one of them.
There is no evidence that public debate on gender identity has resulted in an increase in hate crimes.
And yes, I covered this exact story last November.
A middle-aged male cricket player has been competing against girls as young as 12.
“The player has previously caused injuries… an opponent at county trials was left unable to play for months.”
We have sacrificed sanity on the altar of “inclusivity”…
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/cricket/2023/02/17/parents-demands-answers-ecb-trans-woman-competing-against-girls/
The Cass Interim Report was clear that children struggling with gender - most of whom turn out to be gay - require psychological support.
This ban on “trans conversion therapy” could criminalise such support, thereby green-lighting gay conversion therapy.
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-11637671/Law-banning-conversion-therapy-set-announced-week.html
Professor Robert Wintemute visited McGill University in Montreal to discuss how militant trans activism can be intolerant and intimidating.
Screaming protesters shut the event down.
Prof Wintemute joins me tonight on FREE SPEECH NATION. 7pm on @GBNEWS!