The site's own record of the public posts it publishes, kept so that they can still be read and cited if they are deleted. The words are the account's, exactly as collected from X, except that a mention of an account that is not public is replaced by a neutral label.
What behaviour are we talking about?
I am extremely skeptical of the AAP theory. I personally don't believe that there is a female equivalent of AGP. I will concede, however, that testosterone is one hell of a drug and has a powerful effect on women but that's not the same as there being an erotic motivation to transition as in AGP.
But I was addressing the issue of Genspect being true trans. Which, to my knowledge, it is not.
No. I saw all that. I was at the conference. But I don't know of any AGPs who were invited, nor do I understand how any of the Phil drama makes Genspect true trans.
@[private account] Again, not aware of any AGPs being invited to their conference, nor how any part of the aftermath could lead to the conclusion that the group is "true trans." Without specific examples, I'm at a complete loss.
Sure. But I was putting myself in her world where these young people are innately trans and the only way to alleviate the terrible pain and suffering of having a mismatched gender soul is to medically alter the body. Then I can see how her ghoulish treatment protocol could be considered "ideal." They know as well as we do the side effects and limitations, but they consider them acceptable compared to the anguish of a lifetime trapped in the wrong body.
I don't believe anyone *is* trans. As in, I don't believe there is an innate transgender essence that some people are born with. I've never made a secret of that.
I believe that a combination of medical technology, a political juggernaut, and a social contagion on steroids has turned a once vanishingly rare psychiatric disorder (which was largely centered around a paraphilia) into a cultural movement in which a class of people call themselves transgender and make sense of their lives through that label.
But no one is born trans. There's no such thing as a trans child, and adolescents deserve the right to experiment with their identities and grow and mature without having adult concepts like "trans" thrust upon them by a political movement that has no grounding in reality.
Quotes a post by T13772; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
She's absolutely right: if you start from a position of believing there is a category of people who are innately "trans," then what she describes may well be ideal care.
But if you start from a position that teenagers believing themselves to be members of the opposite sex is a psychiatric disorder, due to maladaptive coping mechanisms and social contagion, the treatment protocol starts to look a whole lot like an atrocious medical scandal.
I would certainly agree, but each psychiatric contagion needs to be considered separately. For example, in the contagion of multiple personality disorder in the 80s, I don’t believe there was a single valid case. I think it was entirely made up and iatrogenic. Misguided therapists produced it, gullible media spread it, and the lives of many innocent people were ruined as a result.
Then if we take the example of anorexia in Hong Kong in the 90s, there were certainly people in Hong Kong who suffered from a form of anorexia before 1994. But when a school girl collapsed and died on a busy Hong Kong street that year, the media frenzy triggered a contagion of what Ethan Watters calls “me-too anorexics.” The messaging gets planted into vulnerable minds and people, normally teenage girls and young women, start to manifest the symptoms. But their cases are still valid as well.
Gender dysphoria is more complex. I think autogynephilia has been around for a very long time, and one symptom is what we currently call gender dysphoria - but it’s more an obsessive fixation on their sexual urges. Most of today’s social contagion kids have nothing in common with those men. They’re the “me-too gender dysphorics,” and while their experience is real, I don’t believe any of them benefit from either being diagnosed with, or more likely self-diagnosing with, gender dysphoria. They’re just interpreting their distress through the lens of gender and coming to the wrong conclusion that they are trans.
Incredible isn't it. Instead of seeing the glaring truth right before their very eyes, that these girls are caught up in the most obvious social contagion in all of history, they conclude they need to find more boys and non-white kids to trans!
In the 19th century, surgeons removed healthy ovaries as a cure for mental illness due to a misguided belief in reflex theory - the entirely pseudoscientific idea that one organ could produce symptoms in a distant organ in the body.
Today, surgeons remove healthy breasts and ovaries as a cure for mental illness due to a misguided belief in gender identity theory - the entirely pseudoscientific idea that a male gender essence can be trapped in a female body.
19th-century women who had imbibed the narrative of reflex theory fixated on their reproductive organs as the source of their mental distress and began presenting to gynecologists requesting to have their ovaries removed, and afterwards, if they survived, many reported being cured. Such is the power of placebo.
These two scandals, separated by 150 years, are eerily similar. Today, teenage girls and young women who have imbibed the narrative of the modern trans rights movement fixate on their breasts and reproductive organs as the source of all their distress and present to gender clinics in search of a surgical cure.
Remarkably, despite all the advances of modern medicine in the intervening years, today’s surgeons have allowed themselves to be swept up in a moment equally as mad as their 19th-century counterparts, unnecessarily removing body parts and turning healthy women into lifelong medical patients.
A medical experiment based upon an untested article of belief was unacceptable in the 19th century. It is unforgivable today.
Quoting @genspect: "Gender affirming care is a greater crime than lobotomies." From part one of our series on past medical scandals.
🚨 Tomorrow, don’t miss our next installment on past medical scandals: Ovariotomy. 📅 Join us May 14 at 7 PM EST with @_CryMiaRiver, @stellaomalley3, & @[private account]. Engage in our live Q&A!
🔗 Register now: https://us06web.zoom.us/webinar/register/WN_GXd5NUe3QgGHysLCjWdNhQ
@[private account] @[private account] Nor can I. And yet here we are. The blame for this despicable situation lies squarely on the shoulders of every trans activist who bullied, attacked, and vilified those trying to raise the alarm.
It took real courage to write this piece, and Nova Scotia trans activists will undoubtedly be having a temper tantrum over it.
So please consider emailing journalist Aaron Beswick to show your support: [email address]
This excellent coverage of the Cass Report on the front page of the @[private account] is a very encouraging display of journalist bravery in Nova Scotia. Here’s hoping it triggers a contagion of courage in a profession that has woefully failed in its duty to report truthfully on the scandal of “gender-affirming care.”
Nova Scotia’s Department of Health and Welfare claims its Gender Affirming Care policy is informed by the “best evidence,” when in truth, it’s guided by WPATH, an extremist group of trans activists masquerading as a medical organization whose standards of care are based on a mountain of junk science.
The children, adolescents, and vulnerable adults caught up in this medical scandal definitely do deserve very much better. The best time to start reporting on this medical scandal was ten years ago when the waiting rooms of gender clinics started filling up with confused teenagers caught up in an obvious social contagion. The second best time is right now.
Quotes a post by T24522; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Talked to @[private account] on @[private account] earlier about Quebec prioritizing the privacy and dignity of adolescents girls over the demands of trans activists with the announcement that all newly built schools will have sex-segregated bathrooms from now on. https://drive.google.com/file/d/1sOvApzV_vkdAEyGyWi9V3uBt0EFHXXeJ/view?usp=drivesdk
Here's the full interview, which I thoroughly enjoyed:
https://theologyintheraw.com/podcast/transgender-health-care-and-the-scandals-revealed-in-the-wpath-files-mia-hughes/
Faced one of my worst fears earlier today: public speaking. But took the opportunity to explain how modern trans activism is the most homophobic movement in existence, meaning if you support it, you are, by default, a homophobe. My foolproof way to reach well-meaning Liberals.
The epidemic we're currently witnessing is very much a culture-bound syndrome. Sure, there have been gender-nonconforming figures in history, and there have even likely been people who felt a deep-seated discomfort with their sexed bodies and felt themselves to be members of the opposite sex. No doubt the psychiatric disorder has existed in various forms at different times in the past, but the phenomenon we see today is culture-bound and the result of the modern trans rights movement.
The multiple personality disorder parallel perfectly demonstrates what I'm talking about. Split personality with dissociation had been recorded sporadically since the mid-19th century and had a small burst in popularity in the 1950s with The Three Faces of Eve. But it wasn't until Sybil in the 1970s that the culture-bound epidemic began, and its cultural niche was society's obsession with the child protection movement combined with the completely pseudoscientific recovered memory movement. Then it raged through North American society, just as today's epidemic is raging through every nation touched by the modern trans rights movement.
Today's epidemic of gender dysphoria is a culture-bound syndrome triggered by the messaging of the trans rights movement. It's eerily similar to the culture-bound epidemic of multiple personality disorder that raged in the 1980s and was triggered by the recovered memory movement.
Quotes a post by T18391; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
"During a question and answer session at the event...two trans fans stood and thanked Page for being an inspiration."
That's not something to celebrate. That's Page helping spread the contagion, leading impressionable young people down a dangerous path. It's Sybil inspiring women to discover multiple personalities or Princess Diana planting the idea of binging and purging into the minds of teenage girls.
I've said it before, and I'll keep on saying it: children and adolescents no more need trans role models than they do anorexic or bulimic role models. Every time we celebrate the likes of Page, we add fuel to the epidemic and increase the number of victims it claims.
Quotes a post by T13555; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
Whenever I mention on here that five out of Canada's ten main pediatric gender clinics do not require a psychological assessment prior to starting blockers or hormones, a trans activist will show up to call me a liar. Because it's so mad, even trans activists don't believe it could be true.
And yet it is true.
In five gender clinics across Canada, a child can self-diagnose as being transgender and be immediately started on an irreversible, life-altering, experimental treatment pathway that has no foundation whatsoever in science.
Because here in Canada, we prioritise ideology over safeguarding. We practice social-justice medicine over evidence-based medicine.
The malpractice lawsuits will be legion.
Talked to @[private account] on @[private account] earlier about the upcoming Rainbow Week of Action, during which Canadian trans activists will take to the streets to demand the continuation of the medical scandal occurring in our gender clinics.
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1qptwfxuZgrwEznUfRevfmZTpuCCIaLwH/view?usp=sharing
An Ottawa mother once told me her daughter was one of five trans-identified girls in her high school class.
I'd say that certainly "could be" a social contagion.
The school, on the other hand, thought it was something to celebrate.
Quotes a post by T31102; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
When we're sifting through the wreckage of this disaster, we must never forget the role trans activists played. We must never forget how they cheered this on, vilifying those of us who tried desperately to stop vulnerable kids falling victim to the medical world's greatest crime.
What makes this medical scandal so catastrophic is that not only did doctors lose their ethical compass at the very same moment the social contagion began, but also the viciousness of trans activists created a climate of fear in which almost no one dared to defend these kids.
Canada is finally willing to accept the fact that maybe, just maybe, social contagion is a factor in the meteoric surge in teens identifying as transgender, and our trans activists are not happy.
Quoting @_CryMiaRiver: 🧵If it's not a social contagion, what is it?
It astounds me that there are still so many people out there who refuse to believe we're dealing with a social contagion of gender dysphoria. Surely there's never been a more obvious one in all of history./1
I much prefer gender identity disorder. WPATH lobbying the APA to change the diagnosis to gender dysphoria was all part of their de-psychopathologisation campaign, which is, in my opinion, the most harmful thing they've ever done.
We need to recognise it for what it is: a transient mental illness brought into existence by the modern trans rights movement. It's no more real than multiple personality disorder in the 1980s, or fugue in the 1880s.
After this cultural madness passes, there will undoubtedly still be autogynephilic men who desperately wish to be women, though. I don't think autogynephilia will disappear.
In the WPATH Files, Jon Arcelus of Nottingham Centre for Transgender Health grappled with how to talk about non-binary surgeries without actually describing them.
“Is ‘non-standard’ procedures the best term to use? They may become standard in the future… any more possible terms that could be used to describe these kinds of procedures without having to describe them?”
Because even he knows that decent people are horrified by such an egregious violation of the Hippocratic Oath, yet at the same time, he predicts they could become mainstream medical practice one day in the future.
Quoting @SexMattersOrg: MORE #WPATH REVELATIONS: NHS gender
doctor backs ‘non standard procedures’ like having both male and female genitalia
@shellenberger @_CryMiaRiver
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2024/04/12/nhs-trangender-doctor-jonathan-arcelus-male-female-genitals/
Yes. What we're witnessing now is a culture-bound syndrome triggered by the modern trans rights movement and its relentless messaging about non-existent gender souls. I am completely convinced this was done so AGPs could deny the existence of autogynephilia, but I don't think anyone deliberately triggered the psychiatric epidemic. I think that was entirely accidental.
Remember when I said WPATH was an activist group masquerading as a medical group? Well, they have this to say in response to the Cass Report:
"Cis-supremacy calls attention to the axes and forces of cis-power that actively dominate and oppress trans people, producing and perpetuating systemic and sustained injustices."
I rest my case.
https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/26895269.2024.2328249
These are all the guidelines in the field of gender medicine. So WPATH's Standards of Care 6 (SOC6) was published in 2001. It was ideologically motivated and removed the need for two surgical referral letters from mental health professionals because trans activists felt that amounted to unnecessary discrimination.
Then SOC6 influenced the Endocrine Society's 2009 guidelines, which were even more ideologically driven, endorsing affirmation and medicalization despite the lack of good-quality science to back this up.
WPATH's SOC7 in 2012 drew on those guidelines, and as you can see from the visual, so did many others. They all then cite each other as proof of their scientific validity, but at the core of all their circular citations sits an empty shell devoid of anything resembling real science.
This is Megan's brilliant article about the Oedipus Trap. She's talking about lobotomies and how Freeman went to his grave believing the trans-orbital lobotomy was a gift to humanity. Many gender doctors will no doubt follow the same path.
https://x.com/asymmetricinfo/status/1625963760526524431
Quotes a post by T01704; posts by private accounts are not reproduced.
This exceptional article examines the ethics of puberty suppression through the lens of philosopher Joel Feinberg’s principle of a child’s right to an open future.
This principle refers to rights that children lack the capacity to exercise but must be preserved for when they are autonomous adults. One such right relates to the desire to have children. The essay beautifully describes something we all instinctively know.
As a child, I was positive I would never want children. All the way up to my mid-20s, I remained steadfast in that belief. Then I hit 30, and the desire to be a mother became all-consuming. I then transformed into a home-birthing, breastfeeding, co-sleeping, baby-wearing, stay-at-home mother. That transformation was only possible because, as a child, my right to an open future was preserved.
Gender-affirming care prioritises the present at the expense of the future. When trans activists smashed the windows of Radio-Canada in Montreal last month in response to a piece of investigative journalism revealing shocking medical malpractice in a Quebec gender clinic, they did so precisely because they think 14-year-old girls deserve the right to sacrifice their future fertility, even if that means a lifetime of regret.
Robbing children of the chance to grow and mature is a crime. Performing harmful and irreversible medical interventions on young bodies in the service of a culturally influenced and likely transient identity is a despicable act for which there can be no forgiveness. One can only hope this dark chapter in human history is now drawing to a close.
https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10508-024-02850-4
Of course WPATH is to blame for this ghastly horror show. The world leading trans healthcare group has an entire chapter in its SOC8 on non-binary surgeries for people who want individually customised bodies and members in the WPATH Files predict a wave of such surgical requests.