The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
Yep. That’s progress! Although terfing on Facebook is a whole different experience. I commented on a PEI human rights commission post recently and the flood of comments from angry trans activists that ensued made me wonder if I’d somehow woken up in 2020. Wild stuff.
As the world emerges from the chaos wrought by the trans movement, the monstrous incongruity between what well-meaning people thought they were supporting and the reality of what has occurred is becoming clear.
Every day, more people wake up to the fact that trans rights was never an ordinary civil rights cause. It was never about equal rights or an end to the discrimination of a long-marginalized group.
It was a total rewrite of reality—a movement intent on bending the world around the false belief held by a tiny number of people who didn’t recognise themselves as mentally ill.
What was sold as medically necessary, life-saving care has turned out to be an atrocious medical crime committed by true believers blind to the brutality of the procedures they perform.
And what the unsuspecting masses thought was a progressive quest for equal rights has instead resulted in the obliteration of women’s rights, the suppression of scientific scrutiny, the erosion of free speech, and the dismantling of child safeguarding.
Read my latest essay in @genspect’s REPATH series on the madness of how we got here.
Not only do trans activists demand that innocent children have their heads filled with an absurd ideology that confuses some into thinking they need body parts chopped off, but they also insist on depriving them of the magic of Harry Potter.
Would be great if Canadians would stop being such pathetic cowards and start placing the well-being of children over the demands of these unhinged ideologues.
My final question to @[private account] was: If you could wave a magic wand and trans as a type of person disappeared, and all the people who are currently medicalised were suddenly healthy and whole again, would you?
And someone in the comments said: no better ending of a video than a fairy tale of genocide.🤦♀️
This medical experiment has been sold as "life-saving" for so long, with irresponsible trans-identified people saying they wouldn't be here today if they hadn't transitioned, that basic medical safeguarding is now equated with genocide.
There is no evidence that these treatments are life-saving, and selling false hope to desperate people is cruel and unethical.
Recently had the opportunity to explain to the Supreme Court of the United States the madness of reframing a mental disorder as healthy and how that created the devastatingly harmful concept of the “transgender child.”
Quotes a post by A0924; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
In this week's Beyond Gender, @[private account] raised a point about gender surgeons that I had never considered: that they are very likely the bottom of the barrel.
And it makes complete sense not just in terms of skills, but also ethics. Because only a surgeon with no ethical principles would spend their days destroying healthy functioning bodily systems.
Only the cranks and the fanatics would make it their life's work to disfigure people in this way without a shred of scientific justification.
Back in the 1970s, at Hopkins, a horrified plastic surgeon once approached Dr. Paul McHugh and said:
“Imagine what it’s like to get up at dawn and think about spending the day slashing with a knife at perfectly well-formed organs, because you psychiatrists do not understand what is the problem here but hope surgery may do the poor wretch some good.”
Horror at the ghastliness of this medical crime is the normal human response.
But the power of trans as a civil rights juggernaut overruled society's natural instincts, resulting in good, decent people supporting the abominable medical crime these surgeons are committing.
It's 2026 and CBC still hasn't grasped the power of social transition.
This whole article is about the harm of informing parents when a child starts going by a new name and pronouns.
No mention of the fact that social transition is a powerful psychosocial intervention that locks the trans identity into a young person's mind, making the likelihood of future medicalisation much greater.
I'd be willing to bet no one at the CBC even has an inkling of this effect. Because that would require actual research. Actually grappling with the complexity of the topic.
Far easier to just keep regurgitating trans activist talking points and painting non-affirming parents as abusive.
One day, heads must roll at the CBC for the part they've playing in fueling this medical scandal.
The replies to this post indicate that reading comprehension is a skill woefully lacking in the trans activist community
Quoting @_CryMiaRiver: Closing down gender clinics isn’t enough to end this scandal. The whole idea that trans is a type of person must be eradicated.
As long as society pretends it’s normal to want healthy body parts chopped off, vulnerable people will continue to be harmed.
Closing down gender clinics isn’t enough to end this scandal. The whole idea that trans is a type of person must be eradicated.
As long as society pretends it’s normal to want healthy body parts chopped off, vulnerable people will continue to be harmed.
WPATH's 2022 conference in Montreal. Still to this day the peak of the insanity for me. They recommended the trans "plurals" use an app so all the alters could talk to each other and make medical decisions.
In the 1980s, psychiatry created a type of person called the “multiple.”
Multiples were supposedly people who had endured horrific abuse as children that had caused the personality to split as a way to cope. These “alter” personalities could number into the tens or hundreds, and could even be non-human—actual examples include a lobster, a cloud, and a devil.
It was a circus of insanity. Totally absurd and built upon nothing but incoherent pseudoscience. The multiple personality experts truly were the lunatics running the asylum.
Yet, in the 1980s, multiples existed as a type of person. The women who had the misfortune to have that label applied to their struggles had their lives ruined. As did their families, because it was normally an innocent male relative who suddenly found himself accused of the most heinous crimes.
In my opinion, “trans” as a type of person is just as harmful, just as pseudoscientific, and just as capable of ruining the lives of patients and their families.
The story of Patient Zero in the puberty suppression experiment perfectly demonstrates why the idea that trans is a type of person is so dangerous.
In the 1980s, FG was a gender-nonconforming lesbian struggling her way through adolescence. She became friends with a fellow tomboy and together they both decided they were boys.
But only FG ended up having her puberty blocked, being pumped full of testosterone, and having healthy body parts surgically disfigured.
Her friend grew up to simply be a butch lesbian.
Why? Because FG’s aunt read Harry Benjamin’s popular book The Transsexual Phenomenon and interpreted FG’s distress as a sign she was “trans.”
Because FG’s family collided with the idea that trans is a type of person, they sought a medical remedy for her gender-nonconformity, and FG was set on a path to living a medicalised life pretending to be someone she is not.
I talked about this and much more in this fabulous conversation with @JamieWhistle and Cori Cohn. Truly one of the most enjoyable interviews I've done in years.
Gender dysphoria is an activist-crafted diagnosis, and it was a stroke of pure genius.
Early trans activists didn’t like gender identity disorder because it pathologized the trans identity, but they couldn’t get rid of the diagnosis altogether because they needed a billing code for their lifelong hormones and radical surgeries.
So they came up with “gender dysphoria,” which shifted the pathology from the identity to the distress one feels when mind and body are not aligned.
From then on, believing yourself to be a member of the opposite sex and wanting extreme body modification was perfectly natural and healthy. No need to investigate the origins of the belief. Why would you? It’s healthy and normal. In fact, let’s celebrate it!
And how do you treat the “dysphoria”? Well, you just chop off the body parts that are causing the dysphoria, of course.
Immediately after this diagnostic shift, the media campaign of trans activism triggered the social contagion of kids identifying as trans and flooding gender clinics, where they were improperly diagnosed and ushered into operating theatres to have healthy body parts needlessly amputated.
Watch the third and final episode of Genspect’s REPATH series that covers 2010 to the present day—the darkest of eras in which the world has celebrated an atrocious medical scandal unfolding in plain sight.
Link below⬇️
It is not compassionate to collude with the key symptom of a mental disorder while at the same time denying the existence of the mental disorder. That does not help those suffering from the mental disorder.
If your eyes are open and you're really truly looking at the scandal of gender-affirming care, at this point the harm is undeniable and something has to be done. We have to fix this.
Watch the third and final episode of @Genspect’s REPATH series where we explain why it’s time to be bold and speak the truth about trans.
Premiering now.
Watch Episode 2 of @genspect's REPATH series which tells the story of how the field of gender medicine was captured by trans activists, setting the stage for the scandal of gender-affirming care
https://youtu.be/JoJNVqH267E?si=Lg02GSXrNaDKSpXv
This is the second essay in our REPATH series that covers the early days of modern trans activism.
https://genspect.substack.com/p/why-wpath-chose-the-path-to-disaster
Watch Episode 2 of @genspect's REPATH series in which @stellaomalley3 and I take a close look at those pivotal early years of trans activism and how a tiny group of dedicated activists created a rights movement destined to unleash a medical scandal.
https://youtu.be/JoJNVqH267E?si=79aeDqJUMBuwcza6
In his 1996 book, The Apartheid of Sex, Martine Rothblatt almost predicted the internet-fueled social contagion of trans identities that was looming on the horizon.
He foresaw the ease with which people would adopt trans identities in the world of cyberspace, but because he believed trans to be an innate type of person, he didn’t foresee how highly transmissible the desire for medical body modification would be.
One interesting concept Rothblatt couldn’t have understood is something called the Proteus Effect.
Coined in 2007, the theory describes how people adapt their behaviour to match their avatar’s appearance when interacting in cyberspace.
A World of Warcraft study revealed that if a person has a sexy avatar, their behaviour becomes more flirtatious, or those with a tall avatar interact with other players in a more assertive, confident way.
However, the effect isn’t just contained to cyberspace. A later study assigned people short or tall avatars, and then had them negotiate in person immediately after emerging from virtual reality. Those who had been given tall avatars negotiated more assertively in real life compared to those who had been given short avatars.
In other words, the Proteus Effect had spilled over into the real world.
A far more tragic version of this unfolded, and continues to unfold, in the era of trans rights.
When legions of confused youth collided online with the idea that trans is a type of person and applied that label to their own struggles, they disconnected from their sex with precisely the ease Rothblatt had predicted, reinventing themselves through new names, pronouns, and avatars.
And when these digital identities began spilling over into the real world, the pursuit of medical embodiment inevitably followed.
In the 1990s and early 2000s, the groundwork for the madness of trans activism and the medical scandal of gender affirming care was laid.
The architects were a small but dedicated group of activists who rejected the psychiatric framing of transgender identities. Instead, they framed the desire for extreme body modification as perfectly natural and healthy.
Astonishingly, the whole world went along with it.
Episode 2 of @genspect's REPATH series, released today, is an in-depth look at how that came to be.
Here's an essay I wrote last year about how trans activists brought the concept of gender identity into existence by embedding it into Canadian law.
https://macdonaldlaurier.ca/gender-identity-in-canadian-law-definition-origins-and-societal-impact-mia-hughes-for-inside-policy/
My thoughts on SOGI:
Gender identity is a politically-crafted concept that was embedded into Canadian law without a coherent definition and without anyone understanding the far-reaching consequences.
There is no evidence to support the existence of gender identities. The concept is unfalsifiable and lacking any objective measures or empirical tests.
It is dangerous to teach impressionable children that pseudoscientific political concepts are established scientific facts.
Teaching children and adolescents that they possess a gender identity and it is that which determines whether they are boys or girls sows confusion during a crucial stage of identity development.
The most vulnerable will misinterpret their gender-nonconformity or the normal struggles of growing up as a sign they possess a mismatched gender identity. This leads some confused youth to the wrong conclusion that they are transgender.
Then, also because of SOGI in our schools, teachers affirm this confusion and allow a change of name and pronouns, sometimes, criminally, without parental consent or knowledge.
When the transgender identity has solidified in the young person’s mind as a result of this culture of affirmation and celebration, the next step is the gender clinic, where doctors who have lost their moral and ethical compass perform drastic and irreversible medical interventions that have no scientific justification or grounding in evidence.
It is a catastrophic safeguarding failure that this political ideology was ever allowed in our schools. Protecting children means removing every last remnant of it from our education systems.
Quotes a post by T21985; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
When trying to reach normal people about the scandal occurring in gender clinics, the biggest problem we all face is that the truth about WPATH is simply too insane for the average person to believe.
Most people find it impossible to accept that an entire field of medicine could be fueled by ideology and guided by fanatics.
So they write us off as conspiracy theorists.
My second essay in @Genspect’s REPATH series tells the story of those crucial years in the late 1990s and early 2000s when trans activists captured WPATH and how that paved the way for the scandal of gender affirming care.
The doctor who gave it to her. It was de Vaal’s idea that she appear on television with him. He was promoting his book about “transsexualism” and needed to boost his credibility by showcasing some patients. He was also a hardcore activist who believed trans was a medical condition not a mental disorder. He felt that public visibility would help reduce stigma and increase societal acceptance. I see Henning as a victim of the cultural moment.
The story of Rik Henning, one of the earliest trans-identified females to speak publicly in the Netherlands, perfectly demonstrates the power of ideas to shape people’s lives.
Henning was a lesbian being treated for a metabolic disorder, yet her endocrinologist just so happened to be Otto de Vaal, the grandfather of gender medicine in the Netherlands.
Testosterone formed part of Henning's treatment protocol, and she apparently enjoyed the masculinization effects so much that she interpreted this to mean she was, “in essence, a man.”
But that was only because she collided with a doctor who believed in trans as a type of person and she lived in progressive Dutch culture where the idea was already widely dispersed.
In 1971, she appeared on national television with De Vaal to raise awareness about “trans men,” and did her part in spreading the idea into mainstream culture that some women are actually men and the appropriate medical treatment is testosterone and bilateral mastectomies.
And those most susceptible to this idea were butch lesbians just like Rik.
Watch the first episode in @genspect's REPATH series on the early history of gender medicine.
My new fans are just so rhetorically captivating. Such charm and eloquence.
I do however happen to have plenty to say about what the APA thinks about trans. But that essay isn’t coming out until next month.
Quotes a post by T26876; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
There is quite possibly nothing that @stellaomalley3 and I love more than geeking out on the history of gender medicine.
Episode 1 of our REPATH series retells the story of the early days of gender medicine, but with a focus on the powerful idea that trans is a way to be a person.
We examine how this shaped not only the actions of a fringe group of doctors and but also the way patients came to understand themselves and their struggles.
PREMIERING on Youtube @ 7pm GMT / 2pm ET ⬇️
Read the full essay here and judge for yourself whether such an unhinged response is justified
https://genspect.substack.com/p/trans-is-a-mental-disorder-and-we
Imagine a group of powerful, well-connected anorexics gather and formulate a plot to reject the psychiatric framing of anorexia and turn their illness into a healthy identity.
They make it discrimination and bigotry to call anorexia a mental disorder and frame access to liposuction and Ozempic as medically necessary and a human right.
The whole world goes along with this.
In the field of anorexia-affirming care, an anorexic receives immediate affirmation of her anorexic identity and unfettered access to the weight-loss medical treatments that her disorder demands.
No psychotherapeutic attempt is made to loosen the grip of the belief.
Then, instead of measuring success by objective outcomes such as physical health and quality of life, researchers in the field opt for self-report: in other words, after giving the anorexic the very treatments that her disorder compels her to seek, the researchers ask her if she is happy.
When she says yes, this confirms that Ozempic and liposuction are beneficial and appropriate treatments for anorexia.
That is the medical world’s current approach to managing the trans phenomenon.
Read how this madness happened in my first essay of @Genspect’s REPATH series
If trans-identified people don’t like the label of mental illness, why not just pretend their compulsion is healthy? They make up such a tiny proportion of the population after all. Why not just go along with it to reduce stigma and be kind?
Simple. Because what happens when all of society colludes with a mental disorder is that all of society goes insane.
It’s how a culture ends up celebrating people for suffering from this mental disorder.
How those who’ve needlessly had healthy body parts amputated are considered good role models for young people. How posters promoting body disfigurement adorn the walls of elementary schools. And how millions of viewers watched a teenage boy’s botched penis amputation surgery for entertainment.
Read my first essay in @genspect's REPATH series on why it’s time to be bold and speak the truth about trans.
A strange idea has been loose in our society for the last few decades. And it’s so pervasive and so deeply embedded in our culture that many people have lost sight of just how odd it is.
It’s the idea that some healthy people require lifelong medical intervention and body part amputation.
Or, to put it another way: It’s the idea that being transgender is a natural variation of human existence, not grounded in mental disorder or psychological challenges.
Anyone who stops to think about this even for a moment can see how nonsensical it is.
After all, how could any man of sound mind want his penis amputated? How could any woman who is balanced and thriving want her healthy breasts cut off?
It just doesn’t make any sense.
And yet, in the era of trans rights, stating the obvious — that an individual’s desire to medically alter the sex characteristics of his or her healthy body is a form of mental disorder — amounts to one of the most offensive, bigoted, harmful views a person could possibly express.
Read my first essay in @genspect's REPATH series on how this dark moment in history could have happened and why restoring truth is the only way out of the madness. Link below.
There are so many examples of McNamara's lunacy, but my personal favourite is this NewsNation segment from 2022.
When asked how kids could make such an enormous, life-altering decision she gives this glorious answer:
“My response is that kids know their genders unequivocally. Cisgender kids know their genders and transgender kids know their genders, and there shouldn’t be really a difference between them.
Think about how sure you felt of your gender from some of your earliest childhood memories. It’s no different. The confusion comes from external factors in our society that impose cisgendernormativity on young people.”
True Believerism in its purest form. Wild that Guyatt would respect such an obvious ideologue.
Guyatt here talking about nefarious "anti-trans forces" — which is actually just people who think it's wrong to chop body parts off healthy kids caught up in a cultural fad.
And calling a paper by Meredithe McNamara (one of the biggest purveyors of misinformation on gender medicine) brilliant and deeply insightful is just too much!
Quotes a post by T03939; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Here's the ruling. The opening line is:
"Child Q is a brave, sensitive, kind transgender girl."
Poor doctor didn't stand a chance.
https://www.bchrt.bc.ca/law-library/decisions/recent/2026-bchrt-189/
Today is the first anniversary of surely one of the most incredible moments in podcast history.
There is no force on earth more powerful at torching the reputations of respected distinguished academics than trans activism.
Believing one absurd falsehood naturally results in supporting that belief with numerous other equally absurd falsehoods.
Here is the perfect example.
Believing in trans kids as an innate healthy category of youth means you have to account for why there’s no mention of them throughout all of human history.
That leads to the belief that legions of youth must have been tortured out of their transness by bigoted parents and their mysterious evil accomplices.
Or that they all just dropped dead from the terrible torment of being trapped in the wrong body in a world before the wonders of gender medicine.
And yet no one noticed this crime against innocent children occurring. Not a single mention of it anywhere, in any nation, in any history book.
Of course the obvious fact that “trans kids” are created by a culture driven mad by the collision of trans activism and modern medicine requires no such wild leaps of imagination, but true believers are impervious to evidence and reason so will never permit themselves to look upon the truth.
You see, if I were doing an Ask Mia Anything tour — a no-questions-off-limits event on all things trans — Fae would not only be welcome, but he’d be brought to the front of the line and handed the microphone.
And that’s the difference between the two sides of the trans debate.
This week’s guest on Beyond Gender, journalist Nick Wallis (@nickwallis), is one of my favourite voices in the gender debate.
After his exceptional coverage of the UK’s Post Office scandal, Nick turned his attention to the scandal of gender affirming care and the madness of the wider trans movement.
In this episode, we covered a wide range of topics, from the Post office throwing innocent people in prison, the lies and false promises of gender medicine, the media beclowning itself on the altar of trans activism, and of course, why Canada insists on being so stupid.
🎧Premiering now
The “adults can do whatever they want” stance in the gender debate has always baffled me.
Because it’s not the trans-identified individuals themselves who are chopping off their own breasts and penises or stripping their own forearms and sewing the harvested tissue onto their groins.
Medical professionals commit these ghastly crimes. And medical professionals are not free to do whatever they want. Medical professionals must be guided by the ethical principle to first do no harm.
These doctors have no right to perform health-destroying procedures that lack any grounding in evidence.
Quoting @genspect: To be clear: we do not believe clinicians should provide treatments that have no evidence base to support them to ANYONE- adults included.
@stellaomalley3 explained Genspect’s position on this during our ROGD Awareness Day webinar.
The mental health world is plagued by diagnostic imprecision. There are issues with what should be counted as a mental disorder and what shouldn’t, and where to draw the line between normal and pathological.
Yet, despite over a century of diagnostic confusion surrounding transgender identities, I happen to think trans is one of the easiest of all the clinical thresholds.
When a person, for whatever reason, fixates on obtaining drastic health-impairing hormonal and surgical interventions, they have crossed the diagnostic threshold and are clearly in the realm of mental disorder.
Such people need help overcoming this desire. They don’t need the medical world to collude with the key symptom of their pathological condition.
I think we should lift some of the outrageous claims and SSE them up. Like “transgender people are in Canada are a marginalized group that has very little power”. I have plenty to say about that!
Author @[private account] poured decades of his life into campaigning for a ban on conversion therapy, so no one else would ever have to suffer the way he had.
Then, as victory was in sight, along came the trans movement and its incoherent demands for the medical conversion of healthy bodies in gender clinics. And they snatched his victory away.
It's the equivalent of me and @stellaomalley3, battle-worn after decades of fighting for care that doesn't involve the destruction of healthy bodies, suddenly finding ourselves bewilderingly force-teamed with the scalpel-happy body modification crowd.
Honestly haven't been able to stop thinking about this part of our conversation for weeks now.
Same. But I constantly try and fight against it.
Because this mass movement is powerful, and has deranged large swathes of the population including this parent.
As long as the concept of the "trans child" is loose in our culture, (or trans adult for that matter), and as long as the live daughter dead son emotional blackmail is part of the cultural script, there are going to be parents who sacrifice their children.
The weight loss side was never a feature of mine. But the all-consuming fixation certainly was. Truly had no idea it could have been considered a mental disorder though. It’s quite fascinating in that sense how it overlaps with trans
Whereas the opposite could be said for trans: it should be so easy to spot because any person with a functioning brain can see that wanting healthy body parts chopped off is odd and weird. Yet here we all are surrounded by people who pretend it’s all perfectly normal.
Can you think of anything more frightening than a bunch of extremist trans activists with license to practice medicine, armed with syringes and scalpels, marching forth on their ideological quest to make the world a better place?
Quoting @genspect: “The field of gender medicine is entirely guided by ideology.”
- @_CryMiaRiver on the Dad Saves America podcast
While preparing to interview eating disorder expert Deanne Jade, I came across an eating disorder I’d never heard of — orthorexia nervosa — and I realised I had once suffered from it.
My mid-to-late 20s were dominated by an all-consuming fixation on healthy eating. For a few years, I thought about nothing else; read voraciously into the topic, and followed a strict, regimented diet (with no exceptions ever).
This naturally had a dramatic effect on my social life because so much of socialising revolves around
food and drink.
It didn’t even enter my mind that my pursuit of health could have been considered a mental disorder. It felt like completely rational behaviour to address the health issues I was having at the time.
And that’s how trans feels to many of those caught up in today’s culture-bound fad. The pursuit of hormonal and surgical body modification feels justified and rational — a true expression of their deepest nature.
But while it’s unclear at what point healthy eating morphs into mental illness — or indeed if orthorexia nervosa even should be classified as such — the clinical threshold of trans is more clearly defined.
The moment a person fixates on having healthy functioning bodily systems medically destroyed with hormones and surgeries, they have crossed the threshold into mental disorder. And all treatment interventions must be geared towards loosening the grip of this pathological fixation.
In the conclusion of the essay I wrote last year about Neil Hopper and the overlaps between autogynephilia and apotemnophilia, I said this:
“The British public’s reversal on Neil Hopper — from applause to disdain — is but a small taste of what awaits when the West finally confronts the truth of what it has celebrated in the era of trans rights: a paraphilia disguised as a healthy identity, with paraphilic men paraded as cultural icons.
Just as many are now wondering what exactly was Hopper’s motivation in pursuing a career amputating limbs, in the coming years, society will similarly have to grapple with what motivated paraphilic men to invade women’s spaces, “breastfeed” infants, and call themselves lesbians, all while the world cheered them on.”
This excellent Guardian article portrays the horror that a daughter feels at the thought of her mother being cared for by such a depraved man.
But surely even worse is all the children who are going to grow up and one day learn that their father “breastfed” them for sexual kicks.
I truly do not believe there has ever been a more insane moment in all of human history.
Pro-ana (pro-anorexia) groups promote anorexia as an identity to be encouraged and celebrated, rather than as the serious, life-threatening mental disorder that it is.
Members support each other, offer weight-loss tips, and often compete for who is the most emaciated.
These communities still exist, although they are less popular these days, and many have morphed into “healthy eating” groups.
One reason for the plummeting popularity is anorexia has been replaced by another mental illness being celebrated as a healthy identity: Trans.
Online trans forums are just as dangerous as pro-ana sites. Members glorify medical body modification, affirm each others’ identities and encourage medicalization, quash doubts, and amplify the false belief that trans is innate and healthy.
And to make matters worse, celebration of this mental disorder isn’t restricted to online niche subcultures. It’s mainstream, and for many years was even mandatory.
Watch today’s episode of Beyond Gender with eating disorder expert Deanne Jade for a fascinating discussion about the overlaps between the two disorders.
🎧Premiering now.
I’m not into “trans men” because I’m straight and I’m not into “trans women” because it is simply impossible that I could ever be attracted to a man with hormonally and surgically created female sex characteristics.
If my husband came out as a woman I’d divorce him faster than you could say autogynephilia.
So, put simply: I would never date a trans person. And that’s not transphobic. Anyone considering undergoing these procedures needs to understand that this is true for most people.
Which is worse?
Trans dolls with changeable genitalia so young children can engage in imaginative "sex change surgery" play
Or
Little crocheted penises for girls being lied to and raised as boys to tuck into their underwear
Me: What sort of absolute unhinged maniac would create “trans dolls” with switchable genitalia aimed at 4-year-olds?!
*discovers it’s the work of Dianne Berg, one of WPATH’s leading experts and author of the Child Chapter in Standards of Care 8
*no longer even remotely shocked
Desist already has a separate meaning though. People who don’t take medical step and then let go of the trans belief.
@stellaomalley3 wrote an excellent piece about our use of the term detransition in the run up to our detrans awareness day event.
https://open.substack.com/pub/genspect/p/harmed-by-medical-transition?r=2dtx6o&utm_medium=ios
With the sensational case of Christine Jorgensen in the 1950s, the private sexual fantasies of autogynephilic men quickly solidified into an all-consuming quest to undergo vaginoplasty.
Early psychiatrists noted how many of the men seeking these drastic surgeries reported being unable to think of anything else from the moment they heard such a surgery was possible.
It has long been recognised that the availability of a medical treatment has the power to iatrogenically create the demand for that treatment because it gives hope to people in distress.
In the 19th century, surgeons removed the healthy ovaries of women as a cure for mental illness. This led to a mini epidemic of women fixating on their ovaries as the source of their distress and begging surgeons to operate.
This often overlooked iatrogenic mechanism is one reason why the continued availability of puberty blockers is so dangerous.
As long as puberty suppression remains a treatment option, it will draw young people who hate their developing bodies into thinking that blocking that development is the miracle cure for all that ails them.
In today’s episode of Beyond Gender, @stellaomalley3 interviews me and the fabulous @TwisterFilm about wannabe amputees, trans, the weird world of fetishes, and much more.
🎧Premiering now
Sorry. Got the date wrong. The article was 2011. Right at the start of the medical scandal.
https://abcnews.com/Health/transgender-kids-pioneer-early-identity-body/story?id=14404963
So much going on here.
First: there is no diagnosis. The kid says I am trans and the doctors say, yes you are trans! It’s healthy. Yay! Let’s celebrate.
Live son or dead daughter was standard emotional blackmail in gender clinics across the western world for many years.
WPATH Files awakenings make complete sense. We had a society-wide echo chamber for about a decade, where no one was allowed to talk about the ideological nature of gender medicine.
WPATH Files was a huge international story and for many was the first time they’d encountered the truth about the world’s leading transgender healthcare group.
And the rest is a bit rich coming from a man who advocates for a drastic life-altering medical treatment for healthy kids based on an “entirely subjective” self declared identity that cannot be “verified in any way.”
Of course, @[private account]’s story, and all the stories told by detransitioners, are so shocking that it’s far easier to dismiss them as untrue.
Here's an article I wrote about what is surely the most insane ruling in the gender wars thus far: the BC human rights tribunal declaring that if you don't believe in gender souls, you are denying the existence of trans-identified people.
https://nationalpost.com/opinion/b-c-human-rights-tribunal-ignores-science-to-silence-debate-on-gender-ideology
Philosopher Ian Hacking’s theory of Making Up People describes how new categories and labels don't just describe pre-existing people but actively create new kinds of people.
One such example is the “fugue” phenomenon of the late 19th century, when psychiatry created the category of “fugueur” and unleashed a mini epidemic of men wandering in trance-like states for hundreds of miles across Europe.
In my opinion, trans is the 21st century equivalent.
Watch today’s episode of Beyond Gender with philosophers Moti Gorin and Alex Byrne (@[private account]), in which we compare trans to bishops, telepaths, fugueurs, and Parisian waiters.
🎧Premiering now.
Today’s guests on Beyond Gender, philosophers Moti Gorin and Alex Byrne (@[private account]), argue that you can't say trans kids don't exist because trans adults exist.
“Who is Caitlyn Jenner, if not one of the world’s most famous transgender adults?”
Simple. Caitlyn Jenner is one of the world's most famous autogynephilic men.
But his paraphilic motivations are disguised with the politically sanitised “transgender” label.
And paraphilic men and children absolutely do not belong in the same category of person.
This was a very interesting conversation, with respectful, intellectual disagreement at times.
Premieres today at 3 PM (ET) / 8 PM (GMT)
The Globe and Mail continues to beclown itself by regurgitating trans activist gibberish.
The US Supreme Court is actually allowing states to ban boys and men from female athletic teams.
Quoting @globeandmail: Supreme Court allows states to ban transgender girls and women from school athletic teams https://www.theglobeandmail.com/world/article-supreme-court-upholds-state-laws-banning-transgender-girls-school/?utm_source=dlvr.it&utm_medium=twitter
I’m currently writing about this same phenomenon in the context of the social acceptance paradox.
How the explosion of trans-identified adolescents was due to increased societal acceptance, but the rising rates of detransition is explained by lack of societal acceptance.
Their ability to pivot from one explanation to other, maintaining the social acceptance narrative in either direction, makes me wish Leon Festinger were still alive to study this cult of True Believers.
The UK’s puberty blocker trial is a textbook example of what Dr. Harriet Hall called Tooth Fairy Science: research conducted on a phenomenon without ever questioning whether the phenomenon exists.
Hall explained that researchers could collect data that are reproducible and statistically significant on how much money the Tooth Fairy leaves, which coins she prefers, whether she pays more for molars, or when the child leaves a note — but without asking whether the Tooth Fairy exists, the entire endeavour is meaningless.
Over the next three years and beyond, the NHS will medicalise “trans kids” and meticulously gather data on bone density, the psychological effects of puberty suppression, and body-image satisfaction.
But all the results will be meaningless because they’re studying something that doesn’t exist.
Ethical research would begin at the same place, with the young person’s adoption of a transgender identity and the diagnosis of “gender incongruence,” but it would travel in the opposite direction.
Instead of accepting a culturally-influenced identity as a condition in need of medical treatment, meaningful research would investigate what ordinary developmental struggles are being misread by so many young people growing up in this era saturated with the messaging of trans activism.
It would investigate which cultural messages are disrupting identity formation and distorting the adolescent’s sense of self, driving the widespread adoption of this fashionable identity.
Studying "trans kids" and "children with gender incongruence" is as pointless as studying the Tooth Fairy.
WPATH is best understood as an extremist trans activist group that frighteningly contains many people with the license to practice medicine.
They are guided by ideology and care nothing for evidence.
Yet 🇨🇦 gender clinics proudly follow these fanatics.
Trans activists used the slur TERF as a means to intimidate, shame, and silence all women who disagree with their ideological worldview.
But the plan backfired on them in the most spectacular way.
By labelling every woman who lives in reality a TERF, they created an army of proud TERFs who will, without a shadow of a doubt, defeat them.
There’s a delicious poetic justice to this that warms my terfy heart.
Link to full interview with @[private account] below
This ghoulish behaviour isn't just restricted to trans activists on the internet either.
Watch this video of the head of a pediatric gender clinic glorifying suicide at the American Academy of Pediatrics annual conference in 2022.
https://x.com/JuliaMasonMD1/status/1579975190012100608?s=20
Quotes a post by T04846; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Another similarity between unmarked graves and trans: people rooting for dead kids.
As journalist @jonkay so astutely observes, there is a very unsettling undertone to the unmarked graves lie:
“We really hope we find these dead kids because it would be terrible if it turned out these 215 kids whose names we don't even know weren't murdered.”
And there’s that same ghoulish undertone amongst proponents of the transition-or-suicide lie.
Whenever a study comes out showing that actually there’s no suicide epidemic in this population, instead of celebrating this positive news, trans activists and proponents of “gender affirming care” are angry and attack the study.
Because they need dead kids in order to justify sterilising and chopping body parts off all the innocent youth swept up in this social contagion.
Link to full interview below.
The 2021 unmarked grave mass hysteria in Canada bears many striking resemblances to the modern trans rights era.
Asking for evidence of the graves is considered denialism. Asking for evidence for gender medicine is considered transphobic.
In both, to be a good person, you must believe, or pretend to believe, in something for which there is no evidence — trans kids/unmarked graves.
Politicians used both events for virtue-signalling photo-ops, kneeling at graves or marching in Pride parades.
Both are fuelled by gullible, incompetent journalism that failed in its most basic duty to interrogate and question astonishing claims. And also sustained by journalists now afraid to admit the grave error they made.
We talked about this and much much more in our fascinating conversation with journalist @jonkay in today’s episode of Beyond Gender.
Premiering now. Link below.
Which is why the entire field of "gender affirming care" must be eliminated.
Rather than being "safe, quality health care," it's a reckless ideological experiment that lacks any grounding in evidence.
People who identify as transgender deserve much better.
Quotes a post by T13153; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Here's a thought experiment comparing trans to people who want their healthy limbs chopped off. In the years since I wrote it, not one person has ever managed to find a flaw in it.
It also happens to be the thread that changed my life.
https://x.com/_CryMiaRiver/status/1624443564884123652?s=20
Quoting @_CryMiaRiver: 🧵Apotemnophilia
In the 90s, Dr. Robert Smith, a surgeon at Falkirk Royal Infirmary, performed leg amputations on two men. Both men were perfectly healthy but suffering from apotemnophilia, a psychiatric condition involving the desire to have healthy limbs amputated./1
This is actually incredible! The Globe and Mail admitting to its total failure in covering the "unmarked grave" mass hysteria — an event that changed Canada, possibly irreparably.
"The fact of the crimes committed against Indigenous children at residential schools over many decades does not automatically validate claims that hundreds of students were dumped into unmarked graves in Kamloops and other residential schools. That is an extraordinary assertion, one that requires proof.
…The media, including The Globe and Mail, did not initially scrutinize, much less challenge, that assertion. The initial headlines and stories in the media simply stated as fact that the remains of 215 children had been found.
Perhaps it will be proven, some day, that there are hundreds of unmarked graves at Kamloops. But it was not proven to be true in May, 2021. It is not proven to be true today.
…The lesson of 2021 should be: assertions about residential schools should be listened to carefully, and then, just as carefully, held up to scrutiny.”
Now do the scandal of paediatric gender medicine, @globeandmail. You have been just as gullible and your reporting has been just as atrocious.
Assertions about "gender-affirming care" should also be held up to scrutiny.
You frequently report that this treatment is life-saving, when there is no evidence that is true.
You call puberty blockers fully reversible, when there is clear evidence that is false.
You blindly accept the existence of "trans kids" without questioning where this sudden explosion of young people "born in the wrong body" came from.
You appeal to the authority of medical associations, including the thoroughly discredited WPATH, and dismally fail to investigate the astonishing levels of fraud, corruption, and institutional capture.
Quotes a post by A2216; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I’ve searched high and low for her Canadian study of 500 young people who have been given puberty blockers, hormones and surgeries with a 96% satisfaction rate and I can’t find it. Best I came up with is the infamous Trans Youth CAN study of 174 youth showing most were medicalised on the first appointment.
Interestingly, Johnson is part of the research team for that study. So if it’s that then she clearly doesn’t know her own work very well. Seems to be a running theme at McMaster!
I’m glad you asked.
First of all, let’s outline the hallmarks of a social contagion event:
- A rapid exponential explosion in numbers.
- The sudden appearance of an entirely new patient group
- Adolescent girls mostly affected.
- Clusters of friends presenting with the same symptom/behaviour
All of these are present in the epidemic of young people identifying as trans in the 2010s.
Now, the way society normally responds to such events is with an immediate search for the trigger event and the vectors for the contagion.
For example, with the bulimia contagion of the 80s, the trigger was found to be media coverage of the disorder.
With the outbreak of anorexia in Hong Kong in the 90s, it was the sensational media coverage of a school girl who had collapsed and died on a busy street.
With TikTok tics in the 2010s, a young Tourettes sufferer’s YouTube channel was swiftly identified.
There are endless examples.
In those instances, clinicians didn’t wait around for decades for someone to conduct a reliable study showing that the event was a social contagion. They recognised all the hallmarks and acted. In the case of bulimia though, not nearly fast enough.
In the case of the trans contagion, all researchers had to do was take a glance at the cultural messaging of the era. The inflection point coincides precisely with the dawn of the trans rights movement, with media celebration of trans-identified public figures, and trans influencers proliferating rapidly on social media.
And those early YouTube influencers actually documented the social contagion on camera for all to see with the How I Knew I Was Trans genre of video — with each young person describing encountering a trans-identified person online and immediately recognising themselves in it and adopting the identity. That’s the social contagion in action.
We don’t need studies to show it’s a social contagion. We just need to open our eyes and look at the evidence that is, and always has been, all around us.
Brandolini’s Law: It takes an order of magnitude more effort to refute misinformation than it does to produce it.
Take one of trans activism’s favourite catchphrases:
“Gender affirming care is evidence-based.”
Sounds plausible. Doctors wouldn’t perform drastic life-altering interventions on healthy kids in the total absence of credible evidence. Right?
Wrong.
The two linchpin Dutch studies upon which the entire experiment is based were so methodologically flawed that the results should have been completely invalidated.
But instead, the medical world mistook the experiment as proven medical practice and adopted the treatment globally and without restraint.
In a terrible twist of fate, this occurred in 2014, right at the very moment the messaging of trans activism triggered the social contagion of kids identifying as transgender.
In this part of my @[private account] talk I explain why it is simply impossible to call “gender affirming care” evidence based.
I appreciate your reply but respectfully disagree. We talk about the whole issue on the podcast. We aim for as wide a range of experiences and viewpoints as possible. People who were medicalised, people who weren't, LGB, experts in the field, people who know nothing about trans but plenty about parallel phenomena, plus a whole lot more.
I thought Pear's contribution was fascinating. I think it really helps people to see that young boys who are just like he was can grow up to be healthy whole gay man without the need for extreme medicalisation.
It was also really interesting from a cultural standpoint. As in, if Pear had been born just a little bit later, he likely would have found himself on a very different path. His story perfectly demonstrates the culture-bound aspect of this phenomenon.
I'm genuinely sorry for what you and those harmed by this scandal have gone through. And all your stories are important. But to understand this mad moment in history, it's essential to understand the whole culture that surrounds it. That's what we aim for on the podcast.
You’re behind the times, Adam. WPATH and modern trans activism moved away from treating “gender dysphoria” years ago. Because it’s pathologizing.
Now you only need “gender incongruence” — just a mismatch between body and mind, no distress required. Anyone with “gender incongruence” should have whatever hormones and surgeries they so desire to achieve their “embodiment goals.” That’s modern gender “medicine.”
But just to be clear: society never had any moral obligation to accommodate even those who experienced “distress” if by accommodate you mean handing the privacy and safety of women and girls to these men.
We also never had any moral obligation to lop off body parts and pump people full of powerful wrong sex hormones just because they demanded it.
In every nation touched by modern trans activism, loving parents have found themselves cast as villains as an incoherent, destructive belief system turns reality upside down.
Because it is impossible to redefine a serious psychiatric disorder as a healthy identity and still leave room for parents to seek help for their children who apply this identity label to their own adolescent woes.
In a world where every announcement of a trans identity must be met with immediate celebration and affirmation, and all requests for medical interventions swiftly accommodated, parents are rendered almost powerless to shield their beloved children from this scandal.
And when Child Protection Services act as foot soldiers for this dangerous ideology, families end up torn apart.
My latest for @genspect tells @[private account]’s story of losing her daughter to this devastating culture force.
C3 dehumanizinghand-codedchild indoctrinationideology cultmedical harmmental illnessstate takes children
The Federal Court of Australia has ruled that excluding a man from a women-only app is discrimination.
The man (who claims to possess an invisible female essence) said in a statement after the ruling:
"I now look forward to getting on with the rest of my life in the community we all know and love. One that embraces freedom and equality for all women."
As if this latest insane ruling finishes the deal: total societal acceptance and everyone lives happily ever after.
He appears totally oblivious to the fact that his actions — and the actions of all men like him who feel they have the right to force themselves into women's spaces — have torpedoed any chance of acceptance of people who identify as transgender.
In fact, the modern trans rights movement is the single worst thing that ever happened to people who call themselves trans.
Ill-considered and poorly-written laws may allow men into women's spaces, but the truth is: all men are men and not a single one is welcome in spaces designated for women.
And the social contagion of courage emboldening women to say NO to these men is now an unstoppable force.
This part is astonishing:
phalloplasty, a procedure the clinic says creates genitals “like biological male genitalia on both a functional and esthetic level.”
A non-functional appendage made out of forearm flesh is just like the real thing! Who knew!
https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/montreal/transgender-surgery-delays-quebec-9.7146840#:~:text=Montreal-,Transgender%20Quebecers%20face%20surgery%20delays%2C%20out%2Dof%2Dprovince%20patients,but%20only%20for%20Quebec%20patients.
Why do early data suggest most detransitioners are female?
Simple. Because the social contagion of the 2010s struck predominantly adolescent girls and that cohort is now reaching adulthood and realising they were sacrificed on the altar of trans activism
My talk at @genspect’s Detrans Awareness Day conference in March compared the madness of the trans rights era to the famous Dam Burst Panic in Columbus Ohio in 1913
Both occasions when false beliefs caused entire populations to take leave of their senses
https://youtu.be/qRXm4mQlv5Y?si=z5Wsk0TaYi563tbm
The inevitable social contagion of detransition is already well underway.
In the same way that thousands of young people once encountered someone just like them online announcing, “I’m trans” — and soon adopted the label themselves. Now those same people are encountering detransitioners.
People who have the courage to say: I once believed I was trans, but now I realise it was all a lie.
Every detransitioner who speaks publicly is helping to spread the idea that recovery is possible.
In a tragic symmetry, the same social mechanism that once drew so many into this medical scandal is now working in reverse — leading people away from further medical harm and towards self acceptance and truth.
But the responsibility for fueling this recovery does not fall on the shoulders of detransitioners alone.
It falls on all of us.
Because we cannot truly support detransitioners while continuing to uphold the very belief that led them into harm in the first place.
True support begins with society-wide ideological detransition. Until then, the waves of detransitioners will just keep on coming.
We must stop pretending that a new type of human being has been discovered — that a serious psychiatric disorder is an innate healthy trait.
We must stop pretending that amputating healthy body parts is medicine, for anyone of any age.
And we must stop pretending that becoming a lifelong medical patient is a human right — something to be encouraged and celebrated.
My talk from @genspect’s Detrans Awareness Day conference in DC on March 12th premieres at noon EST. Link below.
You misunderstand my point. The idea that transgender children must exist because transgender adults exist means that innately transgender people exist. People who are born trans.
My point is no one is born trans.
I was completely obsessed with that scandal for years. I wrote something about it once but it never got published. I did include it in my Stanford seminar. And my Albuquerque talk. It’s the strongest parallel we have.
What’s remarkable is that the moment it was over, psychiatry leapt straight into the trans madness! They didn’t learn a thing!
The concept of the trans child is very useful for a rights movement whose primary goal is to reframe trans identities as healthy.
Because if being trans is innate, then trans kids must exist. And if trans kids exist, then trans identities must be natural—not pathological or deviant.
While it may be a perfect self-justifying loop, it's also completely false.
https://www.foxnews.com/opinion/manufactured-tragedy-transgender-kids-how-society-lost-its-grip-reality
I'm not saying none will persist. But I am saying that even those who do persist are not innately trans. They have a complex mental disorder that requires compassionate ethical care.
In the second interview I shared, I explain how trans identities fall into the same psychiatric category as anorexia.
To be sure, some people develop anorexia and never recover. They suffer from it their whole lives. They are not innately anorexic, and the treatment should not be liposuction and Ozempic.
We must view trans in the same way. Medicalising these healthy youth must be considered a therapeutic failure, not a success as we currently consider it.
No child is trans. That's the tragedy of the whole thing. The concept is just the product of a political movement that has no grounding in truth. And these innocent kids are the collateral damage.
https://www.foxnews.com/opinion/manufactured-tragedy-transgender-kids-how-society-lost-its-grip-reality
What I'm saying is that we need a whole new approach to this field of medicine. One that doesn't view the trans identity as healthy and in need of affirmation. But instead recognises that it is psychopathological and the treatment should focus on overcoming the desire to transition.
Right now, we pretend that trans is healthy. We are forbidden from treating it as a mental illness.
If you're genuinely interested, I've written and spoken about this extensively.
This was the first time I introduced the new framing:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a8uBdSoQCKQ
This thread is actually really interesting. It shows why just campaigning to ban these treatments isn't enough.
We must rid our culture of the belief that trans kids exist. And trans adults for that matter.
We must stop pretending that it's healthy for anyone of any age to want extreme medical body modification.
Bans are not wins.
We win when not a single person thinks that they need to be sterilised and have healthy body parts chopped off in order to live an authentic life.
My heart aches for all the innocent youth caught up in the middle of this who believe they are a type of person that doesn't even exist.
Quotes a post by T24766; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Trans activists discovering the concept of a control group for the first time is genuinely hilarious.
“You can’t assess whether a treatment works by studying people who mostly didn’t have it.”
That’s literally how you study if a treatment works.
Quotes a post by A1706; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
I’m not saying trans youth are gay though. Given the amount of confusion this post has generated, I have to accept that it was poorly worded.
I addressed it here:
https://x.com/_crymiariver/status/2040302339110613053?s=46
Quoting @_CryMiaRiver: Many people in the replies to this have totally missed the point.
The original post was about a 17-year-old with a “stable gender identity.” What that actually means is a young man who has always been extremely gender nonconforming and in this mad era has been told that means he has a “female gender identity” and is therefore a girl.
Decades of research shows that extreme gender nonconformity in childhood is a strong indicator of homosexuality in adulthood.
Of course most trans-identified men are heterosexual — autogynephilic to be precise. But for the kids sucked into this, most of the boys would grow up to be gay if they weren’t being chemically and surgically castrated.
That’s where the phrase “trans away the gay” comes from.
This excellent article will tell you all you need to know.
https://spectator.com/article/the-document-that-reveals-the-remarkable-tactics-of-trans-lobbyists/?edition=us
Many people in the replies to this have totally missed the point.
The original post was about a 17-year-old with a “stable gender identity.” What that actually means is a young man who has always been extremely gender nonconforming and in this mad era has been told that means he has a “female gender identity” and is therefore a girl.
Decades of research shows that extreme gender nonconformity in childhood is a strong indicator of homosexuality in adulthood.
Of course most trans-identified men are heterosexual — autogynephilic to be precise. But for the kids sucked into this, most of the boys would grow up to be gay if they weren’t being chemically and surgically castrated.
That’s where the phrase “trans away the gay” comes from.
Quoting @_CryMiaRiver: No 17-year-old has a stable identity. And no 17-year-old can possibly know who they are destined to become.
Most, if not all of these boys are just gay and haven’t had the chance to settle into their sexuality yet.
Chopping off their penises is an actual crime against humanity.
I can't share the study because the gruesome photographs show up as the thumbnail.
Here's the citation, if you feel so inclined:
Groenman, F., Nikkels, C., Huirne, J., van Trotsenburg, M., & Trum, H. (2017). Robot-assisted laparoscopic colpectomy in female-to-male transgender patients; technique and outcomes of a prospective cohort study. Surgical endoscopy, 31(8), 3363–3369.
But extreme caution is advised because the study is chock full of graphic photographs.
To mark Trans Day of Visibility, let’s have a look at the most ghastly study in the entire field of gender “medicine.”
Standard phalloplasty — where a surgeon fashions an appendage made out of a woman’s forearm and sews it onto her groin — involves the surgical removal of the vagina. As in they actually remove the vaginal wall and sew the woman up.
Colpectomy is the scientific name for this ghoulish crime.
But this particular team of ghouls were researching new techniques because most of the young women having their forearms sewn onto their groins these days are virgins and that makes surgical access for their vagina removal more difficult.
Instead of stopping and asking themselves — “hang on a minute, why are we removing the vaginas of young mentally ill women who haven’t even had a single sexual encounter yet?” — they set about developing a laparoscopic technique so their crime against humanity can continue unabated.
And, as if that weren’t horrifying enough, one of the “benefits” of harvesting the tissue of the vaginal wall is that it can be used as an extra layer in the arm-flesh appendage to reduce the likelihood of urinary fistulas, which result in urine leaking out through one or more unintended openings.
These surgeons deserve no less than Nuremberg-level visibility.
Thank you. I assume I never actually got back to you. I don't remember what I said in that podcast, and I'm in Taiwan right now and don't have the time to rewatch.
However, my thoughts on this are quite stable so I can probably make a good guess.
My concern with the bans are that they are Band-Aids. They don't address the core of the issue, which is that no one is trans; this is not medicine, and this has never been medicine.
We have allowed this madness to take root for decades. We have enshrined access to these insane medical interventions in law. We have allowed extremists to frame these drugs and surgeries as a life-saving human right. And a whole bunch of innocent kids got sucked into believing this to be true.
So the bans are a quick fix, for a complex issue that has no quick fix. I fear these young people will find a way. One detransitioned young man I interviewed recently traveled to Thailand for his surgery in the days before "gender affirming care." We've created legions of young people who believe this is essential life-saving care. Therefore, many will go to great lengths to obtain it.
I'm not against the bans. I just don't think you can call a ban a win. Does that make sense? I know it's a tall order but the real win is shifting the cultural needle to a place where people don't adopt the label trans as an explanation for their suffering. Where the destruction of healthy bodies is not viewed as desirable.
If you're in or around Toronto on April 24th, come and join us for this event.
Trans activists continue to believe that even so much as discussing this topic amounts to discrimination, but they're wrong.
The debate in Canada is finally on, and it could not be more important.
📢I predict trans activists are going to just love my talk when it’s released📢
Quoting @genspect: Mia Hughes @_CryMiaRiver of Genspect Canada: “This is not a time to be timid. This is the time to pull out the megaphones”
Detrans Awareness Day 2026
From the inadequate Conservative response to the scandal of gender medicine, the gibberish wording of Canada's conversion therapy "ban" and how trans activism played the long game when constructing a whole new insane reality, this was a lively and thoroughly enjoyable discussion.
Quotes a post by T21682; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
On the contrary: I talk to Canadians from all walks of life and all places on the political spectrum and every last one of them thinks it's a crime to amputate the healthy body parts of confused kids in the name of "trans rights."
What's more, every single decent Canadian I've ever conversed with thinks women and girls deserve the safety and protection of female-only spaces.
If the Conservatives had the courage to take a bold stand in defence of women and girls, and the right of every child to grow up healthy and whole, they'd find it a winning issue.
Quoting @mark_slapinski: I am a Conservative. And I have some advice for other Conservatives:
Shut the fuck up about trans people.
The obsession with this tiny minority of people is not winning anybody over.
Absolutely. We believe the children. In both trans and the Satanic Panic it's equally mad.
My favourite from the Satanic Panic was the group of children in North Carolina who said they'd been thrown to a school of sharks! For the crackpots swept up in the passion of We Believe the Children, this didn't raise any alarm bells and the daycare owner was hauled off to prison.
But believing that a child knows when they have a mystical gender essence trapped in the wrong sexed body is just as insane. As a species, we have a seemingly unlimited capacity for believing the unbelievable.
Every time I mention the Satanic Panic, trans activists accuse me of stoking a moral panic about youth gender medicine.
But it's not a moral panic if the harm is real.
There were no Satanic cults operating in American daycares. There are legions of young people currently missing body parts.
These two things are not the same.
Quoting @_CryMiaRiver: A moral panic is a mass hysteria in which large swathes of a population get swept up by fear of an imaginary evil or danger, leading to the irrational persecution of innocent people.
Two of the most famous historical examples are the Salem Witch Trials and the Satanic Panic. There were no witches, nor any Satanic cults operating out of daycares.
At the recent @[private account] event, I was accused of stoking a moral panic for my role in the gender debate. I wholeheartedly reject that accusation.
Because in this situation, the harm is not imagined.
Scroll “topsurgery” TikTok and you’ll see thousands of teenage girls and young women displaying mastectomy scars gashed across their chests.
Scroll the horror show of phalloplasty TikTok.
Listen to the stories of detransitioners.
The harm is real, visible, and undeniable.
The truth is, we’re living through an inverted moral panic. Society’s response to the scandal unfolding in plain sight is unforgivable. Most people either ignore the harm, or worse, celebrate it and demand that it continue.
But the true inversion occurs because it is those who dare speak the truth about this scandal who are accused of being evil.
Those trying to protect young people from this medical crime are the modern day witches who find themselves persecuted.
I was astounded in 2022 that people were still able to deny the social contagion raging all around us.
Yet here we are, in 2026, still trying to convince trans activists of this blatantly obvious fact.
Ideology is one powerful drug.
Quoting @_CryMiaRiver: 🧵If it's not a social contagion, what is it?
It astounds me that there are still so many people out there who refuse to believe we're dealing with a social contagion of gender dysphoria. Surely there's never been a more obvious one in all of history./1
It’s clear that the trans contagion is winding down, as all fads eventually do.
But because we prioritized the demands of extremist political activists over the safeguarding of vulnerable children, so many will bear the scars forever.
What a shameful chapter in human history.
The Tale of Two Contagions
In 2019, German psychiatrists observed a sudden surge of adolescent girls presenting to clinics with abrupt-onset Tourette-like tics. This immediately raised alarm bells. Tourette’s typically affects boys and begins in early childhood.
This was an entirely new patient population.
Researchers quickly identified the index case: Jan Zimmermann, a young Tourette sufferer, whose YouTube channel had recently exploded in popularity. The girls displayed the exact same symptoms as Jan: the same outbursts and catchphrases.
The phenomenon soon migrated to TikTok, where it spread like wildfire.
Researchers coined a new term for what they were observing: mass social media–induced illness — a modern iteration of the long-recognized phenomenon of mass sociogenic illness.
Yet, in 2014, when paediatric gender clinics across the Western world began to fill with adolescent girls — another entirely new patient population — “gender-affirming” clinicians didn’t even bother to look for the trigger.
And it wouldn’t have taken much effort to find. All it required was a glance at the cultural messaging of the time.
Because 2014 was the year Time magazine put Laverne Cox on its cover with the headline: The Transgender Tipping Point: America’s Next Civil Rights Frontier.
And with that, the modern trans rights movement launched.
Trans-identified celebrities were everywhere, trans characters appeared in children’s books and television shows, trans influencers proliferated with astonishing speed online, and schools began teaching gender identity ideology as if it were scientific fact.
And in a perfect-storm scenario, smartphones and social media exploded in popularity, creating the ideal super-spreading environment for this seductive idea to go viral.
The message adolescents received was simple: If you hate your body, that could mean you’re trans.
And right on cue, legions of confused adolescents who hated their developing bodies began showing up at gender clinics believing themselves to be trans.
Just like the TikTok tics. A mass social media–induced illness.
Except on this occasion, instead of scrambling to contain the epidemic, doctors picked up their syringes and scalpels and set about permanently medicalising the innocent youth caught up in this powerful cultural storm.
And activists marched in the streets demanding that these young people be allowed to sacrifice their health, fertility, and body parts — while swiftly demonising anyone who dared point out the obvious parallels to social contagions of the past.
I can't share the study because the gruesome photographs show up as the thumbnail.
Here's the citation, if you feel so inclined:
Groenman, F., Nikkels, C., Huirne, J., van Trotsenburg, M., & Trum, H. (2017). Robot-assisted laparoscopic colpectomy in female-to-male transgender patients; technique and outcomes of a prospective cohort study. Surgical endoscopy, 31(8), 3363–3369.
But extreme caution is advised because the study is chock full of graphic photographs.
If you want to know the truth about the scandal of paediatric gender medicine, take everything Canadian activists say on the topic and reverse it.
This latest petition launched by an NDP MP is a perfect example.
There is precisely ZERO evidence that “gender affirming care” is life-saving.
If every systematic review to date finds only low quality evidence, the treatments cannot be called “evidence-based.”
The Canadian Medical Association has no understanding of the fraud, corruption, and ideological capture in the field of gender medicine. Indeed, the CMA is part of the problem.
As for the supposed Charter rights violations:
Performing an unregulated experiment on healthy adolescents threatens their right to security of the person.
It is cruel and unusual treatment to disrupt normal development, induce endocrine disorders and remove healthy organs in the absence of a diagnosis and without scientific justification.
Trans-identified youth should have the equal right to safe evidence-based healthcare that the rest of the Canadian population enjoys. So-called gender-affirming care violates that right.
And lastly, when a field of medicine is guided entirely by ideology, is impervious to evidence and reason, and has demonstrated repeatedly its inability to self-correct, governments have no choice but to step in and protect vulnerable patients.
And I haven't watched the talk yet, but ego-dystonic homosexuality was such a useful diagnosis. Gay rights made a mistake campaigning to get it out of the DSM. Because it was replaced by trans.
I agree. That Blair Peters maniac belongs in this category too. But almost all the rest are True Believers on a quest to save “trans kids.” I’m convinced of it.